UK Islamophobia Definition Row: Deputy PM Angela Rayner backs down amid backlash over de-facto 'blasphemy law'
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
The controversy erupted after Rayner's office launched a consultation to craft an official government definition of Islamophobia, appointing a 16-member working group known as the 'Islamophobia Council' to tackle anti-Muslim hatred. The proposed working definition, based on a 2018 parliamentary report, described Islamophobia as 'a type of racism targeting expressions of Muslimness.'
Critics swiftly objected.
Free speech advocates warned that equating criticism of religious practices with racism risked stifling legitimate debate, potentially creating a de facto blasphemy law. Hindu, Sikh, and secular organisations raised concerns that focusing solely on anti-Muslim hate ignored threats faced by other religious minorities in Britain. Insight UK and the Hindu Council UK called for a unified Religious Hate Council to ensure all communities are protected equally.
Dominic Grieve, former Tory attorney general and author of the foreword to the 2018 definition, is tipped to chair the council. However, critics argue that reusing the 2018 formulation could dangerously blur the lines between racial discrimination and valid religious critique, including discussions around Islamist extremism and grooming gangs.
In response to growing pressure, including a legal threat from the Free Speech Union which described the process as having a 'predetermined outcome,' Rayner has now extended the consultation deadline to July 20 and made it publicly accessible to all stakeholders.
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
The consultation process has also been expanded to include previously excluded groups such as the Christian Institute, Adam Smith Institute, Christian Concern, and the Equality and Human Rights Commission.
The government maintains that its goal is to protect Muslim communities from hate crimes while safeguarding freedom of expression. However, the episode has highlighted deep divides over how Britain tackles religious hatred without undermining civil liberties.
With the consultation closing next week, officials are expected to release a revised draft definition later this month, potentially with softened language or a broader remit to cover all faith groups. For now, Rayner's retreat underscores the political tightrope of combating discrimination while preserving the freedom to question religious ideologies.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
16 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
In spirit of brotherhood, a tribute to ‘Op Sindoor'
A symbol of interfaith harmony and national pride is taking shape in Meerut's Sadar Bazaar. A group of Hindu and Muslim youngsters have come together to build a grand 'kanwar' that has been named 'Operation Sindoor' to celebrate the country's military prowess and the spirit of communal unity. (HT) The initiative is being led by Gaurav, who, with 20 of his companions, is crafting the kanwar as an expression of both devotion and patriotism. It will be taken to Haridwar on July 15. The group will collect holy Ganga water on July 16 and return to Meerut. What makes this kanwar remarkable is not just its scale — 10 feet tall and 12 feet wide — but also its design, which features a statue of Bharat Mata (Mother India), a model of a Rafale fighter jet, an Army tank, and temples, showcasing India's military might and spiritual heritage. 'This is not just a kanwar, but also a glimpse of our nation's strength,' said Neeraj Dhameja, an artisan working on the project. The sentiment was echoed by Imam Shahnawaz Jamali of the local mosque, who has been actively supporting the initiative. 'We stand with our nation. The path of religion passes through humanity. Our unity against terrorism is the real strength of this country,' he said. Gaurav said the kanwar was also dedicated to the 26 innocent people killed in a terrorist attack in Pahalgam on April 22, as well as to India's armed forces and martyrs. The brutal attack had sparked nationwide anger, and the Indian Army responded decisively, delivering a strong blow to terrorists and those supporting them across the border. 'Operation Sindoor is a symbolic tribute to those who lost their lives and to the bravery of our armed forces who defended the nation with unmatched courage,' Gaurav said. This special kanwar will be brought from Haridwar, and the Jalabhishek (ritual water offering) will be performed at the famous Augharnath Temple in Meerut.
Hans India
23 minutes ago
- Hans India
Puttur BJP leader's son threatened by underworld for his ‘misdeed'
A controversy involving the son of a local BJP leader, accused of impregnating and deceiving a young woman, has taken an unexpected turn with the alleged intervention of underworld figure Kali Yogeesh, who has threatened violence if justice is not delivered. The case, which centres on accusations that the BJP leader's son lured the woman into a relationship on the pretext of marriage and later abandoned her, had already sparked outrage in local circles. However, the situation escalated after an audio recording surfaced, purportedly featuring Kali Yogeesh warning of retribution if the accused is not forced to marry the woman after his release from jail. In the call made to a prominent media outlet, Yogeesh questioned the silence of Hindu organisations and BJP leaders, expressing disappointment that no one was standing up for the victim, who he claimed was a Hindu girl from a financially weak background. He alleged double standards in the response to such cases, particularly when the accused has political backing. 'If this injustice continues, and she is not married, I will shoot him when he comes out of jail,' the voice in the audio is heard declaring. The speaker also condemned what he termed the hypocrisy of political leaders who rally for causes of Hindu women only when it suits them. The audio has triggered concern among security agencies and has once again highlighted the underworld's lingering shadow over sensitive local disputes in coastal Karnataka. Police are yet to verify the authenticity of the audio or respond to the threat publicly.
India.com
28 minutes ago
- India.com
India can become country with world's largest Muslim population by..., Hindi population will be...
Representational Image/ AI-generated The Muslim community has emerged as the fastest growing religious group in the world, while Christianity's share in the global population has declined between 2010 and 2020. However, despite the decline, Christianity is still the largest religious group in the world. It is being expected that in the next 25 years, India will be the country with the most Muslims in the world. The Muslim population in India increased by 3.56 crores. The report said that the rate of conversion to Hinduism is very low, and their fertility rate is equal to the global average – due to which their share has remained stable. According to a recent report of the Pew Research Center 'How the global religious landscape changed from 2010 to 2020', the Muslim population increased by 347 million, which is more than the combined growth of all other religions. It also says that in the next 25 years, India will be the country with the most Muslims in the world. What is the cause of the increase of population? The share of Muslims globally increased from 23.9% in 2010 to 25.6% in 2020. This growth was mainly due to demographic factors such as high birth rate and young population. The highest growth of the Muslim population was seen in the Asia-Pacific region, where the world's largest Muslim population resides. The Muslim population in this region increased by 16.2% between 2010 and 2020. Muslims constitute 94.2% of the population in the Middle East-North Africa region, while in sub-Saharan Africa it is 33%. What is the situation of Hindus? The report said that the Hindu population grew by 12% between 2010 and 2020, which is almost equal to the global population growth. The number of Hindus in 2020 was 1.2 billion, which is 14.9% of the global population. The Hindu population in India declined slightly from 80% in 2010 to 79% in 2020, while the Muslim population increased from 14.3% to 15.2%. According to the Pew report, Hindu and Jewish populations kept pace with global population growth. Hindus are the largest religious group in India, Nepal and Mauritius. Although the share of Hindus in India has declined marginally, it still makes up the largest share of the country's population. Christianity declines, atheists increase The number of Christians in the world grew from 2.18 billion to 2.3 billion, but their global share fell from 30.6% to 28.8%. This decline was mainly due to religious abandonment, especially in regions such as Europe, North America, and Australia.
