'Problematic' MAHA report minimizes success of lifesaving asthma medicines, doctors say
Safe treatment protocols for asthma management have been carefully studied over the years, said Dr. Perry Sheffield, a pediatrician and professor at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai.
"The federal government actually has some really beautiful and clear guidelines and strategies, and things that are vetted by and carefully edited by many experts in the field," said Sheffield, who co-directs a region of the federally funded Pediatric Environmental Health Specialty Units that serves New Jersey, New York, Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands.
Asthma affects more than 4.6 million American children, according to the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. It's one of the most common long-term diseases in U.S. children.
The Make America Healthy Again Commission report released in late May, parts of which have been widely criticized, alleges that American children are on too much medication of various kinds, including asthma treatments.
Experts worry that the administration will set policy based on the assessment that would dissuade insurers from covering asthma prescriptions. They also say that the report's assertions could worsen disparities that affect children's access to those medications and undermine years of research around the drugs.
The MAHA commission has until August to release a strategy based on the findings in the report.
Black and Indigenous children as well as those living in inner cities or in lower-income households are among those with the highest rates of asthma. Pollution disproportionately shrouds communities of color and can be a trigger that exacerbates the disease.
The report's message could heighten those disparities, said Dr. Elizabeth Matsui, a University of Texas at Austin professor and a past chair of the American Academy of Pediatrics' Section on Allergy and Immunology.
"One thing that has been very clear is that kids of color are less likely to be appropriately managed in terms of their asthma medication management," she said. "So a message of overprescription that is simply not supported by the evidence also could potentially exacerbate already-existing racial and ethnic disparities in asthma that we have really not made much headway on."
The commission's claims
The report touches on childhood prediabetes, obesity and mental health. However, firearm injuries — the leading cause of death for children and teens in 2020 and 2021, according to the CDC — weren't mentioned.
The 70-page report from the commission, chaired by Secretary of Health and Human Services Robert F. Kennedy Jr., claims four main issues are the drivers behind childhood chronic disease: poor diet, aggregation of environmental chemicals, lack of physical activity and chronic stress, and "overmedicalization."
Matsui and other experts said the report's use of that word is "problematic."
"The implication could be, unfortunately, that when a child has asthma — so, they have coughing, chest tightness, wheezing — that that is not really a disease," said Matsui. "We know for a fact that that's a disease, and we know that it is quite treatable, quite controllable, and that it has profound impacts on the child's day-to-day life."
Other scientists have similarly criticized the report, saying it makes sweeping and misleading generalizations about children's health without sufficient evidence. The White House corrected the report after nonprofit news outlet NOTUS found that it cited studies that didn't exist.
In an emailed statement to Stateline, Health and Human Services press secretary Emily Hilliard wrote: "The MAHA report discusses concerns about the potential overprescription of asthma medications—particularly in mild cases—not to question their importance, but to encourage evidence-based prescribing."
When it comes to asthma, the report says, "Asthma controller prescriptions increased 30% from 1999-2008." That sentence originally cited a broken link to a study from 2011; the link was later replaced. Controller meds include inhalers.
The MAHA report also claims that "There is evidence of overprescription of oral corticosteroids for mild cases of asthma." The original version of the report listed estimated percentages of oral corticosteroids overuse, citing a nonexistent study. The wording was changed and the citation was later replaced with a link to a 2017 study by pediatric pulmonologist Dr. Harold Farber.
The study was not a randomized controlled trial, which increases reliability. Farber told NOTUS that the report made an "overgeneralization" of his research. Stateline also reached out to Farber, whose public relations team declined an interview request.
The implication could be, unfortunately, that when a child has asthma ... that that is not really a disease. We know for a fact that that's a disease. — Dr. Elizabeth Matsui, University of Texas at Austin professor
Oral corticosteroids are liquid or tablet medications used to reduce inflammation for conditions including allergies, asthma, arthritis and Crohn's disease. For asthma, they're used to treat severe flare-up episodes. The Asthma and Allergy Foundation of America says the medications have been shown to reduce emergency room visits and hospitalizations, and that while they do come with risk of side effects, they're mostly used in acute flare-ups. And while rare, asthma-related deaths in kids do occur, and are often preventable.
