Can air drops solve the Gaza crisis? Aid agencies are sceptical
Following pressure from the international community, Israel has announced brief 'humanitarian pauses' between 10am and 8pm each day to allow more aid to be delivered to starving Palestinians, as US president Donald Trump said on Monday: 'They have to get food and safety right now.'
The World Health Organisation has warned that malnutrition is on a 'dangerous trajectory' in the Gaza Strip, with 63 deaths in July. Around one in five small children in Gaza City are now acutely malnourished, according to the UN's Palestinian refugee agency (Unrwa).
Air dropping is a controversial method of aid distribution, as humanitarian organisations have cited a number of safety and efficiency issues.
Medecins Sans Frontier (MSF) operations manager Jacob Burns called it 'humanitarian theatre', adding 'it's absolutely not the only way' to get aid into Gaza.
'For the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), air drops really are a last resort,' spokesperson Sarah Davies told The Independent, as the method comes with its own set of challenges.
Here's all you need to know about the controversial aid distribution method.
What is air dropping?
Air dropping is usually reserved for instances where it is hard to get aid where it needs to go. It involves dropping food items or non food items into an area from an aeroplane. Usually they require a predetermined location with staff on the ground, who have cleared the area of other people, of buildings, or anything that could be damaged or damage the goods themselves. The aid then needs to be distributed on the ground.
'The most efficient way to do this is through things like international organisations who are experienced in this,' said Ms Davies. She added that the ICRC was not currently involved in the air drops.
'We can't deliver assistance in a way that risks people or exposing them to harm. We work by assessing the needs throughout the areas of Gaza, where we're present, and we respond directly to those needs.'
The dangers of air dropping
In the densely populated Gaza Strip, air dropping faces a new challenge of distributing aid without causing harm to individuals.
'The primary danger of the air drop is you cannot safely aim a pallet of aid,' said Mr Burns. 'People have already been killed by aid drops in Gaza.'
Five people died in March last year after at least one parachute failed to deploy in an aid package air drop, leading a parcel to fall on people, according to Gaza's health ministry.
As well as the spacial safety issues, the sheer desperation of citizens can put their safety at risk as they race to get to the food source first.
'If you're starving and suddenly you see food drop out of the sky, obviously you're going to run towards that aid and it's a situation where the strongest will win,' said Mr Burns. He added that separate to Israel's claims that Hamas has been stealing aid, criminal gangs have used violence to loot aid - and air dropping offers no further control over that problem.
'If you're just throwing aid randomly into the Gaza strip then you have no idea who can control that.'
How effectively does it distribute food?
According to the International Committee for the Red Cross, air drops are a less efficient form of transporting aid than land transportation.
'They're really quite unsustainable, because they are very expensive', said Ms Davies, who cited that aeroplanes require fuelling and mechanical requirements that can make it a more expensive operation to supply 'quite limited amounts of items in a way that, unfortunately, we see doesn't always reach those who really need it'.
Mr Burns added that air drops don't allow for as much aid to get in as land transportation would as he called on Israel to 'let aid in in a flood rather than a trickle, which is what air drops are.'
The ideal way of distributing aid
The MSF worker then called for 'organised massive distributions of aid that can meet everyone's needs'.
Land transportation, in which aid is brought into Gaza via trucks by humanitarian organisations, was named by the ICRC as a more effective approach to aid distribution because aid workers can bring in more supplies in a less time consuming, resource consuming way.
The World Food Programme has said it has enough food to feed the entire population of 2.1 million people for almost three months.
'While we do welcome any decisions, any changes that mean that more aid reaches more people, we do reiterate that it needs to be done in a way where people are given dignified access to aid,' said Ms Davies.
'Doing aid entry and aid distribution from land transportation allows international organisations who have experience of decades of work in Gaza, who have the trust of the communities in Gaza to do so in this way.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
4 minutes ago
- The Sun
I have constant pain in my back and legs and doctors can't help – what should I do?
