Jury told to find Garda not guilty on five of 22 allegations related to motoring prosecutions
Tom Flavin, (51), Rathkeale Garda Station, Co Limerick, should be acquitted of all of the charges as there is no real evidence against him, his barrister, senior counsel, Mark Nicholas, said in his closing speech to the jury.
Advertisement
Mr Flavin went on trial before Limerick Circuit Criminal Court on May 27th accused of 22 counts of attempting to pervert the course of justice.
Today, senior prosecuting counsel, Fiona Murphy, told the jury they were to find Mr Flavin not guilty of five of the charges and that they would consider verdicts on the 17 remaining counts.
Mr Flavin, who denies all the charges, is accused of attempting to pervert the course of justice by entering false motor insurance details on the Garda Pulse records computer system, in an attempt to frustrate potential prosecutions against persons for driving without insurance.
The drivers involved were stopped at routine Garda checkpoints around the country and asked by the garda present to produce their insurance and licence details at a nominated Garda station within 10 days of the traffic stop.
Advertisement
All of the drivers asked to do this nominated Rathkeale Garda Station.
Later, when the investigating garda in each of the stops carried out follow-up checks of Pulse, they were satisfied that details entered into the system indicated that the driver in each case was insured. However, the court heard the drivers were not insured, and some were even prosecuted in court afterwards after pleading guilty to driving without insurance at the time they were stopped.
In his closing speech to the jury, Mr Nicholas SC, instructed by solicitor Dan O'Gorman, described Mr Flavin as an exemplary garda who had served with dedication in Croom and Rathkeale, Co Limerick, for many years.
Urging the jury to acquit Mr Flavin and not fall into the trap of speculation, Mr Nicholas added there was radically insufficient evidence to support a conviction.
Advertisement
'He served his community without blemish and without any disciplinary blots - you know that from the evidence. When other Gardai came to give evidence, his superiors, they spoke of him very fondly and well - It wasn't far off gushing, and they spoke with knowledge,' Mr Nicholas told the jury.
The defence barrister spoke of the 'unique challenges' Gardai face in Rathkeale as opposed to other jurisdictions.
'People who live down here know it has an enormous population, transient, in and out at various times of the year. One policeman said (the population) quadruples and with that comes its own set of problems and own sets of vehicles - UK car registrations, UK insurance, some not insured, some not being entirely truthful.'
'We know that a certain number of times that people who were pulled up and stopped and asked for their documentation, produced bogus insurance certificates.'
Advertisement
Mr Nicholas said the charge of attempting to pervert the course of justice is an extraordinarily serious allegation to make against a serving Garda.
'That he (Mr Flavin) must have deliberately, knowing the (insurance) certificate to be false, inputted it into the system with the intention that it would frustrate a prosecution. There has been nothing close to this level of proof in this case whatsoever,' added Mr Nicholas.
The court heard evidence of persons providing documents at Rathkeale Garda station, however it was unclear who exactly produced what at the Garda station, and what exactly was produced.
Fiona Murphy SC, prosecuting, said all of the relevant data entries onto Pulse 'were entered under the ID of Thomas Flavin'.
Advertisement
Ms Murphy told the jury that a statute of limitation of 'six months' generally applied in respect of prosecuting offences of driving without insurance.
'It is the prosecution's case that Tom Flavin knew they (the motorists involved) were not covered (by insurance) and that he entered the details onto PULSE to ensure they (appeared) covered,' Ms Murphy told the jury.
Ireland
Priest calls for end to violent feud in Limerick a...
Read More
'Mr Flavin knew what he was doing, and he did so to ensure those persons were insured (on Pulse) when they were not, in order to ensure there was no prosecution,' Ms Murphy alleged.
The prosecuting barrister told the jury that Tom Flavin enjoyed the presumption of innocence and that the burden of proof 'beyond a reasonable doubt' was all on the prosecution while Mr Flavin 'has nothing to prove'.
Ms Murphy told the jury the prosecution's case was 'a circumstantial case, there is no direct evidence, instead the prosecution relies on indirect evidence'.
It is anticipated that the jury will retire to consider its verdicts on each of the 17 counts on Friday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
20 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Humiliation of DEI-obsessed federal prosecutors and disgraced James Comey's nepo baby daughter whose all-female legal team botched the Diddy trial
After Sean ' Diddy ' Combs was handcuffed inside Manhattan's Park Hyatt hotel in September 2024, federal investigators crowed that his arrest sent a message to the rich and powerful: 'Today, we shatter any false notion of impunity,' declared a special agent at a news conference for the US attorney's office. Almost ten months later, many are left wondering where it all went wrong.
