'You'd love another crack at it' Limerick's Cian Lynch penalties v replay debate
Limerick relinquished their grip on the Mick Mackey Cup that they had held since 2019 as they lost a shootout 3-2 after they and Cork couldn't be separated after extra time.
Albeit two Ulster football finals have been decided in this fashion, the concept of penalties to decide major inter-county games is a relatively new one in the GAA, and it was only after Darragh Fitzgibbon's late, late 65 levelled the game yet again at the end of extra time that Lynch realised that the tie would be decided in his fashion.
It was the first time that it had happened in a top tier Championship game in hurling.
The Limerick captain said: 'I suppose in my own head initially, you think there's going to be an extra five minutes each half. Because that's the way it was before, wasn't it?
'But I suppose when it's said it's penalties, you just accept that and that's obviously the way it is.'
Still, if the prospect of a replay rather than penalties was put to Lynch at the end of the 90-plus minutes, he would have gladly taken it.
'Yeah, of course you would. Sure you love playing the sport. I suppose the pros and cons to either.
'I suppose it's not for me to make a point or make a comment on what's the right thing to do but you'd love to have another crack at it. Any team would.
'But for us, it's just about accepting that that's in the past now. We unfortunately didn't win and Cork did.'
Lynch was gone off the field before the full-time and so he wasn't eligible to take part in the shootout - not that it's something he would have put his hand up for anyway.
'If you were asked to take one, I'm sure 100% you'd do anything you can to help the team, but I wouldn't be someone that's known to stand over a free or a penalty, to be honest with you.
'The five guys, obviously our guys, the five Limerick lads, the same as Cork obviously and Nickie, to step up, that takes some courage. After playing 70 to 90 minutes of hurling, to have it based on standing over a penalty, that is tough. That is some responsibility.
'But great credit to the guys, great credit to Nickie [Quaid] and so on. Just the way it is.'
Limerick now go on to play either Dublin or Kildare in the All-Ireland quarter-final the weekend after next, and Lynch said they won't be looking for an out in the fact that they didn't lose the Munster final in regulation or extra time.
'No, it's still a defeat,' he insisted. 'Obviously, you look at the time played and so on, neither team won and it went to penalties and that's just the way it was.
'You obviously are disappointed. You see an opposition collecting a trophy and celebrating with their fans and stuff. That's tough to take.
'You just have to dust yourself off, regroup, process that feeling and try to drive on again.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
28 minutes ago
- Irish Examiner
Isak, Gyokeres and Ekitike herald a new age of the centre-forward
It's only been a decade since it seemed the centre-forward was being refined out of existence. Spain had won Euro 2012 with Cesc Fabregas as a false nine, and Germany, who largely took Spain as a model, were less than convinced they needed one at the 2014 World Cup. They fielded Thomas Muller as a false-ish nine until the quarter-final, when Jogi Löw finally went back to basics and turned to Miroslav Klose. That he was 36 only seemed to confirm that the old-fashioned No 9 was an old-fashioned phenomenon — a dying breed. Yet this summer, the main interest in the transfer market has been the carousel of strikers. Of course, strikers never entirely disappeared. The four leading scorers in the Premier League in 2014–15 were Sergio Aguero, Harry Kane, Diego Costa, and Charlie Austin. Mauri Icardi and Luca Toni topped the charts in Italy, while Cristiano Ronaldo, his conversion to a No 9 complete, was top scorer in Spain (although that he was followed by Lionel Messi, Antoine Griezmann, and Neymar suggested a greater variety of goalscorer there). The feeling, though, was that the cleverest football — the most advanced football — involved a central forward who was there at least as much for his movement and ability to link play as for his finishing. The phenomenon of goalscoring wide players — such as Messi at Barcelona, Arjen Robben at Bayern, or Eden Hazard at Chelsea, a mantle which has been taken up today by Mohamed Salah, Kylian Mbappe, and Raphinha — meant goals came from a greater array of sources. But while the goalscoring wide forward remains, there has been a return to top-level acceptance for the central striker. Pep Guardiola, the coach who seemed most sceptical of traditional No 9s — never even really seeming entirely convinced by Aguero — perhaps began it when Manchester City signed Erling Haaland. The big Norwegian has caused City to make a significant adjustment to their style. He does not join in play in the way every other Guardiola player does. He does not drop into midfield or pull wide — a creative tension that brought a treble in his first season at the club, but which was perhaps a factor in City's disappointment last season. At the same time, the most common criticism of Arsenal