Woman punched on Tube 'failed by emergency system'
Sally Wynter said she had been left traumatised after being punched by a stranger on a busy Victoria line train on 27 March, but her attacker was able to get away because she could not raise the alarm.
Ms Wynter has written to Sir Sadiq Khan - who has overall responsibility for the Tube network - describing the intercom system as a failure and urging him to "fix it now".
City Hall has apologised, saying it was unacceptable her calls were not answered and an investigation had begun.
Ms Wynter told BBC London that as her train had approached Green Park station at about 16:30 GMT, she "suddenly felt a punch to the right side of my right arm".
"I was pushed into the glass by a stranger that I hadn't seen before," she said, adding her attacker then got off the train.
When she got off the Tube at the next stop, Oxford Circus, she was "in shock" and pressed the emergency button on the platform's intercom "at least four times", expecting a member of staff to respond and then try to stop the assailant.
She said when she received no response, she had tried to contact British Transport Police (BTP), but could not get an urgent response.
She then called 999 and was re-directed to BTP, but gave up and left, she added.
BTP said officers attended the station after being made aware of the incident and conducted a search for the victim.
As they could not find her at the station, a telephone statement was arranged for later in the evening.
The force added that a man from south London was later arrested and bailed in connection with the assault.
It was later reported to police that a child had been attacked at Green Park station shortly after the assault on Ms Wynter, by a man of the same description.
Ms Wynter said she believed it was the same attacker and the second assault could have been prevented if her calls had been answered.
Help points, which include a fire alarm and buttons to call for assistance and for in an emergency, are installed across the Tube network.
Ms Wynter said her situation highlighted that the system failed to help passengers in need, which she said was "very dangerous".
"There's a variety of reasons people use these points and it's quite clear to me that the way these help points are set up is antiquated - these systems don't integrate properly into the campaign around what people should do."
She added: "I was lucky in the sense that I was away from my attacker but it could have been so much worse.
"It's an urgent problem that needs to be addressed. "
In a letter to Ms Wynter, London's Deputy Mayor for Transport, Seb Dance, said passengers on TfL's network "deserved to feel safe" and have "confidence that if things do go wrong, help is always available".
Mr Dance added he was "deeply saddened" about what happened and invited Ms Wynter for a meeting.
In a statement, TfL said: "We are investigating as a matter of urgency why Ms Wynter did not get the help she should have and have reached out to her to offer support."
Listen to the best of BBC Radio London on Sounds and follow BBC London on Facebook, X and Instagram. Send your story ideas to hello.bbclondon@bbc.co.uk
Rise in reports of violence against women on transport
TfL offers bystander awareness training over abuse
Transport for London
The Mayor of London
British Transport Police
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Politico
a day ago
- Politico
Lawsuits dredge up messy NYPD era under Eric Adams as he begins reelection bid
One of Essig's deputies, Christopher McCormack, similarly alleged in a separate suit that he was retaliated against after rejecting some of the candidates proffered by close aides to Adams. He also named Banks, the former deputy mayor for public safety, in his complaint. Those picks, who McCormack found to be unqualified, were eventually placed on elite teams anyway. One candidate allegedly referred by Banks told McCormack he wanted into the 'El Dorado' unit tasked with investigating money laundering because the name 'sounded cool,' according to the lawsuit. McCormack found the applicant to be unqualified. Banks' pick allegedly made it onto the team anyway. Each of the complainants included a monetary angle to their grievances. After each of them left city service, City Hall gave managerial staff at the NYPD a pay hike they missed out on. The suits are just the latest reminder of the chaos that reigned at the department under Adams and the unresolved criminal investigations into some of his closest and most loyal aides that could come back to bite him on the stump. Caban, for example, is reportedly being probed for a pay-to-play scheme involving promotions — a probe that was referenced in one of the suits. He was also being eyed by authorities for an alleged kickback scheme involving his twin brother and security at New York City nightclubs. Maddrey was forced to resign after reports that he sexually assaulted an underling and gave her overtime in exchange. And Banks had his phone taken by federal agents as part of a wide-ranging probe last year. Mayoral spokesperson Kayla Mamelak Altus said the city would review the lawsuits filed Monday and defended the integrity of the NYPD, which is now led by Commissioner Jessica Tisch. 'The Adams administration holds all city employees — including leadership at the NYPD — to the highest standards, and our work at the department speaks for itself: crime continues to topple month after month both above and below ground, with our city seeing the lowest number of shootings in recorded history,' she said in a statement. 'That is no coincidence — it's thanks to the Adams administration's laser focus on public safety.' Adams is running in the general election on an independent ballot line after dropping out of the Democratic primary amid a now-defunct criminal bribery case. He has been touting decreases in major crimes — though has POLITICO has reported, the overall picture is much more complicated — and has cast himself as the candidate needed to keep the city on the right track. The lawsuits filed Monday, movement in any of the state or federal investigations, or new allegations of malfeasance could easily become cannon fodder for his opponents, who include Democratic nominee Zohran Mamdani, fellow independent candidates Andrew Cuomo and Jim Walden, and GOP candidate Curtis Sliwa. The mayor's management record could become an especially potent line of attack for the more moderate hopefuls whose politics — and in the case of Cuomo, his base of Black voters — overlap with Adams.
