Health researchers, MPI clash as study finds campylobacter cases have surged
Photo:
Supplied
Too many people are still ending up sick and in hospital from contaminated fresh chicken meat, public health professionals say.
New analysis released by the Public Health Communication Centre (PHCC) on Thursday shows hospitalisation rates for campylobacter infection have increased by almost 70 percent in 17 years. The study found contaminated fresh
chicken meat
remained the dominant source, causing an estimated 77 percent of infections.
But the Ministry for Primary Industries (MPI) has disputed the figures and is accusing the researchers of scaremongering.
The PHCC study noted that, in 2007, regulatory measures were introduced to reduce contamination levels in fresh chicken meat tested in processing plants. Rates of both hospitalisation and notification halved in just a few months as a result.
But since 2008,
contaminated chicken in New Zealand
caused more than 600,000 symptomatic illnesses, over 9000 hospitalisations, at least 60 deaths and around $1.4 billion in economic costs.
Lead author, University of Otago professor Michael Baker, said that in 2023, the year with the most recent data, there were nearly a thousand hospitalisations. "By any means this is a very consequential health problem and we feel it needs a much more vigorous response."
Government agencies were "too complacent" about the increasing rates of campylobacter infection caused by contaminated chicken, he added.
"If you saw a 70 percent rise in our most common foodborne disease surely you'd be putting a lot of effort into investigating that to figure out what's going on, and I'm not aware of any effort going into that. One of the major problems that we're seeing is our agencies have become very complacent about this infection."
The government should consider a formal inquiry into this serious, long-term regulatory failure, Baker said.
"The
large Havelock North waterborne outbreak
of campylobacter infection [in 2016] resulted in an exhaustive inquiry and a complete reorganisation of the drinking water supply sector. That common source outbreak caused about 7570 cases. By comparison, the 'common source' epidemic caused by contaminated chicken meat results in the equivalent of a Havelock North-sized outbreak every three months in NZ, or 80 such outbreaks since 2008."
But Food Safety's deputy director-general Vincent Arbuckle disagreed with the PHCC's analysis, arguing that between 2006 and 2020 reported rates of foodborne campylobacter infections had halved. These figures were based on public notifications of infections provided by the health system, he said.
"In 2020 New Zealand Food Safety set the target of reducing the rate by a further 20 percent. This milestone was reached at the end of 2024, when rates of foodborne campylobacter infections acquired in New Zealand fell to 70 cases per 100,000.
The drop in infection was thanks to a "concerted effort over many years" from government, scientists and industry throughout the supply chain, he said.
"New Zealand has made considerable reductions in campylobacter infections. We keep an open mind about changes that can further reduce campylobacteria infection, which is a serious foodborne illness, but will not consider changes that are not founded on good evidence."
Arbuckle accepted more people were ending up in hospital with campylobacter but says that was partly because they had put off going to the GP and got sicker, he said.
He also agreed that campylobacteriosis was "the most common, significant foodborne illness in New Zealand".
But he said data suggested "a continued downward reduction due to the sustained efforts between industry, health authorities, the regulator and other parts of the sector such as retail".
"The prevalence [of campylobacteriosis] is reducing, it's not where people would like it to be, but some of the content in this report is simply erroneous and alarmist, particularly the comments about deaths attributed - the simple fact is that ... since 2007 we've had three recorded cases of death where campylobacteriosis was the principle single contributing factor, not 60 as he [Baker] suggests.
"If New Zealand was experiencing the level of deaths directly attributable to campylobacteriosis at the numbers that the authors suggest, there would be an outcry."
But Baker said that deaths from campylobacter infection were generally poorly diagnosed and recorded. By looking at hospital discharge data, however, the researchers were able to get an indication of deaths in hospital with 60 reported deaths for patients with a discharge diagnosis of campylobacter infection as the principal or additional diagnosis over the 14-year period from 2008 to 2021, an average of 4.3 per year. An additional estimated 12 deaths from Guillain-Barré syndrome (GBS) from this source took the total to 68 in the 17-year period, or four per year.