"Asthma medications, including oral steroids, are lifesaving," said Dr. Elizabeth Friedman, a pediatrician at Children's Mercy Kansas City. "I believe that physicians, not politicians, are best equipped and most effectively trained to make the determination of whether or not these medications are needed for our patients."
Friedman worries that federal characterizations of asthma meds will affect how state Medicaid agencies cover the drugs. When Medicaid coverage changed for a common prescribed inhaler last year, many of her Missouri Medicaid patients were suddenly without the drug. They ended up hospitalized, she said.
Friedman directs Region 7 of the Pediatric Environmental Health Specialty Units, a network of experts that works to address reproductive and children's environmental health issues. Region 7 provides outreach and education in Iowa, Kansas, Missouri and Nebraska.
She also said she's concerned that the report is "making a broad, sweeping statement based on one epidemiologic study from one state."
Increased use
An increase in inhaler prescriptions is not necessarily a bad thing, experts say. It's a sign that kids are getting their medication.
There has been an increase in inhaler prescriptions, along with a corresponding decrease in the oral corticosteroids, which is what experts would want to see, said Chelsea Langer, bureau chief of the New Mexico Department of Health's Environmental Health Epidemiology Bureau. She said that means kids are "following their asthma action plans and taking the controller medications to prevent needing the relief or treatment [oral] meds."
Asthma prevalence has increased over the years, meaning more people need medication, noted Dr. Alan Baptist, division head of Allergy and Clinical Immunology at Henry Ford Health in Michigan.
He said that because steroid tablets come with risk of side effects, it is best to limit them.
But for kids without access to a regular pediatric provider or to health insurance that covers an inhaler, cost can be an obstacle, he said. Fluticasone propionate, an FDA-approved medicine for people 4 and older, costs on average $200 or more for one inhaler without insurance.
"What often happens with kids, and especially kids who are in Medicaid, or who are in an underserved or disadvantaged population, they are not given appropriate asthma controller medication," said Baptist, who helped write federal guidelines for asthma treatment best practices as part of a National Institutes of Health committee.
Baptist noted that while he was glad to see pollution mentioned in the report as a danger for kids, it's at odds with the recent cuts to environmental health grants that aimed to address such asthma triggers.
"They're somewhat cherry-picking some of the data that they're putting down," he said. "It says the U.S. government is 'committed to fostering radical transparency and gold-standard science' to better understand the potential cumulative impacts of environmental exposure. If that's what they're saying, then they should be funding even greater studies that look at the effects."
Dr. Priya Bansal, an Illinois pediatric allergist and immunologist and past president of the Illinois Society of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology, said she's concerned the report doesn't define mild, moderate or severe asthma to differentiate the different best-practice treatment plans.
Bansal also said she worries that federal officials' characterization of an FDA-approved drug will lead to insurance companies refusing to cover inhalers or oral steroids for her patients who rely on them.
"I'm going to be worried about coverage for my asthmatics," she said. "The question is, what's the next move that they're going to make? If they think that, are they going to now say, 'Hey, we're not going to cover inhalers for mild asthmatics'?"
Editor's note: This story has been updated with a response from the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Stateline reporter Nada Hassanein can be reached at [email protected].
YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
14 hours ago
- New York Post
Flying blind: Jetblue attendant splashes scalding coffee in eye of Team USA judo coach: suit
A Team USA judo coach suffered permanent vision loss in his right eye when a clumsy JetBlue flight attendant dropped a pot of coffee she was serving — splashing hot java in his face, he said in a lawsuit. Arturas Lanchinskas, a third-degree black belt who owns a top martial arts school in Brighton Beach, Brooklyn, was headed to the Pan American Judo Championships in Lima, Peru in July 2023 to coach the American team when scorching spill on Flight 1825 changed his life. 'It felt like a surge of fire hit the surface of my eyeball,' Lanchinskas, 30, told The Post. 'The pain was sharp and immediate, like a burning needle.' 3 Arturas Lanchinskas, who owns a top ranked martial arts school in Brooklyn, was on his way to a judo championship in Peru when he was hurt. Obtained by the New York Post As luck would have it, the passenger being served the coffee was a doctor, who leapt into action to help and urged Lanchinskas to repeatedly wash out his eye. Oblivious flight attendants, however, chastised the Brooklyn man for using the bathroom so much, according to his attorney, Erin R. Applebaum. 'He was even told, 'Sir, you're not the only one on the airplane, we have other guests who need to use the facilities,' ' she said. 3 The flight attendant was trying to serve coffee to someone else, but dropped the pot, sending the scalding beverage flying, Lanchinskas said in the lawsuit. bignai – 3 Arturas Lanchinskas suffered vision loss in his right eye after being splashed in the face with hot coffee on a JetBlue flight, he said in a lawsuit. Obtained by the New York Post He went to a hospital after the plane landed in Peru, where doctors treated the burns on his face and eye, the attorney noted. Eye specialists in NYC have since diagnosed him with a thermal injury and chemical burn of the right eye, Applebaum said. 'He has a reduced field of vision and his eye is permanently sensitive to light,' she said. Lanchinskas' Darfight Martial Arts is ranked second in the country by USA Judo and Team USA won two silver and five bronze individual medals at the Pan American U15 Championships. JetBlue did not immediately return a request for comment.
New York Post
15 hours ago
- New York Post
The bad diet habit that can make you gain weight — even when you stop
Talk about a scale fail. New research suggests that a common dieting mistake may trigger lasting changes in the body that make eating right more difficult. Worse still, the effects appear to linger long after the bad habit is corrected, quietly sabotaging your ability to maintain a healthy weight. 4 Crash diets often trap Americans in a constant cycle of losing and regaining weight. mojo_cp – Yo-yo dieting is a pattern where people restrict calories to lose weight, then slip back into old eating habits — often gaining back more than they shed and starting the cycle all over again. It's a common problem in the US, where nearly three in four adults are clinically overweight and diet culture tends to favor quick weight-loss fixes over long-term lifestyle changes. Studies estimate that up to 55% of American women and 35% of men have fallen into the yo-yo dieting trap at some point. Curious how the cycle impacts the body, researchers in France put lab mice on a similar diet rollercoaster. 4 Biological changes seen in yo-yo dieting mice may help explain eating behaviors in humans. filin174 – Over several weeks, the animals were fed alternating rounds of healthy, low-fat chow and a high-fat, high-sugar diet meant to imitate Western eating habits. Just like in humans, their weight fluctuated up and down like a yo-yo. But over time, the mice also began binging on the junk food whenever it was available — even if they'd already been fed. When researchers analyzed the mice's fecal samples, they found long-lasting changes in their gut bacteria that altered their internal metabolism. To test it further, the team transplanted the altered gut bacteria into healthy mice that hadn't been dieting. They, too, started compulsively overeating fatty, sugary foods. 4 Gut bacteria plays a critical role in weight management, including by influencing appetite regulation. Dr_Microbe – The researchers also scanned the mice's brains and found increased activity in their reward centers, the region that lights up in response to pleasurable stimuli, including food. The findings suggest that yo-yo dieting may mess with both the gut and the brain — making it tougher to resist high-calorie foods and setting the stage for overeating. While the experiment hasn't been tested in humans, the results suggest that yo-yo dieting could lead to similar changes in people as well. The researchers said further studies will be needed to fully understand the biological mechanisms at play and confirm whether the same effect happens in humans. 4 Large fluctuations in body weight have been linked to several negative health consequences. Kawee – Your gut and brain aren't the only things yo-yo dieting can mess with. 'When weight is quickly lost and regained, the regained weight is typically fat tissue rather than muscle tissue, which can increase the overall body fat percentage over time,' Melissa Hoover, a registered dietician, said in an interview with Piedmont Healthcare. One review found that 11 out of 19 studies linked a history of yo-yo dieting to higher body fat and more belly fat. Hoover also noted that most yo-yo dieters focus on cutting calories but skip the exercise habits that help maintain muscle. 'This eventually leads to loss of muscle mass and body strength,' she said. And the risks don't stop there. Yo-yo dieting has also been associated with an increased risk of developing chronic conditions like type 2 diabetes, heart disease and high blood pressure. In fact, one study found that people who lose and regain weight on yo-yo diets are far more likely to die from heart attack or stroke than people who keep the scale on an even keel — even when that 'steady' weight is slightly chubby. Mentally, the cycle can wear people down. In studies, adults with a history of yo-yo dieting report feeling unhappy with both their health and overall quality of life.
