Italy minister warns concert with pro-Putin conductor risks turning into propaganda coup
FILE PHOTO: Russian President Vladimir Putin (L) awards Mariinsky Theatre's Artistic Director Valery Gergiev during a ceremony at the Kremlin in Moscow, Russia, September 22, 2016. REUTERS/Ivan Sekretarev/Pool/File Photo
ROME - A concert in Italy by a top Russian conductor shunned in the West since the invasion of Ukraine could send the wrong message, the Italian culture minister said on Tuesday, stopping short of asking organisers to cancel it.
Valery Gergiev - regarded as close to Russian President Vladimir Putin - is expected to lead a local orchestra and soloists from St Petersburg's Mariinsky Orchestra on July 27 at the Reggia di Caserta palace near Naples.
The event has drawn protests from Italian politicians and international activists, including the wife of late Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny, who have all urged Italy to cancel it.
"There is a big problem" with the festival, Yulia Navalnaya wrote in an op-ed on Tuesday's la Repubblica newspaper, calling Gergiev a "conscious and active accomplice of Putin's regime".
Gergiev, 72, did not immediately comment.
Italy's Culture Minister Alessandro Giuli said in a statement: "Art is free and cannot be censored. Propaganda, however, even if done with talent, is something else."
The minister said that the concert could "turn a high-level but objectively controversial and divisive musical event into a sounding board for Russian propaganda".
Top stories
Swipe. Select. Stay informed.
Singapore Las Vegas Sands' new development part of S'pore's broader, more ambitious transformation: PM Wong
Singapore Current economic headwinds do not dampen outlook for new MBS building: Las Vegas Sands president
Business MAS records net profit of $19.7 billion, fuelled by investment gains
Singapore $3b money laundering case: MinLaw acts against 4 law firms and 1 lawyer over seized properties
Singapore Man charged with attempted murder of woman at Kallang Wave Mall
Singapore Ex-cleaner jailed over safety lapses linked to guard's death near 1-Altitude rooftop bar
Singapore Singapore CDL's long-time director Phillip Yeo to depart after boardroom feud
Singapore 'Nobody deserves to be alone': Why Mummy and Acha have fostered over 20 children in the past 22 years
Giuli added that the centre-left regional authority of Campania, which organised and paid for the "Un'Estate da RE" festival, was free to choose which events to host.
The president of Campania, Vincenzo De Luca, rejected criticism, telling reporters that blocking cultural exchanges "does not help peace, but only serves to fuel the rivers of hatred".
De Luca, a critic of Israel's military campaign in Gaza, said last week Gergiev had been invited, along with Israeli conductor Daniel Oren, to keep "channels of communication open even with those who do not think like us".
Italy's right-wing government has supported Ukraine and international sanctions against Moscow.
In 2022, several Western cultural institutions, including Milan's La Scala, the Munich Philharmonic Orchestra and New York's Carnegie Hall, severed ties with Gergiev over his failure to condemn Russia's invasion of Ukraine.
A year after, he was made director of Moscow's Bolshoi Theatre, despite being banished from many international concert halls.
Navalny's Anti-Corruption Foundation wrote last week to the Italian interior minister, urging him to deny entry to Gergiev, and to the culture minister and the director of the Reggia di Caserta asking them to cancel the concert. REUTERS
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
23 minutes ago
- Straits Times
How real is Trump's U-turn on Ukraine?
The reversal is significant given the US President's previous views on Putin, but the sanctions grace period and Trumpian fickleness are reasons for caution. For the first time since he returned to power, US President Donald Trump is now explicitly blaming Russia for the continuation of Europe's bloodiest conflict since World War II. 'We want to make sure Ukraine can do what it wants to do.' That statement from US President Donald Trump on July 14 marked a U-turn on his previous position on support for the Ukrainians , locked in a brutal, bloody war against Russian invaders, now in its fourth year. In typical Trump fashion, the remarks made at a White House meeting with Nato secretary-general Mark Rutte were both imprecise and an exaggeration. It is still far from clear how much in terms of weapons and money Mr Trump is willing to contribute to Ukraine's war against Russia. And it's doubtful that the American President truly intends to give the Ukrainians a free hand to decide their future.
