NFL defeats lawsuit over alleged monopoly on team merchandise
Manhattan-based U.S. District Judge Andrew Carter Jr on Monday said, opens new tab retailer Casey's Distributing Inc had not provided enough evidence to support the proposed class action, which claimed that the NFL's tight distribution rules left consumers with fewer options and higher prices.
Casey's buys NFL merchandise from licensed manufacturers and resells it. The Nebraska-based company in 2022 sued the NFL and its 32 teams, accusing them of illegally monopolizing the licensing of trademarked team products.
Casey's claimed it and other online retailers were being denied the opportunity to sell on some platforms such as Amazon.com.
'While plaintiffs have been harmed by the actions of the defendants, the law protects competition, not competitors,' Carter wrote. He said there was nothing in Casey's lawsuit that adequately alleged consumers were forced to pay higher prices due to the alleged scheme.
The NFL and attorneys for Casey's did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
Casey's also named as a defendant the sports merchandise giants Fanatics. Casey's said its products were removed from Walmart after it chose Fanatics as its exclusive seller. Fanatics did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
The NFL and Fanatics had denied any wrongdoing. Walmart and Amazon were not defendants.
In its lawsuit, opens new tab, Casey's said Amazon's online marketplace is the most important platform for small businesses like Casey's to participate in the market for licensed NFL merchandise.
The NFL in asking Carter to dismiss Casey's lawsuit said, opens new tab its online distribution policy was flexible, and that retailers that want to sell on Amazon must first seek approval by NFL Properties, which licenses the intellectual property for the league and its teams.
In a court filing, the NFL defended its distribution rules as lawful, saying they focus on brand and consumer protection and do not impose restrictions or rules on price or output.
Carter said Casey's will have a chance to refile its lawsuit by the end of the month to try to persuade him to allow the claims to move forward.
The case is Casey's Distributing Inc v. National Football Club et al, U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York, No. 1:22-cv-03934-ALC.
For plaintiffs: John Balestriere of Balestriere Fariello and Justin Nematzadeh of Nematzadeh PLLC
For NFL: Bradley Ruskin, David Munkittrick and Jeffrey Warshafsky of Proskauer Rose
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South Wales Guardian
an hour ago
- South Wales Guardian
Shoppers flock to sweet treats inspired by US trends, Mr Kipling owner says
The St Albans-based owner of brands including Mr Kipling and Bisto said there were signs of shoppers switching back to brands. Branded sales across the group grew by 1.2% to £216 million over the 13 weeks to June 28, compared with the same period a year ago. This was driven by an 11.34% jump in sales of its sweet treat branded products including Mr Kipling and Cadbury cakes. Mr Kipling birthday cake tarts, inspired by snack trends in the US, and newly launched 'lunchbox' cake slices helped draw in new shoppers, the company said. Chief executive Alex Whitehouse said the uptick in branded sales was 'driven by the strength of our innovation programme with new product ranges such as Mr Kipling birthday cake tarts performing very strongly, as we brought to Britain a trend that is particularly popular in the US'. 'We expect branded revenue growth to build through the year, as we launch further new products, such as Fuel10K yoghurt and granola pots,' he added. However, revenues from its grocery products declined by 2.7% over the latest period. Demand for items such as gravy, stock and soup were impacted by warmer-than-usual temperatures, Premier Foods said. It pointed to new product launches such as The Spice Tailor rolling out Mexican kits and Bisto bringing out peri-peri gravy to attract more younger consumers. Meanwhile, non-branded grocery revenues declined by 8.8% year-on-year, which Premier Foods said partly reflected consumers switching to brands. Premier Foods said it was expecting sales growth from its portfolio of brands to build throughout the financial year. It is also continuing to target cost-cutting across the business in a bid to bolster profits. Shares in the company were down by nearly 4% on Thursday following the update.
South Wales Guardian
an hour ago
- South Wales Guardian
Energy giant SSE sees UK dry spell hit water power generation
The Perth-based energy giant reported a 4% decrease in output in May and June, compared with the same period last year. This was due to 'unfavourable weather conditions' affecting its hydro power stations, which work by harnessing the power of moving water to generate electricity. SSE's hydro generation dropped by about 40% in the three months to June, compared with the same period a year ago. Scotland has experienced a lack of rainfall, with regions in the east seeing the driest spring since 1964, according to the Scottish Environment Protection Agency. SSE told investors that the dry conditions offset strong operational availability across its renewable power plants. Meanwhile, the company welcomed 'clarity' from the Government's decision not to split the country into different energy pricing zones. Energy Secretary Ed Miliband confirmed earlier this month that the UK would retain a single national wholesale price for electricity but reform the current system. SSE said in a statement to investors that the decision brings 'welcome clarity for both investors and consumers whilst sending a strong investment signal that reaffirms the UK as a world-leading renewables market'. The form said its financial outlook for the year continues to be subject to weather, market conditions and plant availability, with the key winter months still to come.
Leader Live
3 hours ago
- Leader Live
Energy giant SSE sees UK dry spell hit water power generation
The Perth-based energy giant reported a 4% decrease in output in May and June, compared with the same period last year. This was due to 'unfavourable weather conditions' affecting its hydro power stations, which work by harnessing the power of moving water to generate electricity. SSE's hydro generation dropped by about 40% in the three months to June, compared with the same period a year ago. Scotland has experienced a lack of rainfall, with regions in the east seeing the driest spring since 1964, according to the Scottish Environment Protection Agency. SSE told investors that the dry conditions offset strong operational availability across its renewable power plants. Meanwhile, the company welcomed 'clarity' from the Government's decision not to split the country into different energy pricing zones. Energy Secretary Ed Miliband confirmed earlier this month that the UK would retain a single national wholesale price for electricity but reform the current system. SSE said in a statement to investors that the decision brings 'welcome clarity for both investors and consumers whilst sending a strong investment signal that reaffirms the UK as a world-leading renewables market'. The form said its financial outlook for the year continues to be subject to weather, market conditions and plant availability, with the key winter months still to come.
