logo
Influencer drops lawsuit alleging rival creator copied her videos

Influencer drops lawsuit alleging rival creator copied her videos

Yahoo30-05-2025
Influencer Sydney Nicole Gifford said in a TikTok video on Thursday that she has withdrawn her lawsuit against fellow content creator Alyssa Sheil, ending a case that had become closely watched over its possible ramifications for the broader internet content ecosystem.
The move comes more than a year after Gifford first sued Sheil, claiming that Sheil had not just stolen the look and style of her videos but sometimes copied them down to the shot.
'She would change her hair soon after I changed mine and even got a similar tattoo after I posted mine, so in mirror photos where our faces were covered, it all of a sudden looked even more similar to me with that tattoo,' Gifford said in her TikTok video. 'I believe her intention was to look so similar to me and copy my posts so similarly so she could profit off my business.'
She also clarified her intention was not to sue simply over aesthetics, but rather over alleged 'copyright infringement, Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) violation, trade dress infringement, misappropriation, and vicarious copyright infringement.'
Arguments between influencers copying or stealing content from each other typically play out in the digital court of public opinion and rarely, if ever, make it to the actual judicial system. Aesthetics on social media are recycled and reinterpreted so often that it's nearly impossible to lay claim to owning a look or style online.
Gifford's lawsuit sought to take the issue into the courtroom, attempting to apply laws typically used by traditional media to the relatively lax world of influencer content.
The look at the heart of the now-dismissed suit is a minimalist, polished style that is sometimes referred to as the 'clean girl' aesthetic. Gifford, whose videos touch on everything from being a mother to fashion and shopping, has amassed more than 956,000 followers between her Instagram and TikTok accounts.
Sheil, who posts similar content, has more than 162,000 followers across her Instagram and TikTok.
Gifford said she sent many requests for Sheil to stop — from emails to cease-and-desist letters — before suing Sheil in April 2024.
Shahmeer Halepota, an attorney for Sheil, said Gifford walked away from the case with no settlement or financial compensation.
'Ms. Gifford's surrender and settlement for $0 confirms that her allegations were meritless and her claims of inventorship were worthless,' Halepota said.
Thomas Frashier, another attorney for Sheil, said his client has set a 'major precedent' for influencers and social media personalities.
'This is a huge win for content creators everywhere who shouldn't have to fear about being bullied out of the industry by the threat of meritless lawsuits like this one,' he said.
However, Gifford's attorney Kirsten Kumar said her client's case was not without merit, but that she simply didn't have the bandwidth to continue with the litigation.
'I have been working with Sydney since nearly the beginning of this case,' Kumar said. 'I know how strongly she feels about her claims and that the decision to stop litigating is not a reflection of their merit. But priorities can change: Since filing suit, she has gotten married, welcomed her first child and moved out of state.'
This article was originally published on NBCNews.com
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Kelly Osbourne Publicly Reacts to Father Ozzy's Death in Instagram Message
Kelly Osbourne Publicly Reacts to Father Ozzy's Death in Instagram Message

Newsweek

time22 minutes ago

  • Newsweek

Kelly Osbourne Publicly Reacts to Father Ozzy's Death in Instagram Message

Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. 🎙️ Voice is AI-generated. Inconsistencies may occur. Kelly Osbourne made her first public comments on Thursday, two days after the death of her father, rock legend Ozzy Osbourne. "I feel unhappy I am so sad," Kelly Osbourne wrote in an Instagram story. "I lost the best friend I ever had." This is a breaking news story. Updates to follow.

Spinal Tap goes viral, Kate Bush-style, in upcoming sequel
Spinal Tap goes viral, Kate Bush-style, in upcoming sequel

Yahoo

time24 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Spinal Tap goes viral, Kate Bush-style, in upcoming sequel