Chicago Tribune
2 days ago
- Chicago Tribune
Former Chicago Ald. Edward Burke's release from federal prison expected Tuesday
Less than 10 months after reporting to federal prison, Edward Burke was expected to begin spending the rest of his sentence in the Chicago area Tuesday, according to sources close to the once-powerful alderman who have knowledge of the matter. Burke was expected to report to a halfway house as soon as midday. It was not clear whether he would be there long before being placed on home confinement, sources said. Burke, 81, had checked himself into the low security federal prison camp at Thomson, Illinois, in late September to start a two-year sentence on his corruption case. It was an ignominious moment for a onetime city leader who had wielded power for decades as the city's longest-serving alderman. The camp, which houses about 133 male inmates, is situated about 2 1/2 hours' drive west of Chicago, along the Mississippi River. His original release date was expected to be in the first half of next year, but he apparently qualified to leave the facility early due to his age. Most federal inmates are required to serve 85% of their sentences, which originally would have seen Burke released in May 2026 at age 82. Burke lawyer Charles Sklarsky could not immediately be reached for comment on the imminent release. Burke is expected to serve a year on court-ordered supervision. He also was to pay $65,000 in restitution to the owners of the Burger King franchise he was convicted of shaking down, as well as a $2 million fine imposed by U.S. District Chief Judge Virginia Kendall. Burke, one of the last vestiges of the old Democratic political machine, was convicted by a jury in December of racketeering conspiracy, bribery and attempted extortion in a series of schemes to use his considerable City Hall clout to try and win business from developers for his private property tax law firm. Among them were efforts to woo the New York-based developers of the $600 million renovation of the Old Post Office, extorting the Texas owners of the Burger King, who were seeking to renovate a restaurant in Burke's 14th Ward, and intervening on behalf of a developer in Portage Park who wanted help getting the pole sign approved for a new Binny's Beverage Depot location. Even in a state that has seen countless politicians, both Republicans and Democrats, handed prison terms for corruption, Burke has been among the most influential. The head of the vaunted Finance Committee, Burke not only worked the city's purse strings but also was a shrewd ward boss, political tactician and judicial slate-maker. Kendall had ordered a relatively light prison term for Burke, citing the dozens of letters she received from citizens of all walks of life extolling Burke's acts of kindness and charity, even when they had nothing to do with his role as alderman. During his sentencing hearing last June, Kendall said that the comparatively limited period of criminal conduct for which Burke was convicted at trial does not wipe away those decades of good works. She also criticized the U.S. attorney's office for its unprecedented deferred prosecution agreement with former Ald. Daniel Solis, who wore a wire against Burke and others and was rewarded with a deal that will keep him even having a conviction on his record — let alone serving jail time. 'It is uncomfortable for me to see that when the government steps up and says you must send a strong message' to elected officials, that Solis has been allowed to skate, Kendall said at the time. However, she said she agreed with prosecutors that courts must deter other public officials from political corruption, which leads to 'part of this erosion, part of this chipping away at our democracy, really whittling away at our rule of law.' 'When citizens lose faith (in their public officials) they begin to take the law into their own hands,' she said. 'If a citizen starts thinking 'Oh that's just the Chicago Way,' that's when we're eroding it.' In addition to the time behind bars, Kendall ordered the $2 million fine, finding that financial penalties for politicians who engage in corruption should be far higher and noting the money will go to help victims of crime in which the defendants are not as wealthy as Burke. 'I think that really does send a message, if you want to commit public corruption by being greedy, then the disgorgement of your own funds will go toward the people,' Kendall said. Before he was sentenced, Burke read an uncharacteristically brief statement to the court, saying he'd been blessed with a long career and was sorry to 'see it end like this.' Then he asked the judge for mercy. 'Whatever amount of time God has decided to leave me on this earth, I'd like to spend as much of it as possible with my devoted wife, my wonderful children and grandchildren,' Burke said. The Thomson prison was not Burke's first choice of places to serve out his sentence. His attorneys originally requested the prison camp in Oxford, Wisconsin, a facility that had seen so many Chicago-area politicians serve time it was jokingly referred to as 'going to college.' The request was later altered to a camp in Terre Haute, Indiana, however, because the Oxford camp was changing security missions.