OUR resident specialist and NHS GP, Dr Zoe Williams, shares her expert advice. Today, Dr Zoe helps a reader whose blood pressure was flagged as pointing to pre diabetic levels during a routine health check. Q) I'M a 73-year-old woman and have seen different doctors at my surgery for years now but none of them seem to help. In 2011, I was diagnosed with spinal stenosis, where the spaces within the spine become narrowed, which can put pressure on the spinal cord and nerves. In June last year my symptoms got worse. I have constant pain in my back and legs, I am tired all the time (I sleep on and off most of the evening), and have numbness all the time in both calves. In the night I am getting up three times with bladder problems but a urologist I have seen can't find anything wrong with my bladder. My legs feel cold, I have shin pain and tight calves. I feel paralysed when getting out of bed. It's a job to start moving. Can you please suggest what could be causing my symptoms? A) I'm so sorry to hear you have been suffering such debilitating, painful symptoms for so long. Your mention of legs feeling paralysed is concerning and you need to be checked over more urgently. You could call 111 to see if they can arrange for you to be seen if your GP cannot see you. Back pain is a common problem, and you already have a diagnosis of spinal stenosis. However, anyone with back issues needs to be aware of red-flag symptoms which require urgent assessment, and these include severe weakness in legs (not just pain or stiffness), sudden difficulty walking, poor coordination, or frequent falls. These may indicate cauda equina syndrome – a surgical emergency. Other symptoms of concern include loss of bowel or bladder control and numbness or tingling in the groin area.
The Sun
4 minutes ago
- The Sun
Does summer make you sad? Here's why seasonal changes can trigger the blues
AS her daughter played happily in a paddling pool as a toddler, Heidi Ellert-McDermott blinked back tears. 'Everyone seemed to be having such a lovely time and was glowing in the sunshine,' she recalls, 'but I was feeling really low and like I just wanted it to cloud over.' 5 5 5 The speech writer, from Wotton-under-Edge, Gloucs, is not alone in hating the summer months. Seasonal affective disorder (SAD) is a type of depression that affects one in 20 people in the UK. While traditionally associated with dark winters, 'reverse SAD' affects ten per cent of those with the condition. Clinical psychologist Dr Andrea Pickering, fellow of the British Psychological Society and clinical director at Clinical Partners, explains: 'It is triggered by seasonal changes, most commonly during winter but sometimes in summer. 'Blackout blinds' 'Like other forms of depression, it's linked to chemical changes in the brain, particularly involving serotonin which regulates mood, and melatonin which controls sleep. 'In winter, less sunlight leads to lower serotonin levels and increased melatonin production. 'In summer, the brain can become overstimulated by too much sunlight or heat, which can disrupt sleep cycles and leave people feeling agitated, anxious and unbalanced. 'So while the triggers are seasonal, the brain's response is similar to depression, just with different timing.' Heidi, 48, originally from Scotland, says her symptoms started around 2007. She adds: 'I don't remember having the extreme dislike of summer as a child or in my twenties, it kicked in in my mid-thirties. What is Seasonal Affective Disorder? 'I've felt it long enough that my friends don't expect me to dance at a festival or 'just come for an hour' to a roasting hot barbecue any more. 'I use blackout blinds, I've got fans in every room, I sleep with ice packs in my socks and I only venture out in the sunshine when I absolutely have to.' GP Dr Rosie Khan is seeing an increasing number of patients with reverse SAD. She says: 'I see a spike each year, especially in patients already living with anxiety or mood disorders. 'These individuals often report feeling overwhelmed, agitated and unusually fatigued during the warmer months. The longer days, intense heat and social pressure of summer can be just as challenging as winter.' Lisa Ventura, 51, from Worcester, has had reverse SAD symptoms since she was a child. She says: 'I've been to my GP plenty of times over the years but every time I've been told to just eat some ice cream, drink more water and stay indoors. 'None of this helps. In recent years it has been dismissed as the menopause, even though I've never had other symptoms. 'Cooped up' 'It feels like doctors think I'm being dramatic, just as my teachers thought at school.' There are guidelines for treatment of the condition, though. Dr Khan says: 'The NHS recommends a combination of approaches, depending on the severity of symptoms. 'This includes self-help techniques, talking therapies and sometimes medication. 'Lifestyle measures, such as maintaining a regular sleep schedule, staying cool and managing screen time can make a big difference, too.' Lisa, who works as a cyber security expert, says the impact on her life has been huge. 'Every arrangement I make in the summer has to be caveated with 'as long as it isn't too hot' — especially if the temperature goes above 25C,' she says. 