Fintechs in talks with RBI for easier provisioning for default loss guarantee-backed loans
Fintechs believe the provisioning variance is due to the differentiated interpretation of Ind-AS accounting standards, which allow for a 'risk mitigant' like Default Loss Guarantee to be considered while calculating the expected credit loss (ECL) provisions.
Unified Fintech Forum and self-regulatory organisation Fintech Association for Consumer Empowerment (FACE), in their representiations to the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), have said that making full provisions against such loans will lead to 'double provisioning', with both the lending service providers (LSPs) like fintechs and regulated entities such as banks and non-bank lenders setting aside buffers for the same loan pool.
Read more: RBI poised to cut rates as India eyes a steady takeoff
Both the LSP and the regulated entities are provisioning for the same loan pool, thus impacting capital deployment efficiency, said Jatin Handoo, chief executive officer of UFF, formerly Digital Lenders' Association of India.
It might also lead to a 'crowding out' effect where lenders will have less amount of money for lending because they have to take out the extra amount and provide for it separately, he said. 'RBI is open to listening to us and has asked us to come up with data-based use cases, and customer-level and market insights."
Full provisioning by NBFCs
Fintechs offer borrowers loans from multiple banks. These intermediaries usually provide a 'default loss guarantee' (DLG) to cover these loans for encouraging lenders to partner with them.
However, in April, the central bank wrote to at least four non-bank lenders with high delinquencies in their DLG-backed loans. The regulator asked them to provide for all loan pools sourced through third-party digital platforms under the expected credit loss (ECL) accounting norms, regardless of whether these are backed by DLG arrangements.
A senior industry official explained that if the loss on the loan pool was 7% and 5% was covered under a DLG arrangement, some NBFCs usually had a provision cover of 2-4%, depending on their internal modelling and calculations. Audits by RBI in January-February revealed this provision accounting, following which RBI reinforced that the entire provisioning has to be taken by the NBFC and any recoveries under DLG at the end of the loan tenure may be used to write-back the provisions.
'This is not a policy change, but a call-out for those NBFCs that were not doing enough provisioning. It's a prompt for NBFCs to appropriately provision against credit losses, and treat DLGs and recoveries separately," said Kunal Varma, chief executive officer and founder of digital non-banking finance company Freo. However, he said, this may lead to some NBFCs re-evaluating their First Loss Default Guarantee or FLDG-linked relationships in the short term.
RBI's concerns stem from elevated delinquencies in some loan pools sourced by fintechs, leading to higher DLG payouts by them and a hit on the asset quality of a few partner NBFCs. Moreover, there have also been concerns around NBFCs using FLDG arrangements as an alternative to securitisation transactions, bypassing the guidelines of securitisation of loan pools.
RBI's perspective seems to be that DLG arrangements were allowed to give capital comfort from a regulatory perspective and encourage 'skin in the game' for fintechs, but not dilute the accountability of underwriting by regulated entities.
Point of contention
Typically, each fintech—such as Paytm, PhonePe, MobiKwik—ties up with multiple regulated banks or NBFCs to offer multiple loan options to their customers. In turn, lenders can accept DLG arrangements in the form of cash deposits, fixed deposits with a lien marked in their favour, and bank guarantees.
DLG arrangements for pools of small-ticket unsecured loans are generally used for consumption and lifestyle lending, emergency healthcare expenses, education finance for skill development or vocational degrees and diplomas, sustainable energy such as installing a solar roof and lending to small businesses and new-to-credit borrowers.
Read more: How RBI is shaping the future of lending from Bengaluru's HSR Layout
FLDG has been a point of contention since the first digital lending guidelines were issued in August 2022. Worried that these DLG loss absorptions were leading to inaccurate reflection of the credit quality of these borrowers, RBI in June 2023 issued the default loss guarantee framework, capping the value of such arrangements at 5% of the loan pool. It had then specified that regulated entities will be responsible for recognising non-performing assets of individual loans in the portfolio and the consequent provisioning as per current norms, regardless of any DLG cover at the portfolio level.
Even then industry representatives had approached RBI seeking clarity on certain aspects of the guidelines such as treatment of NPAs given the differences with the ECL framework, and on the kind of different cohorts and structures that can be explored under the DLG framework. This had prompted RBI to issue an FAQ in November 2023 clarifying some of these aspects.
