Victorian Liberals question funding unfair dismissal claim defence while refusing to bail out John Pesutto
On Monday, lawyers for Victorian Liberal MP Moira Deeming initiated bankruptcy proceedings against Pesutto after he failed to meet a deadline to pay her $2.3m in legal costs. Pesutto has less than 21 days to pay, enter into a payment agreement or face bankruptcy, which would lead to a byelection in his seat of Hawthorn.
Pesutto's supporters have written to the administrative committee urging them to help him pay Deeming's legal costs. So far, no meeting has been called to discuss these requests. Any deal would require the authorisation of the 19-person committee.
But sources close to Pesutto are increasingly optimistic a loan deal may be struck in coming days, partially funded by the party and its associated entities. They say more than $1m has been pledged by private donors so far, which would reduce the size of the loan.
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
On the same day as the bankruptcy proceedings were initiated, members of the committee discussed the engagement of law firm MinterEllison to represent them in response to the unfair dismissal claim lodged by Nadine Jones, the former director of the party's fundraising arm, Enterprise Victoria.
The engagement of MinterEllison has frustrated some Liberal sources who believe the party should be doing more to help Pesutto. They argue it is 'unfair' and 'hypocritical' for the party to pay the legal costs of administration officials, but not its former parliamentary leader.
Under the Victorian Liberal party's constitution, members of the administrative committee are indemnified for actions taken on behalf of the party. But the same protection is not afforded to senior MPs in the parliamentary wing, including when the opposition leader is performing their duties in the party room.
'It's hard to understand how those most opposed to party funds being used for John Pesutto's legal defence can now argue that the same funds should be used to fund two or more separate legal teams to defend themselves,' said one Liberal source.
'Those administrative members insisting on being separately represented should apply a consistent standard, or explain to members why they believe they're more deserving of party funds.'
One Liberal source, who declined to be named so they could speak freely, said there was a push for the parliamentary leadership team to be indemnified as early as 2023. They said those efforts went nowhere.
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
They questioned why anyone would want to take on a leadership position in the party and carry out their responsibilities, including making difficult party room decisions, without the legal protection in the current political climate.
The committee includes the Victorian opposition leader, Brad Battin, and the federal shadow minister for energy and emissions, Dan Tehan. Both were contacted for comment.
Some members of the administrative wing, who declined to be named, said the engagement of MinterEllison was not hypocritical. They said the matter before the Fair Work Commission was a dispute over alleged workplace misconduct, while the Pesutto matter stemmed from multiple defamatory statements.
The complaint before the Fair Work Commission was submitted by Nadine Jones, who alleges she was stood down a day after a fundraising dinner featuring Gina Rinehart. Jones alleges the party's president wrongly introduced Rinehart as the sponsor of Netball Australia and that she was unfairly punished by the party for the 'embarrassing gaffe'.
Liberal party sources reject any suggestion that Jones was fired for anything other than alleged misconduct.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
12 minutes ago
- Reuters
Google and OpenAI's AI models win milestone gold at global math competition
July 21 (Reuters) - Alphabet's (GOOGL.O), opens new tab Google and OpenAI said their artificial-intelligence models won gold medals at a global mathematics competition, signaling a breakthrough in math capabilities in the race to build powerful systems that can rival human intelligence. The results marked the first time that AI systems crossed the gold-medal scoring threshold at the International Mathematical Olympiad for high-school students. Both companies' models solved five out of six problems, achieving the result using general-purpose "reasoning" models that processed mathematical concepts using natural language, in contrast to the previous approaches used by AI firms. The achievement suggests AI is less than a year away from being used by mathematicians to crack unsolved research problems at the frontier of the field, according to Junehyuk Jung, a math professor at Brown University and visiting researcher in Google's DeepMind AI unit. "I think the moment we can solve hard reasoning problems in natural language will enable the potential for collaboration between AI and mathematicians," Jung told Reuters. The same idea can apply to research quandaries in other fields such as physics, said Jung, who won an IMO gold medal as a student in 2003. Of the 630 students participating in the 66th IMO on the Sunshine Coast in Queensland, Australia, 67 contestants, or about 11%, achieved gold-medal scores. Google's DeepMind AI unit last year achieved a silver medal score using AI systems specialized for math. This year, Google used a general-purpose model called Gemini Deep Think, a version of which was previously unveiled at its annual developer conference in May. Unlike previous AI attempts that relied on formal languages and lengthy computation, Google's approach this year operated entirely in natural language and solved the problems within the official 4.5-hour time limit, the company said in a blog post. OpenAI, which has its own set of reasoning models, similarly built an experimental version for the competition, according to a post by researcher Alexander Wei on social media platform X. He noted that the company does not plan to release anything with this level of math capability for several months. This year marked the first time the competition coordinated officially with some AI developers, who have for years used prominent math competitions like IMO to test model capabilities. IMO judges certified the results of those companies, including Google, and asked them to publish results on July 28. "We respected the IMO Board's original request that all AI labs share their results only after the official results had been verified by independent experts and the students had rightly received the acclamation they deserved," Google DeepMind CEO Demis Hassabis said on X on Monday. However, OpenAI, which did not work with the IMO, self-published its results on Saturday, allowing it to be first among AI firms to claim gold-medal status. In turn, the competition on Monday allowed cooperating companies to publish results, Gregor Dolinar, president of IMO's board, told Reuters.
