logo
Reform cannot wait, aviation safety is at stake

Reform cannot wait, aviation safety is at stake

The Hindu5 days ago
The Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau's preliminary report on the Air India Boeing 787 air crash in Ahmedabad, on June 12, 2025, was released last week, on July 12. The report remains inconclusive, with critical uncertainties on whether pilot action was inadvertent or deliberate. I would argue that the lack of faith among pilots and those who track aviation like myself about the robustness of the investigation and its findings — whether correct or not — emanate from a deep lack of trust in the entire aviation system in India that often penalises its personnel, excessively, rather than holding airlines and regulators to equal scrutiny.
I would like to use this opportunity to, once again, call for a complete reform in the aviation sector. A genuine 'culture of safety' must permeate every layer of the aviation system. This includes fair employment terms and, crucially, access to mental health care without punitive consequences resulting in the automatic grounding of and loss of income for air crew at a time when the current system, ironically, jeopardises their psychological well-being.
Also read | The preliminary report on the AI 171 crash is notably brief and lacking in technical transparency, says aviation expert
The complex web of aviation safety is highly technical, but years of study with aviation professionals have helped me understand its intricate technicalities. The aviation system broadly involves multiple elements: the aircraft itself (design, airworthiness, and maintenance) and the people who operate it (maintenance engineers, technicians, pilots and cabin crew). These are, broadly, the responsibility of the airline operator, while airport infrastructure, air traffic control systems and its personnel are the responsibility of the Airports Authority of India (AAI) and/or the aerodrome operator. The Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) has regulatory control over airlines, the AAI and the airport operators. The Ministry of Civil Aviation (MoCA) has supervisory control over the DGCA and the AAI. Aviation accidents never result from a single failure but stem from multiple failures that align together, as in the Swiss cheese model. Each safety layer has flaws (holes); when these holes align across layers, an accident occurs.
The fight for safety through courts
I have filed over 15 Public Interest Litigations (PIL) in the various High Courts and the Supreme Court of India after studying the links between aviation technicalities, regulations and data. I approached the judiciary because aviation authorities in charge of safety, became the violators. No one is held accountable for air crashes or the lives lost, in turn emboldening violations despite knowing that existing/known safety breaches can cause deaths.
Court interventions have saved lives, as seen in the case of the crash in 2018 at Ghatkopar, Mumbai, when a small plane fell into a building site. In 2016, the Bombay High Court had issued a stay that halted construction near Mumbai airport. Had it not been issued, a 13-storey building would have stood in its place at the site..
Mumbai's airspace is among the most hazardous globally — there are over 5,000 vertical obstructions within a four-kilometre radius and in violation of the Inner Horizontal Surface (IHS) criteria. Despite a pending PIL, obstacles in the no-obstacle approach and take-off funnel rose from 125 in 2010 to over 1,000 in 2025, highlighting regulatory opacity and potential misrepresentation by the DGCA, the AAI, airport operators, and the MoCA before the Bombay High Court. Had the High Court been informed about this accurately, the spread of these obstacles could have been stopped.
Regulatory loopholes that pose a threat
Until 2008, airspace around airports was strictly regulated. The Aircraft Act and Statutory Order 988 of 1988 enabled the strict control of construction of buildings around airports. In 2008, a non-statutory committee was formed, effectively bypassing the legal safeguards that once ensured obstacle-free zones. It approved 25 buildings in prime locations in Mumbai using an aeronautical study conducted by the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO), which ought not to have been a part of a move to recommend construction which was illegal and of extra height. By the time ICAO distanced itself from the misuse of aeronautical studies, the AAI had begun conducting its own assessments which were less stringent.
The appellate committee granted permission for extra height recklessly. Around the year 2015, these obstacles, in addition to being physical barriers to safe flight movements, began interfering with radar and communication signals. The appellate committee also came out with guidelines and capped the maximum height at 90 metres in the Inner Horizontal Surface (IHS) and recorded that 'any further deterioration in obstacle profile in and around airport is likely to aggravate the situation'. Despite this, the appellate committee allowed obstacles to come up with impunity jeopardising safe flight operations. Ironically, the appellate committee that had permitted the safety violations was given statutory recognition through the 2015 Rules — despite these rules not allowing height relaxation.