Daily Mail
20 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
The hidden detail in Bryan Kohberger plea deal legal expert say everyone is overlooking
An Idaho prosecutor was slammed for offering quadruple-murderer Bryan Kohberger a plea deal, but legal experts have now revealed a key detail in the bargain they say guarantees justice. Kohberger, 30, pleaded guilty on Wednesday to the November 2022 murders of Madison Mogen, Ethan Chapin, Kaylee Goncalves and Xana Kernodle in Moscow, Idaho. The controversial plea bargain spared him the death penalty and will instead see him serve four consecutive life terms without the possibility of parole. The deal left unanswered lingering questions that a trial might have explored, such as Kohberger's motives, and divided the victims' families, with some left outraged that the quadruple killer now cannot be sentenced to execution or death by firing squad. But a criminal defense attorney highlighted how the deal included a clause that Kohberger cannot ever appeal. He says that is 'huge benefit' for the families and the prosecution that will spare the monster from challenging his sentence at a later date. 'The idea that for decades we're not going to be suffering through him appealing everything that may have taken place in that trial and it is a sealed deal,' attorney Joshua Ritter told Fox & Friends on Thursday. 'That is huge.' Ritter acknowledged the families' 'frustrations', but insisted the plea was a 'good deal' because a jury conviction and capital sentence - which are not guaranteed - could be appealed for years. 'No trial is guaranteed. Things can go sideways. You never know how things are going to end up,' he said, adding: 'You don't know even if it was a guilty verdict, there's no guarantee they would've even come back with a death verdict.' Bryan Kohberger, 30, pleaded guilty on Wednesday to the murders of Madison Mogen, Ethan Chapin , Kaylee Goncalves and Xana Kernodle in November 2022. The controversial plea bargain spared him the death penalty and will instead see him serve four consecutive life terms without the possibility of parole Ritter admitted the plea was a 'shock' to everyone involved in the case, including the judge. 'If there is going to be a death penalty, you would think this is the case it's reserved for and you would have expected this to go to trial,' he told the broadcaster. 'But end of the day, when you really consider what a trial means and what the prosecution ended up with here, I do think it was a good deal.' Former Idaho Attorney General David Leroy echoed Ritter's sentiment, claiming the plea is 'defensible' and 'explicable in the community's best interest'. 'On balance, this is the best result, even for those families, though they may not currently know it,' Leroy told NewsNation's Elizabeth Vargas Reports on Wednesday. While the prosecution had a 'very strong scientific, circumstantial case' that Leroy says 'kept getting stronger' and would have likely resulted in a conviction, the case would have left everyone suffering for years. He noted that not only is life imprisonment 'agreeable to half of the victim families', but it also ensures immediate justice. 'Two of the families voted right now for closure and applauded and encouraged the prosecutor with very supportive and sensitive messages,' he explained. 'The other two, I can certainly understand, have a biblical, moral approach to an eye-for-an-eye and that's explicable and understandable too.' But Leroy insists the plea is the 'best result' because the families would have the 'suffered' through countless trials and '15 years of appeals'. Kohberger's formal sentencing has been tentatively set for July 23, the week when jury selection would have begun in the case. Victims' families will be able to speak. Kohberger will also be offered the chance to explain himself and apologize. But he can choose to remain silent if he wants to, meaning his motive may forever remain a mystery. Relatives of at least two of the victims attended Wednesday's hour-long hearing in Idaho's Fourth Judicial District Court in Boise. The families were divided about the plea deal. Asked by Judge Steven Hippler how he pleaded to each of the charges, Kohberger, wearing a shirt and tie and seated beside his lawyers, answered, 'guilty' in a steady voice, exhibiting no visible emotion. Kohberger also said under questioning that he was entering his plea freely, he believed it to be in his best interests, was satisfied with his legal counsel and understood the consequences. At the time of the murders, Kohberger was pursuing a doctorate degree in criminal justice at Washington State University in Pullman, a short distance from Moscow in northwestern Idaho. Authorities have not suggested a motive for the murders, which occurred during the early morning hours of November 13, 2022, in an off-campus house shared by five women. Three of the roommates - Kernodle, 20; Mogen, 21; and Goncalves, 21 - were found slain inside the house along with Kernodle's boyfriend Chapin, 20. All suffered multiple stab wounds from a hunting knife, according to authorities. Outlining the prosecution's case, Latah County Prosecuting Attorney Bill Thompson told the court Kohberger planned the violence and purchased the knife online about eight months before the killings. The knife's sheath was recovered, but the murder weapon was never found. Thompson said there was no evidence of sexual assault among the victims or a 'sexual component' to the killings. As evidence Kohberger sought to cover up his crimes, Thompson said investigators found he had meticulously cleaned the inside of his car, which he used as the getaway vehicle. 