‘Étoile' vs. ‘The Residence': How to cancel a show without derailing its Emmy chances
When Prime Video officially pulled the plug on Étoile on June 6, the announcement sent ripples through the entertainment industry. While the cancellation of a freshman series is hardly uncommon, it was the timing of the news, not the decision itself, that may have ended the show's Emmy aspirations.
More from Gold Derby
Zoë Kravitz and Meghann Fahy are the year's biggest Emmy surprises: Poll
'The Pitt,' 'The Studio,' and 'Adolescence' have taken the lead in this pivotal Emmy category
Just one week before Emmy voting began, Étoile was poised for awards consideration. The ballet dramedy marked the return of Amy Sherman-Palladino and Dan Palladino (The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel, Gilmore Girls). The Palladinos are no strangers to Emmy gold, with 10 wins and 24 nominations between them. While Étoile hadn't toped the streamers charts, it was quietly building momentum and Amazon originally committed to two seasons. FYC events were scheduled, and cast appearances had been lined up. The campaign machine appeared to be just getting into full swing.
Then came the surprising announcement, right in the middle of FYC season, and any momentum the show had seemed to have accumulated came to a halt.
In fact, cast members including Yanic Truesdale, Taïs Vinolo, and Ivan du Pontavice were en route to the SCAD Lacoste Film Festival in France when the news broke, and the team had to shift gears. Truesdale, who played Michel in Gilmore Girls, admitted he was disappointed by the cancellation, telling Deadline, 'I was very excited to see the second season because knowing Amy and Dan's writing, they set things in the first season, and then the second season, once everything is established, is really, when they start to fly with the material,' he said.
Though Amazon continued to support the series with billboards and trade ads, the narrative shift was hard to ignore. A cancellation, particularly one announced before nominations are even secured, sends an unintentional message: this show is done.
In an increasingly crowded awards landscape, perception is everything. Had Étoile been allowed to complete its Emmy campaign with even the illusion of future seasons, it might have captured more than two nominations it received in choreography and cinematography — perhaps in production design, costumes, or direction.
Compare that to Netflix's The Residence. Also shuttered after a single season, The Residence managed to sidestep the same buzzkill with the streamer strategically timing its announcement. Netflix waited until July 2, after Emmy voting had closed.
That crucial difference allowed the show to sustain its campaign energy and gave its cast and crew plausible hope. The result? The show landed four nods, including a surprise Best Comedy Actress nomination for Uzo Aduba — an outcome that may have played out very differently if the cancellation news had dropped a few weeks earlier.
A similar situation unfolded in 2021 with Lovecraft Country, which received 18 Emmy nominations for its first season. HBO announced the show's cancellation in July — after voting had ended. Despite the end of the road, the delay in announcing it preserved the show's award-season momentum.
This contrast highlights just how sensitive Emmy campaigns are to timing.
Now, the industry is watching closely to see how Thursday's shocking news that The Late Show With Stephen Colbert has been canceled just two days after receiving an Emmy nomination will affect voters. Once again, it raises the question at the heart of awards season strategy: When it comes to cancellation, does timing make the difference between an Emmy win and a campaign that fades away?
Best of Gold Derby
'Five new life forms from distant planets': Everything to know about 'Alien: Earth' as new trailer drops
Everything to know about 'The Pitt' Season 2, including the departure of Tracy Ifeachor's Dr. Collins
Everything to know about 'Too Much,' Lena Dunham's Netflix TV show starring Megan Stalter that's kinda, sorta 'based on a true story'
Click here to read the full article.
Solve the daily Crossword
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Tom's Guide
21 minutes ago
- Tom's Guide
The best shark movie of the year is now streaming — and it makes ‘Jaws' look like a day at the beach
This year marks the 50th anniversary of the apex shark thriller 'Jaws,' and if Steven Spielberg's masterful classic made you too scared to go swimming in the ocean, wait until you've seen 'Dangerous Animals.' As if an oversized great white with razor-sharp teeth wasn't scary enough, 'Dangerous Animals' increases the fear factor by also throwing a deranged serial killer into the mix, and it's just as unhinged as that sounds. This intense thriller is easily the best shark movie I've seen this year (though the competition isn't fierce with Hulu's 'Into the Deep' a real stinker). This Sean Byrne-directed survival thriller swam into theatres in early June, but it's finally ready to swim into new waters as it's now available to stream on premium video-on-demand via platforms like Amazon and Apple. And this taunt and tense thriller is definitely worth the rental fee. You'll come for the sharks, but trust me, you'll stay for Jai Courtney's deliciously sinister performance. Here's everything you need to know about 'Dangerous Animals.' Zephyr (Hassie Harrison) is an American drifter and surf-obsessive currently trawling through Australia's Gold Coast. After a romantic encounter with realtor Moses (John Heuston), Zephyr's commitment issues surface, and she flees the scene of their hookup. Going for a nighttime surf to clear her head, she encounters Tucker (Jai Courtney), an initially friendly stranger whose horrific true intentions quickly come to light. Abducted by this deranged psychopath, Zephyr awakens handcuffed to a bed in the hull of Tucker's boat. Tucker soon reveals his sadistic ritual, which sees him kidnap victims and then feed them to a pack of hungry sharks while filming the brutal act on a battered old camera. With time ticking away before she becomes fish food herself, Zephyr desperately tries to escape. 