Garda goes on trial accused of assaulting a teenager four years ago
A garda has gone on trial at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court accused of assaulting a teenager in Temple Bar in 2021.
The complainant gave evidence that he suffered a fractured skull and spent five days in Beaumont Hospital following the alleged assault.
Lorcan Murphy (32) of Pearse Street Garda Station has pleaded not guilty to two counts of assault causing harm under section 3 of the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act, 1997.
The assaults on the then 17-year-old are alleged to have taken place on Essex Street, Dublin 2 and Pearse Street Garda Station on June 1, 2021.
In his opening speech yesterday, John Gallagher BL prosecuting, told the court the accused was a serving member of An Garda Siochana and an investigation was carried out by GSOC, which is now known as Fiosru.
Mr Gallagher said the assault is alleged to have happened during the Covid-19 period 'when one set of regimes runs into another' but that at this time limited gatherings outdoors were permitted.
He said there was a short encounter where the alleged injured party was brought to the ground in an effort to restrain him and a number of bystanders were present.
There was a short engagement which lasted a minute or two at most when he was 'brought to the ground', Mr Gallagher said.
Mr Gallagher said the complainant was 'brought to the ground with his knee', and he was 'completely, effectively restrained'. He was handcuffed and brought to his feet.
Counsel said the alleged victim was handcuffed and could not put his hands out to protect himself.
Mr Gallagher said it was the prosecution's case that by sweeping his legs from under the alleged injured party and him landing him on his head, 'this amounted to assault'.
Counsel said the alleged injured party was visibly unconscious when he was lifted into a Garda van and was taken to Pearse Street Garda Station for processing.
Mr Gallagher said there was a second charge of assault at Pearse Street Garda Station, when the complainant was having 'difficulty staying conscious' and he was pulled back by the hair. He said that it was the prosecution's case that this 'manhandling' amounted to a second assault.
He told the jury they would hear medical evidence. Mr Gallagher said there must be a legitimate use of force or reasonable force. He said 'it's not carte blanche' to use force and he told the jury they would be asked to consider whether it was reasonable force.
He also told the jury they would have to hear an account by Gda Murphy and would have to consider if there was 'a basis for using it'.
Mr Gallagher said gardai 'have a very difficult job' but the same laws that apply to everyone else regarding the use of force also apply to the Gardai.
He told the jury that defence counsel Justin McQuade BL wanted it 'clarified' that there had been an earlier engagement between the accused and complainant.
The complainant gave evidence that he could not recall the events and 'the doctor told me it was ok not to remember' but said 'I was assaulted, I was tripped up supposedly, I fractured my skull,' he told the court.
He told the court he was 'drinking that day' and that he had had 'quite a few.' He said he had been 'smoking weed' and said he would normally smoke four or five joints a day. He also said that he 'could have been' carrying alcohol.
He said he was up in Stephen's Green and his girlfriend at the time was in Temple Bar so he went to meet her and said the last thing he remembered was walking past McDonald's on Grafton Street.
The alleged victim said 'waking up in James' Hospital' is the next thing he remembers. He told the court someone in the hospital told him he was involved in an incident with the gardai.
He said he ran out of the hospital. 'I freaked out, I thought there was nothing wrong with me,' he told the court.
The complainant said he woke up with a pain in his head and went to the Mater Hospital where he got a CT scan and then went to Beaumont Hospital where he stayed for five days.
He said he had headaches but has no issues with his memory.
'You heard about this investigation because there was some publicity about it?' Mr Gallagher put it to him, to which he replied 'yeah'.
The complainant said he spoke to GSOC and gave them two videos - one of him on the ground that someone else had recorded and one of the garda approaching him, which he had taken himself.
When the complainant was asked by Mr Gallagher if he was ever charged with any offences in relation to events in Temple Bar on June 1, 2021, he replied 'no'.
CCTV was shown to the court of two gardai on Essex Street and Mr McQuade said his client was the one wearing shorts.
CCTV captured from the exterior of Dolphin House on Essex Street and from Pearse Street Garda Station was shown to the court.
The trial continues today before a jury of eight men and four women with Judge Pauline Codd presiding.