was that they lacked a centre-forward. They needed to play well to win, because they didn't have a player who could pounce on a half chance to steal a victory from a tight game, or at times even convert their good play into goals. Alexander Isak would have seemed a very natural fit for them, but a fee of £120m or more was never within range, and so they have ended up with Viktor Gyokeres. It's a calculated risk given he is 27 and has only really been prolific in the last four seasons — two in the Championship with Coventry and two in Portugal with Sporting — but so long as concerns that he takes too long to get his shot away in crowded situations prove unfounded, he would seem to answer a specific need, even if there are times when Kai Havertz is preferred in that central role. It's Isak, though, who stands at the centre of the great striker shuffle. He is tall and quick, his movement intelligent, and he has proved over the past two seasons a consistent Premier League scorer. It's understandable why Newcastle are so desperate to keep him, but understandable too that he feels undervalued on £120,000 a week/£6.2m a year. He has three years left on his contract, so beyond the fear that he could sulk, there is little reason for Newcastle to let him go. They can insist on a fee of £140m or more — certainly enough to buy a high-class replacement, possibly Benjamin Sesko from RB Leipzig. Which is what makes it odd that Isak made his availability public only after Liverpool had signed Hugo Ekitike, who has a similar profile to Isak but, at 23, is far less developed. Chelsea might also have been interested in Isak had they not already bought two centre-forwards in Joao Pedro and Liam Delap. Perhaps, by selling one or both of Darwin Nunez and Luis Diaz, Liverpool could afford him. To sign a second central forward would be a remarkable step for a club where for several years one of the main roles of the center-forward has been to clear the way for Salah. That perhaps suggests change is coming — Liverpool beginning to prepare for life without Salah, who is, after all, 33. But Isak is not an old-school striker. Alan Shearer was perhaps the last of his line, at least at elite level in England. From Marco van Basten onwards, through Andriy Shevchenko and Thierry Henry, forwards have become much more complete figures, combining elements of the target-man, the channel-runner, and the poacher. Isak and Joao Pedro have the full range of skills; Ekitike and Sesko are developing them. Central forwards, with a wider range of attributes than their predecessors, are suddenly fashionable again as football moves into a new age of the striker. Guardian
Irish Daily Mirror
28 minutes ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Donegal have problems to solve but don't write them off yet
The scoreboard never lies. But sometimes it fails to tell the whole truth and nothing else but. And this was the situation after 56 minutes of Sunday's All-Ireland. On the giant screen above Hill 16, the bare details were outlined in big, bold print: Kerry 0-22, Donegal 0-18. There was no question over who had been the better team. The scoreboard doesn't lie, after all. READ MORE: Passionate Paudie Clifford fires back at Kerry's critics after All-Ireland final win READ MORE: David Clifford hailed as the 'greatest ever' as he wins second All-Ireland Football title But from time to time it does leave out details. And this was one. Across the previous 15 minutes, Donegal had outscored Kerry by eight points to three. Better again, they were just after thieving Shane Ryan's kick-out, the play transferred towards Paddy McBrearty, so often their hero, introduced here as a potential saviour. Except there was a problem. McBrearty is so long in the tooth that his debut came way back in 2011, during Jim McGuinness' first spell. Time, as has been proven repeatedly, always wins against an athlete. It affects the body, erodes pace, stops a footballer reproducing the things their younger self managed to effortlessly do. And that was the dilemma McBrearty was up against. As the ball edged towards the touchline, McBrearty had a choice. Bend low but risk allowing the ball creep over the sideline or kick it along the ground towards a colleague. He took the second option and chose wrong, losing possession and with it all the momentum Donegal had been carefully building over the previous 15 minutes. From the turnover, Sean O'Shea eventually scored a two-pointer. Donegal, meanwhile, scored just once more in the remaining 14 minutes, losing the endgame 1-4 to 0-1. It may not have seemed such a big deal at the time but in hindsight this was a seismic moment. And it led to the inevitable question after such a convincing defeat whether McBrearty and a few other Donegal players had taken too much physical pounding over the years. After all, Michael Murphy is about to turn 36. McBrearty, for his part, is only 31 but has just completed his 15th season as an inter-county player. Between this pair, and Ryan McHugh, there are 219 Championship appearances on their CVs. And it showed, McHugh forced off with an injury, Murphy pushing his body to extraordinary lengths to last the 