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Morning Mail: Australia condemns Israel, stories of housing despair, the problem with Labor's Hecs debt plan
Morning everyone. As Israel launched a new air and ground offensive on Gaza overnight, Australia has joined 24 other countries in condemning Benjamin Netanyahu's government for depriving Palestinians of their 'human dignity'. Plus, we hear from readers about their struggles in the property market, our Full Story podcast asks whether today's new parliament means a new politics as well, and having fun in the First Time Club. A total croc? | Was a crocodile really sighted on the weekend in Noosa, hundreds of kilometres from the reptile's normal territory? Joe Hinchliffe investigates. Latham 'repulsive' | Anthony Albanese said last night that he finds some of Mark Latham's views 'repulsive' after the Labor caucus voted to add text to a portrait of the former leader at Parliament House condemning his actions since he departed federal politics. Albanese told ABC's 7.30 he regrets Latham 'ever being elected leader of the Labor party'. Housing anguish | As house prices rise again, some of our readers share their despairing stories of trying to compete in the market. Some were outbid even before homes were officially listed; another was pipped by an investor; and one couple can't afford to have children. Hecs plan | Cutting student loans by a flat $5,500 would be fairer and more effective than Labor's promised 20% reduction to Hecs debts, a leading independent thinktank says. Frog hope | Hundreds of captive-bred, critically endangered frogs are managing to survive after being released in a mountain stream near Mount Beauty in Victoria, with some moving a 'considerable distance' since release. Trump tip | An artist who first accused Jeffrey Epstein (above left) and Ghislaine Maxwell of sexual assault almost three decades ago has said that she had urged the FBI to investigate powerful people in their orbit – including Donald Trump (above right). Israel offensive | Israel has launched substantial air raids and a ground operation in Gaza, targeting Deir al-Balah, the main hub for humanitarian efforts in the devastated Palestinian territory. Australia has joined the UK and 23 other nations in condemning Israel for depriving Palestinians of 'human dignity' as they issued a call for an immediate end to the war in Gaza. More than 130 Palestinians have been killed in the past 24 hours, according to Gaza's health ministry. Powering up | China has begun building the world's biggest hydropower megadam, according to the country's premier, producing 300m MW every year at a cost of around $A250bn. Bangladesh crash | At least 19 people have died after a Bangladesh air force plane crashed into a school campus in Dhaka. More than 50 others, including children, were taken to hospital, mostly with burns injuries. Scan shock | A man wearing a large weight-training chain around his neck who approached his wife while a magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) machine scanned her knee at a clinic in New York died after he had a 'medical episode' when he was pulled into the device. A new parliament, but is it new politics? As the 48th federal parliament begins today, Reged Ahmad speaks to chief political correspondent Tom McIlroy and political reporter Krishani Dhanji about our new political reality. Tom also writes today about how Labor's whopping majority means some of their members will have to be seated on the other side of the chamber in a symbolic power shift in Canberra. Sorry your browser does not support audio - but you can download here and listen $ Justice Michael Wigney's ruling last week that the federal government does not owe Torres Strait Islanders a duty of care to protect them from the climate crisis will resound through politics for years to come, our environment editor argues today, not least because the judge made a powerful case for why he might have found in the islanders' favour. With the coach trip and packed lunches, Tom Gill's day out to go whale watching on Phillip Island might give school trip vibes. But this is something different – a trip with Melbourne's First Time Club where like-minded adults can enjoy a new experience and build friendships. 'There's no rules today … Just have fun!' says the group leader. Sign up to Morning Mail Our Australian morning briefing breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters after newsletter promotion Football | Liverpool are to take their summer spending to almost £300m (A$600m) after agreeing to pay £69m plus £10m in add-ons for the Eintracht Frankfurt striker Hugo Ekitike (above). Cricket | England batsman Harry Brook has said that England's victory in the third Test against India taught them that 'you don't always have to be nice' and ended a period in which they have tended to be overly friendly. Athletics | Sebastian Coe says World Athletics is closely monitoring the failure of Michael Johnson's Grand Slam Track series to pay athletes in full for their appearances. Shareholders of a childcare chain are demanding answers from management about abuse allegations, the