New York Post
18 hours ago
- New York Post
‘Unfairly' criticized brunch staple actually isn't bad for your heart health: study
Here's something to get egg-cited about. A new study scrambles the long-held belief that eggs are bad for your heart, finding that eating a certain number daily might actually improve your cholesterol levels. But it's not all sunny side up. While one breakfast staple has been eggsonerated, researchers warn that another could spell serious trouble for your ticker. 3 Eggs might not be the real villain lurking on your breakfast plate. Pixel Stories/Stocksy – Eggs are a nutritional powerhouse, packed with vitamins, minerals, antioxidants, protein and healthy fats. But they've long been in the hot seat because they're naturally high in dietary cholesterol. For years, health officials and medical groups have recommended limiting egg consumption, concerned it could raise blood cholesterol levels and increase the risk of cardiovascular disease — the leading cause of death in the US. But growing evidence suggests that risk might not be as significant as once believed. 'Eggs have long been unfairly cracked by outdated dietary advice,' Dr. Jon Buckley, a professor at the University of South Australia and lead researcher on the study, said in a statement. 'They're unique — high in cholesterol, yes, but low in saturated fat. Yet it's their cholesterol level that has often caused people to question their place in a healthy diet,' he continued. 3 Roughly 805,000 people in the US experience a heart attack each year, or about 1 in every 400 adults. Kannapat – To put it to the test, Buckley and his colleagues examined the independent effects of dietary cholesterol and saturated fat on LDL cholesterol — the so-called 'bad' cholesterol that can build up in the arteries and raise your risk of heart disease and stroke. They found that eating two eggs a day, as part of a high-cholesterol but low–saturated fat diet, can actually reduce LDL levels and lower heart disease risk. Instead, real culprit behind elevated blood cholesterol was saturated fat. This primarily comes from animal sources, such as meat and dairy products, along with tropical oils like coconut and palm. 'You could say we've delivered hard-boiled evidence in defense of the humble egg,' Buckley said. 'So, when it comes to a cooked breakfast, it's not the eggs you need to worry about — it's the extra serve of bacon or the side of sausage that's more likely to impact your heart health.' 3 Processed meats like bacon, sausage, hot dogs and ham often contain significant amounts of saturated fats. Nelea Reazanteva – Across the country, nearly 94 million American adults over the age of 20 have high cholesterol, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. However, because high cholesterol typically comes without noticeable symptoms, many people don't know they have it until serious complications arise — such as a heart attack or stroke. To keep cholesterol levels in check, the American Heart Association (AHA) recommends making key lifestyle changes, including limiting saturated fat to less than 6% of your total daily calories. For someone who eats about 2,000 calories a day, that means no more than 120 calories — or roughly 13 grams — should come from saturated fat. That limit is easy to exceed. Just one tablespoon of butter has about 7 grams of saturated fat, while two slices of bacon pack in roughly 4 grams. The AHA also advises cutting back on trans fats and increasing your intake of soluble fiber, omega-3 fatty acids, and pectin-rich foods like fruits and vegetables. Beyond diet, the organization encourages regular physical activity, maintaining a healthy weight, and quitting smoking to help manage cholesterol levels and lower the risk of heart disease.
