US arbitrator orders Zia Chishti to pay $9.1mn to TRG International
The arbitration was regarding the legality of share pledges of TRG Pakistan that were central to Zia Chishti's borrowing Rs2.5 billion from JS Bank to buy additional shares of TRG Pakistan. TRG had alleged that it was part of a plan by him and the JS Group to illegally take over TRG Pakistan as a first step towards taking control of TRG's international assets.
TRG Pakistan shared the development in a notice to the Pakistan Stock Exchange (PSX) on Tuesday.
'The company has been informed by its affiliate The Resource Group International Limited ('TRGIL') that a final award has been issued by a US arbitrator in respect of the arbitration initiated by TRGIL against Mr Chishti challenging the pledging by Mr Chishti of company shares owned by him.
'On January 27, 2025, the arbitrator had issued a partial final award which ruled, inter alia, that shares pledged by Mr Chishti, primarily to JS Bank as security for a loan, were in breach of contractual obligations of Mr Chishti.
'On April 22, 2025, the arbitrator issued a final award that, in addition to the remedies contained in the partial final award dated January 27, 2025, ordered Mr Chishti to pay TRGIL a sum of US$ 9.1 million,' the notice read.
Zia Chishti 'resigns as CEO, director at TRG Pakistan'
TRG contended that Chishti was not allowed to pledge the shares given his contractual undertakings, and had asked the arbitrator to order him to remove the pledge.
In January 2025, the US arbitrator ruled in favour of TRG, and declared that Chishti had breached his contractual obligations by making the pledge. The court then ordered him to remove the pledge.
In April 2025, the arbitrator has ordered Chishti to pay $9.1 million (or PKR 2.5 billion) to TRG.
As questions are raised about the ability of former TRG Pakistan CEO to pay such a significant amount to TRG, the fate of Rs2.5 billion loan from JS Bank to Chishti remains unclear.
In recent filings with the Sindh High Court, JS Bank has declared the loan to be in default.
TRG has had stay orders in place from the Sindh High Court since 2023 preventing the exercise of security on the loan.
Zia Chishti, The Telegraph settle libel suit over reporting of ex-employee's 'grooming' allegations
It is unclear whether the loan continues to be carried on JS Bank's books given the default and the stay orders on collateral.
During the most recent quarter ended March 31, 2025, JS Bank reported profit before tax of Rs2.7 billion, which could get wiped out with a write-off of this loan
Market analysts have questioned the nature of the loan made in 2022, as it represented a huge exposure for JS Bank for a loan made to a single person. The loan was renewed in November 2024 despite the stay orders on the share pledge security were in place, only to be in default two months later.
In the bourse notice on Tuesday, TRG Pakistan also shared that it had received copies of certified orders regarding the adjudication of Writ Petitions 3383 and 3395 of 2025 filed in the Lahore High Court and 693 of 2025 filed in the Islamabad High Court by Zia Chishti.
SHC restrains Zia Chishti, wife from transferring shares of TRG Pakistan: notice
In both writ petitions, Chishti had sought to suspend ad-interim orders of the Civil Judge in Lahore and Islamabad dated December 2, 2024, December 10, 2024, and February 11, 2025, respectively, that restrained the company in respect of its board elections.
'On April 8, 2025 the Honorable Islamabad High Court judge was pleased to dismiss Writ Petition 693 of 2025 and on April 11, 2025, the Honorable Lahore High Court judge was pleased to dismiss Writ Petitions 3383 and 3395 of 2025,' the notice read.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
20 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Azhar Mahmood's contract poses major challenge for PCB
Azhar Mahmood's contract has become a major hurdle for the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB), as terminating him before the end of the agreement would require paying him six months' salary. As a result, he has been appointed interim head coach of the Test team. According to details, Azhar Mahmood was recently appointed by PCB as the interim coach of the red-ball (Test) team. The official press release had stated that he would continue until the completion of his contract. However, sources indicate that the situation is more complicated than it appears. Reportedly, PCB's white ball head coach, Mike Hesson, had outright refused to include Azhar Mahmood in his coaching setup. Sources close to Azhar claim that during the tenures of Gary Kirsten and Jason Gillespie, he was told to continue grooming himself as an assistant coach with the promise of becoming head coach later. When that did not happen, Azhar became disappointed. At one point, he was informally told by an official that he would be given the Test team responsibility, but when no formal announcement was made, he grew concerned and even considered legal options. The main issue for PCB is a contract signed by the previous administration with Azhar Mahmood, which stipulates that early termination would require payment of six months' salary. Azhar had even offered to work with the U19 team, but that proposal was rejected. His salary is paid in US dollars, which translates to around PKR 7.5 million per month, making him one of the most expensive coaches in Pakistan's cricket history. To reduce expenses, PCB recently let go of several mentors — including WaqarYounis and SaqlainMushtaq — who were each earning around PKR 5 million monthly. However, removing Azhar before his contract expires would cost PCB tens of millions of rupees. His contract is set to end in March or April 2025, during which he will likely remain with the Test side for only two series: one against South Africa in October-November, and the other against Bangladesh in March-April. Sources also revealed that Director of High Performance, Aaqib Javed, is not impressed with Azhar's coaching and has openly voiced his concerns in meetings. It is also possible that a permanent Test coach may be appointed even during Azhar's interim tenure.
