
Is diet coke '100x healthier' than sugarcane juice? Experts debunk doctor's viral claim
In the now viral post, Dr. Sadhale wrote, "Diet Coke is 100x healthier than sugarcane juice, but Indian society is not ready to discuss that yet because of culture." He also shared a thread of studies and explanations on how there is no evidence that artificial sweeteners harm gut health.
Is Coke Zero safe for you?
According to the supportive post, Dr. Sadhale made bold claims that coke zero is absolutely safe to consume but its not healthy. He explains, Coke Zero contains Aspartame that breaks down into three components, such as methanol, phenylalanine and aspartic.
Methanol can put you in a coma, while phenylalanine causes brain damage and aspartic causes cancer, he says in the video. But then he gives an example of a tomato that contains 6 times the amount of methanol as Coke Zero, moreover, 100 grams of meat contains 32 times of phenylalanine in it, and one egg contains 34 times the amount of aspartic acid as in Coke Zero, Dr. Sadhale mentions.
A tomato has 6 times the amount of methanol as Coke Zero
100 grams of meat contains 32 times of phenylalanine
One egg contains 34 times the amount of aspartic acid as in Coke Zero
According to the FDA, the safe amount of aspartame is about 50mg per kg of body weight in a single day. While one can of Coke Zero contains 85mg of aspartame, for a normal individual, they have to consume about 3500mg of aspartame to cross the safety guidelines of the FDA. The post instantly went viral, raising health concerns.
Coke zero is absolutely safe for you.But it is not healthy!Let's understand in detail. pic.twitter.com/jsCu9uv4SO
Is Diet Coke healthier than sugarcane juice? If 'no', here's why
Though it is called 'Diet Coke' and has no sugar or calories, it is loaded with artificial sweeteners and chemicals that may take a toll on gut health and lead to a sluggish metabolism over time. "However, when it comes to sugarcane juice, it is natural but jam-packed with sugar and can raise one's blood sugar levels, especially in the case of those having diabetes. So, the healthy alternative for Diet Coke is lemon water or fruit-infused water," says Dr. Rajeshwari Panda, Head of the Dietetics Department at Medicover Hospital, Kharghar, Navi Mumbai.
Does Coke Zero contain artificial sweeteners like aspartame and other chemical additives?
Neither Diet Coke nor sugarcane juice is healthy. Hence, it is imperative to avoid both of them. "Understand that even after Diet Coke claims to have zero calories, it is loaded with artificial sweeteners like aspartame and chemical additives that may give a tough time to the gut, lead to cravings, and affect insulin response over time," warns Dr. Panda.
Sugarcane juice, though high in natural sugar, is not advisable as well. According to Dr. Panda, "It can fluctuate one's blood sugar levels. So, neither is healthy at all. Diet Coke has no nutritional value. Don't drink Diet Coke in the name of healthy or mindful eating."
"There is a hype about Diet Coke, as many videos are circulated online where it is being promoted as a healthy drink. Diet Coke can lead to tooth decay, erode the tooth enamel, headaches, obesity, raise blood pressure, sleep issues, and weakened bones. So, it's better to avoid Diet Coke. It is better to stay alert and say NO to diet soda."
Risks of having sugarcane juice often
Substituting cane sugar for actual cane sugar with high-fructose corn syrup can make the Diet Coke a bit better, but it won't turn it to a healthy beverage, is what experts.
Sugarcane juice, while natural, contains a high amount of sugar and calories. "Frequent consumption can lead to increased blood glucose levels, which poses a risk for developing insulin resistance or type 2 diabetes, especially in individuals predisposed to metabolic disorders," says Dr Manjusha Agarwal, Senior Consultant Internal Medicine, Gleneagles Hospital Parel, Mumbai. Additionally, it lacks essential fibres because it is an extracted liquid, which can lead to spikes in blood sugar without the satiety that whole foods provide.