Stock image
Today's News in 90 Seconds - July 17th
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
6 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
More protests held outside migrant hotels across UK as anger over crisis continues to rise
MORE protests have been held outside migrant hotels across the country yesterday as anger over the issue continues to rise. Another demonstration was held nearby to the Brittania International Hotel in Canary Wharf, East London — which had been revealed earlier this week to be Advertisement 4 Further protests have been held outside migrant hotels across the UK Credit: Gary Stone 4 A man is held by cops during the demonstration by The Bell Hotel, Epping Credit: LNP 4 The two groups of protesters in Epping face off against each other Credit: PA The large group of various ethnicities held a banner saying: 'Stop calling us far right. "Protect our women and children.' Meanwhile, rival groups clashed outside The Bell Hotel in Epping, Essex. Around 300 Advertisement READ MORE ON MIGRANT PROTESTS Around 500 officers from 31 forces across It was the He has denied three charges. Elsewhere, around 250 protested near the Brook Hotel in Norwich, while more than 200 stood outside a migrant hotel in Altrincham, Gtr Manchester. Advertisement Most read in The Sun Live Blog Exclusive Other gatherings over the weekend have been reported in Migrant hotel protests spread across the country with more planned today as cops clamp down on weekend of stand-offs 4 A demonstration was held nearby to the Brittania International Hotel in Canary Wharf, East London Credit: Gary Stone Four in 10 sex attack charges non-Brits Exclusive by Jack Elsom NEARLY four in ten people charged over sex attacks in London in the last seven years are foreign nationals, police figures show. Non-Brits are thought to be behind 2,809 out of 7,798 such crimes — 36 per cent — but make up less than a quarter of the city's population. A further 358 charged are of unknown nationality, meaning the foreigner total may be higher. Brits accounted for 4,631 charges. The largest cohort of foreign suspects were Romanian at 308, but Afghans are the most prolific by share of population at 89. The Centre for Migration Control obtained figures on nationalities of those charged with sex offences since 2018. It said: 'The spike in sexual offences against women and girls is directly attributable to our open borders.' The Home Office said: 'We continue to deport foreign nationals who commit heinous crimes in the UK.' Fury over Sharia law job advert A JOB ad for a 'Sharia law administrator' on the Department for Work and Pensions website sparked fury. Islamic Sharia law is followed by many Muslims around the world — though it is not accepted in the UK. The Manchester Sharia Council job pays £23,500 a year to help provide guidance on matrimonial matters under Sharia law. It requires a diploma or degree in Sharia law but only 'familiarity' with our legal system. Reform UK's Nigel Farage warned: 'Our country and its values are being destroyed'. Tory Shadow Home Secretary Chris Philp said: 'This is wrong. 'We only have one set of laws in the country. No other law should be recognised by the state.'
Irish Daily Mirror
13 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Man sexually assaulted his estranged wife while she was in bed with her children
A man who sexually assaulted his estranged wife on two separate occasions while she was sleeping in her bed with her young children has been sentenced to four years in prison. The 47-year-old father of two, who cannot be identified to protect the identity of his victims, pleaded guilty to two counts of sexual assault on his wife at their family home in Wicklow two years ago. Detective Garda Catherine O'Rourke said the couple, who are both non-Irish nationals, had separated in January 2023 but they had both continued to live in the same house. The witness told a sitting of Wicklow Circuit Criminal Court that the accused entered his wife's bedroom without her permission where she was sleeping with their two very young children on the night of November 10, 2023. Det Garda O'Rourke said the woman woke up at one stage and had the feeling she was being touched in some way. The woman said husband had remarked: 'Sorry, I was horny' after she found him leaning over her before telling him to get out of her room. The court heard that he had digitally penetrated his victim who reported the matter to gardai the following day. Det Garda O'Rourke said the woman also informed them that there had been another incident sometime earlier in March 2023 when she woke suddenly, while she was sleeping in bed with one of her children, to feel being touched on her skin under her nightdress. She said the woman had screamed at her husband to get out of the room when she realised he had been touching her bum. When arrested, Det Garda O'Rourke said the man claimed he had been in his wife's bedroom and had lifted his daughter and had gotten an erection as he had placed her back in the bed. She agreed with Mr Kelly that the accused was in denial about his offending but had cooperated with gardaí. The court heard the defendant, who had six previous convictions for road traffic offences, only pleaded guilty after a trial had commenced last February as his wife was about to give evidence. In an emotional victim impact during which she broke down repeatedly, the woman said she felt very unsafe and violated after the two incidents but she had nowhere to go and did not think the authorities would believe her. The woman said her husband, from whom she has now filed for divorce, would not move out of the house after their separation. 'He would be remorseful for a few days and then say he did nothing wrong,' she recalled. She said he would also accuse her of being difficult and dramatic and attempted to portray her as being promiscuous and a bad mother. The woman said the second assault had devastated her life forever with her children still asking questions about their father. She told the court that her main concern was to keep a family routine for her children despite her own personal feelings about their father. The woman said she believed that after securing a protection order that it would protect her from any further attempt to hurt or scare her. 