Is diet coke '100x healthier' than sugarcane juice? Experts debunk doctor's viral claim
In the now viral post, Dr. Sadhale wrote, "Diet Coke is 100x healthier than sugarcane juice, but Indian society is not ready to discuss that yet because of culture." He also shared a thread of studies and explanations on how there is no evidence that artificial sweeteners harm gut health.
Is Coke Zero safe for you?
According to the supportive post, Dr. Sadhale made bold claims that coke zero is absolutely safe to consume but its not healthy. He explains, Coke Zero contains Aspartame that breaks down into three components, such as methanol, phenylalanine and aspartic.
Methanol can put you in a coma, while phenylalanine causes brain damage and aspartic causes cancer, he says in the video. But then he gives an example of a tomato that contains 6 times the amount of methanol as Coke Zero, moreover, 100 grams of meat contains 32 times of phenylalanine in it, and one egg contains 34 times the amount of aspartic acid as in Coke Zero, Dr. Sadhale mentions.
A tomato has 6 times the amount of methanol as Coke Zero
100 grams of meat contains 32 times of phenylalanine
One egg contains 34 times the amount of aspartic acid as in Coke Zero
According to the FDA, the safe amount of aspartame is about 50mg per kg of body weight in a single day. While one can of Coke Zero contains 85mg of aspartame, for a normal individual, they have to consume about 3500mg of aspartame to cross the safety guidelines of the FDA. The post instantly went viral, raising health concerns.
Coke zero is absolutely safe for you.But it is not healthy!Let's understand in detail. pic.twitter.com/jsCu9uv4SO
Is Diet Coke healthier than sugarcane juice? If 'no', here's why
Though it is called 'Diet Coke' and has no sugar or calories, it is loaded with artificial sweeteners and chemicals that may take a toll on gut health and lead to a sluggish metabolism over time. "However, when it comes to sugarcane juice, it is natural but jam-packed with sugar and can raise one's blood sugar levels, especially in the case of those having diabetes. So, the healthy alternative for Diet Coke is lemon water or fruit-infused water," says Dr. Rajeshwari Panda, Head of the Dietetics Department at Medicover Hospital, Kharghar, Navi Mumbai.
Does Coke Zero contain artificial sweeteners like aspartame and other chemical additives?
Neither Diet Coke nor sugarcane juice is healthy. Hence, it is imperative to avoid both of them. "Understand that even after Diet Coke claims to have zero calories, it is loaded with artificial sweeteners like aspartame and chemical additives that may give a tough time to the gut, lead to cravings, and affect insulin response over time," warns Dr. Panda.
Sugarcane juice, though high in natural sugar, is not advisable as well. According to Dr. Panda, "It can fluctuate one's blood sugar levels. So, neither is healthy at all. Diet Coke has no nutritional value. Don't drink Diet Coke in the name of healthy or mindful eating."
"There is a hype about Diet Coke, as many videos are circulated online where it is being promoted as a healthy drink. Diet Coke can lead to tooth decay, erode the tooth enamel, headaches, obesity, raise blood pressure, sleep issues, and weakened bones. So, it's better to avoid Diet Coke. It is better to stay alert and say NO to diet soda."
Risks of having sugarcane juice often
Substituting cane sugar for actual cane sugar with high-fructose corn syrup can make the Diet Coke a bit better, but it won't turn it to a healthy beverage, is what experts.
Sugarcane juice, while natural, contains a high amount of sugar and calories. "Frequent consumption can lead to increased blood glucose levels, which poses a risk for developing insulin resistance or type 2 diabetes, especially in individuals predisposed to metabolic disorders," says Dr Manjusha Agarwal, Senior Consultant Internal Medicine, Gleneagles Hospital Parel, Mumbai. Additionally, it lacks essential fibres because it is an extracted liquid, which can lead to spikes in blood sugar without the satiety that whole foods provide.
Just because something is natural does not mean it is free from health risks. Regular intake of sugar-laden beverages can contribute to:
Weight gain and associated health problems, such as obesity
Cardiovascular disease
Dental issues
"Moreover, while sugarcane juice does contain some vitamins and minerals, over-reliance on it could result in a dietary imbalance. It's important to enjoy sugarcane juice in moderation and balance it with a variety of other nutrient-dense foods to support overall health."
Always consult a healthcare professional for personalised advice, especially if you have pre-existing health conditions. Moderation is key for maintaining a healthy diet.