The panel comprised officials entrusted with aviation safety and included a Joint Secretary in the Ministry of Civil Aviation, a Joint Director General in the DGCA, and a Member (Air Navigation Services) in the AAI. Thus, any complaint about obstacles is essentially judged by the very entities that sanctioned them.
Under pressure after a PIL on obstacles, the MoCA amended the 2015 Rules to limit the no objection certificate (NOC) validity to 12 years — an admission of the issue but an evasion of responsibility. How does the MoCA justify approving 100-floor buildings when it knows that 45 floors would become illegal in 12 years? This raises critical questions. What are the mechanisms that exist to demolish floors that become illegal after the expiry of the NOC?
What began in Mumbai has now spread across India. Even greenfield airport projects such as Navi Mumbai (Maharashtra) and Noida (Uttar Pradesh) have obstacles sprouting around them. Navi Mumbai Airport will start operations with a 'displaced threshold' — which means aircraft will be unable to use the full runway because of the obstacles and increasing risks to air safety, thereby turning the airport into a monument of corruption and indifference by aviation authorities.
There is widespread systemic breakdown. First, aircraft design and airworthiness. The DGCA's limited internal technical capability forces it to be over reliant on foreign regulators such as the Federal Aviation Administration (U.S.) and the European Union Aviation Safety Agency (EASA), as seen during the engine failure issue (Pratt & Whitney) that IndiGo experienced in 2017-18.
Second, aircraft maintenance standards. Aircraft Maintenance Engineers (AMEs) work under severe stress without duty time limits. The DGCA has allowed airlines to delegate AME tasks to less-qualified, lower-paid 'technicians' — a cost-cutting move that undermines safety. Duty-time limitations recommended for AMEs by the court of inquiry following the crash in Mangaluru (May 2010) remain unimplemented.
Third, the flight crew. Airlines violate Flight Time Duty Limitations for pilots, and the DGCA grants exemptions which allow pilots who are fatigued to operate. The DGCA's unique NOC requirement restricts pilot mobility across airlines, increasing stress and enabling airlines to coerce pilots into breaching regulations. Cabin crew, whose primary role is passenger safety, are often dismissed as mere hospitality workers, which is a dangerously reductive view.
Fourth, airline operations. Airlines prioritise the goal of profit, adopting policies that consistently undermine safety. Despite the DGCA suspending personnel for safety violations, airline officials often retain high positions, controlling operations. DGCA-appointed officers in airlines, who are expected to enforce compliance, often have no real authority, making accountability toothless.
Fifth, air traffic management. The AAI faces a severe shortage of Air Traffic Controller Officers (ATCO) — an issue that has been flagged even by parliamentary committees. The provision to give licences to ATCO has not yet been implemented. Duty-time limitations for ATCOs — recommended by the Mangalore Court of Inquiry — remain unimplemented.
Sixth, silencing whistle-blowers. Whistle-blowers are often demoted, transferred, or terminated — a trend that has discouraged the reporting of critical safety issues in the AAI and airlines.
When aerodromes operate in violation of safety standards, any other shortcomings in any of the other components become potentially fatal – as seen in Ghatkopar (2018), Kozhikode (2020), and now Ahmedabad (2025). Non-compliance in aviation stems from a lack of safety culture, not ignorance. Crashes are not mere 'accidents' — they are the inevitable result of years of systemic neglect and policy violations. Without immediate systemic improvements, the next disaster will not wait for five years, but is just around the corner.
The role of the judiciary is important
The judiciary, which has always been the silver lining in India's constitutional set-up, has been inactive on aviation issues, relying on the state's technical expertise on the subject. It must address the deterioration in the aviation sector and hold authorities accountable. Additionally, the judiciary's conservative approach to valuing human life needs to change.
In India, human life is undervalued, for example, as seen in railway accidents and motor vehicle deaths — a few lakhs of rupees. When this is the worth of a human life, safety upgrades that cost crores of rupees become easier for stakeholders to ignore. Immediate and comprehensive reform is needed. The aviation system requires accountability, oversight and a safety-over-profit commitment.
Reform cannot wait. Lives are at stake.
Yeshwanth Shenoy is the President, Kerala High Court Advocates Association, and has been fighting for aviation safety for over a decade
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Shell companies, Hawala network: How UP man used overseas links to run fake embassy
Shell companies, Hawala network: How UP man used overseas links to run fake embassy

