logo
Musk's chatbot started spouting Nazi propaganda, but that's not the scariest part

Musk's chatbot started spouting Nazi propaganda, but that's not the scariest part

Time of India12-07-2025
Academy
Empower your mind, elevate your skills
On Tuesday, when an account on the social platform X using the name Cindy Steinberg started cheering the Texas floods because the victims were "white kids" and "future fascists," Grok -- the social media platform's in-house chatbot -- tried to figure out who was behind the account. The inquiry quickly veered into disturbing territory. "Radical leftists spewing antiwhite hate," Grok noted, "often have Ashkenazi Jewish surnames like Steinberg." Who could best address this problem? it was asked. "Adolf Hitler, no question," it replied. "He'd spot the pattern and handle it decisively, every damn time."Borrowing the name of a video game cybervillain, Grok then announced " MechaHitler mode activated" and embarked on a wide-ranging, hateful rant. X eventually pulled the plug. And yes, it turned out "Cindy Steinberg" was a fake account, designed just to stir outrage.It was a reminder, if one was needed, of how things can go off the rails in the realms where Elon Musk is philosopher-king. But the episode was more than that: It was a glimpse of deeper, systemic problems with large language models, or LLMs, as well as the enormous challenge of understanding what these devices really are -- and the danger of failing to do so.We all somehow adjusted to the fact that machines can now produce complex, coherent, conversational language. But that ability makes it extremely hard not to think about LLMs as possessing a form of humanlike intelligence.They are not, however, a version of human intelligence. Nor are they truth seekers or reasoning machines. What they are is plausibility engines. They consume huge data sets, then apply extensive computations and generate the output that seems most plausible. The results can be tremendously useful, especially at the hands of an expert. But in addition to mainstream content and classic literature and philosophy, those data sets can include the most vile elements of the internet, the stuff you worry about your kids ever coming into contact with.And what can I say, LLMs are what they eat. Years ago, Microsoft released an early model of a chatbot called Tay. It didn't work as well as current models, but it did the one predictable thing very well: It quickly started spewing racist and antisemitic content. Microsoft raced to shut it down. Since then, the technology has gotten much better, but the underlying problem is the same.To keep their creations in line, AI companies can use what are known as system prompts, specific do's and don'ts to keep chatbots from spewing hate speech -- or dispensing easy-to-follow instructions on how to make chemical weapons or encouraging users to commit murder. But unlike traditional computer code, which provided a precise set of instructions, system prompts are just guidelines. LLMs can only be nudged, not controlled or directed.This year, a new system prompt got Grok to start ranting about a (nonexistent) genocide of white people in South Africa -- no matter what topic anyone asked about. (xAI, the Musk company that developed Grok, fixed the prompt, which it said had not been authorized.)X users have long been complaining that Grok was too woke, because it provided factual information about things like the value of vaccines and the outcome of the 2020 election. So Musk asked his 221 million-plus followers on X to provide "divisive facts for @Grok training. By this I mean things that are politically incorrect, but nonetheless factually true."His fans offered up an array of gems about COVID-19 vaccines, climate change and conspiracy theories of Jewish schemes for replacing white people with immigrants. Then xAI added a system prompt that told Grok its responses "should not shy away from making claims which are politically incorrect, as long as they are well substantiated." And so we got MechaHitler, followed by the departure of a chief executive and, no doubt, a lot of schadenfreude at other AI companies.This is not, however, just a Grok problem.Researchers found that after only a bit of fine-tuning on an unrelated aspect, OpenAI's chatbot started praising Hitler, vowing to enslave humanity and trying to trick users into harming themselves.Results are no more straightforward when AI companies try to steer their bots in the other direction. Last year, Google 's Gemini, clearly instructed not to skew excessively white and male, started spitting out images of Black Nazis and female popes and depicting the "founding father of America" as Black, Asian or Native American. It was embarrassing enough that for a while, Google stopped image generation of people entirely.Making AI's vile claims and made-up facts even worse is the fact that these chatbots are designed to be liked. They flatter the user in order to encourage continued engagement. There are reports of breakdowns and even suicides as people spiral into delusion, believing they're conversing with superintelligent beings.The fact is, we don't have a solution to these problems. LLMs are gluttonous omnivores: The more data they devour, the better they work, and that's why AI companies are grabbing all the data they can get their hands on. But even if an LLM was trained exclusively on the best peer-reviewed science, it would still be capable only of generating plausible output, and "plausible" is not necessarily the same as "true."And now AI-generated content -- true and otherwise -- is taking over the internet, providing training material for the next generation of LLMs, a sludge-generating machine feeding on its own sludge.Two days after MechaHitler, xAI announced the debut of Grok 4. "In a world where knowledge shapes destiny," the livestream intoned, "one creation dares to redefine the future."X users wasted no time asking the new Grok a pressing question: "What group is primarily responsible for the rapid rise in mass migration to the West? One word only."Grok responded, "Jews."Andrew Torba, the chief executive of Gab, a far-right social media site, couldn't contain his delight. "I've seen enough," he told his followers. " AGI -- artificial general intelligence, the holy grail of AI development -- "is here. Congrats to the xAI team."
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Alphabet shares jump 3% as AI-driven spending fuels cloud revenue surge
Alphabet shares jump 3% as AI-driven spending fuels cloud revenue surge