In a statement, Poultry Industry Association executive director Michael Brooks said he agreed the paper was "unnecessarily alarmist".
"The poultry industry works closely with NZ Food Safety and met their set targets to further reduce campylobacter by 20% by 2024," he said.
"We have also met the standards of the National Microbial Database. NZ Food Safety assesses that Michael Baker's paper has significant limitations and relies on several incorrect assumptions and unsupported estimates to reach its conclusions."
The study's co-author, University of Otago Professor Nick Wilson defended their research on
Morning Report
, saying hospitalisation data is the most reliable source to understand what's happening with this "epidemic".
"They're [MPI] focusing on the wrong data. You need to take a broad comprehensive picture that includes looking at the hospitalisations and deaths. Hospitalisations are far more reliable then the data sources that they're focusing on," he said.
"They're just not taking a proper health perspective. You'd expect that a watchdog that's meant to be protecting public health and protecting food safety, it [MPI] just doesn't have a health focus."
MPI looks like they are protecting their own reputation, Prof Wilson said.
"This is a health problem... You need health experts. It's out of their ballpark."
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
9 hours ago
- RNZ News
Christchurch Hospital asks patients' families to help cover short staffing
Christchurch Hospital had so few healthcare assistants on 22 June that managers were asked to see if patients' family members could come in to sit with them. Photo: RNZ / Nate McKinnon Relatives of distressed patients at Christchurch Hospital have been asked to come in to help because of a shortage of healthcare assistants. Information provided by a Christchurch Hosptial staff member, who asked not to be named, shows the hospital had so few healthcare assistants on 22 June that managers were asked to see if patients' family members could come in to sit with them. New Zealand Nurses Organisation delegate Al Dietschin said the request related to patient watches, which were usually done by the assistants to monitor people for confusion, delirium, or dementia symptoms. "Essentially being with the patient to keep them safe, to try and de-escalate when they get agitated, to prevent them from hurting themselves through a fall, or interrupting therapy like pulling on IV lines or catheters. It is a role that is very important for patient safety," he said. Dietschin said relatives were sometimes asked to come in if a patient was particularly agitated and staff believed they would benefit from having a family member with them, but the 22 June request for people to come in or stay longer appeared to come from a need to cover a staffing shortfall. He said patient watch training for healthcare assistant was often inadequate so it was even harder for family members to know what to do. "I've spoken to family members before who are exhausted themselves and haven't been coping with the patient at home, expecting them to come in and deal with them at the hospital setting is not any better," he said. Dietschin said the shortage of healthcare assistants at public hospitals had been an issue for some time because of underfunding and employment freezes. Some casual staff were not getting shifts so it appeared that roster gaps were being left unfilled rather than people being unavailable, he said. Dietchin said healthcare assistants always appreciated help from families but it was unacceptable for hospital managers to expect them to take on the role of employed staff. Health New Zealand's Cantebury director of nursing Becky Hickmott said there was a large volume of patients, coupled with a significant number of staff who rang in sick at short notice. "We worked hard to meet the demand and ensure all patients were seen and cared for appropriately. We also looked to cohort patients that required closer observation," she said. "Where it was known family members were coming in to be with their loved one this allowed nursing resources to be allocated slightly differently - knowing a family member was at the bedside of the patient and hence could escalate any care concerns as required. It was not suggested family would provide care." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
19 hours ago
- RNZ News
Call for wider consultation on memorial for patients' unmarked graves