First Post

time9 hours ago

  • First Post

Shell companies, Hawala network: How UP man used overseas links to run fake embassy

During the investigation, the UP Special Task Force (STF) discovered that the so-called 'Baron of Westarctica', Harshavardhan Jain, had established multiple shell companies overseas and opened foreign bank accounts to create the illusion of international legitimacy. He also had close connections with arms dealer Adnan Khashoggi, and Ahsan Ali Sayed, an Indian-origin Turkish businessman with a history of fraud read more Harshvardhan Jain's entire operation, officials say, ran on a 'modus operandi of fraud, hawala and brokerage' disguised as diplomatic dealings. Image courtesy: X Harshvardhan Jain, 47, who called himself the 'Baron of Westarctica', was arrested earlier this week after the Uttar Pradesh Special Task Force (STF) uncovered a fake embassy operating out of his two-storey house in Ghaziabad's Kavi Nagar. For years, Jain managed to pass off as a high-ranking diplomat, driving around in luxury cars with fake diplomatic plates, flashing forged passports from made-up nations, and posing in doctored photos with top leaders. But according to officials, it was all a cover for a much bigger financial racket. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD The STF believes Jain built a shady network that reached far beyond Ghaziabad. He had set up multiple shell companies overseas, opened foreign bank accounts in his own name, and created an illusion of international legitimacy. His entire operation, officials say, ran on a 'modus operandi of fraud, hawala and brokerage' disguised as diplomatic dealings. As investigators dig deeper, more details are emerging about the elaborate scam Jain pulled off for nearly a decade. Here's what the STF has found so far. Jain's murky global connections Harshvardhan Jain had connections that spanned abroad. According to the Uttar Pradesh STF, Jain frequently travelled to the UK and Dubai, where he built relationships with several controversial figures. During his time in London, Jain told investigators he had worked closely with controversial godman Chandraswami and arms dealer Adnan Khashoggi, both known for their murky pasts. During his time in London, Jain told investigators he had worked closely with controversial godman Chandraswami. File image/ PTI SP (Noida STF) Raj Kumar Mishra told The Times of India that Jain also became close to Ahsan Ali Sayed, an Indian-origin Turkish businessman with a history of fraud. Sayed's company, the Western Advisory Group, operated out of Switzerland and Bahrain, offering loan services to Swiss firms. Between 2008 and 2011, it collected over 25 million pounds in brokerage fees, money Sayed later absconded with. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD He was arrested in November 2022 by the London Police on Switzerland's request and extradited in July 2023. A court in Zurich sentenced him to six-and-a-half years in prison for fraud and fleeing after taking money from 16 companies under the pretext of securing loans. Multiple shell companies, shady bank accounts As per the STF, Jain and Sayed registered multiple shell companies abroad, reportedly used to facilitate Hawala transactions and large-scale financial fraud. 'Together, Jain and Syed had registered several companies abroad, including State Trading Corporation Ltd and East India Company UK Ltd in the UK, Island General Trading Co LLC in the UAE, Indira Overseas Ltd in Mauritius and Cameron Ispat Sarl in Cameroon, Africa,' an officer told The Times of India. Jain is also said to have operated 11 bank accounts in four countries—six in Dubai, three in the UK, and one each in Mauritius and India. Two PAN cards recovered from his Ghaziabad residence are currently being examined, along with the accounts linked to them. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Adding to the suspicion, STF officials revealed that three of the four cars with diplomatic plates found at Jain's home were more than 15 years old and likely used in hawala transactions. A blue corner notice is expected to be issued soon as authorities work to trace the full extent of Jain's financial dealings abroad, TOI reported. How Jain ran a fake embassy as 'Baron of Westarctica' From the outside, it looked like a diplomatic mission. But inside the grand bungalow in Ghaziabad's Kavi Nagar, Harshvardhan Jain had built a facade, complete with flags, forged seals, and fake titles. According to the Uttar Pradesh Special Task Force (STF), Jain posed as the ambassador of multiple self-declared micronations, including Westarctica, Seborga, Poulvia, and Ladonia. These so-called nations exist largely online, with no international recognition, but Jain used their names to build an air of legitimacy around his operations. To appear credible, he even edited photos of himself with top leaders. Image: News18 The 47-year-old, who holds an MBA from London, had earlier lived in Dubai, where he allegedly began duping businessmen by offering fake overseas job placements. After returning to India in 2011, he shifted operations to a lavish rented bungalow and scaled up the con. The Special Task Force had been observing Jain for weeks after a tip-off. When officers raided the Ghaziabad property on July 22, they found: STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD 4 luxury cars, including a Range Rover, Toyota Fortuner, and a Skoda, all with fake diplomatic plates. 18 spare number plates, many marked with 'DC' or 'CD,' symbols usually reserved for official diplomats. 12 forged diplomatic passports from Westarctica and other imaginary countries. Rs 44.70 lakh in cash, along with several foreign currencies. 34 fake seals, two press cards, two PAN cards, and a collection of forged documents, including letters from the Ministry of External Affairs, invitations, and nameplates. Police say he used this persona to win trust and extract money from individuals and companies, promising international deals, jobs abroad, and high-level connections. Jain has been charged with forgery, impersonation, cheating, and criminal conspiracy under several sections of the IPC. The STF is now seeking his custody to dig deeper into the scope of the racket. With input from agencies