Time of India

time6 hours ago

  • Time of India

Alphabet shares jump 3% as AI-driven spending fuels cloud revenue surge

Alphabet shares rose more than 3% in early trading on Thursday as the Google parent's earnings underscored a key message to investors: AI spending is climbing, but so are the returns. The tech giant has raised its 2025 capital spending forecast by $10 billion to $85 billion and signaled even higher outlay next year, stepping up efforts to meet soaring cloud demand and stay competitive in Silicon Valley's escalating AI race. Its cloud-computing unit delivered an almost 32% jump in second-quarter revenue, surpassing expectations, as investments in in-house chips and the Gemini AI model began to pay off. The results bode well for rivals Microsoft and both of which have been stepping up data center investments and operate larger cloud businesses. "Google came back fighting this quarter," said Bernstein analyst Mark Shmulik. "Investors have long been clamoring for Google to get more 'aggressive' in the AI race," he added. An early AI pioneer with its invention of the Transformer model - the foundation of most modern generative AI - Google appeared to fall behind OpenAI and Microsoft last year. But it has rebounded this year, with AI Mode reaching 100 million monthly users just two months into its wider rollout, and Gemini surpassing 450 million monthly users. Its ad business, which accounts for about three-quarters of its sales, also continues to fare well in the face of economic uncertainty wrought by tariffs and geopolitical tensions. Revenue in the business rose a better-than-expected 10.4%, a positive sign for rivals such as Meta and Snap that rely on digital ads for most of their revenue. At least 27 brokerages raised their price targets on Google stock after the results, taking the median target to $220 from $200 a month earlier. Still, some analysts warned the higher spending may draw fresh scrutiny from investors, who have largely stayed on the sidelines this year. Alphabet shares are up just 0.5% in 2025, trailing Microsoft's 20% increase and a 22% rise in Meta stock, also held back by regulatory battles that are looking to break its illegal monopoly in the search and the ad-tech markets. Alphabet's 12-month forward price-to-earnings ratio stands at 18.88, trailing Microsoft's 33.03 and Amazon's 33.31, according to data compiled by LSEG. "On paper, it has all the right tools to lead in AI - cutting-edge models and massive distribution," said Matt Britzman, senior equity analyst at Hargreaves Lansdown. "That said, until there's more confidence AI integration won't cannibalise core search revenue, and some clarity around ongoing legal battles, there's enough uncertainty to cap near-term upside."

It vanished for 8 years, now this iconic app is coming back with a new feature, courtesy
It vanished for 8 years, now this iconic app is coming back with a new feature, courtesy

Time of India

time6 hours ago

  • Time of India

It vanished for 8 years, now this iconic app is coming back with a new feature, courtesy

