Dylan Scannell told Cork chef: 'I am going to smash you when I see you', Cobh murder trial hears
This evidence was given in the trial of 30-year-old Dylan Scannell, of O'Rahilly Street, Cobh, Co Cork, who denies murdering Cork chef Ian Baitson, in Eurospar car park, Newtown Road, Cobh, on March 19, 2024, but admits his manslaughter.
March 19 is the date of death in hospital four days after the incident in the car park. Evidence was heard by Ms Justice Eileen Creedon and a jury of six men and six women at the Central Criminal Court sitting in Cork that the deceased bled heavily after being struck to the left leg with a sword.
Detective Garda David Kelleher testified that Ian Baitson's phone was found at the scene in the car park of Eurospar in Cobh on the day in question and a forensic extraction of all the data on the phone was undertaken.
WhatsApp messages
WhatsApp communications between Ian Baitson, and the accused, whose name appeared in the contacts of Dylan Scannell, consisted of 314 interactions — mainly texts but also including voice notes, images and missed or declined calls between August 2023 and March 2024.
Many of the messages consist of arrangements to 'meet for coin', and for Ian Baitson to pay money in various amounts to Dylan Scannell.
In the course of these, Ian Baitson said he owed various amounts in the order of hundreds of euro and disputed in one text: 'There is no way I owe you €2,500, not a f***ing chance… You want to check that. I know that myself. Not a chance, lad. Don't even think to say I owe that… I actually have it wrote down myself… I am telling you now, lad. Who do you think you are? Ha. I am skitting how you think you can say that. Ha… I owe you less than €500."
Dylan Scannell texted in reply: 'Who do I think I am? Are you taking the piss? Or do you want it that way?'
The deceased texted: 'Lad, I am not taking the piss. I never got that much. Are you getting snappy towards me?... It is not even near to the bill. I will send you what I wrote down.'
Dylan Scannell replied: 'If you think this is snappy, you delusional.'
Mr Baitson later texted: 'I would never bullshit you, ever.'
This exchange occurred on February 20 2024.
In later texts, the deceased said he had two cousins from Coolock, and the accused wanted to know their full names and their Eircodes.
The accused texted on March 10: 'My buddy reckons he knows them,' adding they might be near a particular bar in Coolock.
Mr Baitson said they would not be down to Cobh, adding: 'They run a big operation too, so I am not going to hound them.'
Later on March 10, Mr Baitson texted: 'Lad, I want to sort out this shit, I am not continuing on this no more… €185 on Thursday and we are done… I pay this €185 on Thursday, that is the end of it, you can delete my name, we are done, bud.'
The accused texted: 'It is €2,500, not €25,000. You wanted to do it this way. I was being fair. Who is your cousins and where do they live? Where are you now?'
The deceased texted: 'I owe you €185 from the bill. I am not trying to make any situation. I have no more to do with you or anyone else. So-called friend I thought you were. To pull that bullshit makes me sick, lad.'
The accused replied: 'Listen to me now you cheeky prick. I stopped a fella from cutting your mickey off a couple of months ago and you think you can speak to me like that.'
The deceased texted back: 'Lad, I know you did, I am not speaking shit to you… If my job was to collect for you, no way would I steal from you.'
Other texts disputed whether €350 or €310 were paid by the deceased to the accused through a third party.
Two days later, there was a voice note from the accused saying: 'You scumbag.'
The deceased texted: 'Be on your own, Thursday, when I give you €185… I will see you Thursday with the last €185.'
The accused replied: 'You will see me sooner than that. Trust me… Have something nice for you.'
After a number of texts from Dylan Scannell on March 12, Ian Baitson replied he was busy and not in Cobh. After further contacts from Dylan Scannell, Mr Baitson texted: 'Is there something wrong with you, lad? I am busy. Pretty straightforward.'
Dylan Scannell replied: 'No, bud, just asking where you are — pretty straightforward.' Two days later, Mr Scannell texted threatening texts of a sexual nature and said he was going to come to his home.
At 5.14am on March 15, the deceased texted: 'Was that a threat last night, was it?'
The accused replied: 'Call it whatever the fuck you want, I am going to smash you when I see you… Cheeky c***.
Mr Baitson replied: 'I am joking, lad. Sense of humour. See you after.'
Dylan Scannell texted: 'Have that few quid. Who do you think you are? Think you are a hard man? I am going to chop your fingers off, you smart c***.'
The two men arranged by text to meet at Eurospar car park. At about 8.30pm, the deceased texted he was going there.
Dylan Scannell texted back: 'No, I will tell you when to leave.' Ian Baitson replied: 'OK, bud.'
About 10 minutes later, he texted: 'Go now', and the deceased replied — in what was the last communication of the 314 interactions on WhatsApp — 'On my way.'
A video montage from various CCTV was also shown to the jury without commentary of streets in Cobh and of the Eurospar carpark at the relevant time, without commentary of any kind.
The trial continues.