Healthy alternatives to both Diet Coke and sugarcane juice
Swap sugarcane juice with coconut water, fresh vegetable juices, or homemade lemonade that has less amount of sugar. "It is better to avoid fancy colas that are marketed as healthy and with zero calories. It is nothing but a gimmick to lure the customers. Don't fall prey to such marketing gimmicks that can do more harm than good to the body," explains Dr. Panda.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
37 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
From spice to soul: The story of Indian curry
Ever wondered why a simple bowl of curry evokes such comfort and nostalgia across Indian households? Whether it is on the dinner table at home or ordered from a beloved takeaway, curry remains one of the most loved dishes, not just in India, but globally. But what exactly gives this humble preparation such staying power? Chickpea curry(Unsplash) Despite its global recognition, curry is inherently Indian at its core. From the coconut-based gravies of Kerala to the mustard-heavy jhols of Bengal or the robust rajma of North India, each curry has a unique identity shaped by history, climate, and culture. At the heart of this diversity lies ayurveda, the ancient Indian system of wellness that shaped how Indians have cooked for centuries. Curries are a masterclass in ayurvedic balance: Sourness from tamarind or raw mango, sweetness from jaggery or ripe fruit, bitterness from fenugreek or asafoetida, and a burst of pungent and salty notes all come together perfectly to create a masterpiece. These dishes are designed to aid digestion, stabilise energy, and support mental clarity. In the Ayurvedic worldview, food is medicine. Curry just happens to be the most delicious dose. While the term 'curry' likely has colonial roots, introduced by Portuguese or British colonists who were trying to label the complex, spiced gravies they encountered, it is the Indian kitchen where this dish found its soul. No matter the region, curries represent comfort, resourcefulness, and the joy of shared meals. Each one tells a story through its ingredients, techniques, and intent, a story that long predates the name it's now known by. While spices do bring in flavour, they are so much more than that. Spices deliver aroma, colour, and even functional benefits. From a food science perspective, spices influence the organoleptic properties of a dish: how it tastes, smells, looks, and feels, and interacts chemically with other components to create a cohesive structure. Ingredients like ground nuts, coconut milk, and yogurt add creaminess and act as natural emulsifiers. They are cultural and nutritional optimizations handed down through generations. Many spices used in curry, such as turmeric, cumin, and black pepper, have also been shown to have antioxidant and anti-inflammatory properties. Their medicinal value was recognised in Indian households long before scientific studies validated it. To truly appreciate curry, we must look beyond its surface and understand its layered complexity. At its core, curry holds deep cultural relevance, with each regional variation serving as an expression of local identity, ingredients, and customs. Its flavour is carefully constructed, with every spice and base contributing to a symphony of tastes that create a harmonious dish. Nutritionally, curries provide bioactive compounds, essential nutrients, and wholesome calories. Finally, the culinary technique involved, from roasting and grinding to tempering and slow cooking, adds texture, aroma, and depth, elevating curry from a simple preparation to an artisanal craft. This structure helps explain why curries are a masterpiece in themselves. What appears as a spontaneous blend of ingredients is often a calculated act, with attention to proportions, sequencing, and heat. The same spice may be used differently. It can be whole, ground, roasted, or fried depending on the desired effect. Curry-making is, in many ways, chemistry with soul. Homemade curries, prepared with care and moderation, can be deeply nourishing. But when adapted for speed or scale, think restaurant fare or packaged gravies, they can veer into unhealthy territory. Too much fat, salt, or cream can undo their natural balance. Here are a few tweaks to make curries lighter and better: Swap out trans fats, which are industrially produced fats found in some margarines, packaged snacks, and fried foods. They raise bad cholesterol and lower good cholesterol, increasing the risk of heart disease. Instead, use heart-friendly oils like mustard oil, rice bran oil, or blended vegetable oils. Use distinct flavour enhancers such as lemon juice for acidity, fresh herbs like coriander or mint for brightness, and spices like cumin or black pepper for complexity. Add a small amount of monosodium glutamate (MSG) to enhance savoury depth. Despite misconceptions, MSG is recognised as safe by food safety authorities globally including Food Standards Australia New Zealand, European Commission, WHO, FAO, the US FDA and FSSAI . It also contains just 70% the amount of sodium, compared to salt and has the ability to amplify umami flavour. This helps in reducing salt usage without compromising taste, which is especially important in lower-sodium diets. Use natural emulsifiers and thickeners such as lentil flour, arrowroot, cashews, melon seeds, or ground legumes to add creaminess and structure along with nutritional benefits. These changes retain the richness of flavour while aligning better with modern health standards. Low-fat yoghurt or plant-based cream alternatives can help maintain the creamy texture without compromising heart health. Cooking techniques such as steaming or pressure-cooking help preserve nutrients. As we rethink food with wellness, sustainability, and cultural pride in mind, the curry emerges as a symbol of all three. It is adaptable, rooted, and meaningful. In a world of fast-evolving diets, the curry keeps holding its own. It speaks of both tradition and transformation. It invites experimentation while offering a sense of home. Whether you are exploring a plant-based lifestyle, rethinking your spice rack, or simply aiming to eat more mindfully, curry offers endless, delicious possibilities. And that is something worth savouring. This article is authored by Jamuna Prakash, food consultant and former professor, Department of Food Science and Nutrition, University of Mysore.