'Dangerous Animals' sets out its stall extremely early. The opening sequence introduces us to Tucker, and from this very first appearance, it's abundantly clear that he is somebody best avoided at all costs. It's a shame his first on-screen victims don't see that and pay the price. I've been pretty critical of Jai Courtney's work in awful movies like 2016's 'Suicide Squad' and 'Terminator Genisys' in the past, but the Australian actor absolutely nails his part here. Tucker is the best part of the movie. He's a terrifying presence, completely deranged and downright evil, but Courtney lights up the screen and creates a very memorable antagonist. It's a shame the same can't be said for the hero of the piece, Zephyr. It's not that Hassie Harrison does anything wrong, but the character's arc of transition from a lone-wolf to somebody willing to accept help from others, in this case, Heuston's Moses, is predictable. But really, with a movie like 'Dangerous Animals,' you're not here for the character arcs; it's all about the bloodshed, and this movie does not disappoint. Tucker's cameracord is used quite creatively to give the movie almost a 'snuff film' quality. This really adds to the sense of unease as we see the killer string up victims and plunge them into shark-infested waters. Being attacked by sharks while going for a pleasant swim is one thing to be afraid of, but being tied up, hoisted into the air, and then slowly lowered into a circling pit of sharks is beyond nightmare-inducing, and 'Dangerous Animals' isn't shy about showing the horrific results of Tucker's disturbing method of murder. Those easily frightened should steer clear. Viewers looking for a watertight narrative should probably also give this one a miss. 'Dangerous Animals' has a lot going for it, but it does see character turn off their common sense a little too often, and there are some story beats as flimsy as soggy cardboard. But, for me, these flaws never amounted to more than mere distractions to the real show stealer: Jai Courtney's Tucker, and watching (sometimes through my fingers) his horrific actions. On the surface, 'Dangerous Animals' might have the appearance of a trashy gorefest, but there's quite a bit more to this well-constructed horror-thriller than meets the eye. Director Sean Byrne does a great job contrasting the movie's picturesque location of the Gold Coast with the murderous actions of its antagonist, and the sound design is seriously punchy. For these reasons, and the others highlighted above, I'm not surprised to see that 'Dangerous Animals' was a bit of a critical darling. Shark movies are often dismissed as 'guilty pleasures' or just outright torn to shreds by critics, but not in this case. The movie holds a strong 86% score on Rotten Tomatoes, enough for a 'Certified Fresh' badge. 'Stuffed to the gills with memorable shocks and a thrillingly unhinged heel turn by Jai Courtney, Dangerous Animals will be irresistible chum for horror aficionados,' reads RT's 'Critics Consensus,' and I'm glad to see Courtney's work getting called out for praise. So, if you thought 'Jaws' was too tame, or just want a reason to be absolutely terrified of ever going swimming in the ocean all over again, 'Dangerous Animals' is a shark movie you don't want to skip. Perhaps its biggest strength is that it makes its protagonist unsafe both in the water and on dry land, so there's no escaping or moment to catch your breath. 'Dangerous Animals' isn't the only new movie arriving on streaming this week. Here's a guide to the best new releases across platforms. Plus, horror fans also won't want to miss this new chiller starring Sally Hawkins from the directors behind 2023's 'Talk to Me.'
The Verge
21 minutes ago
- The Verge
Soak up the sunflora this September.
Posted Jul 22, 2025 at 1:27 PM UTC Soak up the sunflora this September. Pokémon Concierge , the adorable stop motion Netflix series, launches its second season very soon. The show, about hospitality worker at a resort exclusively for 'mon and their humans, returns with new episodes September 4th. The announcement came during today's Pokémon Direct and included a brand new trailer featuring all the new poké-friends you'll make.
Gizmodo
21 minutes ago
- Gizmodo
Anker Soundcore 2 Portable Bluetooth Speaker Is Nearly Free, 135K+ Reviewers and 4.6 Stars Can't Be Wrong
Party season is on for a few more weeks, at least for some of us, so it's still a good time to pick up some vibe-setting tech. Outside of good people to hang out with, one of the most important parts of any get-together is a great speaker. There are loads of good options out there, but if you're looking for a great deal, then we've got an excellent choice for you today. Right now, Amazon has 33% off the Anker Soundcore 2 Portable Bluetooth Speaker, which means that instead of the usual price of $45, it's just $30 right now. That's an incredible price, but we're not expecting it to last very long, as this is a limited-time deal. See at Amazon Portable speakers are amazing because you can take them outdoors with you, no matter where you end up, but you can also get a lot of use out of them at home as well. It's amazing to be able to move one of these into whatever room you're hanging out in to continue listening to podcasts, audiobooks, or your favorite albums. We especially love them in the bathroom, but that's because it's the only place the cats can't get into. Look, sometimes you just need a break. This particular speaker is especially good because it has an incredible 24-hour battery life, which means it's going to last long enough to keep the vast majority of parties going. If that's not enough for you though, you can always pair it with a portable power bank, or just use an outlet to charge it while it's in use. It has great sound quality, of course, offering stereo sound despite having such a small size, which means that you'll be able to enjoy whatever it's playing properly. It also has an IPX7 waterproof rating, so you don't have to worry too much if it falls into the pool, or the bath, or if it suddenly starts raining. You can make things even better if you get a couple of these, because you can pair them up together for an even more immersive listening experience. It's easy to justify getting two of them right now too, because at just $30, it's pretty darn affordable. Just keep in mind that this 33% discount won't last forever, so if you do decide to commit to one or more of these, you'll need to act quickly or you'll miss out. See at Amazon