'I couldn't attend my cousin's fiance's 50th birthday party at the end of June as it was a barbecue in 30C heat. There was no way I could sit outside even for a few minutes. 'I'm a huge Black Sabbath fan and I desperately wanted to go to their final concert at Villa Park but my heart sank when I saw it was in July because I knew I wouldn't be able to go if it was hot. 5 5 'I also recently started an outdoor yoga class but have had to miss the first three sessions because of the heatwaves. 'I hate being cooped up at home but I have no other choice.' Dr Pickering says it might not be as common as anxiety, which affects eight million people in the UK, but SAD is 'very real' for those impacted and the symptoms should not be ignored. 'It often shows up as low mood, anxiety or irritability during late spring and summer,' she says. 'People might struggle to sleep, feel restless or panicky, lose their appetite or avoid socialising and going outside. 'It can feel like you're out of sync with others who seem to enjoy the season. 'If these symptoms start to affect your daily life, it's worth speaking to a GP or mental health professional.' Heidi, who says she spends the summer months counting down the days until the clocks go back, wishes more people understood reverse SAD. 'I've googled 'Is hating summer a personality flaw?',' she says. 'I get irritable and start irrationally resenting people for being cheerful in shorts. 'It's like I'm the only person not enjoying the 'best time of year'. It's like being the designated driver at a month-long party. 'I've braved a couple of hot holidays but I can't be more than five metres from a pool or the sea. 'Red flag' 'Rain calms me and fog delights me but disliking summer doesn't mean I'm joyless. I just like my joy chilled — and preferably set to the sound of rain on my windows.' Dr Khan says anyone can be affected by SAD but it is more common in women and usually begins in young adulthood. 'People with a family history of depression or other mood disorders may also be more susceptible,' she adds. 'Those who are highly sensitive to changes in light, temperature or routine, or shift workers or people with anxiety can be more vulnerable, too.' If a dislike of summer starts affecting work or relationships, it could be time to seek help. 'We all have seasonal preferences but when your discomfort in summer becomes emotionally and physically disabling, that's a red flag,' Dr Pickering says. 'Don't dismiss it. Speak to your GP or a mental health professional. Practical lifestyle changes to regulate light and temperature can really help. 'Try using blackout curtains, sticking to a regular sleep routine and limiting exposure to bright light if that's a trigger. 'Most importantly, know that you're not alone and professional help is available.'
The Sun
4 minutes ago
- The Sun
I tested three spot-clearing serums to help keep breakouts at bay – with one for every budget
SUMMER is alway a sticking point for those of us with acne. The sweaty, humid weather and heat-proof, long-wear make-up is a recipe for blocked pores. So I've been testing spot-clearing serums to help keep breakouts at bay. BUDGET The Inkey List 360 skin clearing serum, £16 for 30ml, I am a huge Inkey fan. Founders Mark Curry and Colette Laxton are down-to-earth and never shy away from questions about the brand or the products they're creating, which is always a good sign. This serum does exactly what it says on the tin, helping to control oil production, unclog pores and reduce post-breakout inflammation and scarring thanks to salicylic and lactic acid. Despite being lightweight, it also hydrates skin, thanks to the caring squalane, glycerin and panthenol. It's a true all-rounder and unbelievably good value for money. MID-RANGE It has been a long time since I've used Clinique skincare. It was my mum's go-to brand when I was growing up, so there's something nostalgic and full circle about it entering my stash, even though she has a different skin type and uses different products. This is one of the fastest-working blemish solutions I've ever tried. It reduced the redness around my spots in under an hour and helped relieve the bruised feeling of those under-the-skin spots overnight. It is the most drying of the three, so best for those with extremely oily skin, or paired with a hydrating oil-free moisturiser – but the results are worth the extra step. LUXURY Murad biome-balancing clear & prevent blemish treatment serum, £45 for 30ml, Murad was my go-to brand when my skin was at its worst and I keep a couple of products for when my skin plays up. This serum is new and has become one of my favourite products from the brand. It has a gel-like texture that absorbs in seconds and doesn't leave an oily or sticky residue. The combination of salicylic and mandelic acids is a super gentle way to slowly, but efficiently, slough away dead skin cells while also being antibacterial and reducing acne-causing bacteria at the same time. The salicylic acid also breaks down oil. My skin felt softer from day one and I've definitely had fewer new breakouts since using it regularly.
