Kelly Dever denies seeing key figures near Karen Read's vehicle in 'disaster' testimony: expert
Kelly Dever, who was on duty that morning but did not play any role in the investigation, previously told the FBI that she saw two key figures in the case standing near Read's SUV in the sallyport at Canton's police headquarters for "a wildly long time." They were ATF Agent Brian Higgins — who was carrying on a flirtatious relationship with Read behind O'Keefe's back — and then-Canton Police Chief Kenneth Berkowitz.
They would have been placed next to the vehicle before other investigators found fragments that matched Read's taillight at the crime scene.
Lead Detective's Text Messages Cast Shadow Over Karen Read Murder Trial
Dever testified that she retracted that statement immediately because the FBI agents showed her a timeline that indicated she left work well before Read's Lexus arrived. Then she accused Read's defense team of trying to coerce her into lying about it on the stand.
"You threatened to charge me with perjury during our phone call prior to the first trial if I didn't lie on the stand right now," she told defense attorney Alan Jackson, from the witness stand. "I'm telling you, I did not see anything. Factually, I've been provided evidence by a timeline that it is not correct."
Read On The Fox News App
Karen Read Sells Home And Taps Retirement Fund To Pay Mounting Legal Bills In Murder Retrial
WATCH: Karen Read challenges officer's testimony in tense murder trial
Read denied that her team pressured Dever in remarks to reporters outside the courthouse Monday afternoon.
"We subpoenaed her to testify to what she told other authorities and just wanted her to be as honest with us as she was with them," she said. "And today she's now telling us that was a lie."
She later claimed that Dever seems like "a compromised person."
Dever was visibly frustrated at times, huffing on the stand and at one point snapping at Jackson for mispronouncing her name.
Mother Of Slain Boston Police Officer Wends Wordless Message To Karen Read In Courtroom Showdown
"Like you can't remember my name, I don't remember," she said.
The defense is trying to show jurors that there is reasonable doubt in the investigation's findings — noting that the lead detective was fired for sending inappropriate texts and that Canton police made a series of sloppy missteps early in the investigation, before state police arrived.
Their position is that her SUV never struck O'Keefe, and something or someone else caused his fatal injuries. In her first trial, they also alleged that police framed Read.
Follow The Fox True Crime Team On X
GET REAL-TIME UPDATES DIRECTLY ON THE True Crime Hub
"[Dever] illustrated perfectly the defense theory — that sketchy cops are lying to help the prosecution," said Mark Bederow, a New York City-based criminal defense lawyer who is following the case.
He called her testimony "a disaster" and questioned whether she had been pressured by colleagues in law enforcement into recanting her story, rather than the defense.
"It was a risky move to call her, but her demeanor was so awful that combined with what she admitted telling the feds, it likely helped the defense," Bederow told Fox News Digital.
Karen Read Judge Blocks Sandra Birchmore Mentions; Expert Says Cases Should Be Wake-up Call For Police
Retired Massachusetts Superior Court Judge and Boston College professor Jack Lu called Dever "a profile in courage" and that putting her on the stand suggests desperation from the defense.
"She's out of central casting, says that she has confirmed her prior memory is factually, irrefutably wrong," he told Fox News Digital. "If they say she has damaged her future ability to testify that is laughable."
She's also facing blowback. Lu pointed to a Facebook group called Free Karen Read with more than 40,000 members, where a user urged others to call the police commissioner's office if they "believe Kelly Dever should be given the axe."
Dever could not immediately be reached for comment.