70 minutes, McBrearty struggling in the 15 minutes he got on the park. What if this is it for all three players? What if they all go together over the winter? Or what if they stay but aren't able to reproduce the magic in 2026? Those are the questions that McGuinness will be thinking about on his long trip home today. From history's scrapbook, he'll know that sometimes a defeat becomes a stepping stone - Offaly in 1981, Cork in 1987/88 and The Rebels again in 2007/09. But unless you are Dublin or Kerry, winners of 70 All-Irelands between them, there are no guarantees or 'rite of passage' as McGuinness alluded to in advance of Sunday's final. For every Offaly story from 1982, there are tales of woe: Roscommon in '80, Galway in '83, and Tyrone in '86, Mayo countless times, Kildare in '98, Cork in '99, Down in 2010. Each county lost a final. On no occasion did it lead to something better which is something that often happens outside the Big Two. Teams emerge. Teams lose big games. Teams then disappear. Will this be the case for Donegal? Perhaps not because the evidence suggests Sunday was a blip rather than the start of a worrying trend. Following Sunday's 10-point defeat, it has been suggested that Donegal have a problem scoring goals. Yet only Kerry and Galway raised more green flags in this year's Championship. Then there is the accusation they don't have a marquee forward. And yet between them, Murphy, Conor O'Donnell and Oisin Langan scored nine points from play yesterday, Murphy finishing the season as the Championship's second highest scorer; O'Donnell and Langan as the summer's third and fourth top scorers from play. What if the younger two push on from here? What if Murphy hangs on? What if their messianic manager stays on? While he didn't have his best day on Sunday - failing to figure out that Paudie Clifford needed to be closed down - McGuinness has previously shown his capacity to recover from setbacks, the 2013 defeat to Mayo being way worse than Sunday's loss to Kerry. The following year they bounced back, defeated Dublin, made it an All-Ireland. This season too is an upgrade on last year - a fourth All-Ireland final coming on the back of a semi-final appearance in 2024. Continuing their upward trajectory will take nerve, not necessarily a change of manager but certainly change within the manager. Alex Ferguson constantly evolved, and frequently replaced his assistants. Bill Belichick was the same, likewise Brian Cody and Joe Schmidt. What McGuinness now needs is a fresh voice rather than a dissenting one, a person who can replicate the role Rory Gallagher provided in 2011 and 2012. Remember only one team in the country were better than them in 2025 and even if that was by a considerable margin, the reality remains that for Donegal to reach the top, evolution rather than revolution will get them there. Don't write them off just yet.
Irish Daily Mirror
28 minutes ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Thousands of fans line the streets as victorious Kerry team get heroes' welcome
Tens of thousands of jubilant fans lined the streets of Tralee and Killarney on Monday evening as the Kerry Senior Football team returned home to a heroes' welcome following their stunning victory over Donegal in the All-Ireland final at Croke Park. The Kingdom's 39th title — their first in several years — sparked celebrations across the county, with green and gold flags waving proudly and chants echoing through the town as the team paraded the Sam Maguire Cup through the streets on an open top bus. The winning team and management travelled from Dublin to Tralee by train. They then travelled on the open top bus via Boherbee with a Garda escort to a Welcome Home reception in Denny Street. Prior to their arrival, Dreams of Freedom and DJ Big Jim entertained the thousands of fans with live music. David Clifford and Paudie Clifford during the homecoming (Image: ©INPHO/Ben Brady) Mayor of Tralee, Councillor Terry O'Brien, told the crowd: 'It's a huge honour for me to welcome you all to the capital town of the county to welcome home the Sam Maguire. We want to extend a huge thanks to Jack O'Connor and his team.' Manager Jack O'Connor, who has led Kerry to his fifth All Ireland title, told Master of Ceremonies Alan Cantwell: 'It's incredible, we were just talking about the size of the crowd. I think this tops it all. Thanks very much. 'This team at the moment is built for Croke Park, particularly with the new rules, with the way the pitch plays, it's a fast pitch and I think it suits us. 'We just wanted to get back to Croke Park. We knew as soon as we got back there we'd be okay. So that's the way it happened. Kerry manager Jack O'Connor during the homecoming (Image: ©INPHO/Ben Brady) 'It was a tough season; we lost a lot of good men along the way - some made it back, others didn't, unfortunately so will have to wait another year. 