Just because something is natural does not mean it is free from health risks. Regular intake of sugar-laden beverages can contribute to:
Weight gain and associated health problems, such as obesity
Cardiovascular disease
Dental issues
"Moreover, while sugarcane juice does contain some vitamins and minerals, over-reliance on it could result in a dietary imbalance. It's important to enjoy sugarcane juice in moderation and balance it with a variety of other nutrient-dense foods to support overall health."
Always consult a healthcare professional for personalised advice, especially if you have pre-existing health conditions. Moderation is key for maintaining a healthy diet.
Healthy alternatives to both Diet Coke and sugarcane juice
Swap sugarcane juice with coconut water, fresh vegetable juices, or homemade lemonade that has less amount of sugar. "It is better to avoid fancy colas that are marketed as healthy and with zero calories. It is nothing but a gimmick to lure the customers. Don't fall prey to such marketing gimmicks that can do more harm than good to the body," explains Dr. Panda.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Time of India
36 minutes ago
- Time of India
Duty relief to boost pharma companies' access to UK drug stores
Live Events (You can now subscribe to our (You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel The India-UK FTA is expected to give a strong tailwind to India's pharmaceutical and medical devices sectors with tariff relief and smoother regulatory pathways acting as critical drivers, industry experts told agreement will boost exports giving an easier access to the UK market. It is expected to help Indian companies - especially those in generics and biosimilars - to scale their market presence, fast track product approvals, provide a push to cross-border R&D and UK has committed to zero tariff on nearly 99% of Indian pharma exports. While Indian pharma exports to the UK were largely duty free even earlier, the latest agreement formalises the status which brings in long-term clarity to to industry estimates, the pharma market size of the UK stands at about $45 billion and is expected to shoot to $73 billion by 2033. The share of the Indian drugs can see a significant push from the UK's generics segment which is currently pegged at $5 pharmaceutical exports to the UK crossed $910 million in FY24, according to estimates."The agreement strengthens supply chains , enhances access to affordable medicines , and drives Foreign Direct Investment (FDI)," said Namit Joshi, Chairman of Pharmexcil."This partnership paves the way for collaborations in bulk drug imports, CDMO (contract manufacturing), and joint research, empowering India's competitive edge and promoting global partnerships."The pact will open up trade and economic opportunities between the two countries. "The pharma sector will have opportunities to supply quality medicines contributing to better patient care in the UK," said Sudarshan Jain, Secretary General, Indian Pharmaceutical Alliance."The tariffs relief on generic medicines and key medical devices like surgical instruments and diagnostics under the FTA will enhance the affordability and appeal of Indian products in the UK market," said Manoj Mishra, Partner and Tax Controversy Management Leader, Grant Thornton Bharat. The move significantly boosts the competitiveness of Indian generics and high-quality affordable healthcare solutions, positioning India to scale its footprint in one of Europe's most valuable healthcare markets, said the medical devices sector too the move is expected to open new opportunities, said experts.