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
'Send them home': To promote tougher policies, report claims Spokane's homeless aren't from here
Jul. 7—Half of the homeless people in Spokane aren't from here and should be given bus tickets home, more strictly enforced by police and cut off from long-term services, according to a recent report released by the Spokane Business Association, a prominent political advocacy group funded by businessman Larry Stone. A week after the report's release, the association proposed an amendment to the city's charter, which if approved by voters would reshape the city's homelessness laws and force Spokane to shift funding away from affordable housing, firefighting equipment and other priorities to fund emergency shelters, more visible police patrols and other policies recommended in the report. Critics in City Hall have dismissed the report as unscientific, unhelpful and politically motivated ahead of the November elections, when several seats currently or recently occupied by progressives are being challenged by candidates more in line with the Spokane Business Association's policy goals. But the report's author and the organization sponsoring the survey argue the data is concrete proof that Spokane's homelessness policies not only are ineffective at helping people get off the streets, they're attracting people from elsewhere who are drawn to the city by lax law enforcement. Just over 50% of the roughly 230 homeless people surveyed for the association said they moved to the city after becoming homeless. This contradicts the federally mandated "point-in-time" counts, annual standardized surveys that try to reach every homeless person living on the streets or in a shelter. The point-in-time counts have their own flaws, as the authors of Spokane County's 2024 report readily acknowledged. But of the 2,021 people surveyed in last year's point-in-time count, roughly 80% said they lived in Spokane County before becoming homeless. Robert Marbut, President Donald Trump's "homeless czar" from 2019 to 2021 and the consultant contracted to conduct the survey, argues his data is more accurate because he also asked where people were born, went to high school and whether they have family in Spokane. It is not clear why these additional questions would sway the data by 30 points, but Marbut's recommendations for dealing with this influx are clearer, and consistent with the "Velvet Hammer" approach he has pitched cities across the country for at least a decade: Spokane has to get tougher with the homeless, pressuring them into treatment or departure. Gavin Cooley, an executive of the Spokane Business Association, argued Marbut's expertise lent the report more authority than it lost from a lack of cited sources, and dismissed as "deeply political" a recent article from Range Media that turned to an expert in homeless research to pick apart the report's methodology and conclusions. Cooley believes the media and politicians are overly focused on attacking the data and not paying enough attention to the conclusions Marbut reaches with that data. "You can certainly note the deficiencies as you see them ... but I think it'd be a pity to miss the higher level order of what's being recommended," Cooley said. Every effort should be made to send people back where they came from, particularly if they've been in Spokane for less than 90 days, according to the report. Those who stay should be cut off from long-term services, which should be reserved only for those with longstanding ties to Spokane. For those who are from Spokane, the report recommends mandatory treatment services in order to receive housing, which city officials claim would violate state and federal law. Marbut has spoken out for at least a decade against policies he believes are "enabling" the homeless with "goodies," including Housing First policies that have been the national standard since 2013, in which homeless people are given stable housing upfront to enable them to then address addiction, mental health and social reintegration. Attempts to relocate the homeless en masse are even older. The phrase "Greyhound therapy" has been used to describe the practice since the 1970s and has been criticized by researchers for just as long for redistributing the social costs of homelessness rather than improving them. Many of America's largest cities have, at one point or another, attempted similar policies; between 2011 and 2017, the Guardian