David McBride lodges High Court application to challenge conviction
The ACT Supreme Court jailed McBride for five years and eight months for theft and leaking the material to three journalists.
He was to face a jury but pleaded guilty when it became evident the court would not allow his basic defence that it was his duty to share the documents in the public interest.
His point was that soldiers in Afghanistan were being "over-investigated" for alleged war crimes and he wanted the public to know.
McBride appealed against his sentence and conviction, but that was thrown out earlier this year.
His High Court appeal canvasses the same issues, drawing a distinction between disciplinary duties and duties of office, and relying on the Oath of Allegiance to the Sovereign.
The oath, which McBride made to Queen Elizabeth II, includes a promise to serve the sovereign according to law, and "… faithfully discharge my duty according to law".
The appeal centres on the scope of that duty.
His lawyers say in their submissions to the High Court, that the ACT Court of Appeal "… erroneously assumed that a duty of service requires unqualified obedience to orders".
The appeal court remarked that if it accepted McBride's argument it would "… also extend to conduct of members in all spheres of a member's military service, including on the battlefield".
McBride's lawyers say in their High Court application they are not encouraging general defiance of orders, but rather suggesting it should be recognised "duty cannot be reduced to blind obedience".
"… the applicant sought to communicate to the public evidence of serious misconduct at the highest levels of military command." the submissions to the High Court say.
"An insistence that duty is wholly defined by orders strips away the necessary safeguard against executive overreach and ignores the principle that duty is judged by law, not merely military command."
The application even cites the Nuremberg War Crimes Tribunal after the Second World War "which recognised following orders is no defence to actions that violate fundamental principles of law, such as crimes against humanity".
"There must be circumstances where a soldier can and indeed must, disobey orders — even if those orders are authorised pursuant to military law."
Only the ABC used the material David McBride provided, in a series called the Afghan Files, which revealed allegations Australian soldiers were involved in illegal killings in Afghanistan.
This was not, of course, what David McBride had hoped to achieve by handing over the documents.
He had begun copying the material, printing it and taking it home in 2013.
A search showed he had removed 235 documents, 207 of which had a secret classification.
McBride knew for a long time he would face charges.
During the investigation the ABC was raided by Australian Federal Police looking for evidence in the case.
It was not until 2019 that he finally appeared in the ACT Magistrates Court, with even longer to wait for trial, after interruptions from the pandemic.
He is now in Canberra's jail.
It is not known when the High Court will consider the application.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
29 minutes ago
- News.com.au
New campaign for probe into 2012 death of gold prospector Bruce Schuler
Serious concerns linger over the evidence used to convict a husband and wife of murder on a remote Queensland property 13 years ago, as they face dying behind bars. Dianne Wilson-Struber and Stephen Struber were found guilty at trial of killing gold prospector Bruce Schuler, 48, at the couple's giant Cape York leasehold in July 2012. Mr Schuler's body has never been found, but police alleged in a circumstantial case that he was shot dead by the Strubers before they hid his remains. Both Dianne and Stephen maintain they had nothing to do with Mr Schuler's disappearance and their case led to the introduction of 'no body, no parole' laws in the Sunshine State. Retired detective Graeme Crowley, who wrote a book and made a podcast about the investigation and trial, said 140 'discrepancies' he has identified led him to believe the wrong people might be in jail. 'There are there are serious concerns with the investigation, there are serious concerns with the evidence, there are serious concerns with the way the prosecutor presented the evidence,' he told 'So if you accept any or all of those, then likely they didn't commit this murder.' Family of Ms Wilson-Struber in March launched a petition to the Queensland government for a long-awaited inquest to be held into Mr Schuler's disappearance. Petition author Sharon Ferguson wrote that the inquest would enable legal teams currently investigating the case to test evidence brought against her sister, Dianne. But Mr Schuler's widower, Fiona Splitt, has condemned the campaign and says the only mystery is the location of her husband's body. No body, no weapons Mr Schuler disappeared from Palmerville Station, a property twice the size of Singapore, after camping there overnight with his dog Red and three prospecting friends on July 8, 2012. They did not have permission to be on the land, and the Queensland Supreme Court heard Struber had confronted one of the party for trespassing a week earlier. On the morning of July 9, Mr Schuler's companions reported hearing two gunshots ring out 10 to 15 minutes apart coming from the direction he was last seen. They later gave evidence at trial of seeing a car belonging to the Strubers driving toward a key crime scene. After searching for Mr Schuler, his friends reported him missing to police that night. Police arrived the next morning to conduct a wide-ranging land, water and air search, and executed a search warrant at the Schuler's home. Officers discovered three of the Strubers' large array of guns – two .22 calibre rifles and a .357 magnum – were missing, and the couple was arrested for questioning. They were not charged with Mr Schuler's murder until October 30, 2012, without police finding the Mareeba man's remains. 