What will Ireland's costly five-year schools abuse inquiry achieve?
Government
has announced the establishment of an
inquiry into sexual abuse in all schools, primary and second level
. Now people who suffered physical abuse are asking, 'what about us?'
Four categories of abuse are used in classifying abuse – sexual, physical, emotional, and neglect. In the legal world, a
claim of sexual abuse
appears to have top billing when it comes to redress, but that should not take from the fact that the effects of any abuse, experienced as a child, can be difficult to measure.
When we consider the hurt caused by verbal abuse, mockery, classroom humiliation, exclusion, we realise that these experiences can have lifelong consequences for the individual and society.
Social class played a part in the abuse in
schools
.
READ MORE
Noted Brazilian educator Paulo Freire, writing about oppressors versus the oppressed, made the point that very few, if any, are capable of overcoming the views and prejudices of the class into which they were born.
Teachers in schools, be they religious or secular, tended to come from middle class origins and many took the view that it did not matter if one treated the children of the poor differently from the those whose parents were better off, parents with whom the teachers could more easily identify.
This was relevant from the foundation of the primary school system in the 19th century, though it began to change gradually in the 1960s and with the introduction of free education.
It is questionable what a five-year, costly Government inquiry, which will divert financial and personnel resources from the educational budget, will achieve. If the net of inquiries of past abuses continues to be widened, will a point of closure ever be reached?
We know that abuse happens in families. Will future governments trawl through every family in the land so that every child who was ever abused in any setting is going to have a voice?
[
'I'm angry that my abuse as a child does not count' – State must pay for school sexual abuse
Opens in new window
]
Minister for Education Helen McEntee said institutions and religious orders involved in historical sex abuse in schools will be "held accountable" for the "awful" crimes. Photograph: Cate McCurry/ PA Wire
Presumably the inquiry will identify those who allege abuse. Will it then have the task of assessing the truth of any allegation? Will it presume that all allegations are true? There is the question of natural justice, whereby the accused has the right of reply to his/ her accuser. Having verified whether an allegation is credible (and there is a difference between credibility and truth) there is the question of who will bear the cost of redress. And we need to ask ourselves, and those who represent us in Government, if 'giving a voice' actually brings healing. It may – but being the public voice that represents all those who suffered could also serve to lock one into the hurt.
Tánaiste Simon Harris has insisted that the religious organisations will have to pay and the Opposition are adamant that they have 'got away' with not paying.
Religious organisations have already paid some money and handed over buildings. There has not been any calculation of the money and salaries that wereploughed back into schools. This might be as immeasurable as the degree of abuse.
The reality of child abuse within and without the churches has been revealed and openly debated for the past 30 years. It has shattered the institution of the Catholic Church and, in many ways, has been as transformative as the Reformation was in the 16th century. The credibility of the Church of Rome has been marred, possibly beyond repair.
But there may come a point where we are in danger of ignoring present abuses in favour of scrutiny of the past.
Finally, questions must be raised about school management. The greater number of our schools are under the management of the Catholic Church. The pay back in terms of church practice and adult belief seem minimal. The passing on of faith is primarily the role of the family.
This is the time for the Catholic hierarchy to hand back the schools to the State.
Margaret Lee is a retired Principal Social Worker with experience in Child and Family Services, as well as on Child Protection Committee.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Lobby other EU countries to allow Irish Central Bank to drop Israeli war bonds, TDs recommend
An Oireachtas committee has recommended the Government lobby other EU states to change rules that stop the Irish Central Bank from refusing to act as a competent authority in Europe for Israeli war bonds. Third-country issuers, such as Israel, can choose any EU state as their home member state and competent authority. That authority reviews its bond prospectus and, in this case, authorises Israel to sell bonds in the EU market. Before 2021, the UK was the EU home member state under the regulation for the state of Israel. Ireland was chosen as the new home member state following the UK's departure from the EU after Brexit in 2016. Politicians from all parties have expressed concern that Ireland is the competent authority that gives authority to Israel to sell bonds in the EU market, including what Israel markets as 'war bonds'. However, the committee has been told by the Central Bank that it is powerless to refuse to act as the competent authority under current rules. The rules and criteria that determine approval of the prospectus do not cover Israel's continuing military activities in Gaza , but rather include risk rules based on financial and fiscal criteria. The governor of the Central Bank, Gabriel Makhlouf, told the Oireachtas Committee on Finance in June that Ireland had no power to unilaterally remove itself from being the competent authority. Any decision to change that situation, he said, would be made by the third country, in this case Israel, and by that third country alone. The committee, chaired by Sinn Féin TD Mairéad Farrell , published a report on Tuesday, the main recommendation of which was that the Government engage at EU level with a 'view to amending the EU Prospectus regulations to permit each individual European