tracked over 20,000 homeless people given bus tickets out of and sometimes between 16 U.S. cities. Proponents, including the Spokane Business Association, argue that such programs reconnect people to families and friends and can lead to a long-term improvement in their situation. Spokane's homeless service providers have engaged in the practice for years, however. If a homeless person requests a bus ticket, and a friend or family member declares they can take them in, they will be provided a ticket. Julie Garcia, who runs the homeless services organization Jewels Helping Hands, which manages several of the city's homeless shelters, estimated her organization hands out around 250 tickets a year. There appears to be little academic research into whether these programs lead to long-term reductions of homelessness or just move it elsewhere. The Guardian reported that, of the thousands being bused from San Francisco through the Homeward Bound program between 2010 and 2015, the city had records of following up with only three people after they reached their destinations. But the Spokane Business Association report goes further to suggest that the city should cut off people who decline these tickets from long-term homeless services and even emergency shelters after 21 days. While much of the study copies nearly verbatim a similar report on King County that Marbut was commissioned to write for the Discovery Institute, Marbut claims that Spokane is unusual in one regard: Homeless people aren't coming to Spokane for its quality services, but for its lax enforcement. "What we got on the street was generally, they treat me nice here, they don't hassle me," Marbut said. "It wasn't that they came here because of the services — many communities I go to, it's, 'Oh, they have great services' — but here it was, 'They sort of let me be.' " This picture notably doesn't match what many homeless people on Spokane's streets have told The Spokesman-Review in recent years, who described being pushed from place to place throughout the day by law enforcement, security guards and business owners. "We literally don't get to sit down like this," said Amber, a 32-year-old homeless woman interviewed under an overpass in August. "We are moving constantly. ... So many people have cracked feet and heels." Cooley dismissed this type of enforcement as an "occasional blow of the horn," and wants to see tougher laws and stricter enforcement — not because he wants them to go to jail, which he says would be ineffective and expensive — but to force people to change their lives. Cooley acknowledged that Washington's involuntary treatment laws are not extensive enough to force a homeless person into drug or mental health treatment. Instead, he argued, the city should use its tougher homelessness laws to offer them a choice: either go to jail, or enter "voluntary" treatment. Or they could leave, Cooley noted. "If you find that a great number of people have no connection to Spokane at all, and you suddenly begin to say you cannot use fentanyl in this community unfettered ... how many of those folks will stick around?" Cooley asked. In an interview, Mayor Lisa Brown dismissed the report as misinformed, arguing many of the report's claims about the city's policies were untrue and some of its recommendations were already standard practice. "I believe this is really about the political campaigns in November," Brown said, noting Stone's longstanding funding of candidates opposing progressive policies and production of high-dollar videos to encourage tougher homelessness policies. "I also believe that, with the resources they are apparently able to mobilize, it would be great if, as a show of good faith, they put them into an actual solution, rather than a propaganda campaign against the city and the majority on the city council," Brown added. But Cooley believes the evidence was clear, regardless of the survey's findings, that what the city is doing is failing to have a significant impact on the city's visible homeless population or its soaring overdose deaths. "I know Seattle really damn well, and I can't believe the rapid turnaround as it relates to enforcement," Cooley said. "And what I don't know is where those people are ... but I know they've made a visible turn in on-street homelessness." The report has started to leak into the broader public conversation on Spokane's homelessness policies. Wendy Fishburne, vice president of the East Spokane Business Association, appeared to quote parts of it verbatim Monday before the Spokane City Council voted to reform its homelessness laws. "Research shows that people do better recovering from addiction when they're surrounded by their families of origin," Fishburne said. "Find out where people actually come from and compassionately send them home ... so that our resources could be used for our folks."