'There's no body, there's no cause of death, the witnesses didn't see Bruce Schuler shot, they didn't see him carried away,' Mr Crowley said. 'All they heard was two gunshots. And from there, the police concluded he was murdered.' The evidence What police did find during the searches of Palmerville Station was tyre marks in cow pats and burnt patches of grass near where Mr Schuler was reportedly last seen. There were two pieces of twine containing his DNA and spent projectiles found in bloodstained glass. Mr Schuler's DNA was also located on a bloodstained leaf, a white film canister, and four partially burnt matches. Forensic officers noted damaged trees and a broken termite mound consistent with recent vehicle contact, which they said showed marks matching Mr Struber's vehicle. Police later established that Wilson-Struber made an anonymous call to the Palmerville Station homestead from a payphone in Mareeba three days after Mr Schuler disappeared. She advised the officer who answered that the police were looking in the wrong spot and that they should be looking '12-15km east'. At trial, Struber stated he and his wife had spent the day of July 9, 2012 repairing a loader and were not in the area where shots were reported. 'We weren't there,' he said. A jury rejected this claim, after deliberating for just four hours, and Justice Jim Henry sentenced them both to life in prison. The couple's subsequent appeals over their convictions also failed. Ms Splitt's campaigning led to the introduction of 'no body, no parole' laws in Queensland in 2017, after more than 8000 people signed her petition. The U-turn One of the key 'discrepancies' Mr Crowley zeroed in on during his research is what witnesses said about a four-wheel-drive seen at the time shots were reported. It was alleged at trial that after first being shot at, Mr Schuler ran up a steep gully toward a secondary crime scene. The Strubers were said to have driven their car from where the first shot was fired 200m away to the second site where the blood and burnt patches were found. 'But all three prospectors told the police after the first shot, the car drove about somewhere between 20 and 50m,' Mr Crowley said. 'When it got the trial, the jury didn't hear that.' Mr Crowley said the prosecutor instead put to the witnesses that the car was seen heading in a northerly direction, toward crime scene two, to which they agreed. He said this 'one of the most important, disturbing, significant discrepancies' in the case. 'Because how do you murder someone … how do you put a body on the trail of the ute … if the ute does not go to the crime scene?' A new campaign Ms Ferguson is firm in her belief that her sister, Wilson-Struber, is innocent. She described her sister as a 'happy, caring, loving person' before the incident that changed their family – who had been in possession of Palmerville since the 1960s – forever. 'She cared about people, animals. She enjoyed her lifestyle on the property because she grew up on that property, and it was just part of her life.' Ms Ferguson's petition calling for an inquest to finally be held into the matter gained more than 5000 signatures, and is due to be introduced to parliament in August. A coroner handed down non-inquest findings in 2016, following the Strubers' convictions and based on police material and evidence heard at trial. 'I was very disappointed with that,' Ms Ferguson said. 'I think if they would have done a proper coronial inquest in the first place, maybe they would've been a lot more answers. 'The ultimate, result for me would be that we find out what really happened to Bruce Schuler, where his body may be. 'So his family can have closure and the right people who committed this crime can be incarcerated for what they did.' Ms Ferguson said a new legal team had been engaged to prepare a fresh court appeal, which could be heard in November. Ms Splitt recently told the Cairns Post that the latest wave of attention on the case had taken a toll on her family. Although she has also wanted an inquest to be held, she rejected the assertion that the petition was also aimed at supporting Bruce. 'The insensitive comments and things that people say on social media and calls for an inquest take an immense mental and emotional toll … and it is hurting my family and Bruce's family,' she said. 'We have trusted the legal process throughout this entire ordeal, and we trust that the authorities will continue their investigation based on the facts, evidence, and proper legal procedure. 'We are confident that the truth will prevail if we continue to focus on the facts and not get sidetracked by distractions.'
