'Fix this': Calls for immediate change as Panthers caught in 'unfair' farce
As it stands, the NRL competition continues during State of Origin, and has a detrimental effect on the clubs with the most players in the showpiece event. As well as not being allowed to play NSW or Queensland players the weekend before an Origin game, clubs are often forced to make difficult decisions for the games that follow.
This weekend, Panthers coach Ivan Cleary won't have son Nathan, Isaah Yeo, Liam Martin, Dylan Edwards or Brian To'o at his disposal when Penrith travel to Auckland to take on the Warriors. Because State of Origin 2 is in Perth on Wednesday night, the Panthers haven't found a viable way to fly their Origin stars to Auckland for Saturday's game (taking into account rest and recovery).
Adding to the frustrating situation is the fact Lindsay Smith is now the 19th man for NSW, meaning he'll have to remain in Perth until after Wednesday night's game. Smith is expected to fly to New Zealand and play on Saturday, but the Panthers aren't willing to risk injury to the other five with so much travel and a short turnaround.
Speaking last weekend, Ivan Cleary labelled the situation "unfair". He said: "The Origin players won't be playing because they can't. I don't think it's fair that we can't play... we should be able to make that decision. Through flights, we just can't get them there."
Cleary will roll with a largely second-string side to take on the Warriors, and the Panthers are astronomical odds to beat the home side. It's a hammer blow considering the four-time defending champs have battled back from last on the ladder to be ninth heading into Round 16.
As many fans have pointed out, the current system completely compromises the NRL competition. The ideal scenario would be to put the NRL on hold for three weeks and play all three Origin games on back-to-back-to-back weekends. The NRL has seemingly realised this is the way forward, but it looks like any change to the current Origin system won't come into effect for at least three years.
One person wrote on social media on Monday: "Standalone Origin would fix this. Unfortunately some people can't live without club footy for a couple of weeks so we are stuck with the current system."
Another commented: "The game should be rescheduled if there's a literal inability to get the players there - that's crazy." While a third added: "The NRL is trying to expand out of NSW and QLD but persists with allowing Origin to disrupt it?! Makes no sense."
RELATED:
Canberra Raiders 'fuming' after key figure signs with Roosters
NRL world sends flood of messages over news about Yvonne Sampson
Others pointed out that Origin-affected games are a good opportunity for younger players or fringe-first graders to gain valuable NRL experience. While some suggested Cleary and the Panthers shouldn't be whinging considering they've won four-straight premierships.
Tellingly, a poll of over 20,000 Yahoo Sport Australia readers has a standalone Origin series as the preferred option. Over 60 per cent of voters believe the current system compromises the NRL competition.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
USA Today
8 hours ago
- USA Today
Panthers rookie OLB Princely Umanmielen stands up for franchise legend Cam Newton
A Carolina Panthers rookie is not tolerating any Cam Newton slander. The franchise legend has recently received quite a bit of vitriol, almost all of it personal, for his take on Philadelphia Eagles star Jalen Hurts. After Newton recently excluded the Super Bowl LIX Most Valuable Player from his list of the NFL's top ten quarterbacks, his career has been poked and prodded at by dissenting talking heads, analysts and fans alike. Newton himself punched back this past week, calling out a handful of celebrity detractors including ESPN's Stephen A. Smith, Ryan Clark and Dan Orlovsky, Pro Football Hall of Famer Terrell Owens and rapper Gillie Da Kid. Well, he got some backup on Sunday—when Panthers outside linebacker Princely Umanmielen took a stand for the team's all-time leading passer on Twitter/X . . . Oh, and he's not just saying that because he plays for the Panthers . . . Umanmielen's defense of Newton will probably endear him to the Carolina faithful even further. The 2025 third-round pick already had plenty of Panthers fans smiling after the first week of training camp, where he picked up a few would-be sacks on back-to-back days at practice. He also poked fun at his first big play, which caused an abrupt end to the opening outing on Wednesday. Although he was eventually cleared of being overzealous on his strip-sack of Bryce Young, Umanmielen hilariously acknowledged that he'd try to keep his quarterback clean moving forward . . . There seems to be little doubt that Umanmielen, hands included, is quickly becoming a favorite in Carolina. Follow @ThePanthersWire on Twitter/X for more Panthers content.
