Speaker 'concerned' over disqualification move in Punjab Assembly
In a formal letter addressed to the speaker of the Punjab Assembly, Swati criticised the recent decision to suspend 26 opposition lawmakers for 15 sessions and raised objections to the potential disqualification proceedings against them under Article 63(2) of the Constitution.
Terming the move a misinterpretation of constitutional powers and contrary to democratic traditions, Swati emphasised that while maintaining decorum within the assembly is vital and Rule 210(3) of the Assembly's Rules of Procedure is relevant for disciplinary measures, any subsequent attempt to seek disqualification under Article 63(2) would constitute overstepping constitutional boundaries.
He warned that such measures could lead to the misuse of constitutional provisions and pose a threat to the autonomy, sanctity, and dignity of all legislative assemblies across the country.
Swati further highlighted that a combined reading of Articles 66 and 69 with Article 127 of the Constitution clearly provides immunity to members for their conduct within the House, and any external interference in such matters is unconstitutional.
Stressing the long-term implications of the issue, the K-P Assembly speaker noted that actions like these could set a dangerous precedent, ultimately undermining parliamentary democracy and the supremacy of the Constitution.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
an hour ago
- Express Tribune
No headway in talks over suspended PTI MPAs, dialogue to continue
Listen to article The second round of negotiations between the Punjab government and the opposition over the reinstatement of 26 suspended members of the provincial assembly concluded on Sunday without any resolution, though both sides agreed to continue dialogue in the coming days. According to sources familiar with the discussions, the government and opposition failed to reach a consensus regarding the suspension of the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) lawmakers, whose membership remains inactive following a heated session last month. The lawmakers were suspended by Punjab Assembly Speaker Malik Muhammad Ahmad Khan after opposition benches disrupted Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz's speech on June 27. The session descended into chaos as treasury and opposition members engaged in a physical altercation, despite repeated appeals by the Speaker to restore order. Read More: Punjab speaker forms committee to address suspended PTI members' references The ongoing impasse follows an earlier consultative meeting between the Speaker and the suspended MPAs, during which disqualification references filed against the members were also discussed. To resolve the standoff, Speaker Khan formed an eight-member negotiation committee, comprising Chief Whip Rana Arshad, Parliamentary Affairs Minister Mujtaba Shuja-ur-Rehman, Khawaja Salman Rafique, Samiullah Khan, and Ahmad Iqbal. Additional representation was included from allied parties: Ali Haider Gillani (PPP), Chaudhry Shafay Hussain (PML-Q), and Shoaib Siddiqui (IPP). Despite no significant progress in the second round of talks, both sides signaled readiness to engage further. Leader of the Opposition Malik Ahmad Khan Bachhar said discussions were ongoing and that more meetings were scheduled. 'This was our second meeting, and there was agreement on continuing the talks. Consultations are underway regarding the Assembly's Rules of Procedure,' he told reporters. Bachhar emphasized the need for party-level consultation, noting that such complex issues could not be resolved in a single sitting. 'We are two distinct political entities. The Speaker has urged adherence to the rules, and once consensus is reached, it will be communicated to all stakeholders,' he added. Also Read: Suspended MPAs split over protest limitation Speaking to the media after the meeting, government representatives described the atmosphere as constructive. Punjab Finance Minister Mujtaba Shuja-ur-Rehman stated that the sanctity of the Assembly was paramount and that the opposition had acknowledged the importance of preserving its dignity. 'One or two more meetings may be required, but we are hopeful of a dignified resolution,' he said. He clarified that the government was not seeking to de-seat the suspended lawmakers but was merely asking for observance of Assembly decorum. 'They are elected representatives. Our objective is not punitive but to ensure the House functions within its prescribed rules,' Shuja-ur-Rehman added.