Straits Times
23 minutes ago
- Straits Times
Ukraine says Russian strikes kills three in the east
Find out what's new on ST website and app. A man riding a bicycle beneath anti-drone nets in Orikhiv, in Ukraine's Zaporizhzhia region, on July 15. KYIV - A combined Russian strike on the afternoon of July 15 killed three people in eastern Ukraine, local authorities said, after US President Donald Trump gave Moscow 50 days to reach a peace deal with Ukraine. Russia has been stepping up its summer offensive campaign as Washington-mediated ceasefire talks stall, claiming more ground in eastern Ukraine while pounding it with combined drone, artillery and missile strikes. 'Two dead and two injured: law enforcement officers recorded the consequences of another enemy attack in the Kupiansk district,' the Kharkiv region prosecutor's office said on social media, adding that the victims were 67 and 69 years old. Regional authorities in Sumy said a 50-year-old local resident had died after 'the enemy fired artillery at the outskirts of the Velykopysarivska community'. Elsewhere on the front line, Russian forces claimed two more villages in the Donetsk region, increasing the pace of their advance. A Ukrainian drone attack on Russia's western city of Voronezh wounded 27 people, local officials claimed on July 15. Mr Trump said he had struck a deal with Nato to supply American air defence systems and weapons to Ukraine and threatened Russia with tariffs and sanctions, as he grows frustrated with Russian leader Vladimir Putin for rejecting a ceasefire and instead intensifying attacks. AFP
Straits Times
36 minutes ago
- Straits Times
Britain's Tara Moore handed four-year ban after CAS upholds ITIA appeal
Find out what's new on ST website and app. Tara Moore, Britain's former number one-ranked doubles player, ate contaminated meat but was not able to show that the doping violation was not intentional. LONDON - Britain's Tara Moore, who was previously cleared of an anti-doping rule violation (ADRV), was handed a four-year ban on July 15 after the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) upheld an appeal filed by the International Tennis Integrity Agency (ITIA). Moore, Britain's former number one-ranked doubles player, was provisionally suspended in June 2022 due to the presence of prohibited anabolic steroids Nandrolone and boldenone. Moore said she had never knowingly taken a banned substance in her career and an independent tribunal determined that contaminated meat consumed by her in the days before sample collection was the source of the prohibited substance. Moore lost 19 months in the process before she was cleared of the ADRV but CAS upheld the ITIA's appeal against the first instance 'No Fault or Negligence' ruling with respect to nandrolone. 'After reviewing the scientific and legal evidence, the majority of the CAS Panel considered that the player did not succeed in proving that the concentration of nandrolone in her sample was consistent with the ingestion of contaminated meat,' CAS said in a statement. 'The panel concluded that Ms Moore failed to establish that the ADRV was not intentional. The appeal by the ITIA is therefore upheld and the decision rendered by the Independent Tribunal is set aside.' Moore had previously said how she saw her reputation, ranking and livelihood 'slowly trickling away' for 19 months during her initial suspension. The 32-year-old had also filed a cross-appeal at CAS 'seeking to dismiss the ITIA appeal, dismiss the nandrolone result in the ADRV or alternatively confirm that she bears no fault or negligence'. However, CAS said the cross-appeal was declared inadmissible and her four-year period of ineligibility would start from July 15, with credit for any provisional suspension that has already been served. 'Our bar for appealing a first instance decision is high, and the decision is not taken lightly,' ITIA chief executive officer Karen Moorhouse said in a statement. 'In this case, our independent scientific advice was that the player did not adequately explain the high level of nandrolone present in their sample. Today's ruling is consistent with this position.' REUTERS