Ask anyone on the street about the upcoming sequel to Spinal Tap, and they'd probably look at you quite strangely. Believe us, we know. For months, we've been conducting surveys with street people regarding the cultural awareness of Spinal Tap II: The End Continues, and most respond with a casual, 'Oh, didn't hear about that one.' Part of that is because much of the excitement surrounding Spinal Tap these days is focused on the re-release of the original This Is Spinal Tap in honor of the film's 41st anniversary. The other half is that there hasn't been that much promotion regarding the film, its plot, or its release since its announcement. But The End will continue this fall, when Spinal Tap II hits theaters, hopefully to reviews that warrant a little more than two words. Ahead of the re-release and the new film, director and co-star Rob Reiner, who plays Marty DiBergi, the diegetic director of the movie within the movie, shared the set-up for the sequel with Collider and explained why this is all Kate Bush's fault. Reiner says that the film opens 15 years after Nigel Tufnel (Christopher Guest), David St. Hubbins (Michael McKean), and Derek Smalls (Harry Shearer) last played together. Not only had they not played together, but 'they were not talking to each other. It was bad blood.' Over the course of the film, we find out what caused the bad blood, but more interestingly, why they decided to get the band back together. Following the death of their manager, Ian Faith (played by the late Tony Hendra in This Is Spinal Tap), Faith's daughter is bequeathed the group's contract, which stipulates one more performance. Reiner continues: [Hope] thinks, 'Well, this is worthless because they haven't played in 15 years. Who knows about these guys?' Then we thought of Kate Bush, who had a song of hers on that show, Stranger Things. All of a sudden, there was a resurgence of this song and her and everything. We said, 'That's it.' We get a famous rocker or somebody to be screwing around in a soundcheck, sings a song of Tap's, somebody catches it on an iPhone, sticks it up on TikTok, it goes viral, and all of a sudden this last concert becomes valuable. That became the premise of the film. That's as much as I can tell you, but that's how we came up with the idea. We can't wait to see what streaming series caused 'Sex Farm' to break like the wind on TikTok, but as far as premises for a legacy sequel to a landmark mockumentary goes, that's not the worst in the world. Spinal Tap II: The End Continues is gonna rock you in theaters on September 12. Correction: An earlier version of this article misstated that Ian Faith played Tony Hendra. This was incorrect. The late Tony Hendra played the character Ian Faith in This Is Spinal Tap. This has been corrected throughout. We regret the error. More from A.V. Club Superman gets a big, blue reboot that supercharges a beleaguered genre Spoiler Space: Jurassic World Rebirth once again makes dinosaurs everyone's problem Federal court of appeals unsubscribes Americans from "Click to Cancel" Solve the daily Crossword

Former Food Network Star Recalled Anne Burrell ‘Going Through Some Stuff' as Her Death Is Ruled a Suicide
Former Food Network Star Recalled Anne Burrell ‘Going Through Some Stuff' as Her Death Is Ruled a Suicide

Yahoo

time42 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Former Food Network Star Recalled Anne Burrell ‘Going Through Some Stuff' as Her Death Is Ruled a Suicide

A little over a month after her unexpected passing, Anne Burrell's death has been ruled a suicide. The New York City medical examiner's office has determined that the 55-year-old Food Network star's cause of death was from 'acute intoxication due to the combined effects of diphenhydramine, ethanol, cetirizine, and amphetamine,' according to People. As Star reported last month, Burrell was 'found next to dozens of pills,' per the New York Post and her husband, Stuart Claxton, found her 'unresponsive' in the shower of their Brooklyn, New York home. Additionally, a rep for the New York City Fire Department told Page Six that the person who called 911 said Burrell went into 'cardiac arrest' and was 'DOA [dead on arrival].' Days after her passing, fellow Food Network star Duff Goldman hinted that the former Worst Cooks in America host had been privately struggling years prior. 'Anne and I became friends in probably 2006,' Goldman wrote in a June 19 Instagram post. 'She was going through some stuff and I had heard that she was feeling it, so on a trip to NYC from Baltimore I had made her a cake that said 'Don't let the bastards win.' She never did.' 'We had a complex relationship, and I remember the last conversation we had before our paths drifted was a pretty feisty debate about the merits of catfish,' he recalled. 'I believe the words 'trash fish,' 'tastes like mud,' and 'cake boy' were used.' 'Anne and I always had a spirited and somewhat acerbic back and forth,' Goldman continued. 'I really never knew why our paths drifted but I always hoped that wherever she was, Anne was doing well and was finding some happiness.' Goldman explained that about two years ago, he attended an event in New York City where he ran into the former Secrets of a Restaurant Chef host. 'Now, at this point we hadn't spoken in years, and I won't go into what we talked about but I will say that that conversation left my heart lifted and full of light, for it truly seemed to me that Anne really had found a measure of happiness and love,' Goldman penned. 'Life is tough, and we have to be tough to get through it.' 'Anne was as tough as they come,' he added, 'but when you got past the armor there was a depth of compassion and kindness that was absolutely beautiful. My heart sings when I think of the love and tranquility that it seems Anne had found recently.' Burrell is survived by her husband and his son, Javier, her mother, Marlene, and sister, Jane.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store