USA Today
8 hours ago
- USA Today
4 standouts from Week 1 of Panthers 2025 training camp
The Carolina Panthers are a bit more out of sight for this year's edition of training camp. With the organization in the middle of their construction on a new practice facility, fans have not been allowed to attend the team's workout sessions. But that doesn't mean a few players haven't shined through to start the summer. Here are four standouts from the Panthers' opening week of camp . . . WR Hunter Renfrow Renfrow has yet to drop the pen on his comeback story. After missing the entire 2024 campaign due to a challenging bout with ulcerative colitis, the former Pro Bowler signed with Carolina in the spring. He impressed head coach Dave Canales during mandatory minicamp and has kept on stacking days into training camp. "It's just the Hunter Renfrow I remember," Canales told reporters on Saturday. "He looks healthy. I think everyone who's watched football over the last four or five years remembers what he looks like, and he's really playing in top form right now. I'm really excited to have him here and to have his family, which is right down the road here after this practice, just to be able to connect with him. And it's a great story that's unfolding right before our eyes." The Panthers' wideout room is a bit crowded, at least compared to years past. But the 29-year-old Myrtle Beach, S.C. continues to make an intriguing case for a spot. WR Jimmy Horn Jr. Horn is also trying to make a space for himself at the end of the room. The 2024 sixth-round pick, as he did during the spring, has opened quite a few eyes with his speed. Mike Kaye of The Charlotte Observer noted that Horn looked especially fast in one-on-one coverage drills on Saturday, beating fellow rookie defenders by "four or five yards." And by the looks of his footwork here, that shouldn't be too surprising . . . Horn made a few nice catches in seven-on-seven action and gave a preview of his prowess as a returner, too. And like Renfrow, he got some props from up top. Canales described what he admires about Horn on Thursday. "Yeah, I just love the way that he plays football. It's full speed all the time," Canales stated. "Some guys, we have to really teach them how to get in a walk-through mode. He's one of those guys. Everything he does is fast. "I think about Deven Thompkins—who I love, who was here last year. They just bring out the best in everybody because you know, when they're out there, they're going 100 miles per hour, full speed and they're looking to take the top off. So, I love that style about Jimmy. And what he's shown us—whether it's in drills or in the team periods, he's just all gas." OLB Princely Umanmielen Umanmielen caught the attention of many on Wednesday, when his close call on a strip-sack of quarterback Bryce Young caused an abrupt end to practice. That decision came from Canales, who initially thought Umanmielen was a bit too physical on the play. Upon further review, however, the rookie pass rusher actually tried to avoid making contact with Young. "We watched the film—he was actually trying to avoid . . . Bryce didn't have anywhere to go in the pocket," Canales said following Thursday's session. "So as he pulls his arm back, he kinda hits him and you can see Princely running kinda by. "Still made a point of it. Still great to teach the guys in those moments. But just another great teachable moment for the whole group. Hey, let's not pass judgement on what happened. I saw the play kinda, but I didn't see specifically. We'll be able to rewind it ten times and figure out what happened. "But had a couple 'nother good rushes today by Princely. Every day, shows up and does something good. I'm really encouraged with the effort, first and foremost, that he's giving and the strain to finish all the way through practice." One of those good rushes by Umanmielen saw the rookie beat starting left tackle Ikem Ekwonu on an inside move for another would-be sack. S Demani Richardson Richardson made what deemed as the "play of the day" from the first outing . . . Richardson is one of a few contenders vying for the starting spot next to free-agent signee Tre'von Moehrig. If he continues his ball-hawking ways, the undrafted rookie from 2024 could make himself a real factor in the backend of the defense. Follow @ThePanthersWire on Twitter/X for more Panthers content.
Yahoo
20 hours ago
- Yahoo
Raiders thrash Newcastle to continue first place charge
Matthew Timoko has provided the game-defining presence to lead Canberra to a 44-18 win against Newcastle, building a four point buffer over the second-placed Melbourne Storm. With six rounds left before the finals, the Raiders don't have to play any current top four opponents and have a bye in hand. If the Green Machine are able to win the minor premiership, it would be their first since 1990, when coach Ricky Stuart was halfback. However, Canterbury could cut Canberra's two-win lead to one if they beat Manly later on Sunday. The victory at GIO Stadium was the Raiders' ninth on the trot, the first time they have achieved that feat since 1994. Timoko provided the stability, weaving and winding through Newcastle's defence and earning two tries. He also broke through Newcastle's defence three times and ran 138 metres. Savage strikes right before half-time! ⏰ — NRL (@NRL) July 27, 2025 Joe Tapine (139m) led the Raiders up the middle, with Jamal Fogarty providing circling kicks and two try assists. The Knights produced a courageous first half performance with Dane Gagai (16 runs) and Tyson Frizell (145m) creating a see sawing contest. Big names Kayln Ponga, Bradman Best and Fletcher Sharpe were all out, and as the game continued their creative presence was missed as the Knights were unable to break down a solid Canberra defence. Newcastle's season is also now all but over as they sit well adrift of the top eight, tied on 16 points with last-placed South Sydney. Both teams went try-for-try in the first half. Kaeo Weekes strolled over first after Jed Stuart broke free down the left edge and passed to Hudson Young, who laid it off to the Raiders' No.1. The Knights were able to level the scores when Phoenix Crossland drew the Raiders out before passing to Leo Thompson, who provided a short ball to Kai Pearce-Paul. Canberra shrugged off the Knights' try, going on the offensive and finding their second when Simi Sasagi broke free of a Tyson Gamble tackle and crashed over. Newcastle had been sniffing around the Raiders' right edge all game and earned their second try when Gagai found Greg Marzhew, who strolled over untouched. But on the stroke of half time Xavier Savage was able to put Canberra back in front when Timoko broke free on the right edge and found his winger. The second half was a different story, with the Raiders scoring four unanswered tries, including two for Timoko. Substitute Noah Martin was able to score his first NRL try when he pounced on a Jamal Fogarty kick.