News.com.au
29 minutes ago
- News.com.au
Roads closed, traffic chaos: Sydney prepares for bridge march
Tens of thousands of pro-Palestinian protesters are expected to stream across the Sydney Harbour Bridge on Sunday after the Supreme Court rejected a bid to block the anti-war march across the landmark. Conditions are expected to be wet for the rally, with the Bureau of Meteorology predicting 10 to 35mm of rain on Sunday, but organisers claim as many as 50,000 people could take part. Protesters will gather at Lang Park in the Sydney CBD at 1pm before marching across the bridge. Beginning at York and Grosvenor streets at 1.30pm, protesters will then file onto the bridge before finishing on the northern side of the bridge at Bradfield Park, according to rally organisers the Palestine Action Group. The march is expected to last three hours. Traffic on the bridge will be closed from 11.30am and is expected to be re-opened by 4pm. Residents and motorists are being urged to avoid the area having been warned of significant disruptions. Bus services will terminate in the CBD on the south side of the bridge and at North Sydney and St Leonards on the northern side. Trains will be running across the Harbour Bridge during the march, but delays are expected given the number of people predicted to be streaming into the city. Transport for NSW says that 'extensive' queues are expected at the entrance to the Sydney Harbour Tunnel, with a flow-on effect expected for the rest of the traffic network. Motorists are being urged to consider alternative routes and allow plenty of extra time, including going from the northern beaches and north shore to the airport. The Metro service will not in operation between Tallawong and Sydenham on Sunday due to trackwork. Buses will replace Metro services between Tallawong and Chatswood . Palestine Action Group organiser Josh Lees, who has been the public face of the group's push to hold the historic march across the bridge, hailed a NSW Supreme Court decision on Saturday as a 'huge victory for the Palestine movement in this country' Premier Chris Minns had publicly expressed his opposition to the march. And the NSW Police made an application to the NSW Supreme Court to block the protesters being issued with a Form 1, which affords protesters protection from anti-assembly laws However Justice Belinda Rigg refused the Commissioner's application. 'The fact the proposed assembly is likely to cause significant inconvenience to residents … is far from determinative,' Justice Rigg said in her judgment. 'If matters such as this were to be determinative, no assembly involving inconvenience to others would be permitted.' The Palestinian Action Group said in a social media post: 'Tomorrow we are going to make history! 'We will hold a massive march over the Sydney Harbour Bridge, dedicated to using our people power to stop the genocide in Gaza. 'We are working with police and NSW transport to ensure a safe, family-friendly event for everyone.'
The Advertiser
6 hours ago
- The Advertiser
Elderly man charged with murder after woman's stabbing
An elderly man has been charged with the murder of a woman, while another man in his 20s is fighting for life following separate overnight stabbing attacks across two states. Homicide Squad detectives were investigating an attack on an elderly woman who was found fatally injured at a house in Coleraine, about 35km from Hamilton, in Victoria's southwest. Local officers found the 81-year-old woman alive shortly after 1am on Saturday, but she died at the scene. Police arrested and interviewed an 81-year-old Coleraine man who was known to the victim before charging him with murder on Saturday evening. He has been remanded in custody and will face the Warrnambool Magistrates Court on Monday. In a separate incident, two men were also stabbed at a house gathering in Sydney's west overnight, one of them suffering critical wounds. Emergency crews were called to a residential unit in Patricia Street, Mays Hill, in the city's inner west, in the early hours of Saturday following reports a man in his 20s had sustained serious injuries. He was located and treated at the scene by paramedics for an apparent life-threatening knife wound to the torso before being taken to Westmead Hospital. Police said a second man of similar age was found nearby with a wound to his arm. He was also transported to Westmead. It is understood the pair and others at the address were known to each other. The Coleraine incident comes days after an Australia-first knife ban targeting young offenders. Victorian parents were urged on Thursday to hand in their children's machetes and knives at police amnesty posts. A total of 45 stations across the state will host disposal bins set up for the three-month initiative. Carrying one of the deadly, long and broad-bladed knives is outlawed, while a sales ban with some exemptions is already operating. 