logo
How dictatorship killed cricket's dream and patronised football in Italy and Argentina

How dictatorship killed cricket's dream and patronised football in Italy and Argentina

Indian Express5 days ago
Italy's Benito Mussolini and Argentina's Juan Peron were dictators in different ideological guises that broke their countries. The Italian instigated war and destruction; the Argentine inflation and bankruptcy. Both used football as a nation-unifying, propaganda tool; and indirectly stubbed out from their fields and consciousness the other major sport that arrived with the English traders and imperialists in their countries. Cricket — the second most watched sport in the world, but with its imprints limited to a dozen outposts of the Commonwealth.
A century later, Italy qualified for the T20 cricket World Cup, even as the probability of missing out on the World Cup that they really care for looms. But cricket in Italy was as old as football. Horatio Nelson's soldiers were the first to play a game on Italian soil, when they anchored in Naples in 1793. A century and unification of the country later, the British traders opened the Genoa Cricket and Football Club in 1893, which dropped cricket from its name but is a Serie A regular.
Italy cricket's grand old man Simone Gambino fishes out the history. 'Italy was unified in 1870 and the English helped a lot to unify. They did pour the mass of capital into industry in the north of Italy. Textile industry in particular. And in Milan, Genoa, and Turin, the three cities in the northwest of Italy, there were many Englishmen who started playing cricket and football. This was the beginning of football,' he says.
The English names the English assigned to the cities remain. But cricket did not. 'Mussolini hated the English. So everything that was English, he kicked it out, and obviously cricket disappeared,' he says. He built grand football stadiums across the country, restructured the league, pumped in money, and hosted the 1934 edition of the World Cup that Italy won but under the shadow of rigging games. The story goes that Mussolini invited Ivan Eklind, the referee appointed to take charge of the hosts' semi-final with Austria, to an exclusive dinner. The next day he awarded a controversial penalty to Italy. Italians defended the crown the next edition, but Jonathan Wilson, in his seminal book Inverting the Pyramid wrote about the manager Vittorio Pozzo 'made full use of the prevailing [fascist] militarism to dominate and motivate his side.'
A decade later in Argentina, Peron too recognised football's infinite powers to galvanise his political narrative. His government granted generous loans to football clubs to construct stadiums and infrastructure. His favourite club Racing received 16,700,000 pesos to build the Estadio Presidente Perón. His wife Eva, though, would play a bigger role wiping the slate of cricket clean.
In 1947, she sought the outfield of Buenos Aires Cricket Club for a fundraising function. The cricket body refused and she ordered the wooden pavilion to be razed down and burned. Cricket historians consider it a symbolic moment when cricket in the country, popular from the late 19th century, met a brutal death, as chronicled fabulously by journalists Timothy Abraham and James Coyne in the book Evita Burned Down the Pavilion.
Involved in the crossfire was Argentina's greatest cricketer, Clement Gibson, son of planters who settled in Argentina in the 19th century. He was a swing bowler with a devastating leg-cutter that pitched on leg-stump and hit the off-stick, and a celebrated figure in Cambridge and Sussex. In a tour game against the touring Australians in 1921, he grabbed six wickets in the second innings to mastermind a famous comeback after England XI were bundled out for 43 in the first innings. A decade later, Douglas Jardine summoned him to attend a camp for the Bodyline series. But he picked up an injury and shortly returned to Argentina with a healthy haul of 249 wickets at 28, to look after the wild sprawling ranches.
After a dispute over his brewery, the first lady commissioned two sets of hitmen to kill him. He had fled to the family's northernmost ranch. They never returned, assumed dead and Gibson lived till he was 76, making occasional visits to his son in England. Cricket, by then, was confined to the few English families that still lived in the country and survived as a relic of the era of British planters. Argentina still plays cricket and in an expanded T20 World Cup format the ICC is envisioning could one day qualify.
But on the whims and vendettas of leaders and dictators hinged the fate of sports. Perhaps, cricket would not have thrived in Latin America or Italy or the Netherlands. Perhaps, the English did not stay long enough. Even if they were, cricket was never the sport of masses, confined to the gentry clubs, in all these countries. Football was the masses' opium in the barrios and favellas. The game did flourish in the nitrate mining communities of Atacama Desert in Chile as well as Mexico, Uruguay and Panama (where West Indies great George Headley was born). Maybe, cricket could not capture the local rhythms as football did, or captured its sensibilities. Or you could imagine, the subcontinent's sport of choice if the English had not lingered too long. Or if it were the Portuguese or the Dutch or the Spaniard. Perhaps it still could have been cricket. But Italy qualifying for the T20 World Cup makes you dwell on conjectures. What if Mussolini and Peron encouraged cricket? Or the princes of India's states patronised football? History of sports is thus the history of empires and emperors too.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Xavi Hernandez and Pep Guardiola's applications were not genuine: AIFF
Xavi Hernandez and Pep Guardiola's applications were not genuine: AIFF