Express Tribune
2 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Rosie O'Donnell laughs off Trump's illegal threat to revoke her citizenship
Former President Donald Trump has sparked controversy once again by threatening to revoke the U.S. citizenship of comedian and television host Rosie O'Donnell, calling her a 'threat to humanity.' The remarks, posted on Trump's social media platform Truth Social on July 12, were widely condemned as unconstitutional and legally baseless. -TruthSocial. 'Because of the fact that Rosie O'Donnell is not in the best interests of our Great Country, I am giving serious consideration to taking away her Citizenship,' Trump wrote. 'She is a Threat to Humanity, and should remain in the wonderful Country of Ireland, if they want her. GOD BLESS AMERICA!' O'Donnell, 63, relocated to Ireland earlier this year after Trump's return to the presidency. In a TikTok video from March, she explained she was pursuing Irish citizenship due to her heritage and to protect her family, particularly her autistic son, amid political turmoil in the U.S. Legal experts swiftly denounced Trump's threat. Steve Vladeck, a constitutional law professor at Georgetown University, described the statement as 'coercive expatriation' and 'patently unconstitutional.' Amanda Frost, a law professor at the University of Virginia, affirmed that 'the president has no authority to take away the citizenship of a native-born U.S. citizen.' The 14th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution guarantees citizenship to all persons born or naturalized in the country and forbids the government from abridging their rights. In response, O'Donnell issued a series of strong rebuttals across social media. On Instagram, she posted a photo of Trump with disgraced financier Jeffrey Epstein and criticized Trump's leadership and values. 'You want to revoke my citizenship? Go ahead and try, King Joffrey with a tangerine spray tan,' she wrote, referencing a villain from Game of Thrones. Speaking to RTÉ Radio, O'Donnell dismissed the threat, saying she is 'the latest in a long list of artists, activists and celebrities to be threatened' by Trump. Despite the escalating feud, she emphasized that her move to Ireland was motivated by a desire for safety and decency for her family. Her response has been in the highest comedic spirits, her instagram feed shows how shes been cracking jokes in the face of an adversity.
Express Tribune
4 hours ago
- Express Tribune
PTI expels five MNAs for backing 26th amendment, seeks disqualification
Listen to article The Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) on Sunday formally expelled five of its National Assembly members for defying party directions and voting in favour of the 26th Constitutional Amendment — a move the party termed a 'flagrant breach of oath, loyalty, and parliamentary discipline.' The expulsions were confirmed through formal notifications issued by PTI Chairman Barrister Gohar Ali Khan. The lawmakers — Aurangzeb Khan Khichi, Zahoor Elahi, Usman Ali, Mubarak Zeb, and Muhammad Ilyas Chaudhry — were elected on PTI tickets and, according to the party, had pledged to uphold its parliamentary stance. An official PTI statement said the party's parliamentary meeting on September 2, 2024, had unanimously decided to oppose the 26th Amendment at all stages. These instructions were submitted to the Speaker of the National Assembly on September 5 for record. However, on October 21, the five lawmakers voted in favour of the bill, enabling the government to pass it with 225 votes — just one above the required 224. Following the vote, PTI issued show-cause notices to the MNAs on November 5, asking why they should not be disqualified for defection and breach of party discipline under Articles 62 and 63. A hearing committee was formed but none of the lawmakers responded or appeared. The party further alleged that the MNAs had joined another parliamentary party by taking seats on the treasury benches and attending its meetings, which it says constitutes formal defection under constitutional provisions. Read More: Gandapur says Imran Khan ready for talks with decision-makers 'You are hereby declared to have violated your commitment, oath, and loyalty to the party,' the notification read. 'You voted in favour of the 26th Constitutional Amendment Bill, 2024, and by conduct have joined another parliamentary party. You are therefore expelled from the party forthwith.' The PTI leadership has also requested the Election Commission of Pakistan to initiate proceedings for the disqualification of the five MNAs under Article 63A of the Constitution. The five MNAs had voted in favour of the 26th Constitutional Amendment Bill, which enabled the government to secure 225 votes — one above the 224 required for passage. The 26th Amendment introduced significant changes to Pakistan's judicial structure, including revisions to the process of judicial appointments, the tenure of the Chief Justice, and the composition of the Judicial Commission.
