Employers' national insurance rise ‘straw that breaks camels back', Lords told
Crossbench peer Lord Morse, former head of the National Audit Office, warned that 'not all big businesses have equally broad shoulders' as he said the Government had not considered the 'differential damage' of the move.
Chancellor Rachel Reeves announced a hike to employer national insurance contributions (NIC) in the autumn budget, with the aim of raising around £25 billion a year.
Lord Morse told peers: 'Employer national insurance has no direct relationship to that employer's profitability, and thus to that employer's ability to pay more tax.
'If an employer happens to be in an industry that habitually has payroll costs of a relatively high proportion of its total expenditure, it will necessarily attract a higher cost from the increase in employer national insurance, that if it had that same turnover and spent a lower percentage of its outgoing costs on payroll, but, for example, a higher amount on technology, data and other non-labour costs.
'If a business has a very substantial turnover, but relatively low margins, such as a lot of the major construction contractors…that its ability to pay more national insurance may be much less than it would be in another more profitable sector.
'Not all big businesses have equally broad shoulders. I know that's a popular government expression, and some big businesses may find the additional NIC charge very much more damaging than others. It may even be the final straw that breaks the camel's back, in some cases.
'Different industries form larger or smaller proportions of economic activity in different areas of the UK, and they tend to be concentrated.
'If a high proportion of local business activity happens to be in a high payroll model of business this means that the local economy is likely to be disproportionately impacted, and we are hearing examples of that in Northern Ireland, but it's not just there.
'It's not rocket science. I'm saying I must admit, but I'm not sure that HM Government has considered these points of differential damage, if not, they should do so.'
The debate on Monday evening was called by DUP peer Lord Morrow who said the Government had not given thought to the 'disproportionately negative impact' removal of agricultural property relief and increases to employer national insurance would have on Northern Ireland.
He told peers: 'The Government's plans are detrimental in many ways, but not least the reality that many businesses will be simply unable to absorb the increased cost of national insurance contributions or the inflation-busting wage increases, but the bill still has to be paid, and this will be shifted onto the consumer, who will have to contend with higher prices amidst an extremely difficult time for many families across Northern Ireland.
'In Northern Ireland, the rise in the rate of national insurance contributions from 13.8% to 15% will hit our agricultural sector hard.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
WIRED
an hour ago
- WIRED
Photos: Here Are the Piles of Used Bedding and Children's Play Sets Left Near DOGE's Old Offices
Jul 23, 2025 1:17 PM Elon Musk's DOGE minions have largely moved out of the General Services Administration. A dystopian scene of bedding and discarded kids' toys remains. Elon Musk's associates at the so-called Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) have begun vacating their headquarters at the General Services Administration (GSA) in Washington, DC. An apocalyptic scene of toddler play sets, mattresses, and pillows remains. Near rooms where DOGE once operated, a seemingly abandoned children's wooden kitchen set sits next to a rainbow climbing arch and an easel covered in crumpled paper, according to photos obtained by WIRED. Other children's toys are within reach, with colorful books and other playthings neatly organized in white plastic bins. A few related items are strewn about the floor. Nearby, trash bags stuffed with pillows and five mattresses, some with sheets and mattress toppers still on them, are stuffed in a corner. It looks like a scene out of a zombie movie, where villagers had to flee in the middle of the night to avoid a raid. But it's not a movie; it's the aftermath of DOGE's wholescale assault on the GSA, and the federal government writ large. DOGE isn't gone, but as it morphs into its new phase, post-Musk's chainsaw-style leadership, the children's toys have been left behind. GSA did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Mattresses have been left behind at GSA. Courtesy of WIRED Source Chairs are piled up all over the office. Courtesy of WIRED Source Pillows have been stuffed in garbage bags. Courtesy of WIRED Source In January, after president Donald Trump's inauguration, Musk's DOGE took over a few key government agencies that provided the keys to dozens of others, including the Office of Personnel Management, which functions as the federal HR system, and the GSA, the government's operations and IT department. Steve Davis and Nicole Hollander, two longtime Musk lieutenants who played a crucial role in Musk's acquisition of X, were listed as high-level GSA employees, according to directory screenshots obtained by WIRED. (Davis and Hollander are partners and have a child together. During Musk's acquisition of X, they moved into the company's office building in San Francisco with their newborn baby.) Thomas Shedd, a former Tesla engineer, became the director of the GSA's Technology Transformation Services division. A number of young, inexperienced technologists, as WIRED first reported, were also brought to the GSA: Edward Coristine, a former Neuralink intern, and Ethan Shaotran, a student at Harvard, joined the agency as well. Davis, Hollander, Coristine, and Shaotran all had A-suite access, linking them to the highest levels of the GSA org chart. At the GSA, DOGE set up shop on the sixth floor of the office building. The area where they worked, which had previously been open, was redesigned to accommodate a locked door, a key card to swipe in, and a security guard. Longtime GSA employees reported seeing groups of young men walking around the office dressed in t-shirts and shorts, and, in some cases, wearing sunglasses. In March, GSA acting administrator Stephen Ehikian hosted an all hands meeting with GSA staff. During a Q&A, he was asked about the DOGE team at GSA. He responded that no such team existed. Many employees were in disbelief. 'Like we didn't notice a bunch of young kids working behind a secure area on the 6th floor,' a GSA employee told WIRED. Children's toys and play sets have been abandoned at GSA. Courtesy of WIRED Source Multiple bed frames have been piled in a corner. Courtesy of WIRED Source Furniture has been packed into a room near DOGE's old offices. Courtesy of WIRED Source That sixth floor of the GSA office is now open to other employees, following Musk, Davis, and Hollander's apparent step back from DOGE in May. On Monday, President Donald Trump announced Michael Rigas, deputy secretary of state for management and resources, as the new acting administrator of the GSA, according to an internal memo viewed by WIRED. The move effectively sidelines Ehikian, who enthusiastically carried out the DOGE agenda during his tenure as the acting administrator. Ehikian's wife previously worked as a designer at Musk's social networking company X. But DOGE is not entirely gone from GSA—DOGE associates Nate Cavanaugh and Justin Fox have been seen in the office in recent weeks, multiple sources confirm to WIRED. And while DOGE has lost its flashy leadership, WIRED has reported that the so-called agency has continued embedding itself throughout the government, leading projects and cutting contracts.
Bloomberg
2 hours ago
- Bloomberg
Allegra Stratton: Can the Lionesses Bring Starmer Luck?
As well as England's women's football team getting through to the finals of the Euros last night, Keir Starmer will also be very pleased to see Narendra Modi step off the plane tonight. This is government as anyone would like it. Alongside a beautiful goal in extra time to send the Lionesses through to the final (the government has announced their manager will get a damehood should they win), the sight of the Indian prime minister arriving tonight will also be a happy one for Starmer. If he chose to, he could squint and just focus on these two things for few days, and all would be well.
Washington Post
3 hours ago
- Washington Post
Ukrainians are protesting a law targeting anti-corruption agencies. Here's why
KYIV, Ukraine — Ukrainians are taking to the streets to protest a new law they worry will undermine the work of two key anti-corruption agencies , by eroding the independence of bodies meant to provide a check on power. Discontent over the law led to the first major demonstration against the government in more than three years of war, marking the most serious fracture yet in the national unity that has helped Ukraine resist Russia's invasion.