Read More
Witness at Cobh murder trial said he saw man holding a sword and striking another man on the leg
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
16 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Woman requests to meet attacker to ask how he could have been 'so cruel'
A Spanish tourist who was raped in Dublin city centre during New Year's Eve celebrations has said she wants to meet her attacker in a safe space and ask him how he could have been so cruel. The prosecution will now look into providing restorative justice for the complainant to allow her to do this, with the court hearing that it is rarely utilised for victims in rape cases before the Central Criminal Court. Christopher O'Grady, formerly of Muirhevnamor, Dundalk in Co Louth, was found guilty of one count of raping the then 19-year-old woman on 1 January 2019 following a trial last March. He was homeless at the time. In her victim impact statement, which was read out by prosecution counsel Tony McGillicuddy SC, the woman said: "I don't know why, but I want to meet him in a safe space and look him in the eyes and ask him what reason would anyone have to be so cruel to a young woman." She said she wants "to know if he believes his own lies", adding "I want him to truly see me and be forced to see himself as monstrous as I saw him". She outlined the effects the rape has had on her, saying O'Grady turned her life upside down. "He didn't see the person behind the body," she said. She described how she can no longer socialise or dance like she used to, is fearful of walking alone at night and is hypervigilant of other young women who are out at night. Padraig Dwyer SC, defending the 33-year-old O'Grady, submitted his client was guilty of rape on the basis that he was reckless as to whether the young woman was consenting or not. He said O'Grady now accepts his guilt and wishes to apologise to the victim for the hurt and pain he caused her. After some consultation with both O'Grady and the complainant, the court was told they are both willing to engage in restorative justice. Ms Justice Caroline Biggs warned O'Grady that this does not mean he will not serve a custodial sentence for his offending. She noted that any restorative justice process would need to be managed by appropriate individuals, given the effects of the crime on the complainant. Mr McGillicuddy said he had some knowledge of restorative justice but was "not aware of it being used for an offence of this nature". "I'm not sure how developed that system is or which agency would be appropriate to do it," he said. Ms Justice Biggs adjourned the case to 24 July to give the prosecution time to look into the issue. 'Like a doll' The trial heard the woman had been in the city centre to watch the New Year's Eve fireworks that night when she got separated from her friend and came into contact with O'Grady outside a shop. She told the court she was trying to find a bar to meet her friend and O'Grady walked her through the city centre to a car park area, where the alleged rape occurred. The woman said she felt "like a doll" and did not have any strength in her body during the alleged incident. Afterwards, the court heard she walked with O'Grady back through the city centre for about 40 minutes, where she then spoke to a couple - a man and woman - outside a shop and parted ways with O'Grady. The woman ended up in a B&B with the second man after the woman went home, where they had anal sex before the woman went home to her accommodation. She told the court that it was painful and she persuaded the man to stop. The trial was played CCTV footage of the encounter, which occurred in the hallway of the B&B. Ms Justice Biggs warned the jury that they may find the footage "intrusive" and "distressing", but added she had made the decision that it needed to be shown in court as O'Grady had a constitutional right to put the evidence before them. When the complainant woke up the next morning, she told the court she "realised I had two rapes and there might be a medical issue with that". She then went to hospital. The court heard no charge was brought against the second man, who gave evidence in the trial. Sergeant Eoghan Kirwan told the court that O'Grady has 65 previous convictions, including public order offences, criminal damage, drugs and theft. He took a bench warrant while on bail for this offence and has been in custody since August 2024. The defence counsel said O'Grady was living a "shambolic" lifestyle at the time of the offence, that he was homeless, begging on the streets and doing drugs.