The Hindu

time11 minutes ago

  • The Hindu

Xavi Hernandez and Pep Guardiola's applications were not genuine: AIFF

A day after its top official claimed that World Cup-winning Spanish great Xavi Hernandez was among the applicants for India football coach's position, the All India Football Federation said that the e-mail received in his name was found to be "not genuine" and three others have been short-listed for the job. The AIFF did not reveal the names in the pruned list but it is widely believed that Khalid Jamil, currently the head coach of Indian Super League side Jamshedpur FC, is the front-runner for the post left vacant by Spaniard Manolo Marquez. "The AIFF received an e-mail furnishing the applications from Spanish coaches Pep Guardiola and Xavi Hernandez. The authenticity of their applications could not be confirmed, and it has since emerged that the e-mail applications were not genuine," AIFF stated in a media release. One of its officials, on conditions of anonymity, had stated on Friday that the application of Xavi could not be processed as the AIFF did not have resources to hire his services. The IM Vijayan-headed Technical Committee, it is learnt, has also kept Englishman Stephen Constantine, who has previously coached India, and Slovakia's Stefan Tarkovic in the short-list. Constantine has coached the Indian team in two phases earlier, while Tarkovic is the most decorated among the shortlisted candidates having managed Slovakia during the 2020 Euro Championship, where his team beat a fancied Poland which had Bayern Munich legend Robert Lewandowski in its ranks. "Following comprehensive discussions and a rigorous selection process, 10 candidates were selected for the committee to review, following which, the TC shortlisted three," the release also stated. "Given the immediate needs of the national team, it is advisable to recommend three coaches from the short-listed pool for final consideration," former India skipper Vijayan was quoted as saying in the release. "Other prominent applicants, many of whom are highly qualified international coaches, will be taken into account for long-term strategic roles in the future," he added. National Team Director Subrata Paul, also a former India skipper, spoke about preference being given to those with some understanding of Indian football. "It is a very important moment for Indian football, and we are committed to appointing a coach who not only brings technical expertise but also understands the unique style, culture, and dynamics of Indian and Asian football. "We believe such a coach will be able to connect with our players quickly and effectively," Paul stated.

Chess World Cup: Humpy, Deshmukh draw Game 1 in final
Chess World Cup: Humpy, Deshmukh draw Game 1 in final

Hindustan Times

time15 minutes ago

  • Hindustan Times

Chess World Cup: Humpy, Deshmukh draw Game 1 in final

Mumbai: Moments before Divya Deshmukh shook hands with Koneru Humpy, she sat pressing her eyes and covering her face with her left hand for a few seconds. Quite visibly and evidently, the 19-year-old wasn't too pleased about the end result of the opening game of the FIDE Women's World Cup all-India final in Batumi, Georgia on Saturday. Koneru Humpy. (HT) A draw isn't the worst outcome for the youngster playing with white, but Divya could look back with a sense of missed opportunity after she couldn't manage to press home the advantage from an aggressive opening. Instead, a draw after 41 moves ensued, which would give the seasoned Humpy a slight advantage going into Game 2 of the title clash on Sunday. The two-time World Rapid champion will play with white in the second classical game and press for a decisive result. Should the deadlock remain on Sunday, tie-breaks will have to be unlocked on Monday to determine the new World Cup champion – who, either way, will be an Indian. Divya had her chances to make a critical push towards that, and even Humpy, 38, admitted she came out of that contest having avoided a potentially tricky slope. Asked in the official post-match interview by FIDE if she felt she had overcome a very complicated situation, Humpy said, 'Ya, I agree', before highlighting the 'clearly better position for white'. Divya placed herself in that better position after a Queen's Gambit Accepted opening. 'I think she prepared for my game, which I played earlier. I just misplayed in the opening and she got into an advantage,' Humpy said. By the 12th move, the teen had gained a positional advantage, as was reflected in the evaluation bar. The key miss came on the 14th move, for which Divya took significant time and was even seen smiling a little while staring at the board. Instead of pressing the attack by developing her queen, Divya traded on b7 and then played It pulled her down on the evaluation bar and brought Humpy back on level terms. Both players then made little inaccuracies. Divya was also now battling time pressure, constantly looking at the clock as it came down to below 15 minutes. Time pressure can often lead to blunders but Divya did not let the clock unsettle her into making one. Humpy, who had plenty more time, remained good in defence. Both players could have agreed to a draw much earlier but carried on looking for any kind of opening. The position was fully balanced once Divya, whose body language remained more animated, came down to under five minutes on the clock. With the black secure and Humpy feeling 'out of danger' after a point, she sat composed. Soon, after another three-fold repetition, the players shook hands.