However, these circulars were repealed when the consolidated Digital Lending Guidelines were issued on 8 May 2025, leading to some confusion on how provisioning for these loans may be interpreted. Fintech lenders believe that DLG is a form of credit guarantee or enhancement—the entire purpose of which is to provide capital comfort to the lender and help free up the lender's capital for additional on-lending.
'As per Ind-AS, NBFCs were considering the credit enhancement provided by an FLDG for purposes of computing the ECL on a loan portfolio (given that an FLDG qualifies as a credit enhancement intrinsic to the contractual terms of the arrangement, which is the requirement under Ind-AS 109)," said Shilpa Mankar Ahluwalia, partner, head-fintech, Shardul Amarchand Mangaldas & Co.
RBI's 8 May directions, however, suggest that the amount of the DLG cover cannot be adjusted to reduce ECL computation, which could alter the cost-benefit to NBFCs given the zero-provisioning benefit of DLGs, according to experts who believe it could also send 'mixed signals" to market participants, investors and new entrants in the LSP space and may lead to the opinion that fintechs are not to be trusted.
Read more: Lenders concerned about education loans as US tightens curbs on student visas
Already, DLG rules only allow lien-marked deposits or bank guarantees, which practically removes any performance risk on such guarantees, said Ahluwalia. 'The industry also claims that capping the DLG at 5% had already prompted NBFCs to implement strong credit underwriting and risk tools, and removing the provisioning benefit of DLG cover may increase costs of digital loans and reduce credit access."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
CEO of Russia-backed Indian refiner Nayara resigns after EU sanctions, sources say
Russia-backed Indian refiner Nayara Energy has named a new chief executive after its previous CEO resigned following European Union sanctions that targeted the company, four sources with knowledge of the matter said on Friday. The reshuffle at the top is the latest disruption for the company since the EU announced a new round of sanctions last Friday directed at Russia over its war in Ukraine. This week, a tanker carrying Russian Urals crude was diverted away from Nayara's Vadinar port to unload its cargo at another port in western India, Reuters reported. That came after two other tankers skipped loading refined products from Vadinar, Reuters reported. Mumbai-based Nayara has appointed company veteran Sergey Denisov as chief executive to replace Alessandro des Dorides, the sources said. Denisov's appointment was decided at a board meeting on Wednesday, they said. Nayara Energy did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Des Dorides, who joined Nayara Energy in April 2024, did not immediately respond to a message sent on LinkedIn. Denisov has been with the company since 2017. Nayara Energy has condemned the EU's "unjust and unilateral" decision to impose sanctions. Russia's Rosneft holds a 49.13% stake in Nayara and a similar stake is owned by a consortium, Kesani Enterprises Co Ltd, led by Italy's Mareterra Group and Russian investment group United Capital Partners. India, which has become the top importer of seaborne Russian oil in the aftermath of Moscow's Ukraine invasion, has also said it does not support the bloc's sanctions.
New Indian Express
an hour ago
- New Indian Express
RBI Governor says FTA with UK will help India, bats for more such pacts with other nations
MUMBAI: Reserve Bank Governor Sanjay Malhotra on Friday welcomed the signing of the free trade agreement with the UK, saying it will help multiple sectors of the Indian economy. Speaking at the FE Modern BFSI Summit here, Malhotra said multilateralism has "unfortunately" taken a back seat, and the country needs more such pacts (like the UK FTA) with countries and added that negotiations with the US are in advanced stages. "Hopefully, it (UK FTA) should help is the way going forward now, because unfortunately multilateralism seems to have taken a back seat," Malhotra said in the central bank's first comments on the trade deal with the UK signed in London. "It should help various sectors in our manufacturing as well as on the services side," Malhotra added. Malhotra said that given the current realities, where multilateralism has taken a back seat, it is necessary for India to have more such pacts with other countries. He also acknowledged that there are many more such pacts in the negotiation stage. India and the UK signed the FTA during Prime Minister Narendra Modi's two-day visit to the UK. The agreement has been in the making for many years now and will open up markets for both countries across goods and services. Meanwhile, Malhotra backed his US counterpart Jerome Powell for his work on upholding the Federal Reserve's independence, at a time when US President Donald Trump has gone public with his disagreement with its policies. "He (Powell) is doing a very good job. Maintaining the independence of the central bank is very important. I think he has done a commendable job," Malhotra said. On cryptocurrency regulations, Malhotra said the government-appointed panel to look into the issue in India will take into account the RBI's concerns. There is no work for a separate currency for the BRICS grouping, the RBI governor said, maintaining that like any other country, India is working on popularising its own currency, and the US dollar is here to stay. India has an agreement with the UAE and is also looking at some arrangement with Maldives on the rupee trade, he said. "The dollar is here, as you're all aware, it's going to be here, you know, for some time, for a longish time. It's because you need some universal cross-border currency," the RBI governor said. Meanwhile, he also appreciated the work done by the Ministry of Petroleum in managing the oil procurement despite the sanctions on Russia.
