Review: Rethinking the Stanford Prison Experiment (opinion)
The Stanford Prison Experiment: Unlocking the Truth, a three-part National Geographic documentary, casts doubt on that gloss by interviewing academics and former subjects who say Zimbardo misrepresented his methodology and the implications of his results. Although Zimbardo claimed he gave very little direction to the "guards," for example, recordings show that he and his colleagues encouraged harsh treatment of the "prisoners."
The documentary suggests the so-called experiment is better understood as an improv game in which the subjects acted in ways they thought Zimbardo expected. Yet after torture at the Abu Ghraib military prison in Iraq came to light decades later, Zimbardo, a relentless self-promoter, glibly argued in media appearances and in his book The Lucifer Effect that his research anticipated such abuses by showing "how good people turn evil."
Director Juliette Eisner gives Zimbardo (who died last October, after the documentary was completed) ample opportunity for rebuttal. To some extent, his answers reinforce the impression of slipperiness. But his defenses also highlight an ambiguity at the heart of his experiment: Were the subjects just play-acting, as some now claim, or is that description a self-deceiving rationalization for mortifying behavior?
In the end, Zimbardo loses patience with Eisner's inquiry, declining to answer follow-up questions on the grounds that he has already thoroughly refuted his critics' arguments. Viewers can judge for themselves whether that is true.
The post Review: Rethinking the Stanford Prison Experiment appeared first on Reason.com.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
2 hours ago
- New York Post
Child services worker arrested after boy, 3, dies when left in her car for hours in 108-degree heat
A child protective services worker in Alabama has been arrested after a 3-year-old boy in her care died while left for hours in her car in 108-degree heat — and she's already been cut loose on bail. Department of Human Resources employee Kela Stanford, 54, was charged last Friday over Ke'Torrius Starks Jr.'s tragic July 22 demise in Birmingham that saw him left alone in the vehicle for five hours in the searing heat, police said. Stanford, who works for a third-party contracted by the department, had been tasked with taking little Ke'Torrius to a supervised visit with his biological father the day he died. Advertisement 4 Ke'Torrius had been living in temporary foster care and was left in the Department of Human Resources worker's car for five hours as temperatures reached 108 degrees. Starkes Family The worker had picked the boy up from a day care where he'd been dropped off by his foster family ahead of the scheduled visit, according to authorities. After the visit, Stanford allegedly ran errands — including stopping at a grocery and tobacco store — instead of taking the child back to the day care. Advertisement The worker then drove to her own home, where she left Ke'Torrius buckled inside the car with the windows rolled up — as temperatures soared to 108 degrees, cops allege. The little boy was later pronounced dead at the scene. 4 Department of Human Resources employee Kela Stanford, 54, was charged last Friday over Ke'Torrius Starks Jr.'s tragic July 22 demise in Birmingham. Jefferson County Jail 4 Ke'Torrius Starks Jr., 3, died after being left alone in a scorching car by a child protective services worker in Alabama. Courtesy Starkes Family Advertisement Stanford was booked into the Jefferson County Jail under the state's Amiyah White Act, which prohibits leaving a child or an incapacitated person unattended in a car. She was released on a $30,000 bail that same day, jail records show. 'This is a terrible tragedy that was completely avoidable and unnecessary,' the Jefferson County District Attorney's office said. It wasn't immediately clear how long Ke'Torrius had been with his foster family or why he was removed from his biological parents. Advertisement 4 The child's foster family had dropped him off at daycare so a DHR worker, contracted by a third party, could pick him up for a scheduled visit with his biological father (above). FOX54 News Huntsville The visit with his biological father was part of a court-ordered process for parents to regain custody. 'Words can't even express how I feel right now,' his father told KBTX. 'As soon as I leave my son, the first thing he says is, 'Daddy, I want to go with you.' He says that every time, and it really hurts.' Stanford was fired over the tragedy. 'The provider has terminated their employee. Due to confidentiality, DHR cannot comment further regarding the identity of the child or the exact circumstances,' the agency said.
Los Angeles Times
a day ago
- Los Angeles Times
L.A. Times Publishes Public Records Database on Police Use of Force and Misconduct in California
The Los Angeles Times today published the Police Records Access Project, a new searchable database featuring once-secret police records. Built by UC Berkeley and Stanford University, 1.5 million pages were obtained from nearly 700 law enforcement agencies to create the database, which currently includes records from almost 12,000 cases about use of force and misconduct by California law enforcement officers. The database expands public access to internal affairs records that disclose how law enforcement agencies throughout the state handle misconduct allegations and uses of police force that result in death or serious injury. In addition to The Times, the database can be accessed online via KQED, the San Francisco Chronicle and CalMatters. Learn more about the Police Records Access Project and access the database.
Los Angeles Times
a day ago
- Los Angeles Times
Searchable database on cases of police use of force and misconduct in California opens to the public
A searchable database of public records concerning use of force and misconduct by California law enforcement officers — some 1.5 million pages from nearly 700 law enforcement agencies — is now available to the public. The Police Records Access Project, a database built by UC Berkeley and Stanford University, is being published by the Los Angeles Times, San Francisco Chronicle, KQED and CalMatters. It will vastly expand public access to internal affairs records that show how law enforcement agencies throughout the state handle misconduct allegations and uses of police force that result in death or serious injury. The database currently includes records from nearly 12,000 cases. The database is the product of years of work by a multidisciplinary team of journalists, data scientists, lawyers and civil liberties advocates, led by the Berkeley Institute for Data Science (BIDS), UC Berkeley Journalism's Investigative Reporting Program (IRP) and Stanford University's Big Local News. Other key contributors include the ACLU Foundation of Southern California, California Innocence Coalition, the National Assn. of Criminal Defense Lawyers, UC Irvine law school's Press Freedom Project and UC Berkeley law school's Criminal Law & Justice Center. The team collected, organized and vetted millions of public records, used emerging technologies such as generative AI to build the database. Financial support was provided by the State of California, with additional funding from the Sony Foundation and Roc Nation. Every document in the database was released by a law enforcement agency after being redacted in compliance with California's public records laws. Work on the database began in 2018, when journalists in some 40 newsrooms formed the California Reporting Project and began sharing documents obtained through records requests. In all, reporters sent more than 3,500 public records requests to police departments, district attorney's offices and coroners all across the state.
