Bunnings accused of abusing market power
David Woodman: How are you today ma'am?
Customer: I'm well, how are you today?
David Woodman: I am very well thank you. What can I do to help you?
Emilia Terzon : David Woodman's family has owned hardware stores for generations. This one on the outskirts of Brisbane is under threat.
Katherine Mingin: Bunnings have bought the property next door and have advertised or put in the newspapers that they're going to build a 15,000 plus square metre box next door to us.
Emilia Terzon : Bunnings says that its store will enhance competition in the Jimboomba region, but David Woodman thinks it will decimate his profits.
Katherine Mingin: Being a small family business we can't sustain that so we'd probably end up shutting the store.
Emilia Terzon : While Bunnings can legally set up next door to his Mitre 10, a Four Corners investigation has found that Bunnings is using clauses in its leases to block rivals setting up near its stores. Suppliers have also come forward with fresh allegations of being treated badly by the hardware giant. For eight years George Mingin and his wife Katherine supplied live worms to Bunnings, only to be dumped when they asked for a price increase.
Katherine Mingin: We ended up putting a lot of hard work for absolutely no gain whatsoever. In fact we've lost everything that we put back into the business simply to supply Bunnings.
Emilia Terzon : Professor Clinton Free from the University of Sydney questions whether Bunnings has simply become too big.
Clinton Free : It's an enormous success financially but it also starts to raise big questions about market power.
Emilia Terzon : Market research firm IbisWorld estimates that Bunnings' parent company Wesfarmers controls a third of the retail hardware market while one rival says the figure is double this. Bunnings disputes both estimates.
Clinton Free : Bunnings has managed itself very skilfully through flying under the radar a little bit, having a very trusted brand. That has meant that it's not been subject to scrutiny in the same way that for example Coles and Woolworths have.
Emilia Terzon : The competition watchdog has also had its eye on dodgy discounts. Four Corners has found there is a large caveat around Bunnings' famed price match guarantee.
Bunnings advertisement: Citeco ladder, $159. Where you find a competitor's lower price on the same stocked item, we'll beat it by 10%.
Emilia Terzon : But good luck finding that Citeco ladder anywhere else because it's a home brand. Bunnings now sells around 9,000 home brand products. Matt Steen from Consumer Advocacy Group Choice says that even some of the barbecues are Bunnings' home brand but as a shopper, you'd never know it.
Matt Steen : There's nowhere on the packaging or on the products themselves that actually says it's a Bunnings only product. I think Bunnings should basically make it more transparent about how people can actually get that 10% guarantee, realistically get it, which is not including their home brand products. And so incorporation of some kind of labelling into their packaging and products would be really useful.
Emilia Terzon : In a statement, the ACCC told Four Corners that home brands could be misleading or deceptive if they are marketed as though they are produced by a third party. Bunnings says it complies with all legal and regulatory requirements that apply to labelling and it applies its famed price match guarantee on like-for-like items. The company declined an interview with Four Corners. In a statement, it said it has a genuine commitment to value, service and fairness.
Sabra Lane: Emilia Terzon reporting there and you can see the full Four Corners episode, 8.30pm tonight on ABC TV or anytime on ABC's iView.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

ABC News
8 hours ago
- ABC News
Renters finding the market ever more expensive
Rents in Australia may not be going up as fast as they were, but the rental market remains at record highs. Mike Lorigan reports.


SBS Australia
8 hours ago
- SBS Australia
Australia lifts biosecurity controls on US beef imports
Australia lifts biosecurity controls on US beef imports Published 24 July 2025, 9:20 am The White House has trumpeted Australia's decision to relax restrictions on US beef imports as an example of the US making 'Agriculture Great Again'. The Australian government is also under pressure to explain a lack of transparency over a major payment to the US for AUKUS amid the ongoing trade negotiations.

News.com.au
8 hours ago
- News.com.au
NSW Premier Chris Minns warns trains a ‘massive' election issue after brutal report
NSW Premier Chris Minns has given a frank assessment of Sydney's train network, warning if they don't turn things around 'then voters will send a message' next election. Transport for NSW data released on Thursday revealed the bleak reality for commuters, with 16 per cent of city trains not running on time in the 2024-25 financial year. The result is the worst for Sydney's rail network in years and comes after months on instability wrought by protracted industrial action and major technical failures. Mr Minns on Thursday refused to blame industrial action as being the sole cause of the network's issues, admitting it was a 'huge challenge for the government'. 'If we don't rapidly improve performance on our railways in the coming months, then voters will send a message to us loud and clear at the next election,' he said. 'This is a massive issue for us. I'm not running away from it … I'm not putting it down to industrial disputes. 'The pressure and the responsibility is on us, the government, to increase reliability and on-time running in the public transport network. 'I can assure you, we're putting resources into it as we speak.' Mr Minns admitted solving the state's longstanding pay dispute with the Combined Rail Unions had been the government's 'focus'. With a deal reached, Mr Minns said the 'full resources' of senior leadership of Sydney Trains and TfNSW, and the Premier's office, would be on 'punctuality'. 'We're a big international city, (and) the only way big international cities work and people can get to work and from work is using public transport,' he said. 'There is no alternative, and we need to make sure that it's world class'. Mr Minns said the state government had invested $740m into backlog maintenance on the rail network. At the same time, TfNSW secretary Josh Murray announced in an email to staff on Wednesday plans to slash 950 senior positions at the transport authority. It comes after earlier jobs were cut as part of an election pledge by Mr Minns to slash senior echelons of the public service by 15 per cent. Public Service Association general secretary Stewart Little said the union was seeking details on the specific positions to be cut. Asked whether he could assure commuters the cuts would not affect the performance of the network, Mr Minns said: 'Yes, I can. 'I've looked and scrutinised these numbers very closely, and I'm not flippant about this. 'I realise that these are jobs, they're families, they're people's lives and … it's a difficult decision for the government to make. 'The simple truth, however, was that Transport for NSW grew by 48 per cent over four years – a massive, massive increase in the headcount of that department. 'We need more on-the-ground, frontline public servants doing the difficult but necessary job of providing that service, and that's where our focus is going.' Addressing the data later on Thursday, Opposition Leader Mark Speakman said it 'came as no surprise' to commuters. 'This is not just a set of statistics. This is a set of failure by the Minns Labour government,' he said. 'We have the worst on-time performance on the city network since data started to be collected in 2019. 'One in six Sydney trains last year were late, and around one in three regional trains were late. 'This is a government that has failed to handle Sydney Trains. The Premier provides an apology but no plans to fix the trains. There's no timeline to get things fixed.' Mr Speakman called on the government to explain which jobs would be cut and how that would impact the network. When asked what he would 'do differently', Mr Speakman said he had 'a plan to get the trains running on time'. 'We have a program with clear timelines and a clear set of performance criteria to get, pardon the pun, the trains running back on track. 'What we'd be doing is having a clear plan with clear performance criteria, so you could mark whether you're making satisfactory progress.' Opposition transport spokeswoman Natalie Ward floated removing Mr Murray as Transport secretary. The Rail, Tram, and Bus Union led the Combined Rail Unions through months of industrial action. Earlier this month, they voted to approve a deal with the state government. While the details of the pay agreement are not known, the opposition has accused Labor of providing the union with 'perks'.