With his immigration bill, Canada's prime minister is bowing to Trump
But right now, Canadian prime minister, Mark Carney, is bucking all of that lore after pressure from the US in the form of Donald Trump's 'concerns' about undocumented migrants and fentanyl moving across the US-Canada border. In response, the recently elected Liberal PM put forward a 127-page bill that includes, among other worrying provisions, sweeping changes to immigration policy that would make the process much more precarious for refugees and could pave the way for mass deportations.
If passed, Carney's Strong Borders Act (or Bill C-2) would bar anyone who has been in the country for more than a year from receiving refugee hearings. That would apply retroactively to anyone who entered the country after June 2020. If they arrived on foot between official ports of entry, meanwhile, they'd have to apply for asylum within 14 days of entering Canada – a disastrous outcome for people fleeing Trump's persecution. The bill also gives the immigration minister's office the authority to cancel immigration documents en masse.
This bill has been widely condemned by politicians and advocacy groups such as Amnesty International and the Migrants Rights Network, who are rightly worried about just how much havoc a change like this could wreak. Jenny Wai Ching Kwan, a member of Parliament for Vancouver East, told reporters the bill would breach civil liberties and basic rights.
So what excuse does Canada have for this kind of 180 on its immigration legacy? According to the government, the aim of this legislation is to 'keep Canadians safe by ensuring law enforcement has the right tools to keep our borders secure, combat transnational organized crime, stop the flow of illegal fentanyl, and crack down on money laundering'.
In reality, the Bill C-2 contains measures that public safety minister, Gary Anandasangaree, has admitted were a response to 'the concerns that have been posed by the White House'.
'There are elements that will strengthen [our] relationships with the United States,' he said in a press conference. 'There were a number of elements in the bill that have been irritants for the US, so we are addressing some of those issues.'
Tim McSorley, the national coordinator for the International Civil Liberties Monitoring Group, condemned the federal government over the senselessness of this move. 'If the government is serious about addressing concerns regarding illegal gun and drug trafficking, it must introduce legislation specifically tailored to that goal, as opposed to a wide-ranging omnibus bill,' he said.
The demonization of immigrants has been a talking point for populist leaders throughout the west, so it's not surprising to see Carney lean into that rhetoric in order to appease Trump. Spurred on by the xenophobic rhetoric coming out of the US, Britain, and large swaths of Europe, anyone who comes from away is forced to bear the blame for the economic messes and ensuing societal erosion these countries have found themselves battling.
By feeding directly into this pipeline, Carney makes Canada not the powerful country poised to beat Trump at his dangerous games (elbows up, my foot), but a cowardly ally in the US's campaign of terror against immigrants.
Tayo Bero is a Guardian US columnist
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
Eight migrants deported from Djibouti to South Sudan, Homeland Security says
WASHINGTON/NAIROBI, July 5 (Reuters) - The Trump administration has deported to South Sudan eight migrants who had been held for more than a month by the U.S. at a military base in Djibouti, the Department of Homeland Security said on Saturday, after the migrants lost a last-ditch effort to halt their transfer. An aircraft carrying U.S. deportees arrived in South Sudan on Saturday, two officials working at Juba airport said. An airport staffer speaking on condition of anonymity told Reuters he had seen a document showing that the aircraft "arrived this morning at 6:00 am" (0400 GMT). An immigration official also said the deportees had arrived in the country but shared no further details, referring all questions to the National Security Service intelligence agency. Earlier, a South Sudan government source said U.S. officials had been at the airport awaiting the migrants' arrival. The fate of the migrants had become a flashpoint in the fight over the legality of the Trump administration's campaign to deter immigration through high-profile deportations to so-called "third countries" where migrants say they face safety concerns, which has already gone from lower courts to the Supreme Court twice. South Sudan has long been dangerous even for local residents. The U.S. State Department advises citizens not to travel there due to violent crime and armed conflict. The United Nations has said the African country's political crisis could reignite a brutal civil war that ended in 2018. The eight men, who according to their lawyers are from Cuba, Laos, Mexico, Myanmar, Sudan and Vietnam, had argued their deportations to South Sudan would violate the U.S. Constitution, which prohibits cruel and unusual punishment. They had been held in U.S. custody in Djibouti since a federal judge in Boston in May blocked the Trump administration from immediately moving them to South Sudan over due process concerns. Following additional litigation, the Supreme Court on Thursday sided with the administration, lifting those limits. Two courts considered requests from the migrants' lawyers on an emergency basis on Friday, when courts are otherwise closed for the July 4 Independence Day holiday, but ultimately U.S. District Judge Brian Murphy in Boston said the Supreme Court order required him to deny their bid, clearing the way for their deportation. The location of the men in South Sudan after their arrival was not immediately known.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Poll shows Trump's approval rating dropping among key group