It's up to the jurors to decide whether she was truthful on the stand or when she first made her statements to the FBI.Original article source: Kelly Dever denies seeing key figures near Karen Read's vehicle in 'disaster' testimony: expert
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
7 minutes ago
- CBS News
Bronx family grieving after off-duty FDNY firefighter killed in hit-and-run
A Bronx family is grieving and the New York City Fire Department is in mourning after the tragic death of a hero firefighter. Matthew Goicochea, 31, was killed early Thursday in a hit-and-run on the FDR Drive while he was off-duty. Police said he failed to navigate the roadway, fell off his motorcycle, and was struck and killed by a driver, who did not stay on the scene. No arrests have been made, and the investigation is ongoing. "There are not words that I can explain the pain that I'm going through right now," mother Brigida Goicochea said. "I can be a little serious, so whenever he was around, he would always make sure that I wasn't taking everything so seriously, but he also made me braver," sister Stephanie Goicochea said. Matthew Goicochea attended Cardinal Spellman High School in the Bronx, and loved playing soccer, his family said. "I think we're all going to carry on constantly with him as our light source," sister Samantha Goicochea said. "Always with a happy, smiling face. Always, always willing to help," father Robert Goicochea said. "Don't wait for the next person to be careful, you be careful. You think about that person that's on the road, and they're trying to get to their mom or their dad," Brigida Goicochea said. Goicochea had been with FDNY since 2022. "From when he was very young, he wanted to be in the FDNY," Robert Goicochea said. "He would get excited about going into fires so that so that he could help people," Brigida Goicochea said. In 2024, he received a medal for rescuing an unconscious fire victim. The president of the firefighters' union, Andrew Ansbro, released a statement calling Matthew Goicochea "an exceptional firefighter and a trusted member of his company." "He will be deeply missed by his FDNY family and all who knew him, especially the members of Ladder 41, Engine 90 of the Bronx and the Ten House. All New Yorkers share in this loss—we have lost a true hero in the prime of his life," the statement said, in part. "New York City ... has lost a loyal son. A loyal son," Robert Goicochea said. "When we went to the fire houses, you could tell that people were touched by him and touched by the loss," Stephanie Goicochea said.
CNN
32 minutes ago
- CNN
Cash, gloves and screenshots: Top investigators detail Bryan Kohberger's unusual behavior after Idaho student murders
In the days after murdering four University of Idaho students in an off-campus home, Bryan Kohberger's behavior shifted dramatically and investigators would later find that he had fixated on news coverage of the killings and began paying for items in cash – often wearing gloves – as he avoided the area of the murders. The details emerged Friday in CNN's wide-ranging, sit-down interview with Idaho State Police Lt. Darren Gilbertson and Moscow Police Chief Anthony Dahlinger. The key investigators shared new insight into Kohberger's unusual behavior and the violent struggles that took place inside the home in November 2022. 'Everything lined up' for investigators once they started looking into Kohberger as a suspect, Gilbertson told CNN. By the time the FBI linked Kohberger to DNA found on a knife sheath left at the scene, the investigation had dragged on for several weeks, with thousands of tips pouring in, he said. Kohberger's name seemed to click everything into place, he added. The former criminology graduate student, who was sentenced to life in prison on Wednesday as part of a controversial plea deal, showed 'very strong changes in behavior' after the killings, Gilbertson said. Though Kohberger returned to the area a few hours after the murders, investigators said they believe he never set foot in Moscow again after that, he said. Here are some of the key revelations from investigators: Though it would take investigators nearly two months to identify and arrest Kohberger at his parents' Pennsylvania home, the killer had spent those weeks taking strange precautions. 'He stops using his debit card, his credit cards. He starts only using cash,' Gilbertson said. '(In) video and surveillance that we would collect and pick up after that, he's often wearing gloves.' Before law enforcement seized his electronic devices, Kohberger had been wiping data from them. Even so, he had kept several screenshots and pictures of news coverage of the killings, according to Gilbertson. However, investigators found no evidence on the devices that Kohberger had known the victims, Gilbertson said, debunking reports that the killer had photos and the social media accounts of some of the victims on his phone. 'To this date, we have never found a single connection – anything – between any of the four victims or the other two surviving roommates with him. No pictures, no texts,' Gilbertson said. Kohberger pleaded guilty earlier this month to the murders of Kaylee Goncalves, Ethan Chapin, Xana Kernodle and Madison Mogen after spending years insisting he was innocent. The deal with prosecutors, which has received polarized reactions from the victims' families, allowed him to skirt a trial and took the death penalty off the table. Though the sentence has allowed police to release a trove of investigative documents that provide desperately-sought insight into the crime, Gilbertson and Dahlinger agreed there is one question that may never be answered: Why did he do it? What is clear to investigators, according to Gilbertson, is that Kohberger was 'very consumed' with criminology and the psychology around murder. Though investigators are confident a knife was used to kill all four victims, Goncalves was struck in the face by an unknown object and the extent of her struggle with Kohberger is still unknown, Gilbertson said. 