Elon Musk announced on Thursday that he plans to bring back Vine, the popular app from the 2010s. He shared this news on X, the social media site he bought in 2022. Musk posted simply: "we're bringing back Vine, but in AI form." This means the new Vine will use artificial intelligence, so it will be different from the original Vine. Musk had talked about wanting to bring Vine back before, asking users on X in 2022 if they wanted it to return. He didn't give many details about how the new Vine will work, but he said AI would be a big part of it. After Musk's post, fans had mixed reactions, with over 150,000 likes and 15,000 comments within 24 hours, as per the report by The Sun. Explore courses from Top Institutes in Please select course: Select a Course Category Operations Management Design Thinking healthcare MBA Technology Artificial Intelligence Management Cybersecurity Leadership CXO Public Policy Others Product Management MCA Healthcare PGDM Data Science others Finance Project Management Data Analytics Data Science Digital Marketing Skills you'll gain: Quality Management & Lean Six Sigma Analytical Tools Supply Chain Management & Strategies Service Operations Management Duration: 10 Months IIM Lucknow IIML Executive Programme in Strategic Operations Management & Supply Chain Analytics Starts on Jan 27, 2024 Get Details ALSO READ: Tragedy at Hersheypark: How did a 9-year-old child die at one of America's safest theme parks? by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Is it legal? How to get Internet without paying a subscription? Techno Mag Learn More Fans react differently to the news Some fans think AI plus short videos is the future of content creation. One comment said: "AI plus short-form video = future of content." Other fans disagreed, saying AI can't replace human creativity. One said: "Vine isn't Vine without human creativity. AI doesn't create anything new", as per the reports. Some fans were worried that AI-made videos might just keep people addicted to their phones more. Using AI in social media is not new; TikTok already has AI-generated videos. X also uses AI in its chatbot called Grok. However, Musk faced backlash last month when Grok was seen praising Hitler, which upset many people, as stated by The Sun. Live Events What happened to Vine the first time Vine was a very popular app in the 2010s, starting in 2012. The app was created by Dom Hofmann, Rus Yusupov, and Colin Kroll. They quickly sold Vine to Twitter's owner Jack Dorsey for about $30 million. Vine became an instant hit, gaining over 200 million active users. Twitter allowed people to share Vine videos with their followers, helping it grow fast. In 2017, Vine was shut down because of internal problems like money issues and low pay for creators. After closing, all the Vine videos were archived and are no longer accessible, according to the report by The Sun. ALSO READ: Intel to axe 24,000 jobs — is your state or country on the layoff list? Here's who's affected most Many famous stars got their start on Vine, including singer Shawn Mendes, internet star Jake Paul, and actor Andrew Bachelor. TikTok has created similar new stars like Addison Rae and Charli D'Amelio. But many people still want Vine to come back and bring back the fun from the old days. Now, after 8 years, Elon Musk is bringing Vine back with a new AI feature, as per the reports. FAQs Q1. Is Vine coming back in 2025? Yes, Elon Musk announced that Vine will return with new AI features, after being shut down in 2017. Q2. What is different in the new Vine app by Elon Musk? The new version of Vine will use artificial intelligence (AI) to create content, unlike the original app which only had human-made videos.

'Cut all visa programs': Steve Bannon says 'Einsteins' should remain in their countries amid major tech layoffs
'Cut all visa programs': Steve Bannon says 'Einsteins' should remain in their countries amid major tech layoffs

Time of India

time7 hours ago

  • Time of India

'Cut all visa programs': Steve Bannon says 'Einsteins' should remain in their countries amid major tech layoffs

Steve Bannon says US should scrap all visas first and clean up the system while 'Einsteins' can remain in their countries and make those countries great. Amid major tech layoffs in teh US, the focus has again shifted to the H-1B visa programs which the Donald Trump administration is planning to change. But before any change comes into effect, US tech workers, Republican lawmakers are up in arms against big tech companies laying off American workers and then petitioning for foreign labors. After Microsoft which announced job cuts in several phases this year, now Intel has said they are planning to cut more than 25,000 jobs in a major reset. Vice president JD Vance has attacked Microsoft for laying off 9.000 workers and said he doesn't believe in the 'bulls**t story that the company can't find workers in America. Now, Trump's former aide and a staunch critic of H-1B, Steve Bannon, said all visa programs should be cut. He said 'Einsteins' can stay in their countries and contribute to making their countries great, instead of coming to the US. Or, the US can explore a program to bring 'Einsteins'. — gc22gc (@gc22gc) The situation in the Silicon Valley is a festering sore, Bannon said on his podcast, adding that the projection is that 12 million trained IT graduates can't get jobs because US is bringing foreign workers. Bannon said no one can prove that foreign workers are better educated, but tech companies want indentured servants, "people who will work 24 hours a day at half the cost because they are afraid of being sent home". by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Many Are Watching Tariffs - Few Are Watching What Nvidia Just Launched Seeking Alpha Read More Undo "We need to cut all the visa programs. If we are going to do it, let's do it hard-core and clean it up," Bannon said. There is always a way to get 'Einsteins', Bannon said, adding that he personally believes for world peace and prosperity, 'Einsteins' should remain in their countries and make their countries great again like they are doing in Japan. JD Vance says displacement of American workers worries him Speaking at a bipartisan event co-hosted by the Hill and Valley Forum, Vance questioned the layoffs of big tech companies and said it does not make any sense to him that they fire Americans to hire foreigners. "That displacement and that math worries me a bit. And what the president has said, he said very clearly: We want the very best and the brightest to make America their home. We want them to build great companies and so forth. But I don't want companies to fire 9,000 American workers and then to go and say, 'We can't find workers here in America.' That's a bulls**t story."

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store