12 SANDF members in Hawks murder case claim state evidence is weak
They appeared in the Randburg magistrate's court on Tuesday for a bail application. The two defence lawyers read their affidavits regarding their personal circumstances and their involvement in the case.
Most of them stated that they did not believe the state had a solid case against them and that the prospects of a successful prosecution were 'very slim'.
Some of them stated that they were about to carry out a sensitive operation before they were arrested.
They are facing three counts of murder. They also face counts of kidnapping, fraud, obstructing the administration of justice, making false statements under oath and theft of a motor vehicle.
The court ordered that their photographs and names should not be published due to a security risk and an outstanding identity parade, which was yet to be conducted.
The charges stem from the alleged kidnapping of Abdella Hussain Abadiga and Kadir Jemal Abotese at the Mall of Africa on December 29 2022.
Their whereabouts remain unknown. The accused are charged with the murders of Abadiga and Abotese.
Soldiers argued in their affidavits that during the day of the incident, they were conducting a military exercise when the offences of kidnapping and murder were committed.
One of the soldiers was arrested at OR Tambo International Airport. The court heard the member was arrested during his arrival from training.
'I have no knowledge of the alleged deceased. The warrant of arrest didn't contain a charge of murder,' testified one of the soldiers in an affidavit read in court. 'Merits of the matter will be determined later during the trial, should it be held. I submit that the state case is not solid against me ... I opted to play the open cards.
'I have no knowledge of those counts. The charges referred to under these counts are brought with an ulterior motive,' testified another in an affidavit read in court, referring to some of the counts he was facing.
According to the charge sheet, Mathipa, who was tasked with investigating the kidnapping and murders of Abadiga and Abotese, and investigating the involvement of the SANDF members, was killed near the N1 highway in Hammanskraal.
National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) spokesperson Phindi Mjonondwane said the matter was postponed until Thursday to allow the investigating officer to verify some of the addresses that were presented by the accused on their bail applications.
' We will be guided by the investigation process. For now, we would not be in a position to comment much about what will unfold in the case, as investigations are ongoing but safe to say that this prosecution forms part of our broader mandate to deal decisively with organised crime, and also by ensuring that the perpetrators of such crimes are brought to book.
'They come and face justice, as has been the case in this case that is before the court. All accused are subjected to a judicial process, one that will become transparent so that all of society can have their questions answered,' she said.
She said the state was yet to present the evidence of the investigating officer by way of an affidavit that will be presented in court.
TimesLIVE
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
2 hours ago
- The Citizen
‘Police are the chief criminal syndicate': Saps R120bn budget criticised by MPs
Members of Parliament expressed their concerns about corruption in the police service. MPs have sharply criticised the police's budget, with several voicing concerns over persistent corruption in the South African Police Service (Saps). On Friday, Police Minister Senzo Mchunu presented the department's budget for the 2025-2026 financial year at the Good Hope Chamber in Cape Town. The presentation was followed by a debate in which MPs scrutinised both the spending plan and annual performance targets. Mchunu tables Saps budget In his address, Mchunu highlighted the police's key priorities, which include reducing the murder rate, tackling gang violence, addressing gender-based violence and femicide (GBVF) and rooting out corruption. To support these goals, he said several critical enablers had been identified to bolster the crime-fighting strategy. These include strengthening crime intelligence, enhancing forensic services and upgrading infrastructure such as police stations. 'This budget is about improved policing,' Mchunu told MPs. The total allocation for Saps stands at R120.89 billion. ALSO READ: 'No arrest warrant for police crime boss Fannie Masemola', IDAC says Specific allocations include R219.2 million to secure the G20 conference in November 2025, R400 million for the 2026 local government elections and R34.8 million to cover the appointment of an additional deputy minister. Additionally, R150 million is being reallocated from Saps' operational budget to the Directorate for Priority Crime Investigation (DPCI), also known as the Hawks. Mchunu also announced the recruitment of 5 500 new police trainees in January 2026. 