Donald Trump is losing ground fast with Generation Z, with a string of new polls showing his approval among young voters has plunged to record lows. The latest YouGov/Yahoo survey found Trump's net approval among Gen Z voters collapsed from -23 in May to a staggering -41 in June, with just 27 percent approving of his job performance. A separate Quantus poll showed his Gen Z approval dropped from 46 percent in June to just 35 percent in early July, and an ActiVote poll found disapproval surged to 62 percent. It comes just months after he made surprising gains in the 2024 election. Experts say the sharp drop reflects frustration with Trump's handling of key issues like the economy, inflation, and immigration. On inflation alone, YouGov/Economist data shows his Gen Z approval sank from 32 percent to just 23 percent over the past month. Trump had significantly narrowed the Gen Z gap in 2024, losing 18–29-year-olds to Kamala Harris by just four points. A key part of that push was his teenage son Barron, who became an unlikely asset on the campaign trail. The 18-year-old emerged as a quiet but powerful influence on his father, with some calling him a political ambassador for his generation. Barron understood what Gen Z cared about and used that insight to help steer Trump's outreach strategy. He encouraged his dad to appear on comedian Theo Von's podcast and helped line up his viral 90-minute interview with Kick streamer Adin Ross, which drew 500,000 live viewers and, according to Trump's Truth Social account, racked up 100 million total views. Working alongside conservative influencer Bo Loudon, Barron also pushed Trump to engage with Gen Z favorites like YouTuber-turned-boxer Jake Paul and entrepreneur Patrick Bet-David, host of the PBD Podcast. The approach appeared to work, at least for a while, but fresh polling suggests that goodwill is rapidly evaporating, as the broader electorate seems largely unfazed by his recent military actions. Despite authorizing U.S. airstrikes on three Iranian nuclear sites during the so-called '12 Day War' between Israel and Iran, the president's approval rating has remained frozen at 47 percent, according to a new Daily Mail/J.L. Partners poll. It is the same figure recorded on June 6 — before Israel launched its initial strikes — and again on June 18, just days before the U.S. entered the conflict. His disapproval rating also held steady at 53 percent. However, roughly a third of voters said their opinion of Trump had soured in recent weeks, with many citing fears of a broader conflict with Iran, concerns over his 'dictatorial behavior' for bypassing Congress, or frustration over what they saw as ego-driven decisions. Another 30 percent said their view of the president had improved — crediting him for showing strength, keeping his promises, and taking swift action to defend U.S. interests abroad. The poll, conducted June 24–25 among 1,025 registered voters, came just after Trump helped broker a ceasefire between Israel and Iran following a barrage of intercepted Iranian missiles. It carries a margin of error of plus or minus 3.1 percent. Meanwhile, a separate shock poll shows most voters are turning against Trump's so-called 'Big Beautiful Bill' — his massive tax-and-spending package that now heads to his desk after clearing both chambers of Congress. The sprawling Republican-led bill promises $1,000 'Trump Accounts' for newborns, eliminates taxes on tips and overtime, injects billions into the border wall, and bans states from regulating AI for the next decade. It also imposes new work requirements for Medicaid and food stamps. While Trump and GOP leaders have hailed it as 'the largest tax cut in history,' most voters remain unconvinced. Just 28 percent support the bill, while 36 percent oppose it, according to a new Daily Mail/J.L. Partners poll — giving it a negative net rating of -8. Support plummets outside of Trump's base: Republicans back it by +36, but independents oppose it by -14 and Democrats by a staggering -41. The Congressional Budget Office projects the bill will add $2.4 trillion to the national debt by 2034 while slashing taxes by $3.75 trillion. Even some Republicans are uneasy. Sen. Ron Johnson threatened to block it over deficit fears, while Sen. Josh Hawley objected to Medicaid cuts. A CBS News/YouGov poll also found that 47 percent of Americans believe the bill will hurt the middle class — further signaling trouble for Trump's economic agenda ahead of November.