Age claims. Chinese EVs will make up close to half of all sales in Australia by 2035, according to research cited by the Fin Review. Adelaide has become the most expensive city in the country in which to learn to drive, the Advertiser says. Economy | The minutes of the Reserve Bank's monetary policy July board meeting will be released at 11.30am. Politics | George Brandis will deliver a webinar on the Australian Liberal party titled: What has gone wrong? If you would like to receive this Morning Mail update to your email inbox every weekday, sign up here, or finish your day with our Afternoon Update newsletter. You can follow the latest in US politics by signing up for This Week in Trumpland. And finally, here are the Guardian's crosswords to keep you entertained throughout the day. Until tomorrow. Quick crossword Cryptic crossword
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Sacrifice Aussies may need to make if they want to keep using cash
Australians may have to go back to paying fees again for using rival bank ATMs like they did a decade ago if they want to keep having access to cash, a finance expert says. The Big Four banks in 2017 agreed to scrap those $2 fees for customers who used the automatic teller machines of a competitor. While it was regarded as good news, that policy is threatening the future of cash in Australia with very few consumers now using banknotes to pay for everyday goods and services. Australia's key cash-in-transit company Armaguard, owned by billionaire transport magnate Lindsay Fox's family, needs $50million a year in handouts to survive and now federal regulators are proposing Australia have a new minister for cash. In just seven years, the number of ATMs have more than halved, plunging from 13,814 in June 2017 to just 5,476 in June last year, Australian Prudential Regulation Authority data showed. The Commonwealth Bank , Westpac , NAB and ANZ used the abolition of rival ATM fees to take away those cash dispensing machines and squeeze Australia's cash-in-transit companies during contractual negotiations. This has made distributing cash unprofitable with the Big Four banks, supermarket giant Woolworths and retail group Wesfarmers - the owner of hardware chain Bunnings, Kmart and Officeworks - last week announcing they would provide a $25.5million lifeline to Armaguard from July to December. Jason Bryce, the founder of Cash Is Welcome, said Armaguard wouldn't need to be subsidized by the banks and the supermarkets if those old fees for using rival ATMs still existed - and generated $500 million a year in revenue. 'I think it was a bad, short-sighted move - I don't want to prescribe the answers - but the problems date from that decision,' he told Daily Mail Australia. 'There's no doubt the $2 ATM fee for customers of other banks kept the cash distribution system paid for and viable in Australia - since 2017, since that decision, the cash industry has contracted and been under pressure. 'There needs to be some kind of structural change to provide support, go forward, to cover the $50 million-odd per year that Armaguard is now getting. 'There should be no need for $50million a year - the problem has been created by the banks and the supermarkets.' Mr Bryce said the abolition of those rival ATM fees had led to the big banks putting extra pressure cash deliverers, to the point that Spanish group Prosegur in 2023 merged with Armaguard to survive. 'The two big companies have merged into one and that one company is on the verge of bankruptcy,' he said. Peter Fox, the executive chairman of Armaguard, told The Australian Financial Review its 'shortfall in revenue' was 'caused by the four major banks and two retailers which slashed their margins to Armaguard in a period of cut-throat competition'. Commonwealth Bank chief executive Matt Comyn last year admitted the banks were 'very, very aggressive' towards Armaguard. 'The banks drove Armaguard to the brink of bankruptcy,' Mr Bryce said. 'Matt Comyn says the banks underpaid Armaguard for cash-in-transit.' 'It's really up to the banks to pay more. 'So banks now don't really have much of a leg to stand on when they complain about handing over $25million for six months.' The disappearance of major bank ATMs saw the appearance of third-party ATMs that charge $3 fees for use. 'There's less bank-owned ATMs and there's more third-party ATMs that charge $3 or so,' Mr Bryce said. The Council of Financial Regulators - which includes the RBA - and the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission is proposing a new federal minister in charge of cash distribution who would have oversight over a registered entity that would 'provide critical cash services to a significant part of the market'. 'Despite the rise of digital payments, cash remains vital for many Australians, particularly in regional and remote communities,' it said in a consultation paper. 'Cash supports secure, inclusive, and resilient transactions for those who prefer or rely on it.' The federal government last year announced a cash mandate would be coming into force on January 1, 2026 requiring businesses to offer customers a cash option.