Irish Daily Mirror
16 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Tourist rape victim wants to meet attacker 'to ask how he could be so cruel'
A Spanish tourist who was raped in Dublin city centre during New Year's Eve celebrations has said she wants to meet her attacker in a safe space and ask him how he could have been so cruel. The prosecution will now look into providing restorative justice for the complainant to allow her to do this, with the court hearing that it is rarely utilised for victims in rape cases before the Central Criminal Court. Christopher O'Grady (33), formerly of Muirhevnamor, Dundalk, Co Louth, was found guilty of one count of raping the then 19-year-old woman on January 1, 2019 following a trial last March. He was homeless at the time. In her victim impact statement which was read out by prosecution counsel, Tony McGillicuddy SC, the woman said: 'I don't know why, but I want to meet him in a safe space and look him in the eyes and ask him what reason would anyone have to be so cruel to a young woman.' The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week '...I want to know if he believes his own lies. I want him to truly see me and be forced to see himself as monstrous as I saw him.' She outlined the effects the rape have had on her, saying O'Grady turned her life upside down. 'He didn't see the person behind the body,' she said. She described how she can no longer socialise or dance like she used to, is fearful of walking alone at night and is hypervigilant of other young women out at night. Padraig Dwyer SC, defending O'Grady, submitted his client was guilty of rape on the basis that he was reckless as to whether the young woman was consenting or not. He said O'Grady now accepts his guilt and wished to apologise to the victim for the hurt and pain he caused her. After some consultation with both O'Grady and the complainant, the court was told that they are both willing to engage in restorative justice. Ms Justice Caroline Biggs warned O'Grady that this does not mean he will not be serving a custodial sentence for his offending. She noted that any restorative justice process would need to be managed by appropriate individuals, given the effects of the crime on the complainant. Mr McGillycuddy said he had some knowledge of restorative justice but was 'not aware of it being used for an offence of this nature'. 'I'm not sure how developed that system is or which agency would be appropriate to do it,' he said. Ms Justice Biggs adjourned the case to July 24 to give the prosecution time to look into the issue. The trial heard the woman had been in town to watch the New Year's Eve fireworks that night when she got separated from her friend and came into contact with O'Grady outside a shop. She told the court she was trying to find a bar to meet her friend and O'Grady walked her through town to a car park area where the alleged rape occurred. The woman said she felt 'like a doll' and didn't have any strength in her body during the alleged incident. Afterwards, the court has heard she walked with O'Grady back through the city centre for about 40 minutes, where she got talking to a couple – a man and woman - outside a shop and parted ways with O'Grady. The woman ended up in a B&B with the second man after the woman went home, where they had anal sex before the woman went home to her accommodation. She told the court it was painful and she persuaded the man to stop. The trial was played CCTV footage of this encounter, which occurred in the hallway of the B&B. Ms Justice Biggs warned the jury that they may find this footage 'intrusive' and 'distressing', but she said she had made the decision that it needed to be shown in court as O'Grady had a constitutional right to put the evidence before them. When the complainant woke up the next morning, she told the court she 'realised I had two rapes and there might be a medical issue with that'. She went to hospital. The court heard no charge was brought against the second man, who gave evidence in the trial. Sergeant Eoghan Kirwan told the court that O'Grady has 65 previous convictions, including public order offences, criminal damage, drugs and theft. He took a bench warrant while on bail for this offence and has been in custody since August 2024. Defence counsel said O'Grady was living a 'shambolic' lifestyle at the time of the offence, that he was homeless, begging on the streets and doing drugs.
Irish Daily Mirror
2 days ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Woman brought rolling pin to bed to fight off rapist husband
A woman who brought a rolling pin to bed with her because she was in fear of her estranged husband later used that rolling pin to fight him off as he raped her. The 43-year-old man had pleaded not guilty to two charges of rape at their Tipperary home on dates in April and May 2022. A Central Criminal Court jury later convicted the man on one charge of rape but failed to reach a verdict on the first incident of alleged rape. Mr Justice Paul Burns imposed a sentence on the man of seven years with the final year suspended. A local investigating detective told Michael Hourigan SC, prosecuting, that the couple had been married since 2010 and had a daughter together. The marriage had run into difficulties after the woman said he was drinking to excess. She said he also caused bruises on her arms and legs by 'pulling, pushing and grabbing' her strongly on regular occasions. In 2015, she applied for a divorce but the man seemed to be in denial. They were sleeping separately and at the time of the rape had not had sex in over a year. The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week The detective said in April 2022, the woman later told gardaí that she woke up to find the man raping her. She then began to regularly lock her bedroom door. This was the charge that the jury failed to reach a agreement on. Mr Hourigan said the Director of Public Prosecutions has directed that this charge will not be tried again before a jury and a nolle prosequi was entered, meaning the man no longer faces prosecution for this charge. The detective said that on May 15, 2022 the woman had an argument with the man and described the atmosphere in the house as 'not good'. She did not lock her bedroom door that night but the detective agreed with Mr Hourigan that she 'thought it prudent to bring a rolling pin to bed with her'. She woke up that night to find the man raping her. She struck him twice with the rolling pin before he stopped raping her. The woman reported the rape to the gardaí and they arrived at their home to arrest the man. He was considered too drunk to be interviewed at the time but was later questioned six times. He denied any wrongdoing. The detective read the woman's victim impact statement into the record. She said since the rape her life has 'extremely changed' mentally, physically and financially. 'I could not cope with what had happened,' she said as she described experiencing nightmares, anxiety and PTSD. She said she was not eating, not sleeping and suffered a mental breakdown. The woman said she had no happiness and began drinking heavily. The woman said she does not know how she will cope financially in the future. She can no longer work and has unpaid bills, including her mortgage. Colman Cody SC, defending, said although his client made no admissions and does not accept the jury's verdict he was co-operative with the garda investigation. He said his client was aware of the issues the woman has been experiencing financially but is not in a position to assist with this because of the fact that he is in custody and is unable to work. Mr Justice Burns noted the couple had been separated but still shared a home due to their financial circumstances. He said the accused had broken trust and taken advantage of the woman being asleep, with the violation occurring in her own bed. He also noted the prior relationship between them was an aggravating factor. He set a headline sentence of eight years, before noting in mitigation the man's lack of prior convictions, work history, co-operation with gardai and that he was a good father. Mr Justice Burns imposed a sentence of seven years with the final year suspended for three years.