The Hindu
38 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Doctors stress the need for gender-neutral cervical cancer prevention strategy in India
For years, the human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccine has been closely associated with preventing cervical cancer in women. However, doctors are now pushing for a more inclusive approach, urging that boys too be vaccinated to curb transmission and protect against several other cancers linked to the virus. At the Conquer HPV and Cancer Conclave, an initiative by the Serum Institute of India in Hyderabad on Thursday, doctors underscored the need to reframe HPV as a public health concern rather than solely a women's health issue. 'Why boys? Because they are the carriers. HPV is primarily transmitted through sexual contact. In both Indian and Western statistics, about one in three boys are found to have the virus by the age of 15. While it may not cause immediate symptoms or health issues in boys, it is often passed on to girls, increasing their risk of cervical cancer,' said Dr. M. Surendranath, HoD, Paediatrics, DNB Faculty, Vijay Marie Hospital, Hyderabad. He pointed out that HPV is not limited to cervical cancer. 'It can also lead to penile cancer, anal cancer, and oropharyngeal (throat) cancer in men. Moreover, HPV types 6 and 11 cause genital warts, psychologically distressing, though not cancerous. Australia's decision to vaccinate boys under its national immunisation programme has significantly brought down cases of genital warts,' he said. Silent virus, late consequences One reason for the lack of awareness, doctors say, is that HPV doesn't show symptoms early on. 'It is unlike other viral infections where you get a fever or rash. In the case of HPV, most people don't even realise they've been infected. It can remain dormant in the body for decades and only manifest as cancer years later,' said Dr. D. Leela, consultant gynaecologist, St. Theresa's Hospital and Asvins Hospital, Hyderabad. Screening and prevention: Not just vaccines While vaccination is a crucial step in prevention, doctors highlighted the importance of screening, especially for women aged 30 and above. 'There are three levels of screening. The government-recommended method is VIA (Visual Inspection with Acetic Acid), where simple vinegar is applied to the cervix to check for abnormalities. Then there is the more familiar Pap smear or cytology. And finally, the most sensitive but costly option is the HPV DNA test, which detects the presence of the virus directly,' the doctor added. Vaccine targets and coverage The most commonly used HPV vaccines in India are quadrivalent, targeting types 6, 11, 16, and 18. While 6 and 11 are responsible for genital warts, 16 and 18 account for over 80% of cervical cancer cases. 'As far as genital warts go, they are relatively uncommon in India compared to Western countries. In our clinical experience, they account for about 5 to 10% of cases in gynaecological practice. Many of these patients go to dermatologists instead,' said Dr Surendranath.

Mint
3 hours ago
- Mint
India-UK FTA to boost bilateral trade for pharma, medtech, say industry bodies
The India-UK free trade agreement, signed on Thursday, is expected to open up new opportunities for Indian pharmaceutical and medical device makers. The deal is also expected to improve access to medical devices from the UK in India. Medical device manufacturers anticipate an increase in trade between the two countries but are awaiting clarity on non-tariff measures and on whether regulatory processes will be streamlined. 'Previously, medical devices imported into the UK were duty-free, so tariff restrictions were not an issue but regulatory approval costs and time were a challenge,' said Rajiv Nath, forum coordinator of industry body Association of Indian Medical Device Industry (Aimed). The body had previously sought recognition of regulatory approvals from the CDSCO or the Quality Council of India's voluntary Indian Certification for medical devices to fast-track approvals by the UK's Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA). 'We look forward to an update on this,' said Nath. However, medtech manufacturers are also seeking strict monitoring of imports to India, to prevent other countries rerouting products into India through the UK. Mint had previously reported that domestic manufacturers raised concerns over the possibility of Chinese-origin products being routed through the UK to exploit the zero-tariff provisions under the FTA. India levies about 7.5% import duties on medical devices from the UK, which are expected to come down in a phased manner after the deal, Nath said. In 2024, medical device exports to the UK increased by 13% year-on-year to ₹ 1,015 crore, while imports from the UK rose 36% to ₹ 2,295 crore, according to Exim data. 'It not only strengthens trade ties but also opens new avenues for advanced technology collaborations between Indian and UK companies,' Himanshu Baid, managing director of Poly Medicure Ltd, said in a statement. 'With India exporting medical devices worth approximately $115 million to the UK, one of our top 10 export destinations, this agreement is poised to further boost our presence,' he added. The trade deal is also expected to open up the market for India's generic drugmakers. 'As per the indications, the pharma sector will have opportunities to supply affordable and quality assured medicine contributing to better patient care in the UK,' said Sudarshan Jain, secretary general of the Indian Pharmaceutical Alliance (IPA). 'We are awaiting further details to identify specific areas where these opportunities can be effectively leveraged,' he added. Generic players like Lupin, Biocon, Dr. Reddy's Laboratories and Wockhardt, which have exposure to the UK market, could stand to benefit.