Business Recorder
a day ago
- Business Recorder
Disallowing expenditure: Govt likely to increase limit to Rs2.5m
ISLAMABAD: The government is likely to increase the limit from Rs200,000 to Rs 2.5 million for disallowing expenditure attributable to cash sales exceeding Rs2.5 million per transaction. Tax experts told Business Recorder that the amendment to Section 24 of the Income Tax Ordinance 2001, which prohibits the deduction of expenses for cash sales exceeding Rs200,000 has generated considerable concern within the business community. The new provision introduced through Finance Act 2025 has been implemented from July 1, 2025. The government has now proposed to implement this law in phase-wise manner to protect the revenue collection, as well as, ensure documentation. This law would be fully implemented in three years period, sources said. Under the proposed revised law, the law would be fully implemented in three years period in phases. In the first year, the amount of Rs200,000 has been proposed to be increased to Rs 2.5 million for disallowing expenditure per transaction. In the second year, the amount would be decreased from Rs 2.5 million to Rs 1.5 million and subsequently to Rs 0.5 million. The percentage of disallowance would be decreased from 50 percent to 20 percent which would be gradually increased in three years period, the new proposal said. According to the details, the disallowance introduced via Section 24 of the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001 pertains exclusively to the head 'Income from Business', as defined under Section 18. This provision disallows 50 per cent of expenditure attributable to cash sales exceeding Rs200,000 per transaction as per Finance Act 2025. Hence, the restriction applies solely to business income and is not applicable to individuals or entities earning income under any other head under the Finance Act 2025. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
a day ago
- Business Recorder
All major markets in Lahore stay shut
LAHORE: All major commercial areas, including Shah Alam Market, Akbari Mandi, Hall Road, Mall Road, Anarkali, and others, were shut down, with support from all factions of the city's traders' unions. The Lahore Chamber of Commerce also endorsed the protest. The strike, called in protest against expanded powers granted to the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR), divided traders into opposing camps. Traders' leader Haji Maqsood Butt declared the strike a success and warned that if the FBR continued to 'harass' traders or exert 'unjustified authority,' further action would be taken. 'We are united, and we reject forced compliance,' he said. Lahore Chamber of Commerce and Industry President Mian Abuzar Shad has appreciated the business community for showing a great response and the overwhelming success of the nationwide shutter-down strike on July 19. The press conference was attended and addressed by Senior Vice President Engineer Khalid Usman, Vice President Shahid Nazir Chaudhry, former Presidents Mian Anjum Nisar, Muhammad Ali Mian, former Senior Vice President Ali Hussam Asghar and former Vice President Faheem ur Rehman Saigol. Speaking on the occasion, LCCI President Mian Abuzar Shad said that the 19th of July 2025 will go down in history as a defining day of awareness, unity and struggle by Pakistan's business community. He extended heartfelt gratitude to the traders, shopkeepers, industrialists and all market associations of Lahore who responded to the LCCI's call and ensured a complete, peaceful and disciplined strike. Lahore has proven today that it is not just a city – it is a sentiment, a force. The LCCI President also appreciated the strong response from other cities including Karachi, Hyderabad, Sukkur and others who joined hands for a common cause. He added that Lahore and Karachi collectively contribute over 60% of Pakistan's economic activity. Today, that 60% was silenced, not by force, but by choice to register protest against oppressive and non-consulted tax measures. He informed the media that nearly eight hours of negotiations were held via Zoom on July 18 , involving top government officials including Haroon Akhtar Khan, Chairman FBR Rashid Langrial, Bilal Azhar Kayani and others while from the LCCI, the meeting was attended by the LCCI President Mian Abuzar Shad, Senior Vice President Engineer Khalid Usman, Vice President Shahid Nazir Chaudhry, Former Presidents Mian Anjum Nisar and Muhammad Ali Mian, Former SVP Ali Hussam Asghar and former Vice President Faheem ur Rehman Saigol. During the discussion, the LCCI demanded urgent revisions and clarifications on Section 37AA, Implementation of E-Invoicing and e-bilty system, 16% sales tax on rent of properties and 20% tax on transactions above PKR 200,000. 