'Additionally, 250 police trainees with qualifications in law, forensic investigation and information technology will be placed in the directorate [Hawks] upon completion of their training.' Watch the budget vote debate below: The minister emphasised the need for targeted, intelligence-led deployments in high-crime zones across four provinces, including Gauteng and the Western Cape. He highlighted that R85 million was earmarked for the top 30-plus five high-contact crime stations. Community engagement efforts will receive R28 million for community policing forums (CPFs) and R8.5 million for initiatives such as imbizos. A significant R1.6 billion is allocated to combat GBVF. Infrastructure investment includes R670 million for constructing and upgrading police stations, R20 million for procuring and converting vehicles to enhance mobile service centres and R45 million for day-to-day maintenance of existing facilities. Saps budget criticised While ANC MP Erald Cloete expressed support for the budget, uMkhonto weSizwe (MK) party MP David Skosana rejected the spending plan, saying that South Africans were being 'betrayed by the very same institutions meant to safeguard them'. He accused both Saps and the Independent Police Investigative Directorate (Ipid) of failing in their mandates. Skosana likened the country's crime levels to a war zone and condemned the lack of accountability. 'It is a chilling indictment of a police service that has lost control,' he said on Friday. He warned that if the budget is passed, it would amount to a 'death sentence' for citizens. Skosana also said Ipid's annual performance targets, particularly regarding rape and corruption cases, were 'laughable', 'inadequate' and reflected what he described as an under-resourced institution. He highlighted Ipid's backlog of 10 500 cases and slammed its proposed R428.6 million budget. 'Only R9 million was allocated for forensic investigators. We are essentially throwing a glass of water on a forest fire. [It is] pure strategic failure.' READ MORE: Police sergeant arrested in Kamogelo Baukudi kidnapping case issued suspension letter The MK party member further took aim at Saps' administrative budget. 'R72 billion is set aside for administration, much of which goes to a bloated management structure and a system that seems more interested in sustaining itself than saving the public.' Moreover, Skosana condemned the lack of a concrete strategy to fight internal corruption. 'The so-called lifestyle audits mentioned in the budget are nothing more than a PR exercise. 'Officers implicated in criminality continue to rise through the ranks, protected by political connections and institutionalised silence.' He called for urgent action to reduce case and DNA backlogs, hire more officers and tackle corruption effectively. 'Chief criminal syndicate' Democratic Alliance MP Lisa‐Maré Schickerling also criticised the budget, calling it 'obscene' in the face of the police's declining credibility and rising crime statistics. 'One must ask, are we funding public safety or institutional failure? The reality on the ground is devastating,' she said. Schickerling raised alarm over South Africa's high GBV rates and Ipid's plan to only address 35 rape cases this year. 'That's not a plan, that's an admission of defeat and a resignation letter addressed to every woman that the system has failed.' Despite her concerns, she acknowledged there were some positives in the proposed budget. EFF MP Leigh‐Ann Mathys also rejected the budget, expressing scepticism that it would lead to any real reduction in crime. 'Minister, even if we add your President [Cyril] Ramaphosa's Phala Phala dollars, it is not going to help,' she said. READ MORE: Corruption crisis deepens within Gauteng police force Mathys warned that the reported dysfunction in Saps was a 'tip of the iceberg'. 'If we continue down this path, South Africa is going to lead the world in committing mob justice purely because the police are the chief criminal syndicate,' the EFF MP said. 'We have a history of high-ranking Saps officials caught with their hands in the cookie jar of corruption,' Mathys added. IFP MP Russel Cebekhulu echoed concerns about police corruption, referring to recent arrests of senior crime intelligence officers, including the division's head, Dumisani Khumalo. 'This undermines public trust and threatens the integrity of policing in South Africa,' Cebekhulu said.
Mail & Guardian
2 hours ago
- Mail & Guardian
Judge president's emoji expert disputes accusers's claims
Eastern Cape Judge President Selby Mbenenge. (Nelius Rademan/ Foto24/Gallo Images) A defence witness told a judicial tribunal on Thursday that emojis exchanged in WhatsApp messages between Eastern Cape Judge President Selby Mbenenge and a junior legal professional were consistent with casual conversation, challenging claims that they were used to Information and communications technology expert Vincent Mello testified that the messages — central to a misconduct inquiry against Mbenenge — reflected standard emoji use, citing references from Unicode Consortium and Emojipedia. His analysis countered previous expert evidence which suggested the symbols were deployed with sexualised intent. Mello was called by Mbenenge's legal team to analyse disputed WhatsApp messages between the judge president and legal professional Andiswa Mengo, who has accused him of sending inappropriate messages of a sexual nature over WhatsApp. During the second sitting in May, linguistics specialist Zakeera Docrat testified that emojis had been used for non-standard purposes to depict sexual acts and as a means to sexually harass. Mello told the tribunal that his interpretation revealed the contrary and said his findings relied on the Unicode Consortium standards and Emojipedia, an online reference site that catalogues emoji definitions. His testimony suggested that the tone of the conversation was This contrasts with Mengo's own testimony, in which she described persistent late-night messages, requests for photos and a sense of pressure due to