Some of the pegs marking the burial places of former patients of Porirua Hospital, buried in unmarked graves at Porirua Cemetery. Photo: Supplied/ Porirua City Council A memorial is being set up to recognise the more than 1800 former patients of Porirua Hospital who were buried in unmarked graves. Porirua City Council is creating the memorial and Pacific leaders want to be meaningfully involved in the process, by incorporating prayer, language and ceremonial practices. More than 50 people gathered at Porirua Cemetery in June, after the council's plans became public, many of whom were descendants of those buried without headstones. Porirua cemeteries manager Daniel Chrisp was encouraged to see families engaging with the project. Daniel Chrisp speaks at a Family Forum held beside the Porirua Cemetery chapel. Photo: Supplied/ Facebook - Friends of Porirua Cemetery Chrisp's team placed 99 pegs to mark the graves of families who had come forward so far and he said one attendee told him it was deeply moving to photograph the site where two relatives were buried. "It's fantastic that we've got to this point, having the descendants of those in unmarked graves encouraged to be involved," Chrisp said. "These plots represent mothers, fathers, brothers, sisters, children and other relatives, so it's important to a lot of people." The Porirua Lunatic Asylum, which later became Porirua Hospital, operated from 1887 until the 1990s. At its peak in the 1960s, it was one of Aotearoa New Zealand's largest hospitals, housing more than 2000 patients and staff. As part of the Royal Commission of Inquiry into Abuse in Care, the government established a national fund for headstones for unmarked graves. Porirua City Council applied for $200,000 to install a memorial that would list every known name. However, some Pacific community leaders say they were never consulted, despite Pacific people being among the deceased. Porirua Cook Islands Association chairperson Teurukura Tia Kekena said this was the first she had heard of the project and was concerned Pacific communities had not been included in conversations so far. "If there was any unmarked grave and the Porirua City Council is aware of the names, I would have thought they would have contacted the ethnic groups these people belonged to," she says. "From a Cook Islands point of view, we need to acknowledge these people. They need to be fully acknowledged." Porirua Hospital in the early 1900s. Photo: Supplied / Porirua City Council Kekena learned about the project only after being contacted by a reporter, despite the council's ongoing efforts to identify names and place markers for families who had come forward. The council's application for funding was part of its response to the Royal Commission of Inquiry. Kekena said it was important how the council managed the memorial, adding that it mattered deeply for Cook Islands families and the wider Pacific community, especially those with relatives buried at the site. She believed a proper memorial should reflect Pacific values, particularly the importance of faith, family and cultural protocol. "It's huge," she said. "It's connecting us to these people - just thinking about it is getting me emotional. "Like I said, the Pākehā way of acknowledging is totally different from our way. When we acknowledge, when we go for an unveiling, it's about family. "It's about family. It's about family honouring the person that had passed and we do it in a way that we have a service at the graveside with the orometua [minister] present. "Yeah, unveil the stone by the family, by the immediate family, if there were any here at that time." She also underscored the connection between remembering the deceased and healing intergenerational trauma, particularly given the site's history with mental health. "It helps a lot, it's a way of healing the trauma. I don't know how these people came to be buried in an unmarked grave, but to me, it's like they were just put there and forgotten about. "I wouldn't like to have my family buried in a place and be forgotten." Kekena urged the council to work closely with the Cook Islands community moving forward, and said she would bring the matter back to her association to raise awareness and check possible connections between local families and the names identified. Yvonne Underhill‑Sem, a Cook Islands community leader and professor of Pacific studies at the University of Auckland, said the memorial had emotional significance, noting her personal connection as a Porirua native to Whenua Tapu , another Porirua cemetery. "In terms of our Pacific understandings of ancestry, everybody who passes away is still part of our whānau," she said. "The fact that we don't know who they are is unsettling. "It would be a real relief to the families involved and to the generations that follow to have those graves named." A Porirua City Council spokesperson said they had actively shared the list of names with the public and encouraging all communities, including Pacific groups, genealogists and local iwi, to help spread the word. So far, 99 families had come forward. "We would encourage any networks, such as Pacific, genealogists and local iwi, to share the list around for members of the public to get in touch," the spokesperson said. The list of names is available on the council's website and includes both a downloadable file and a searchable online tool . Porirua City Councillors Izzy Ford and Moze Galo say the memorial must reflect Pacific values. Photo: Supplied/ Porirua City