'The defendant had studied crime,' Thompson said. 'He had done a detailed paper on crime-scene processing... He had that knowledge and skill.' Kernodle and Chapin had attended a party the night before, while best friends Mogen and Goncalves had visited a local bar and food truck. All four returned to the house before 2am. Their bodies were found hours later that morning. Two other roommates, Bethany Funke and Dylan Mortensen, survived unharmed. According to prosecutors, Mortensen told investigators she heard someone crying in one of the victims' bedrooms and opened her door to see a man, clad in black, walk past her and out of the house. Authorities said they linked Kohberger to the murders using DNA evidence, cell phone data and video footage. He was arrested weeks after the killings in Pennsylvania, where he was visiting family, and was returned to Idaho to face charges. The family of Goncalves criticized the plea agreement as a 'secretive deal and a hurried effort to close the case without any input from the victims' families,' according to a statement. Her father, Steve Goncalves, said outside the courthouse on Wednesday the four life sentences did not represent justice. But Mogen's mother and some other family members said in a statement they 'support the plea agreement 100 per cent' as 'the best possible outcome for the victims, their families and the state of Idaho'.
BreakingNews.ie
31 minutes ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Four men appear in court charged with seizure of €31m worth of cocaine in Co Cork
Four men have appeared before a court in West Cork charged in connection with the seizure of €31 million worth of cocaine in Courtmacsherry in west Cork on Tuesday. All four men have been remanded in custody. One of the men has an address in Germany whilst three of the men are British nationals. Advertisement Levant Gulay, Mark Dohery, Ben Sandford and Christopher Hibbett appeared before Bandon court charged in connection with the seizure of 440kgs of cocaine. They were brought to the court by members of the Garda National Drug and Organised Crime Bureau. Gardai were assisted by the Armed Support Unit. Detectives from the Garda National Drugs and Organised Crime Bureau gave evidence of the arrest, charge and caution of the four accused at garda stations in Bandon in the county and Togher in Cork city. All four men were charged with possession of cocaine and possession of cocaine for sale or supply at Meelmane, Courtmacsherry, Co Cork on July 1st 2025. Advertisement Det Garda John McWeeney gave evidence of the arrest, charge and caution of Mark Doherty (40) of Waterfoot Avenue, Glasgow, Scotland. He said that Mr Doherty made no reply when the charges were put to him. Det Garda Shane Kiely gave evidence of the arrest, charge and caution of Ben Sandford (39) of Woodgreen, Drum Road, Keith, Moray, Scotland. He also made no reply to the charges. Det Garda Marguerite Reilly gave evidence of arrest, charge and caution in relation to Levant Gulay (31) of Schwabeenstrasse 76, Neu Ulm, Germany. He made no reply to the charges. Det Garda Gavin Curran, gave evidence of arrest, charge and caution of Christopher Hibbett (44) of Lower Park, Trissillian, Truro, England. Advertisement Det Garda Curran told the court that Mr Hibbett stated 'I'm fucking sorry, that's it' when he put the possession of cocaine for sale or supply charge to him earlier today at Togher Garda Station. Solicitors Myra Dineen and Plunkett Taaffe, representing Mr Gulay and Mr Doherty respectively, said that their clients were reserving their positions on bail. Both solicitors opted to stand in for Frank Buttimer for Mr Sandford and for solicitor Eddie Burke for Mr Hibbett. They confirmed that they were also not seeking bail for either man at this juncture. Sgt Tom Mulcahy told Judge Joanne Carroll that gardaí were seeking a remand in custody for all four men to Macroom District Court on July 9th. Judge Carroll remanded all four accused to appear in court on that date. Advertisement Judge Carroll also requested that defence solicitors provide two days notice to gardaí if their clients intend to make bail applications on the next occasion. All four men also have to supply statement of means to the court. The men were held under drugs trafficking legislation which allowed gardai to detain them for seven days. The arrests occurred as part of a Joint Task Force Drugs Interdiction Operation.