Mbenenge's powerful position. She said his messages were unwanted and inappropriate but she felt unable to challenge him. Under cross-examination by Mbenenge's counsel, Griffiths Madonsela, Mello said that in his analysis of the WhatsApp exchanges, he counted 189 emoji used — 97 by Mbenenge and 69 by Mengo. He told the tribunal that the 'rolling on the floor laughing' emoji was used 27 times by Mbenenge and 28 times by Mengo. The 'see-no-evil monkey' emoji was used 24 times by Mbenenge and 20 times by Mengo. The 'winking face' was used twice by Mbenenge and once by Mengo. Other emojis in the messages included the 'thinking face' and 'face with tongue' — both used by Mbenenge — and the 'flushed face' and 'squinting face with tongue' used by Mengo. Mello interpreted these emojis as casual and in line with standard use. He also noted the use of the 'peach' and 'eggplant' emojis — widely regarded as suggestive symbols for buttocks and male genitalia, respectively — while notable, could not be attributed any specific intent. Mello further testified that a portion of the WhatsApp messages exchanged between the two — from 22 June to 8 July 2021 — was missing from the record, making the communication incomplete. He suggested that the missing messages raised questions about the integrity of the evidence. The WhatsApp messages have been a central feature in the case, which has grappled with interpreting the tone and content of the digital exchanges between Mbenenge and Mengo. In May, digital forensic analyst François Muller, However, Mello told the tribunal that he had only examined data extracted from one of the phones — the one provided to him by Mbenenge's legal team — and not the full set of data Muller had reviewed. This drew criticism from evidence leader Salome Scheepers, who questioned whether Mello's opinion was informed by a complete dataset. Scheepers also challenged Mello's qualifications, arguing that he lacked the forensic and linguistic expertise necessary to interpret digital evidence, specifically the contextual nuances of emoji use. In May, Docrat warned that emojis were not neutral symbols and could vary in meaning depending on the recipient's interpretation, the platform and the interpersonal history between the communicators. Scheepers drew on Docrat's earlier testimony to argue that Mello's approach — which focused on Unicode definitions — was too narrow. She pressed Mello on the variability of emoji meanings across different devices and social contexts, noting that the same emoji could convey different messages, depending on the relationship between the users. Scheepers further said some emojis, such as the 'see-no-evil monkey', could be interpreted flirtatiously — an interpretation not captured by standard references nor by Mello's interpretation. Mello maintained that his role was technical and not interpretive. He also cast doubt on the authenticity of certain images included in Mengo's complaint. According to him, the photos she claimed were sent by Mbenenge did not match WhatsApp's metadata structure. The tribunal has also heard arguments about CCTV footage allegedly missing from the court building on the date Mengo said she was harassed. Scheepers confirmed during cross-examination in May that some footage from the relevant day was no longer available, despite requests from the tribunal. The lack of CCTV evidence has further complicated the tribunal's efforts to establish a definitive timeline of events. Mengo, who testified earlier in the year, maintained that Mbenenge made sexual advances, sent inappropriate messages and exposed himself to her at the Mthatha high court buildings. Her testimony was supported by screenshots and messages, although she admitted under cross-examination that some conversations had continued beyond the alleged incidents. The defence has argued that Mengo's continued engagement with the judge — with light-hearted emojis and informal language — contradicts her claims of persistent harassment. The defence said Mengo had reciprocated with messages that reflected a cordial relationship. Strengthening the defence's case, Mbenenge's witness, former secretary Zintle Nkqayi, The tribunal is expected to conclude on 11 July, before which Mbenenge will take the witness stand.
The Herald
7 hours ago
- The Herald
Man spotted carrying a printer near guesthouse led to fake cash bust
The three men arrested in connection with a counterfeit money racket in Pretoria are Cameroonian nationals. National Prosecuting Authority spokesperson Lumka Mahanjana said Philliph Mumbai, 42, exited an e-hailing service vehicle in Elardus Park and was walking to a nearby guesthouse when he was stopped by patrolling police officers on July 1. "They questioned him about a printing machine he was carrying and where he was headed. When he could not answer, the police requested t he take them to the guesthouse. On arrival, they discovered Maxwell Basong, 39, and Tieze Zemeniouh, 38, operating a similar printing machine and printing counterfeit money. "During the arrest, Mumbai allegedly attempted to bribe the officers with R2,000 in exchange for their release." The men have appeared in the Pretoria magistrate's court on a charge of possession of counterfeit goods. Mumbai also faces a charge of corruption. The case was postponed to July 10. Mahanjana said: "It is alleged the three accused operated a syndicate involved in the printing and distribution of counterfeit rand and US dollar notes. The counterfeit money was allegedly sold and used to purchase goods." TimesLIVE