Rahul, Gill lead Indian fightback after England dominate
Rahul, Gill lead Indian fightback after England dominate

Hindustan Times

time15 minutes ago

  • Hindustan Times

Rahul, Gill lead Indian fightback after England dominate

Mumbai: There are going to be tough days in Test cricket when nothing is going right for you, and the opposition is completely on top. After three closely fought games, India had such a poor outing in their first innings of the fourth Test at Old Trafford. By the end of Day 3 with England 186 runs ahead with three wickets in hand in their first innings, they were already too far behind in the game. India's KL Rahul (L) walks off with captain Shubman Gill (R) at the end of Day 4 of Manchester Test. (AFP) The mettle of a good team is seen in how they respond in such situations – throw in the towel or make a statement by fighting till the last ball is bowled. There were alarm bells when India again turned out flat in the field to play a poor opening session on Saturday. Captain Ben Stokes moved fluently to his 14th Test hundred and then added quick runs to ensure a monumental 311-run lead for his team with one-and-a-half days to go. Being kept on the field for 157 overs, it can take a toll mentally and physically. India's worst fears came true in the 15 minutes they had to negotiate before lunch on Day 4. In the very first over, Chris Woakes struck a double blow. The swing bowler produced a beauty to induce an edge off Yashasvi Jaiswal to be caught in the slip. Next ball, Sai Sudharsan was out for a golden duck, hanging out his bat to also be caught in the cordon. With his team tottering at 0/2, Shubman Gill walked in to bat in the first over itself. It was a real test of nerves for the young captain. There was extra pressure that he had not got runs in the previous three innings. His captaincy in the field had also come under the scanner after allowing England to amass 669, their highest total at Old Trafford. To his credit, Gill chose the occasion to make a strong statement by stroking a delightful half century. Considering what had happened in the first session, it was an important effort to calm his dressing room. It was proof he has the steel to handle the tough situation and the skill to negotiate English conditions. In a superb partnership with the dependable KL Rahul, he put behind the horror start to play through the next two sessions. From two wickets for one run at lunch, India had advanced to 174/2 in 63 overs at stumps. Rahul was batting on 87 (210 balls, 8 fours) and Gill was 78 not out (167 balls, 10 fours). It is the highest partnership for a stand that started at 0/2. It is still a long way to go but thanks to the resilient third wicket pair, the lead is now down to 137 and the visitors' dressing room would have started to harbour thoughts of a draw. England were left to rue the chance they gave to Gill on 46 when Liam Dawson failed to hold on to a catch at gully off Brydon Carse. Gill put it behind to complete his fifty off 83 balls. During the innings he went past Virat Kohli's 655 runs against England in 2016. He is on 694 runs now. Rahul has crossed 500 runs for a series for the first time. Gill had shouldered arms in the first innings to be leg before to Stokes. With Stokes deciding not to bowl, Chris Woakes, Jofra Archer and Carse kept probing that chink against the incoming ball. Gill though was equal to the task with decisive footwork. He was hit on his thumb by a rising ball from Archer but put the painful blow behind and hit some beautifully timed boundaries. Against Woakes, there were two rasping square cuts and a sublime off-drive, before treating the crowd to back-to-back classical straight drives off Carse on either side of the stumps. A model of concentration, Rahul did his usual thing, played late and showed good judgement of his off-stump to leave the balls well. The pitch was showing signs of wear and tear and Stokes introduced spin early. Dawson's first over was played out cautiously, but Gill continued the counter-attack against the pacers to collect two more boundaries off Archer. With Dawson bowling a tight line in his second spell of 12-4-15-0, the two batters were watchful after tea. While Rahul took 141 balls to reach his fifty, with just three fours, he outscored Gill in the final session.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store