'I was very wrong,' she added before breaking out in tears. She said her ex-husband continued to act brazenly in the house which would leave her whole body shaking and feeling 'in survival moment every time.' The woman said she could no longer sleep in the bedroom where the assault took place and would have to make up an excuse for her children why she was sleeping on the floor of their room. The court heard that she stopped wearing make-up and nail polish and took to wearing long-sleeved clothing because she felt the need to hide and make herself invisible, while she also developed severe skin conditions from stress. The woman said she had to take extended sick leave from her job after breaking down hysterically after returning to work several weeks after the second assault. She described how she had developed thoughts of suicide and had made an actual plan to take her own life while her children were with their father. 'My children are the only reason I am still alive. They are the reason I didn't do it,' she observed. The woman also fought back tears as she explained her belief that her neighbours no longer invited her children on playdates because of gardaí calling to her house. The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week After a period of living elsewhere, the woman said her ex-husband had returned to the house in January 2024 without her permission and refused to find alternative accommodation. The court heard he subsequently began to live in his car which was parked in front of her house which made her feel she was under surveillance all the time. The woman said what happened had also caused her great financial difficulties. She again broke down as she explained how she tried to keep co-parenting her children after the assault for their sake, despite her not being able to talk to or be in the same space as her ex-husband. The woman said his conviction came as a 'massive relief' because she did not believe she would ever be truly remorseful for what he had done. Judge John Martin sentenced the accused to four years in prison for the second sexual assault and 18 months for the first offence to run consecutively. However, the judge said he would suspend the final 18 months of the sentence on condition that the defendant keep the peace for a period of two years after his release from prison and have no further contact with his wife without her express consent. He said an aggravating factor in the case was how the accused had twice assaulted his wife in the same bed where his children were sleeping for his own 'gratification or power trip.' Noting the man was now on the sex offenders register, Judge Martin said his children were also secondary victims in the case, although he accepted the accused's expression of remorse as genuine. Sign up to the Irish Mirror's Courts and Crime newsletter here and get breaking crime updates and news from the courts direct to your inbox.
The Irish Sun
19 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Elite team of cops to monitor anti-migrant social media posts to clamp down on unrest as critics blast ‘disturbing' move
AN elite team of cops will be tasked with monitoring social media for anti-migrant posts. Detectives are being handpicked from forces across the UK to take part in the new programme amid fears of rioting as the small boats crisis escalates. Advertisement 3 The new unit will monitor social media posts about immigration Credit: UKNIP 3 The step has been slammed as an attack on freedom of speech Credit: Getty 3 Lucy Connolly was sentenced to 31 months in prison for her misinformed posts about Southport Credit: PA The division, overseen by the Home Office, will look to "maximise social media intelligence" gathering after forces were slammed for their response to last year's unrest. Protests outside asylum hotels is continuing to heat up, with crowds gathering yesterday in the likes of Norwich, Leeds and Bournemouth - and more demonstrations planned today. Deputy PM Angela Rayner warned the Cabinet last week that the Government must step in to address "real concerns" about immigration. However, critics have labelled the social media policing plans as "disturbing" and questioned if it further restricts freedom of speech. Advertisement The National Internet Intelligence Investigations team, will work out of the National Police Coordination Centre (NPoCC) in Westminster. The NPoCC provides the central planning for forces across the UK in terms of "nationally significant protests" and civil disorder. And enforced lockdown rules during the Covid pandemic. Lucy Connolly fury It comes after Tory councillor Raymond Connolly's wife account just hours after evil murdered three girls in the Merseyside town on July 29 last year. Advertisement Most read in The Sun Breaking Ms Connolly, 41, shared a call to arms following the deaths of Bebe King, six, nine-year-old Alice Dasilva Aguiar and Elsie Dot Stancombe, seven, last July. Posts wrongly claimed monster Ms Connelly's punishment sparked fury across the political divide. 16 arrested after protests outside Epping migrant hotel as ring of steel ramps up around TWO asylum seeker centres Furious Brits noted that despite the former child minder quickly deleting her post, she remains in prison while paedos such as Hugh Edwards escaped jail time. Advertisement Referring to the social media cops, Chris Philp, the shadow home secretary, told the "They're setting up a central team to monitor what you post, what you share, what you think, because deep down they know the public don't buy what they're selling." He added Labour are no longer "pretending" to fix Britain and are now "trying to mute it" - turning the country into a "surveillance state". Nigel Farage, the Reform UK leader, said: 'This is the beginning of the state controlling free speech. It is sinister, dangerous and must be fought. Reform UK will do just that.' Advertisement