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
an hour ago
- Business Standard
Inflation, growth outlook to guide rate cuts, not current CPI data: RBI Guv
With data showing a steep decline in price rise in June, Reserve Bank Governor Sanjay Malhotra on Friday said that the outlook on inflation and growth will determine future rate cuts, making it clear that the current data will not influence the trajectory. Speaking at the FE Modern BFSI Summit here, Malhotra also stated that the RBI's rate cuts will not lead to asset bubbles and added that the central bank has more ammunition in its arsenal beyond rate cuts to help the economy. It can be noted that the RBI has cut its key rates by 1 percentage point this year, and official data pointing to headline inflation cooling to 2.1 per cent against the 4 per cent target has led to expectations of further easing. "Rate cuts will depend on the outlook for both growth and inflation rather than the current numbers," Malhotra said. "We have to remember that monetary policy works with a lag and hence outlook on the outcomes on key data like inflation for up to 12 months is kept in mind while taking the rate calls." He reminded that as per the current projections, CPI is expected to rise to 4.4 per cent in Q4, but admitted that the current outcomes suggest there will be a downward revision to the number. Data available till June suggest that banks' lending rates have declined by around 0.50 per cent this year, the same as the RBI's rate cuts till then, signalling a complete transmission of the RBI's decision. The rate cuts are aimed at upping the credit growth, Malhotra said, exuding confidence that they will not lead to the creation of asset bubbles. He said the 12.1 per cent credit growth for FY25 is better than the decadal average of over 10 per cent, but admitted that the number is trailing at around 9 per cent levels in FY26. Malhotra assured the industry that the RBI will provide "the right macroeconomic conditions for growth" through its policies, liquidity stance and regulatory moves. The shift in stance to "neutral" from "accommodative" suggests that the bar for delivering a rate cut is much higher now, Malhotra said. When asked if the RBI has expended its tools to support growth very soon with the deep rate cuts, Malhotra said there is more ammunition in the RBI armoury and added that there are more tools available with the central bank, but declined to specify any. Despite the cut in cash reserve ratio (CRR) to 3 per cent, the RBI will have sufficient funds to tackle any eventuality, he said, pointing out that even during the COVID crisis, it utilised only 1 per cent. CRR cut is not just a liquidity move, but an attempt to reduce the cost of intermediation, which will help lower the borrowing costs as well, the governor said. The RBI has undertaken moves to make its regulations simple and clear through an attempt to fit all the regulations in 33 master regulations, he added. At present, there are over 8,000 regulations of which only about 3,000 are in use, and the rest have become obsolete, Malhotra noted. The RBI is also setting up a regulatory review cell to revisit a regulation after every 5-7 years and keep it contemporary, he added. The costs and benefits of a regulation are very important for the RBI, Malhotra said, adding that a set of protocols has been finalised to introduce every regulation only after consultation. Bank officials are doing a weekly visit to each of the over 2.7 lakh panchayats in the country to deepen financial inclusion, understand their concerns and also do re-KYC for the accounts. Meanwhile, the governor reiterated the RBI's concerns about allowing industrial houses to promote banks, saying any entity undertaking a real economy, along with financial sector activity, exposes the system to potential conflicts of interest. It is only the voting rights which are capped at 26 per cent as per the Banking Regulation Act, and even foreign banks can have up to 100 per cent shareholding in a domestic bank, he said. At present, the government is subsidising the payments infrastructure given its huge benefits, and in the future, there will be a need to have payments either by the state or users to ensure that the system keeps on, the governor said. Amid the Indusind Bank troubles, Malhotra said that while a bank board has to be vigilant on all the goings-on, it cannot be held responsible for every misdemeanour at a lender.
