I tried Magnum supermarket dupes and a 47p winner are as good as the real deal and cheaper than Aldi and Lidl
A Wall's Magnum is la crème de la crème but as they cost significantly more than most supermarket rivals, are they worth it?
6
A three pack will now set you back £3.50 - 25p more than even last year - and twice now, Magnums have also been outed for shrinkflation.
A year ago, the ice cream was downsized from 110 to 100ml and then this year, it reduced the number in the pack from four to three whilst keeping the price the same.
This effectively bumps the price of each ice cream up by a third.
You can pick them up for less than 50p each at Lidl. But do they stack up on taste?
LYNSEY HOPE finds out:
Magnum Classic
£3.50 (£1.16 each)
Nutrition: 231 calories, 14g fat, 20g sugar
Lynsey says: "Deliciously thick chocolate which is the making of the Magnum for me and why these ice creams are such a hit.
"The vanilla ice cream is creamy and perfectly sweet. Whilst delicious, they used to have branding on the chocolate which has disappeared so it's actually quite hard to tell them apart from the own brands.
"They are actually a little smaller than most at 100ml, rather than 110ml, so not only are they more expensive but you're getting less for your money."
Taste: 8/10
Value: 4/10
Overall score: 12/20
Milk Chocolate Ice Creams by Sainsbury's
£1.86 for 4 (46.5p each)
Nutrition: 247 calories, 15.9g fat, 18.5g sugar
6
Lynsey says: "You get in four in the pack at Sainsbury's which makes these brilliant value, costing less than 50p each.
"Exceptional value, beating even Lidl and Aldi on price per lolly. The chocolate on these Sainsbury's ice creams isn't quite as luxurious as the Magnum Classic, but it has a lovely smooth flavour and isn't too rich.
"It's quite thin but moreish. The ice cream has a strong vanilla flavour, which dominates and they are a good size at 110ml each."
Taste: 9/10
Value: 10/10
Overall score: 20/20
Tesco Milk Chocolate Ice Creams
£2.10 (70p each)
Nutrition: 229 calories, 14.1g fat, 18.5g sugar
Lynsey says: "The chocolate on the Tesco ice creams was too thick and I didn't like the texture or flavour.
"The chocolate was overpowering, almost burnt tasting. The ice cream was too dense and heavy.
"They've also jumped in price from 45p in 2023 to 53p in 2024 and they are now 70p each. They are a good size, at 110ml, but probably my least favourite."
Taste: 3/10
Value: 4/10
Overall score: 7/20
Lidl Bon Gelati Ice Creams
£2.85 for 6 (47.5p each)
Nutrition: 268 calories, 17.1g fat, 22g sugar
Lynsey says: 'Not only are Lidl's ice creams the most generous in size at 120ml, they are amongst the best value too.
"They had a lovely aroma as I tore off the wrapper, the chocolate was the thickest and the ice cream was creamy with just the right hint of vanilla.
"They didn't melt too quickly and I Ioved the texture too. A worthy winner.'
Taste: 10/10
Value: 10/10
Overall score: 20/20
How to save money on your supermarket shop
THERE are plenty of ways to save on your grocery shop.
You can look out for yellow or red stickers on products, which show when they've been reduced.
If the food is fresh, you'll have to eat it quickly or freeze it for another time.
Making a list should also save you money, as you'll be less likely to make any rash purchases when you get to the supermarket.
Going own brand can be one easy way to save hundreds of pounds a year on your food bills too.
This means ditching "finest" or "luxury" products and instead going for "own" or value" type of lines.
Plenty of supermarkets run wonky veg and fruit schemes where you can get cheap prices if they're misshapen or imperfect.
For example, Lidl runs its Waste Not scheme, offering boxes of 5kg of fruit and vegetables for just £1.50.
If you're on a low income and a parent, you may be able to get up to £442 a year in Healthy Start vouchers to use at the supermarket too.
Plus, many councils offer supermarket vouchers as part of the Household Support Fund.
M&S Chocolate Sticks
£2.40 for 3 (80p each)
Nutrition: 229 calories, 13.5g fat, 22.5g sugar
Lynsey says: "I really loved the flavour of the M&S ice creams. The ice cream was milky and creamy without being too sweet.
"The chocolate was thinner than others but it had a nice 'snap' and a rich, decadent flavour.
"These really melted in the mouth. Again they are smaller than others at 100ml per ice cream - and more expensive."
Taste: 9/10
Value: 5/10
Overall score: 14/20
Asda Milk Chocolate Ice Creams
£2.10 for 3 (70p each)
Nutrition: 230calories, 14g fat, 19g sugar
Lynsey says: "Loved the chocolate on the Asda dupes, which was thick with a creamy and rich flavour. It really melted in the mouth.