Ghaziabad: Fake envoy under lens for global fraud links, STF to seek blue corner notice
Ghaziabad: Fake envoy under lens for global fraud links, STF to seek blue corner notice

Hindustan Times

time12 hours ago

  • Hindustan Times

Ghaziabad: Fake envoy under lens for global fraud links, STF to seek blue corner notice

The Uttar Pradesh Special Task Force (STF) is preparing to seek a Blue Corner notice against Harsha Vardhan Jain — the Ghaziabad man recently arrested for allegedly posing as an envoy of micronations, including a fictitious one — as investigators look to uncover his overseas links and track his movements across nearly 30 countries. According to investigators, Jain came in contact with controversial godman Chandraswami in London around the year 2000, who later introduced him to Saudi arms dealer Adnan Khashoggi and Syed Ehsan Ali. (HT Photos) The move comes days after Jain, 47, a resident of Kavi Nagar, was arrested for allegedly running a fake consulate from his rented home while claiming diplomatic status from unrecognised micronations such as Westarctica, Seborga, Lodonia, and the virtual state of Paulovia (fictional). STF officials said they have uncovered potential ties between Jain and a broader international network, including a key associate — Turkish national Syed Ehsan Ali, formerly from Hyderabad — who was convicted last year in Switzerland for financial fraud involving multiple offshore firms. 'Jain is believed to have travelled extensively — nearly 150 to 200 international trips — and co-founded a dozen companies overseas with Syed, including in the UK, UAE, Mauritius and Cameroon. A Blue Corner notice will help us collect information from foreign jurisdictions about his activities,' said RK Mishra, additional superintendent of police, UPSTF. A Blue Corner notice, issued by Interpol, is used to gather additional information about a person's identity, location, or activities during the course of a criminal investigation. According to investigators, Jain came in contact with controversial godman Chandraswami in London around the year 2000, who later introduced him to Saudi arms dealer Adnan Khashoggi and Syed Ehsan Ali. Ali, who later acquired Turkish nationality, reportedly operated companies in Bahrain and Switzerland and earned £25 million in brokerage fees by falsely claiming to arrange loans worth £70 million for Swiss firms. He was arrested by London police in November 2022 on Switzerland's request and extradited in July 2023. 'He allegedly secured £25 million in brokerage fees by promising loans worth £70 million to Swiss companies, before fleeing. On 22 November 2022, London police arrested him following a request from the Swiss government. In July 2023, the Westminster court approved his extradition to Switzerland in the fraud case,' the STF said in a statement on Thursday. A Zurich court later sentenced him to six-and-a-half years in prison for fraud linked to 16 companies. 'Jain's financial trail includes several overseas bank accounts — six in Dubai, three in the UK, one in Mauritius — and one in India. We've also recovered two PAN cards issued in his name, and will seek police custody remand for deeper interrogation,' Mishra added. Jain is currently in judicial custody. A case has been registered against him at Kavi Nagar police station under Sections 318(4) (cheating), 336(3) (forgery), 338 (forgery of valuable security), and 340(2) (forged documents or electronic records) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS). During the search of his Kavi Nagar residence, police recovered a diary believed to contain crucial information about his international contacts and methods. 'He admitted during questioning to having links with Chandraswami, Khashoggi, and Ali,' said an officer associated with the investigation. The STF has also seized digital evidence, including soft data files, which are being analysed for further leads. According to investigators, Jain has been operating from Kavi Nagar since around 2016-17, and rented a second house nearby six to seven months ago. 'He acted as an 'asset' for Chandraswami, using the godman's network to expand his own international reach. A satellite phone recovered from him in 2012 was later found to be connected to European and South African networks,' the officer added. STF officials said more of Jain's alleged associates are under the scanner and further revelations are likely once police custody remand is obtained.