Central Bank to refuse to act as a Competent Authority'. It has also recommended that the Central Bank conduct an immediate internal review in advance of any renewal in September of the Israeli bond prospectus. It said that review should determine whether it is in compliance with the levels of disclosure, accuracy and transparency required by the EU Prospectus. At the meeting in June, committee members expressed concern that the continuing destruction and deaths in Gaza were not being taken into consideration in determining the right of Israel to sell bonds, which several committee members pointed out were being openly marketed as 'war bonds'. The report states: 'In response to questions around whether enhanced scrutiny is applied to sovereign bond issuers involved in armed conflict or under international investigation, representatives of the Central Bank told the Committee that a judgement is made as to whether a prospectus is particularly complex and if there are issues that are challenging to articulate. 'Ultimately, however, the judgement rests on whether the disclosure is appropriate to the financial risk.' At the meeting, members expressed concern with regard to both the exposure of the EU financially to Israel and the current situation in Israel. 'Members further described the prospectus regulatory regime as 'narrow and arguably amoral ... Jesuitical in the way that it is interpreted and applied, which is mindful of only its basic, legalistic obligations in satisfying the regulatory framework in place', the report stated. Amid cross-party opposition to the Central Bank continuing in that role, the committee has also recommended that any future review of its role as the competent authority by the regulator should take into account the nature of the case taken by South Africa against Israel under the Genocide Convention and the interim findings of the International Court of Justice (ICJ) in that regard. It also said the illegal situation created by Israel in the Occupied Palestinian Territories should also be taken into account.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Public to be 'bombarded with cool stuff' at Dublin's Dead Zoo Lab
Nikita Hand speaks to the media at the High Court after Conor McGregor loses his appeal over the verdict in the civil rape case. Video: Stephen Conneely
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Records falsified relating to mentally ill inmate found dead, prison watchdog finds
Records relating to the supervision of a severely mentally ill Spanish resident who was found dead in his cell in Cloverhill Prison were falsified, a prison watchdog has found. The Office of the Inspector of Prisons, which is led by Mark Kelly, was highly critical of how the Irish Prison Service (IPS) handled the detention of the deceased, whom it called 'Mr O', in 2022. It determined Mr O was in custody on suspicion of a minor offence and was due to be transferred to a psychiatric hospital the day after he was found dead in a close-supervision cell on August 10th, 2022. Prisoners under close supervision are supposed to be checked every 15 minutes. A prison journal recorded that staff had checked the prisoner at 7am, 7.15am and 7.30am. However, Mr O had been found unresponsive sitting on the toilet in his cell at 6.50am, causing staff to issue a 'Code Red' and call for an ambulance. This 'clearly' indicates the three journal entries had been filled in ahead of time by staff, 'entirely negating the value of this recording safeguard', the inspectorate said in a newly published report. The inspectorate also noted 'an (unsuccessful) effort had been made to erase the three entries'. The statutory inspection body has raised concerns about the falsification of prison records on several previous occasions. It echoed concerns contained in a recent report by the Council of Europe's Committee for the Prevention of Torture (CPT) that found several cases of records being falsified. The issue was particularly notable in Cloverhill and Limerick Prisons, where falsified records were discovered following several prisoner deaths in close-supervision cells. The CPT said minimal action had been taken by local prison management to address this. The Inspector of Prisons said it is 'imperative' the falsification of records 'is treated with the utmost seriousness' by management. Regarding Mr O, it said he was detained on a public order charge at Dublin Airport on August 4th after he was observed acting erratically. He was unable to take up bail after he was judged to be of unfit mind to sign the bond. In Cloverhill, his behaviour was observed as 'bizarre and erratic'. Staff reported he 'was standing on his bed in a state of undress and shouting at the floor and refused to respond to questions asked by the nurse'. Gardaí told prison staff the judge would strike out the charge against Mr O if treatment could be arranged. Staff also learned he had spent time in psychiatric hospitals outside the State and had not been taking his medication for a lengthy period of time. A place was found for Mr O in St Vincent's hospital in Fairview. He was due to be transferred on August 11th. However, early on August 10th, he was found unresponsive in his cell. Attempts to revive him were unsuccessful and he was pronounced dead at 9.45am. The inspectorate's report does not detail a cause of death. The inspectorate repeated recommendations that 'urgent consideration' be given to quickly transferring mentally ill suspects charged with minor offences to local psychiatric hospitals. 'It remains unacceptable that prisoner-patients such as Mr O, suspected of minor offences, and suffering from a mental health disorder, cannot more rapidly access in-patient psychiatric treatment in local civil psychiatric hospitals.' In response, the IPS said it is working on implementing several recommendations in this area and that additional resources are being assigned to Cloverhill. Regarding the falsification of records, it said a 'digitisation project' will commence later this year that will improve record-keeping and limit 'the risk of falsification'. It said staff who are found to falsify records 'are sanctioned in line with the code of discipline'.