"However, the ice cream tasted a little watery and this let them down.
"They are a good size at 110ml but they've also gone up quite a lot in price, now costing 70p each.
"Reasonable value compared to the big brand but Sainsbury's and Aldi both offered better value for money."
Taste: 5/10
Value: 4/10
Overall score: 9/20
Aldi Gianni's Milk Chocolate Ice Creams
£1.99 for 4 (49.7p each)
Per ice cream: 234 calories, 13.6g fat, 18g sugar, 0.11g salt
6
Lynsey says: "Quite close to the Magnum in texture, with a smooth and dense ice cream which tasted lovely but was less sweet.
"The chocolate was a little grainy, but it had a nice flavour and just the right snap as you took a bite.
"One of the lowest in sugar and fat too, so that's a bonus. At just 49.7p per ice cream, these are a bargain."
Taste: 9/10
Value: 10/10
Overall score: 19/20
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scotsman
18 hours ago
- Scotsman
Travellers call for removal of growing Edinburgh illegal travellers site after nearly two years in Granton
Residents who say their lives have been made 'hell' by a group of travellers in Edinburgh have launched a petition calling for them to be moved on. Sign up to our daily newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to Edinburgh News, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Travellers first pitched up on the derelict site between Waterfront Avenue and West Granton Road, on the land behind the Lidl supermarket and B&M store, back in 2019. There are now dozens of campervans and caravans at the site in north Edinburgh. Smoke hangs over the Granton site, after a fire on Wednesday, July 23. | Submitted Locals living in the area said that the initial group were no trouble, with problems only arising when a larger group arrived on the site more than a year and a half ago. This group was joined recently by more travellers, who are believed to be those who were moved on from nearby Forthquarter Park last month, after locals there launched an online petition. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Angry locals in Granton have now also launched a petition calling for the travellers to be moved from Waterfront Avenue. Launched yesterday, Wednesday, July 23, the petition has so far had 52 signatures. The petition founder said: 'This issue has persisted for years, and it's time we take a stand for our community's safety and wellbeing.' Adding: 'The challenges we face on a daily basis are numerous and exhausting. Children on quad bikes dangerously racing along pedestrian paths, fires causing potential hazards, and aggressive dogs creating perilous situations are just the tip of the iceberg. 'The constant noise and even instances of abuse have cast a shadow over our once peaceful life. Additionally, fly-tipping has become rampant, tarnishing our environment and adding to the distress of residents.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Travellers at the west side of the site in Granton. | National World Local residents, who asked not to be named, told the Evening News more about what life is like living next to the growing group of travellers, with regular fires reportedly set at the site in recent weeks. One said: 'What a mess they have left around the place, particularly at the back of B&M. There was a large fire yesterday with smoke everywhere. And the kids are up and down on their quad bikes all day every day. 'The whole block is frustrated. It's a living hell. The police came here yesterday to say nothing could be done until someone gets hurt.' The large area currently occupied by the travellers in Granton has been earmarked for a state-of-the-art home for Scotland's national collection of 130,000 artworks, The Art Works, as part of the wider Granton Waterfront development. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The plans were approved last month, although the site remains occupied by dozens of campervans, caravans and other vehicles. Two photos of recent fires at the travellers site in Granton, taken by locals. | Submitted Speaking about the lack of action taken to deter or move on the travellers, one local said: 'It's not council land, so they have washed their hands of it. It's the Scottish Government that owns that land. 'Some of the travellers have been there since 2019, with more arriving in the years after. The group causing most of the problems came here about a year and a half ago. It's been hell since they arrived. 'It's mostly kids out on quad bikes every day, they are too young to be on those bikes, yet they are out all day and sometimes at night, causing a real racket.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Another local added: 'They rally around here on motorbikes pretty much every night. So I don't go out at night, I feel trapped in my home. I really just want them to go now. They have even got a cockerel and you hear it every morning. And the mess they have left around here is just awful.' Another group of travellers on the west side of the derelict land off Waterfront Avenue in Granton, Edinburgh. | National World And another Waterfront Avenue resident added: 'I would rather they weren't there. They have been setting bonfires which release toxic gases. I'm pretty sure if I did that the council and police would get involved. But they seem to have a law for themselves. 'I had an instance of young children aged between just six and eight carrying bolt cutters as big as them, trying to steal a neighbour's bike. I hope the National Galleries development planned for the site goes ahead sooner rather than later. Hopefully those plans start to move forward. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'However, there really needs to a designated area in Edinburgh for these traveller people to live, so they are not causing issues for locals.' The Scottish Government has been contacted for comment. The City of Edinburgh Council declined the opportunity to comment on this story. Speaking about officers reporting to the scene yesterday, a Police Scotland spokesperson said: 'Around 10.30am on Wednesday, July, 23, officers received a report of concerns around off-road bikes in the Waterfront Avenue area of Edinburgh. 'Enquiries into the matter are ongoing and officers are engaging with local partners regarding the concerns.'