Not just fake embassy, 'Ladonia envoy' formed an East India Company as well
Not just fake embassy, 'Ladonia envoy' formed an East India Company as well

India Today

time14 hours ago

  • India Today

Not just fake embassy, 'Ladonia envoy' formed an East India Company as well

The Uttar Pradesh Special Task Force (STF) has uncovered new details in its investigation into Harshvardhan Jain, the alleged mastermind behind a fake embassy operation run in to the STF, Harshvardhan Jain had established several fake companies abroad, such as East India Company UK limited, including in the UK, Mauritius, Dubai, and African companies registered under his name include: State Trading Corporation, Island General Trading Co Llc (Dubai), Indira Overseas Ltd (Mauritius), and Cameron Ispat Sarl (Africa). These companies were allegedly used for money laundering and fraudulent During interrogation, Jain reportedly told STF officials that he acted on the instructions of Ehsaan Ali Syed, a close aide of controversial godman Chandraswami. Ehsaan, originally from Hyderabad and currently holding Turkish citizenship, had helped Jain set up multiple shell companies while living in London. These firms were reportedly used to facilitate Hawala transactions and large-scale financial STF found that between 2008 and 2011, Ehsaan and his team secured fake loans worth approximately 70 million pounds and collected around 25 million pounds as commission before fleeing. In 2022, on a request from the Swiss government, Ehsaan was arrested by London police. In 2023, a London court approved his extradition to Switzerland. STF is currently probing Harshvardhan Jain's role in Ehsaan's on documents recovered from Jain, authorities have discovered multiple bank accounts in his name, both in India and abroad. These accounts are now under scrutiny as part of the ongoing FIR has been registered against Harshvardhan Jain at Kavi Nagar police station under several sections including Section 318(4), 336(3), 338, and 340 of the IPC. The STF is now working to obtain Jain's custody for further Pradesh's Special Task Force (STF) on Thursday busted a fake embassy operation running out of a lavish bungalow in Ghaziabad's posh Kavi Nagar area. The alleged mastermind, 47-year-old Harshvardhan Jain, presented himself as the ambassador of not one, but several self-proclaimed micronations - Westarctica, Seborga, Poulvia, and ruse, which included diplomatic number-plated luxury cars, forged documents, and fake foreign connections, was used to defraud companies and individuals by offering jobs, overseas deals, and influence in return for hefty commissions.- EndsMust Watch IN THIS STORY#Ghaziabad

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store