UK judge warns of risk to justice after lawyers cited fake AI-generated cases in court
High Court justice Victoria Sharp said the misuse of AI has 'serious implications for the administration of justice and public confidence in the justice system.'
In the latest example of how judicial systems around the world are grappling with how to handle the increasing presence of artificial intelligence in court, Sharp and fellow judge Jeremy Johnson chastised lawyers in two recent cases in a ruling on Friday.
They were asked to rule after lower court judges raised concerns about 'suspected use by lawyers of generative artificial intelligence tools to produce written legal arguments or witness statements which are not then checked,' leading to false information being put before the court.
In a ruling written by Sharp, the judges said that in a 90 million pound ($120 million) lawsuit over an alleged breach of a financing agreement involving the Qatar National Bank, a lawyer cited 18 cases that did not exist.
The client in the case, Hamad Al-Haroun, apologized for unintentionally misleading the court with false information produced by publicly available AI tools, and said he was responsible, rather than his solicitor Abid Hussain.
But Sharp said it was 'extraordinary that the lawyer was relying on the client for the accuracy of their legal research, rather than the other way around.'
In the other incident, a lawyer cited five fake cases in a tenant's housing claim against the London Borough of Haringey. Barrister Sarah Forey denied using AI, but Sharp said she had 'not provided to the court a coherent explanation for what happened.'
The judges referred the lawyers in both cases to their professional regulators, but did not take more serious action.
Sharp said providing false material as if it were genuine could be considered contempt of court or, in the 'most egregious cases,' perverting the course of justice, which carries a maximum sentence of life in prison.
She said in the judgment that AI is a 'powerful technology' and a 'useful tool' for the law.
'Artificial intelligence is a tool that carries with it risks as well as opportunities,' the judge said. 'Its use must take place therefore with an appropriate degree of oversight, and within a regulatory framework that ensures compliance with well-established professional and ethical standards if public confidence in the administration of justice is to be maintained.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Priests indulged in ‘binge drinking culture' and played ‘seven last shots of Christ' at Welsh cathedral
Priests at a cathedral described as having a 'culture of binge drinking' have been accused of playing a 'seven last shots of Christ' game after a Good Friday service. Former choir singers at Bangor Cathedral have claimed there "seemed to be any excuse to bring out the wine" at the church, which has been embroiled in controversy in recent weeks. The accusations follow a safeguarding review at Bangor Cathedral, which raised complaints about alcohol use and sexual behaviour. The Archbishop of Wales, Andrew John, announced his retirement after the critical report of his diocese. There is no suggestion that the archbishop behaved inappropriately. The Church in Wales told the BBC that in light of the report, there must be a "change in leadership, procedures and governance in the diocese of Bangor". A former singer at the church anonymously told the BBC that she had been sexually assaulted there in 2022 by a man training to become a priest. The Church in Wales told the BBC she was one of two people who complained about the man's behaviour. The incident was reported and the man's priest training was not taken forward. The woman said the man had 'considerably too much to drink' in the lead up to the assault. She said: "I'd already warned people that night he's drinking a lot more than everyone else. So these warning signs were ignored and that led to that assault." Though she received an apology, she said the drinking culture did not change. "Several bottles of prosecco would be gone through on a Sunday morning," she added. "Any sort of external event or big internal event there was prosecco or wine." She also recalled an inappropriate drinking game played by members of the choir and priests after a cathedral concert on Good Friday in 2023. "A few of the priests came out with the choir," she said. "It was deemed appropriate to do the seven last shots of Christ.' "Because Christ has seven last words, therefore we sang seven pieces of the seven last words in the concert - and that somehow translated into seven shots of Christ," she added. "I think I left after the first shot because I was like 'I don't think this is appropriate'. There's too many people taking shots in dog collars for me to be comfortable." A former lay clerk at the cathedral also shared their experiences of the 'culture of binge drinking'. Esmé Byrd, 29, told the BBC that some people would get "really catastrophically drunk" and also shared concerns around a lack of safeguarding training. A spokesperson for The Church in Wales told the BBC that they did not believe Bangor Cathedral to be unsafe for children, but that improvements to policy were required. They said "the abuse of alcohol is always inappropriate", adding: 'Previous concerns about a drinking culture at the Cathedral contributed to the decision to undertake a Bishop's visitation. "The Implementation Group who are addressing the recommendations from the visitation are developing a policy concerning alcohol use. Alcohol is not now generally available after services. "The inappropriate use of alcohol within and during cathedral-related activities included encouragement by some towards others to consume alcohol. "This inappropriate behaviour is addressed in the actions which are required following the visitation process. "DBS checks are required and safeguarding training delivered in line with UK legislation, and the Church in Wales policies." The Independent has contacted Bangor Cathedral and The Church in Wales.
Scottish Sun
an hour ago
- Scottish Sun
Ex-England ace arrested at Stansted in front of stunned passengers after taking budget flight to UK
Scroll down to find out why the star was arrested 3 LIONS STAR NICKED Ex-England ace arrested at Stansted in front of stunned passengers after taking budget flight to UK Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) A FORMER England and Premier League footballer was arrested at an airport in front of stunned passengers after flying into the UK. The unnamed star was held shortly after getting off a budget airline flight at Stansted airport following a journey from Europe. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 1 A former England and Premier League footballer was arrested at Stansted Airport in front of stunned passengers (stock picture) Credit: Alamy Police yesterday confirmed he was arrested earlier this year in connection with breaching a court order. Details of the circumstances surrounding the alleged breach are not clear. A source said: 'You can imagine it was a huge surprise for other passengers at the airport when they saw him being spoken to by police officers at passport control. 'He had already been recognised by lots of people on the plane journey so it wasn't as if he was keeping a low profile. READ MORE ON FOOTBALL DALL OR NOTHING Leeds icon Dallas reflects on first year of retirement after horror injury 'He played for England and in the Premier League so he was attracting plenty of attention. 'It seemed as if an issue was flagged up to the Border Force officers at passport control at Stansted, which led to police being called. 'He was questioned for a while and then taken away by the police. 'It caused quite a kerfuffle as there were lots of other passengers around in the arrivals area of Stansted where he was arrested. 'Stansted is a very busy airport and he had travelled from a popular European destination on a budget airline.' A spokesman for Essex Police told The Sun on Sunday yesterday: 'A man was arrested at Stansted Airport on April 27 on suspicion of breaching a non-molestation order, and has been released on bail.' Major UK airport warns of flight delays after being hit by 'ongoing IT issue' as passengers urged to check journeys People who breach a court order, depending on the circumstances, can face criminal action resulting in a possible jail sentence.
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
Boy, 4, dies after ‘gravestone falls on him at cemetery' in broad daylight
A FOUR-YEAR-OLD boy has tragically died after a gravestone fell onto him in a cemetery. Paramedics rushed to Rawtenstall Cemetery in Lancashire at around 1pm today where cops confirmed the boy had sadly died. Lancashire Police have said his death is not being treated as suspicious and said they will pass a file to the HM Coroner "in due course." A spokesperson for Lancashire Police said: "We were called to Rawtenstall Cemetery at 1pm today [July 5] following reports a gravestone had fallen onto a child. "Tragically, and despite the best efforts of the emergency services, the boy sadly died. "Our thoughts are with his loved ones at this devastating time. "His death is not being treated as suspicious and a file will be passed onto HM Coroner in due course."