The Sun
18 hours ago
- The Sun
Secret code on fruit & veg will tell you how fresh they are – as ‘best before' dates stripped from 1,000s of products
Every year, Brits throw away 10.7million tonnes of food CRACK THE CODE Secret code on fruit & veg will tell you how fresh they are – as 'best before' dates stripped from 1,000s of products SUPERMARKETS have begun to strip 'best before' dates from many pre-packaged greens to help fight food waste. In the UK, the average household throws out nine pieces of fruit every week, which adds up to £468 in the bin every year. 3 Supermarkets have started to ditch best before dates on their fruits and veggies Credit: Alamy The best way to tell if your fruits and veggies are off is to go by what they look like, taste like, or smell like. But, if you've been left a little flustered by the change to packaging, experts have revealed a secret code to help you decipher how fresh your groceries are. It also means you can buy food with the longest life to make sure it makes it to your plate, rather than a bin. According to consumer site Which?, different supermarkets use their own secret codes to show when your food is still at its best – but you need to know what to look for. At Asda and Tesco, the key is a letter followed by a number. Each letter stands for a month – A for January, B for February, all the way to L for December. The number is the day of the month. So H22? That's August 22. Sainsbury's shoppers face a different puzzle. Their code starts with J, ends with S – a nod to founder John Sainsbury – with the date tucked in between. So J0904S means your item is good until April 9. Morrisons keeps things simple. Just the first letter of the month and the date – like O12 for 12 October. But watch out – June and July both start with 'J', which could cause a bit of a brain-fade in the fridge aisle. Which? warns: 'Food is usually perfectly edible after its best-before or sell-by date – it should be fine to eat if it looks and smells OK.' But with use-by dates, like on pre-cut fruit, it's a strict deadline: eat it by midnight, or risk getting ill. The scale of food waste in the UK A survey by Aldi of 2,000 Brits revealed the shocking truth: although a third of us want to eat more fruit and veg, over half admit they chuck too much of it away. The worst fruit offender? Bananas – with the average home tossing 115 a year. Tomatoes, mushrooms and even easy peelers aren't far behind. Nearly a quarter of people admit they never finish a bag of salad before binning it, while 57 percent don't actually know how to store fresh food properly. So next time you're in the fruit and veg aisle wondering whether those mushrooms are still good – check the code, not the label. As well as saving yourself some cash, you'll be doing good for the planet too. Every year, the UK throws away an eyewatering 10.7million tonnes of food - that's around 25 percent of all the food we buy. Whilst businesses aren't saints by any means, households alone contribute to over half of the food wastage in our country. It was revealed that 6.4million tonnes of food were thrown into kitchen bins in 2021 - and roughly 70 percent of that was perfectly edible. 3 Remember to check the codes on your veggie packaging Credit: Which?
BBC News
2 days ago
- BBC News
Weston woman wins British Citizen Award for creating food bank
A young woman has won a British Citizen Award for creating her own food Ahmed from Weston-super-Mare built her own charity with studying for a law degree, which she has now Food Charity was created after Miss Ahmed, 21, spent her childhood with her father who would give out free meals to those who needed them, from his said: "When I was five years old I would see [my dad] doing all of the work and I would say to him 'let me help you'." "He instilled it into us as we've grown up," she 2015 Miss Ahmed began to help people by herself and support for her work grew by word of October 2023, Aishah's Food Charity was officially launched after the Covid pandemic, as a hot meal food bank."I saw the struggle from lockdown and the rising of the cost of living and I said to myself I've got to do something," she Wednesday Miss Ahmed works at her charity, on Walliscote Road in Weston-super-Mare, and it is also ran by volunteers on Sundays. 'It means everything' Miss Ahmed's father and brother do all of the cooking and her mother and sister and her take the food to site, package it, and hand it out to well as this, the charity reached out to various supermarkets including Lidl, Aldi, Sainsbury's and Asda who provide food for them to donate."It makes me feel good - The whole reason I do it is because I want those who are less fortunate to have things they want."The charity has also branched out by now donating items like sleeping bags and tents and bed sheets."It means everything to me this charity, it really does" she said.