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Shock poll shows Trump's approval rating savaged by key group
Donald Trump is losing ground fast with Generation Z, with a string of new polls showing his approval among young voters has plunged to record lows. The latest YouGov/Yahoo survey found Trump's net approval among Gen Z voters collapsed from -23 in May to a staggering -41 in June, with just 27 percent approving of his job performance. A separate Quantus poll showed his Gen Z approval dropped from 46 percent in June to just 35 percent in early July, and an ActiVote poll found disapproval surged to 62 percent. It comes just months after he made surprising gains in the 2024 election. Experts say the sharp drop reflects frustration with Trump's handling of key issues like the economy, inflation and immigration. On inflation alone, YouGov/Economist data shows his Gen Z approval sank from 32 percent to just 23 percent over the past month. Trump had significantly narrowed the Gen Z gap in 2024, losing 18–29-year-olds to Kamala Harris by just four points. A key part of that push was his teenage son Barron, who became an unlikely asset on the campaign trail. The 18-year-old emerged as a quiet but powerful influence on his father, with some calling him a political ambassador for his generation. Barron understood what Gen Z cared about, and used that insight to help steer Trump's outreach strategy. He encouraged his dad to appear on comedian Theo Von's podcast and helped line up his viral 90-minute interview with Kick streamer Adin Ross, which drew 500,000 live viewers and, according to Trump's Truth Social account, racked up 100 million total views. Working alongside conservative influencer Bo Loudon, Barron also pushed Trump to engage with Gen Z favorites like YouTuber-turned-boxer Jake Paul and entrepreneur Patrick Bet-David, host of the PBD Podcast. The approach appeared to work, at least for a while, but fresh polling suggests that goodwill is rapidly evaporating, as the broader electorate seems largely unfazed by his recent military actions. Despite authorizing U.S. airstrikes on three Iranian nuclear sites during the so-called '12 Day War' between Israel and Iran, the president's approval rating has remained frozen at 47 percent, according to a new Daily Mail/J.L. Partners poll. It is the same figure recorded on June 6 - before Israel launched its initial strikes - and again on June 18, just days before the U.S. entered the conflict. His disapproval rating also held steady at 53 percent. However, roughly a third of voters said their opinion of Trump had soured in recent weeks, with many citing fears of a broader conflict with Iran, concerns over his 'dictatorial behavior' for bypassing Congress, or frustration over what they saw as ego-driven decisions. Another 30 percent said their view of the president had improved - crediting him for showing strength, keeping his promises, and taking swift action to defend U.S. interests abroad. President Donald addressing the press at the conclusion of Wednesday's NATO Summit in the Hague, has had an approval rating that remained steady before and after the so-called '12 Day War,' new polling from the Daily Mail The poll, conducted June 24–25 among 1,025 registered voters, came just after Trump helped broker a ceasefire between Israel and Iran following a barrage of intercepted Iranian missiles. It carries a margin of error of plus or minus 3.1 percent. Meanwhile, a separate shock poll shows most voters are turning against Trump's so-called 'Big Beautiful Bill' - his massive tax-and-spending package that now heads to his desk after clearing both chambers of Congress. The sprawling Republican-led bill promises $1,000 'Trump Accounts' for newborns, eliminates taxes on tips and overtime, injects billions into the border wall, and bans states from regulating AI for the next decade. It also imposes new work requirements for Medicaid and food stamps. While Trump and GOP leaders have hailed it as 'the largest tax cut in history,' most voters remain unconvinced. Just 28 percent support the bill, while 36 percent oppose it, according to a new Daily Mail/J.L. Partners poll - giving it a negative net rating of -8. Support plummets outside of Trump's base: Republicans back it by +36, but independents oppose it by -14 and Democrats by a staggering -41. The Congressional Budget Office projects the bill will add $2.4 trillion to the national debt by 2034 while slashing taxes by $3.75 trillion. Even some Republicans are uneasy. Sen. Ron Johnson threatened to block it over deficit fears, while Sen. Josh Hawley objected to Medicaid cuts. A CBS News/YouGov poll also found that 47 percent of Americans believe the bill will hurt the middle class - further signaling trouble for Trump's economic agenda ahead of November.
