logo
Armed forces united by uniform not divided by religion: Delhi HC

Armed forces united by uniform not divided by religion: Delhi HC

Time of India01-06-2025
The
Delhi High Court
has upheld the termination of services of a Christian army officer over his consistent refusal to fully participate in the weekly
regimental religious parades
and said the
armed forces
were united by their uniform rather than being divided by their religion.
A bench of Justices Navin Chawla and Shalinder Kaur rejected the petition by the
Indian Army
Lieutenant, who served as a 'Troop Leader' of a squadron, against the termination order passed on March 3, 2021, that dismissed him from the Indian Army without pension and gratuity.
The court opined that the petitioner kept his religion above the lawful command from his superior, and disobedience was an offence under the Army Act.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
IIT Delhi AI Programme
IITD TAILP
Apply Now
Undo
"In the present case, the question is not of religious freedom at all; it is a question of following a lawful command of a superior. It is not disputed by the petitioner that his superiors have been calling upon him to attend the religious parades by even entering the sanctum sanctorum and perform the rituals if this would help in boosting the morale of the troops. In the present case, the petitioner has kept his religion above a lawful command from his superior. This clearly is an act of indiscipline," said the bench.
"Our Armed Forces comprise personnel of all religions, castes, creeds, regions, and faiths, whose sole motto is to safeguard the country from external aggressions, and, therefore, they are united by their uniform rather than divided by their religion, caste, or region," it stated.
Live Events
The petitioner submitted that his regiment maintained only a temple and a gurudwara for its religious needs and parades, and being of monotheistic Christian faith, he sought exemption from entering the innermost part of the temple while accompanying his troops for the weekly religious parades and other events.
The authorities defended the termination, saying efforts were made through other Christian officers in the army, and he was also taken to the pastor of a local church, who told the petitioner that entering the 'sarv dharm sthal' as part of his duties would not impinge on his Christian faith. However, he remained undeterred.
In its judgement passed on May 30, the court "saluted" the dedication of "those who guard our borders day and night in adverse conditions" and said uniformity in appearance as well as respect for all the religions was quintessential to a cohesive, disciplined, and coordinated functioning of an armed force and the ethos of the armed forces placed nation before religion.
It further said that although regiments might historically bear names associated with religion or region, it did not undermine the secular ethos of the institution, and religious war cries only serve a purely motivational function, intended to foster solidarity and unity amongst the troops.
The court observed that in the present case, the Chief of Army Staff concluded that the conduct of the petitioner was in violation of the essential military ethos, and it could not "second-guess" the decision unless it was manifestly arbitrary.
"While there can be no denial of the fact that the petitioner has the right to practice his religious beliefs, however, at the same time, being the Commanding Officer of his troops, he carries additional responsibilities as he has to not only lead them in war but also has to foster bonds, motivate personnel, and cultivate a sense of belonging in the troops," the court observed.
It therefore held that the petitioner's refusal to fully participate in the weekly regimental religious parades, despite counselling at multiple levels of command and multiple opportunities being given to him for compliance, demonstrated an unwillingness to adapt to the requirements of military service and the armed forces.
It said the termination of the petitioner was justified, and since the religious sentiments and the morale of the troops were in question, a formal court martial was "unsuitable for resolution" as it could be detrimental to the secular fabric of the armed forces.
"While to a civilian, this may appear a bit harsh and may even sound far-fetched, however, the standard of discipline required for the Armed Forces is different. The motivation that is to be instilled in the troops may necessitate actions beyond ordinary civilian standards," the court observed.
"We find no grounds to interfere with the Impugned Order dated 03.03.2021. The petition is, accordingly, dismissed," it held.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

RSS's national education chintan baithak begins
RSS's national education chintan baithak begins

Time of India

time38 minutes ago

  • Time of India

RSS's national education chintan baithak begins

Kochi: A four-day education-focused 'National Education Chintan Baithak', organised by Shiksha Sanskriti Utthan Nyas (SSUN), an RSS-linked body working to "revive Indian ethos in education", commenced at Adi Shankara Nilayam, headquarters of Chinmaya International Foundation, at Veliyanad near Piravom on Friday. The event was inaugurated by RSS sarsanghchalak Mohan Bhagwat. This is the third national chintan baithak of SSUN, following previous meetings at Vrindavan in 2012 and Coimbatore in 2019. Around 100 delegates, including SSUN national coordinators and selected educational experts from various parts of the country, are participating in the event. Addressing the inaugural session, SSUN chairperson Pankaj Mittal said, "Since inception, the Nyas strived to rejuvenate Bhartiya education by blending traditional knowledge systems with modern-day needs, offering a meaningful alternative to the current system. In Bharat, the aim of education was never limited to livelihood—it was a path toward becoming a complete human being. That is the direction in which we must take our education system. " Speaking at the event, Atul Kothari, SSUN national secretary, emphasised the need for a balance of materialism and spirituality in education. He stated that the work of the Nyas and the transformation of Bharat's education are interconnected. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like The Top 25 Most Beautiful Women In The World Car Novels Undo He stressed the importance of focusing on solutions alongside identifying problems. Also present on the occasion were Swami Viviktananda of Chinmaya Mission, SSUN convener A Vinod. The session was conducted by Sanjay Swami, SSUN co-convener. Meanwhile, Gyan Sabha 2025, a two-day conference scheduled for July 27 and 28, will focus on bringing Kerala's traditional knowledge systems into mainstream education. The event will highlight areas like Ayurveda, Kalaripayattu, tourism, architecture, tantric practices and the state's rich mathematical heritage alongside the philosophies of various social reform movements. The organisers said the aim is to support the vision of Atmanirbhar Bharat by encouraging self-governance, entrepreneurship and holistic development in the education sector.