'It certainly appears something else struck her to cause the marks that we saw that is not consistent with a fist,' Gilbertson said. There is also no evidence she was bound or gagged, he added. A recently released preliminary autopsy report found each of the victims had suffered 'sharp force injuries' – though Goncalves also had 'asphyxial injures' and 'blunt force injuries.' She had been stabbed more than 20 times, the document says, though her father said after the killer's sentencing Wednesday she had been stabbed more than 30 times. The knife, which investigators believe was a Ka-Bar knife, has also not been found. A tan, leather sheath for one such weapon containing Kohberger's DNA was found at the scene of the killings. Goncalves's sister addressed Kohberger during Wednesday's sentencing, telling him, 'If you hadn't attacked them in their sleep, in the middle of the night like a pedophile, Kaylee would have kicked your fucking ass.' As Kohberger was fatally stabbing Goncalves and Mogen on the third floor of the home, prosecutors have said they believe Kernodle was still awake on the floor below. Gilbertson said she was likely eating food she'd had delivered after a late night out. 'We believe that she heard something going on upstairs and at least started in that direction. But we don't know how far she got, or whether she went up the stairs or all the way up the stairs,' Gilbertson said. Kernodle was stabbed more than 50 times, and many of her wounds were defensive, the autopsy said, indicating she tried to fight off her attacker. Chapin, her boyfriend, was asleep in her bedroom and Kohberger killed him as well, prosecutors have said. 'She fought. She fought back and she fought hard,' Dahlinger said. As she resisted Kohberger, 'The fight just continued,' Gilbertson added. Jeff Kernodle, Xana's father, said on Wednesday that he almost went to his daughter's home on the night she was killed. But he had been drinking, and she told him not to drink and drive. Now, he said on Wednesday, he wishes that he had. 'You would have had to deal with me,' he told Kohberger in court. Before her death, Goncalves had expressed fears that she was being followed, and investigators have said her death elicited hundreds of tips and pieces of information about her having a stalker. Gilbertson confirmed her fears were correct. 'Somebody had followed her, and I know Kaylee absolutely felt that it was real. We investigated that heavily, we tracked down every bit of it,' Gilberson said. 'Fortunately, it was not what we would term or think of as stalking.' Someone had followed Goncalves but never contacted her, he said. 'It ended up being an instance where somebody saw a very pretty girl and was hoping to maybe be able to talk to her, or maybe be able to get a date or something,' Gilbertson said. In December 2022, police said investigators had identified an incident in October in which two men were seen at a business and one man appeared to follow Goncalves inside and as she exited to her car. The man did not make contact with her. Investigators contacted both men and learned they were trying to meet women at the business. Detectives said they believe this was an isolated incident and not a pattern of stalking. There was no evidence to suggest the men were involved in the killings, they said. CNN's Eric Levenson, Dakin Andone, Maureen Chowdhury and Antoinette Radford contributed to this report.
The Hill
36 minutes ago
- The Hill
Andrew Schulz slams Trump over Obama allegations amid Epstein controversy
Podcaster Andrew Schulz slammed President Trump during a Thursday episode of the Flagrant podcast, criticizing Trump for his handling of multiple controversies. Earlier this week, the president accused former President Obama of influencing the findings in Russiagate while distancing himself from the public's push for more information on Jeffrey Epstein's criminal dealings. 'He is rebuking the base, like almost like spitting in their face,' Schulz said. FBI Director Kash Patel and deputy director Dan Bongino have defended Trump amid the ongoing Epstein saga. In July, the two supported the release of the agency's findings that concluded the deceased financier kept no 'client list' and announced the Trump administration would not unveil additional files tied to convicted sex offender's dealings. 'He campaigned on it. He put Bongino and Kash in there, which might be the stupidest thing in the history of the world. Why would you put the two guys that have nonstop pounded the pavement talking about how we're going to expose this Epstein thing, and the second they get in there like, 'You better shut the f*** up,'' Schulz said. The comedian said this week's release of files related to Martin Luther King Jr. was another attempt at 's— distractions' to throw people off the hunt for more information on Epstein. His co-host Akaash Singh agreed, adding that the administration was 'hiding something crazy.' Storylines have swirled regarding Epstein's ties to Trump as the Wall Street Journal published an article outlining a 2003 birthday letter sent to the businessman in 2003. It allegedly bears Trump's signature and is typed in the font of a naked woman, according to the outlet. Trump denied ever writing the correspondence and sued the outlet over the report.