'We got tremendous support this year. And more than anything we have you, the supporters, because you backed the team like never before in the quarter-final and semi-final and that was huge. And we just had a great momentum going into the final," he said. "It's hugely rewarding to keep your best players for the biggest day. For Gavin to play as well as he did and captain the team in an All-Ireland final, that's the stuff of dreams. When asked if he will return for next year's season, Mr O'Connor replied: 'We will keep that for another day.' Joe O'Connor - who scored a goal in the last minute - said: 'We got a good start and the crowd got behind us and the atmosphere was unbelievable in Croke Park. Kerry fans celebrate as the team returns to Tralee (Image: ©INPHO/Ben Brady) Speaking of his goal, assisted by Killian Spillane, he said: 'I missed plenty of them and had to practice a lot over the last few weeks. I just had a hit and hope and the scenes afterwards were class." 'It's a special feeling. It's the stuff of dreams to bring the Sam Maguire down Denny Street, it's something you dream of as a child. It's a great achievement to be able to represent our county and then obviously manage to bring some silverware back home,' Kerry player Dylan Casey told Radio Kerry's Terrace Talk prior to taking his position on the stage. Their next stop was Killarney, where the victorious team took an open top bus from Fitzgerald Stadium to a reception in the Glebe Car park before travelling to the Gleneagle Hotel, where the celebrations continued with a victory Super Ceili for supporters and a disco. It was a moment of pure joy for Kerry supporters, young and old, as they honoured their champions and the county's proud footballing tradition. Earlier, a group of Kerry senior footballers swapped celebrations for something even more meaningful - a visit to Children's Health Ireland (CHI) at Temple Street in Dublin on Monday morning. Players Diarmuid O'Connor, Paul Murphy, Killian Spillane, Gavin White and Tadhg Morley turned up bright and early, proudly bringing the Sam Maguire Cup with them. A view of a Palestine flag at the homecoming (Image: ©INPHO/Ben Brady) Their appearance was part of a post-final tradition that sees All-Ireland champions visit young patients in hospital. The players posed with the Sam Maguire along with staff and patient Chloe Garrell, 10, from Walkinstown in Dublin. A thrilled Amy Lilly, 4, lifted the Sam Maguire Cup with Kerry player Paul Murphy, while Saoirse McDonagh, 10, from Liscannor, Co Clare was pictured with RTÉ Sports Commentator Marty Morrissey. Cody Sheedy, 14, from Ballinahinch, Co Tipperary, was also pictured with Sam Maguire Cup and player Paul Murphy. And in keeping with a long-standard tradition, the Kerry team visited The Boar's Head pub on Dublin's Capel Street on Monday morning after their All-Ireland win, carrying the Sam Maguire Cup and delighting fans. In a tweet on X on Sunday after the All-Ireland final, Taoiseach Micheal Martin congratulated the winning side. An Taoiseach tweeted: "Wonderful game of Gaelic football at Croke Park under the new rules. Scintillating display by Kerry against a very spirited Donegal team. Congratulations.' Meanwhile, Kerry's win over Donegal in the All Ireland football final drew an average audience of 933,000 viewers to RTÉ One's coverage on The Sunday Game Live, with 79 per cent of the available audience tuning in as Joanne Cantwell presented live coverage of the Kingdom's record-extending 39th All Ireland title. Viewership peaked at 1,033,000 towards the end of the game. The Sunday Game Live (including Sunday Game Beo) had 378,000 streams on RTÉ Player yesterday. Sunday Game Beo on RTÉ News channel and RTÉ Player, presented by Gráinne McElwain, had Irish language commentary of the final, while Sunday Sport on RTÉ Radio 1 brought listeners all the action from the final, as did Raidió na Gaeltachta's Spórt an Lae. On Sunday night, Jacqui Hurley and pundits picked the Football team of the year, while Kerry captain Gavin White was named Man of the Match on The Sunday Game on RTÉ2, which was watched by an average of 175,000 with a share of 22 per cent, while there were 34,400 streams on RTÉ Player. The craic began on Saturday night on RTÉ One as an average audience of 309,000 watched Up For The Match on RTÉ One as Jacqui Hurley and Des Cahill were joined live in studio by GAA legends and fans and Marty Morrissey was joined by Hollywood star Matthew Broderick live in Kilcar, Donegal ahead of the All-Ireland final. Up For The Match had 44,000 streams on RTÉ Player. Fans were heavily engaged with The Sunday Game across RTÉ's social media platforms, with video views reaching 6.73 million with over 705,000 engagements. President Michael D Higgins' last men's All Ireland Final was the top-performing piece of content across all RTÉ social channels and platforms. And in Donegal on Monday evening, there may have been no Sam Maguire but Donegal supporters gathered in their thousands in Donegal Town to acknowledge the championship achievements of the county's senior gaelic football team. The Donegal Homecoming began at 6.30pm at the Pier car park in Donegal Town, where there was live music from Onoir, Darren Boots and others prior to the team's arrival. Sign up to the Irish Mirror's Courts and Crime newsletter here and get breaking crime updates and news from the courts direct to your inbox. The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week