'We asked for a public statement or at least official meeting minutes to share with our stakeholders. Neither was provided. This left us with no choice but to proceed with a strike,' said Mian Abuzar Shad. LCCI Senior Vice President Engineer Khalid Usman and Vice President Shahid Nazir Chaudhry said that we are patriots. We are willing to pay taxes. But we demand justice and inclusion in policymaking. Our protest is not for personal gain but to safeguard millions of livelihoods across the country.' The LCCI leadership said that business community has been invited at the LCCI on July 23 (Wednesday) to chalk out the next steps. LCCI President Mian Abuzar Shad made a appeal to Prime Minister Shahbaz Sharif and Deputy Prime Minister Ishaq Dar to hear our legitimate demands and help avoid a nationwide economic crisis. They said that this is not an individual's issue. This is about collective survival. Those who thought a strike would never happen should now open their eyes to the ground reality. They said that business community is the backbone of Pakistan's economy andtheir concerns must be taken seriously. The leadership warned that inaction will result in larger movements, but added that their doors remain open for dialogue. LCCI President Mian Abuzar Shad extended his thanks to national media. Meanwhile, Pakistan Hosiery Manufacturers and Exporters Association (PHMA) has joined hands with chambers and trade bodies across the country in a complete industrial shutdown to protest against the controversial arrest powers granted to the FBR under Section 37AA of the Income Tax Ordinance, besides calling for final tax regime and restoration of EFS in its original form for the export industry. The nationwide strike, observed today, was held on the joint call of the Lahore Chamber of Commerce and Industry and other business groups demanding immediate withdrawal of anti-industry laws introduced through the federal budget. Zonal Chairman of PHMA Abdul Hameed, along with former chairmen Shafiq Butt and Naseer Butt, announced the closure of hosiery units as part of the countrywide strike, warning that such legislation would only deepen the crisis facing Pakistan's export-oriented sectors. The PHMA leadership said the business community could no longer stay silent while draconian laws continued to erode the confidence of investors and exporters. They said the participation of PHMA in this strike was not symbolic but a complete operational shutdown in protest against what they termed economic strangulation by the government's policies. Abdul Hameed expressed grave concern over Section 37AA, which gives FBR officers the authority to arrest businesspersons without due process or prior investigation, merely on suspicion of tax evasion. He said this law is a clear violation of constitutional rights and a serious blow to the already fragile industrial environment of Pakistan. Abdul Hameed termed it a 'black law' that legitimizes harassment of genuine taxpayers and exporters, adding that the textile and hosiery sector is already grappling with liquidity shortages, inflated utility tariffs, and a shrinking export order pipeline. PHMA former chairman Shehzad Azam Khan said their protest goes beyond just one law. He reiterated key demands of the value-added textile sector, including restoration of the normal tax regime, a reduction in the discretionary powers of FBR officials, and immediate reinstatement of the original structure of the Export Facilitation Scheme (EFS). He criticized the sudden and unexplained changes made in EFS parameters, which he said had undermined the very foundation of a system meant to support exports. By altering the EFS framework without consultation, the government has left exporters with unmanageable procedural burdens and operational uncertainty, they added. The strike call had received overwhelming support from nearly all chambers of commerce and industrial associations across the country, including Karachi, Faisalabad and Sialkot. Thousands of industrial units, large and small, remained closed for the day as a mark of protest. PHMA leaders warned that if the government failed to meet the business community's demands, the protest could enter the next phase, including indefinite closures and international complaint filings by exporters who fear losing credibility among global buyers due to erratic policymaking at home. Shafiq Butt also demanded the withdrawal of unreasonable taxes imposed on cash withdrawals and raised serious objections to the e-invoicing system that has made compliance nearly impossible for small and medium-sized enterprises. Former chairman Shafiq Butt said the government's attempt to boost revenue by criminalizing business activity is short-sighted and self-destructive. He warned that such coercive measures would push more businesses into the undocumented sector rather than increase tax compliance. Naseer Butt echoed these concerns, saying industrial output is already below 60 percent capacity in several textile zones, and any further disruptions would be disastrous for exports and employment. PHMA leaders also urged Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif and Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb to hold urgent consultations with business stakeholders instead of relying solely on bureaucratic advice. They said restoring business confidence through fair taxation, regulatory stability, and policy consultation is the only path forward. They reminded the government that Pakistan's economic recovery depends heavily on exports, and any attack on the export base is equivalent to sabotaging the country's future. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