BJP leaders must speak up on Mahadayi project, says minister Laxmi Hebbalkar
BJP leaders must speak up on Mahadayi project, says minister Laxmi Hebbalkar

Time of India

time38 minutes ago

  • Time of India

BJP leaders must speak up on Mahadayi project, says minister Laxmi Hebbalkar

Belagavi: "It is not right for the Goa govt to say that it will not permit the Mahadayi project. BJP leaders must speak up on this issue," said minister for women and child development Laxmi Hebbalkar. Speaking to reporters here on Friday, the minister said that the BJP leaders claimed during the Lok Sabha elections that Goa gave permission for the Mahadayi project and used it as a political tool while distributing sweets in celebration. "Now, answers must come from them," she asserted. Rejecting allegations by the Goa CM that the Karnataka govt is politicising the Mahadayi issue, the minister clarified that the state govt has no need to politicise matters related to drinking water, health, or education. Responding to recent attacks on Kannadigas in Goa, the minister strongly condemned the incidents. "Whether it is Karnataka or Goa, both are integral parts of India. I condemn the attacks on Kannadigas. Such acts are completely wrong," she said. She pointed out that many people from Goa come to Karnataka, and Karnataka residents also visit Goa. "Goa's economy depends on people from other states. Goa govt must ensure that visitors and tourists from other states are not harassed," minister Hebbalkar urged. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like TV providers are furious: this gadget gives you access to all channels Techno Mag Learn More Undo She also said that the Goa govt must not remain silent on the attacks against Kannadigas and that she would bring the issue to the attention of HK Patil, the minister in charge of border affairs. 'No meeting held by Surjewala with officials' Meanwhile, Hebbalkar clarified that State Congress in-charge Randeep Singh Surjewala has not held any meetings with govt officials. "He only met with ministers and discussed how they are performing in terms of public service," she said. "Surjewala meets with ministers and MLAs once in every three months. It is not an evaluation meeting. He only gathers information about departmental activities," she added. When asked about minister KN Rajanna's recent statement that a revolution would happen in Sept, Hebbalkar responded, "Ours is a party that listens to the high command. CM and deputy CM have already given a clear explanation. I do not wish to comment further on this," she said.

AP eyes strategic defence role post UAV missile test
AP eyes strategic defence role post UAV missile test

Time of India

time38 minutes ago

  • Time of India

AP eyes strategic defence role post UAV missile test

1 2 3 Vijayawada: A day after the successful trial of UAV launched precision guided missiles from Andhra Pradesh soil, the state govt has made a quick move to position itself as a leader in defence and aerospace manufacturing sectors. A delegation of TDP MPs led by parliamentary party leader Lavu Sri Krishna Devarayalu met Union defence minister Rajnath Singh in New Delhi on Friday and handed over a proposal from chief minister N Chandrababu Naidu to set up defence manufacturing units in AP. They urged him to look into the series of landmark initiatives by the govt aimed at transforming the state into a strategic defence production hub. Krishna Devarayalu said they have submitted a comprehensive defence development plan to make AP a leader state in attracting investments in the defence sector. "The chief minister has emphasized on the establishment of four defence and aerospace manufacturing hubs in the state. The state govt has proposed two separate clusters — Jaggaiahpet and Donakonda with nearly 6,000 acres — for missile and ammunition production. About 4,000 acres have been readied at Orvakal in Kurnool district to set up units for drones, robotics, and advanced components. The chief minister has also proposed an aircraft and defence electronics city at Lepakshi-Madakasira where we have identified about 10,000 acres. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like If A Cat Bites Their Owner Heres What It Really Means Gloriousa Undo We want the Centre to make use of about 3,000 acres available in Visakhapatnam-Anakapalli for naval equipment and weapons testing," the Narasaraopet MP said. The chief minister wants the Centre to set up the DRDO industry-academia centre of excellence at IIT-Tirupati and a common ammunition storage facility by the ministry of defence, Krishna Devarayalu added. "The CM has sought support for defence investments and strategic projects, including the 2,400 crore BEL strategic complex at Palasamudram, and revival of UADNL's 60,000 TPA aluminium alloy plant in Nellore. The govt is ready to give land and provide required infrastructure for HAL's expansion project at Lepakshi," he said.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store