1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732) Lifeline 13 11 14 Men's Referral Service 1300 766 491 An elderly man has been charged with the murder of a woman, while another man in his 20s is fighting for life following separate overnight stabbing attacks across two states. Homicide Squad detectives were investigating an attack on an elderly woman who was found fatally injured at a house in Coleraine, about 35km from Hamilton, in Victoria's southwest. Local officers found the 81-year-old woman alive shortly after 1am on Saturday, but she died at the scene. Police arrested and interviewed an 81-year-old Coleraine man who was known to the victim before charging him with murder on Saturday evening. He has been remanded in custody and will face the Warrnambool Magistrates Court on Monday. In a separate incident, two men were also stabbed at a house gathering in Sydney's west overnight, one of them suffering critical wounds. Emergency crews were called to a residential unit in Patricia Street, Mays Hill, in the city's inner west, in the early hours of Saturday following reports a man in his 20s had sustained serious injuries. He was located and treated at the scene by paramedics for an apparent life-threatening knife wound to the torso before being taken to Westmead Hospital. Police said a second man of similar age was found nearby with a wound to his arm. He was also transported to Westmead. It is understood the pair and others at the address were known to each other. The Coleraine incident comes days after an Australia-first knife ban targeting young offenders. Victorian parents were urged on Thursday to hand in their children's machetes and knives at police amnesty posts. A total of 45 stations across the state will host disposal bins set up for the three-month initiative. Carrying one of the deadly, long and broad-bladed knives is outlawed, while a sales ban with some exemptions is already operating. 1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732) Lifeline 13 11 14 Men's Referral Service 1300 766 491 An elderly man has been charged with the murder of a woman, while another man in his 20s is fighting for life following separate overnight stabbing attacks across two states. Homicide Squad detectives were investigating an attack on an elderly woman who was found fatally injured at a house in Coleraine, about 35km from Hamilton, in Victoria's southwest. Local officers found the 81-year-old woman alive shortly after 1am on Saturday, but she died at the scene. Police arrested and interviewed an 81-year-old Coleraine man who was known to the victim before charging him with murder on Saturday evening. He has been remanded in custody and will face the Warrnambool Magistrates Court on Monday. In a separate incident, two men were also stabbed at a house gathering in Sydney's west overnight, one of them suffering critical wounds. Emergency crews were called to a residential unit in Patricia Street, Mays Hill, in the city's inner west, in the early hours of Saturday following reports a man in his 20s had sustained serious injuries. He was located and treated at the scene by paramedics for an apparent life-threatening knife wound to the torso before being taken to Westmead Hospital. Police said a second man of similar age was found nearby with a wound to his arm. He was also transported to Westmead. It is understood the pair and others at the address were known to each other. The Coleraine incident comes days after an Australia-first knife ban targeting young offenders. Victorian parents were urged on Thursday to hand in their children's machetes and knives at police amnesty posts. A total of 45 stations across the state will host disposal bins set up for the three-month initiative. Carrying one of the deadly, long and broad-bladed knives is outlawed, while a sales ban with some exemptions is already operating. 1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732) Lifeline 13 11 14 Men's Referral Service 1300 766 491 An elderly man has been charged with the murder of a woman, while another man in his 20s is fighting for life following separate overnight stabbing attacks across two states. Homicide Squad detectives were investigating an attack on an elderly woman who was found fatally injured at a house in Coleraine, about 35km from Hamilton, in Victoria's southwest. Local officers found the 81-year-old woman alive shortly after 1am on Saturday, but she died at the scene. Police arrested and interviewed an 81-year-old Coleraine man who was known to the victim before charging him with murder on Saturday evening. He has been remanded in custody and will face the Warrnambool Magistrates Court on Monday. In a separate incident, two men were also stabbed at a house gathering in Sydney's west overnight, one of them suffering critical wounds. Emergency crews were called to a residential unit in Patricia Street, Mays Hill, in the city's inner west, in the early hours of Saturday following reports a man in his 20s had sustained serious injuries. He was located and treated at the scene by paramedics for an apparent life-threatening knife wound to the torso before being taken to Westmead Hospital. Police said a second man of similar age was found nearby with a wound to his arm. He was also transported to Westmead. It is understood the pair and others at the address were known to each other. The Coleraine incident comes days after an Australia-first knife ban targeting young offenders. Victorian parents were urged on Thursday to hand in their children's machetes and knives at police amnesty posts. A total of 45 stations across the state will host disposal bins set up for the three-month initiative. Carrying one of the deadly, long and broad-bladed knives is outlawed, while a sales ban with some exemptions is already operating. 1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732) Lifeline 13 11 14 Men's Referral Service 1300 766 491