Hindustan Times
37 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Indian institutions face challenges in joining knowledge clusters for resource sharing: Report
New Delhi, Indian higher-education institutions face significant challenges in joining large knowledge clusters for resource sharing, primarily due to infrastructural limitations, financial constraints and institutional cultural differences, according to a new report by QS I-GAUGE. Indian institutions face challenges in joining knowledge clusters for resource sharing: Report QS I-GAUGE is an independent education-rating system that brings together the global experience and expertise of London-based QS Quacquarelli Symonds and the knowledge of Indian educational luminaries. The report, titled "From vision to reality: Tracking NEP 2020 implementation in Indian higher education", that was released on Thursday has a series of findings on the progress of the implementation of the National Education Policy in the country's higher-education institutions. "Indian higher-education institutions face significant challenges in joining large knowledge clusters for resource sharing, primarily due to infrastructural limitations, financial constraints and institutional cultural differences. While curricular flexibility has been successfully integrated in many institutions, the implementation of multiple entry and exit options as envisioned under NEP 2020 remains limited," the report said. "The establishment of student support and service centres is well-implemented, but institutional partnerships for mental health and well-being with national institutions of importance, such as National Institute of Mental Health and Neuro Sciences, Ranchi Institute of Neuro-Psychiatry and Allied Sciences and All India Institute of Medical Sciences is currently inadequate," it added. The report collated data from 165 higher-educational institutions based in 21 states and three Union territories to highlight the progress made by the institutes so far and identify critical gaps and emerging opportunities that must be addressed to realise the transformative vision of the policy. "There is a high degree of institutional alignment with the National Higher Education Qualifications Framework and most institutions report near-complete alignment between programme-learning outcomes and course-learning outcomes. Although there is a strong intent to involve industry experts and professors of practice in curriculum development, actual appointments of PoPs remain significantly low. "Key barriers to achieving institutional autonomy include financial dependence, bureaucratic processes, internal resistance to change and limited institutional capacity. International research collaboration and the signing of memoranda of understanding with global institutions remain underdeveloped across many higher-education institutions," it said. The report noted that there is a growing intention to adopt the principles of the Indian Knowledge System, though the progress has been gradual. "With the right vision, strategic investment and focussed effort, meaningful integration of Indian Knowledge System into mainstream education can be accelerated," it said. This article was generated from an automated news agency feed without modifications to text.
The Hindu
an hour ago
- The Hindu
Community Health Officers trained as first responders to snakebites in Mysuru
A five-day training on snakebite management was conducted with 280 Community Health Officers, who were equipped to be the first responders to snakebites in Mysuru district. The training programme was conducted recently by the District Surveillance Unit Office of the Department of Health and Family Welfare in Mysuru, in collaboration with Humane World for Animals India (formerly Humane Society International India), and Liana Trust. A release said that the training covered essential information on primary treatment and emergency management of snakebites, and is an attempt to address a major public health concern in the country. It is reckoned that an estimated 58,000 people die due to snakebites, and around 2,00,000 people suffer from life-altering health issues in India every year, the release said. The training programme has helped to provide knowledge to community officers which will not only save human lives, but also prevent killing of snakes by people, out of fear, the authorities added. The training of the 280 Community Health Officers was conducted for five days, and they were drawn from all the taluks of the district. They were given extensive information on topics such as commonly encountered venomous snakes, identifying signs of snakebite, prevention strategies, do's and don'ts during a bite incident, the importance of coexistence with snakes in rural areas, and the psychological and socio-economic impact of snakebites on families and individuals. District Surveillance Officer D.G. Nagaraj pointed out that Community Health Officers are the primary responders to community health problems and serve as a key link between rural communities and public health systems. Hence, training them on snake bite management was vital, he said. He said that there are nearly 330 Community Health Officers in Mysuru, and all of them are now trained as first responders to snakebite and its management. Jerry Martin, founder and trustee of Liana Trust, which is striving to address and resolve human-wildlife conflict, said while research into developing new treatments and improving existing ones is ongoing, the role of community education in preventing bites and deaths is just as important. According to Sumanth Bindumadhav, director of Wildlife Protection at Humane World for Animals India, if community members have the correct information, snakebites can be prevented, human lives can be saved, and cruelty towards snakes can also be curtailed. Humane World for Animals India and Liana Trust have been working with Mysuru district since 2018 to make the city a model for snakebite prevention and management strategies through ecological studies, social surveys, community outreach, policy reform, and institutional capacity building. In February 2024, Karnataka became the first Indian state to declare snakebite as a notifiable disease, the release added.