Council - RNZ Porirua City Councillors Izzy Ford and Moze Galo - two of the three Pacific members on the council - said Pacific families must be central to the memorial process. Ford said burial sites carried deep cultural weight for Pacific communities. "We know that burial sites are more than just places of rest,"Ford said. "They are sacred spaces that hold our stories, our ancestry and dignity - they are our connection to those who came before us." Public notices and websites were not enough, she said. "If we are serious about finding the families of those buried in unmarked graves here in Porirua, we have to go beyond public notices and websites." Government funding would be limited and council must work with trusted Pacific networks to reach families, Ford said. "It means partnering with groups who carry trust in our community... Pacific churches, elders and organisations communicating in our languages through Pacific radio, social media, community events, churches and health providers." Galo agreed, and said the memorial must reflect Pacific values in both design and feeling. "It should feel warm, colourful, spiritual and welcoming," he said. "Include Pacific designs, carvings and symbols... there should be room for prayer, music and quiet reflection. "Being seen and heard brings healing, honour, and helps restore our connection to our ancestors. It reminds our families that we belong, that our history matters and that our voice is valued in this space." Galo said the work must continue beyond the unveiling. "Community involvement shouldn't stop after the memorial is built. We should have a role in how it's maintained and used in the future. "These were real people with families, love and lives that mattered. Some were buried without names, without ceremony and that left a deep pain. "Honouring them now is a step toward healing and a way of saying, 'You were never forgotten'." Members of the public who recognise a family name on the list are encouraged to get in touch, by emailing cemeteries@ LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.
RNZ News
a day ago
- RNZ News
Vigilance, not luck, helping NZ avoid widespread measles outbreak
A paediatrician specialising in infectious diseases says the increase in measles cases in the lower North Island is an unfortunate example of just how infectious it is. The current outbreak in Wairarapa and Manawatū reached eight cases on Thursday. Health NZ says the cases stemmed from overseas travel. Dr Emma Best from the Immunisation Advisory Centre said measles "seeks out" people and young children who were not immunised. "If you're not immune to measles, and you are in the space of somebody who has measles or doesn't know they're getting measles, there's a very, very high chance that you will get measles," she said. "The spread, the fact that the close contacts of the returned traveller sequentially... we're getting more cases, is unfortunately expected." With outbreaks in Canada, Australia, parts of the United States and southeast Asia, Best said it was important overseas travellers were vaccinated against measles. Auckland also saw a measles outbreak earlier in the winter . Best said vigilance, not luck, meant New Zealand had avoided an outbreak on the scale of other countries so far. "We've been incredibly vigilant, which is great, and really carefully managing this should there be any single cases that occur, but actually, this has got away from most other countries in the world. "We know that it's out there, so with any traveller or returned traveller from pretty much any region in the world now, there's going to be some risk. "New Zealand is working incredibly hard to keep ourselves safe from measles, and that primarily starts with making sure we vaccinate our own population really well and making sure that anyone who travels know they need to be vaccinated, including infants younger than one." In New Zealand, babies typically received their first measles vaccine (MMR) at 12 months of age and the second at 15 months, but Best said young infants travelling abroad could receive the vaccine to protect them before they go away. It was "really stressful and concerning" to see people in hospital with diseases, such as measles, that there were vaccinations for, she added. "Most people want the best for their kids, they want to get vaccinations, they want to have conversations about it. We have got poor rates of vaccinations since Covid, but we're working extra hard to get the message out there." Anyone travelling overseas with a young child needed to make sure they had all their vaccinations. "Definitely having a conversation about the measles vaccination, which we can give early in the context of travel, means we can give it to younger than one year of age to protect an infant who's going on a plane, in transit, those types of thing. "Prepare yourself for travel and stay vigilant when you return for measles-type rashes as well." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
