Just Let Your Kids Play With Makeup
Call it the fear of 'girly-girl' culture—the princess movies, sparkly dresses, and, of course, makeup that Keough says become part of many little kids' orbits when they turn 3. These interests, the thinking goes, feed into a culture that grinds the spirits of bright young women into pixie dust by insisting that their outward appearance is ultimately more important than their actions. The concern is a frequent topic in Facebook parenting groups and modern advice columns, which feature questions such as what to do when a 3-year-old is obsessed with pink despite a hard-and-fast 'No sparkle princesses!' rule. Recently, parents' anxiety has been stoked by YouTube and TikTok influencers who turn makeup routines into entertainment—popular videos that have led to an influx of fifth graders in Sephora aisles. Late last year, to cultivate a younger clientele, the beauty retailer Ulta even debuted tiny toy versions of popular makeup products, essentially collectibles shaped like eyeshadow palettes or lipstick. The response was robust sales—and panicked articles declaring that the toys were 'hooking young kids on makeup' before their brains could reject such glitter-coated temptations. 'The anxiety,' Keough told me, 'is very real.'
But a child's curiosity about makeup isn't necessarily a red flag, or even a fluttery pink one. When a 3-year-old asks for a lipstick tube of her own, she's doing something that is, in Keough's words, developmentally 'so normal'—and that can even be helpful. Today, many experts think that toys symbolizing makeup, or a spare amount of nontoxic cosmetics, can have cognitive and developmental benefits for preschool and elementary-age children, as long as they're used as part of child-initiated play. A knee-jerk rejection of girlhood signifiers—being against princesses, say—ends up putting a double standard on playtime that can cast girls themselves as weak or unwanted. Compare the kerfuffle over Ulta's lipstick figurines with Ferrari's similar partnership with Hot Wheels, which produced no discernible outrage at all. The typical clutter of boyhood rarely faces the same scrutiny as 'girly' toys.
[Read: How to have a realistic conversation about beauty with your kids]
Little girls clamoring for lipstick is a healthy part of role-playing, Tara Well, a psychologist and Barnard College professor who specializes in personality development, told me. Children begin experimenting with their appearance early as part of their identity formation, the process of realizing that they are distinct beings with their own body and desires. A version of this type of play begins around six months, when babies become fascinated with their own reflection. (If you've ever held up a baby to a mirror and cooed 'Who's that? Is that you?' then you've helped guide this practice.) By 18 months, toddlers will typically recognize themselves in the mirror, and they'll also use visual aids—dress-up clothes, masks, perhaps makeup—to role-play as caregivers or story characters, a kind of exploration that tends to continue for many years. This is why my goddaughter, when she was a toddler, would pretend to spray her grandmother's perfume on herself before coming to dinner, and why the 5-year-old daughter of a friend swiped a Sweet'N Low packet from the table when we were all at brunch, then rolled it up to look like a 'pink lipstick' that she dabbed onto her face until her buttered toast arrived.
The act of creating pretend makeup or putting on the occasional swipe of real lip balm can also reinforce fine-motor and planning skills, Keough told me. Putting on (actual or pretend) makeup requires grip—and it teaches a child to identify and follow a simple sequence of events: uncapping the product, pinpointing the specific part of the face where it belongs, using it carefully, putting it away. When children 'turn' regular objects into makeup, such as the sweetener packet at the diner, they're also developing problem-solving skills. Drawing pictures and building with blocks have similar benefits, Keough said, 'but to say playing with makeup, or pretend makeup, is useless isn't accurate.'
Trying to ban such 'glamour play'—as Well described the practice of playing with items that deal with appearance—can also backfire. Such rejections can tamp down a child's natural curiosity and desire for agency, which might cause some developmental issues, such as loss of confidence in one's natural desire to explore the social environment, Well told me. That's especially true in today's highly supervised childhoods, where many young kids' sights, smells, and tastes are entirely prescribed by adults. Imagining a makeup-wearing future gives children the ability to feel a tiny bit of control and wish fulfillment, just as imagining having a beard or a mustache could. 'A lot of kids will pretend to shave like Daddy,' Keough told me. 'People don't seem so concerned about that.'
Many people have argued that there's a thin line between an interest in beauty and an embrace of unhealthy societal norms, such as the idea that a woman's worth is primarily determined by her appearance or ability to sexually attract a man. But the desire to wear makeup isn't always about appealing to the male gaze. Women wear lipstick in corporate boardrooms, congressional meetings, and places of worship—and not because they want a date. Many female leaders have made a signature cosmetic look, such as bold lipstick, a part of their visual calling card. Witness the fire-red lips of Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, who has said she often wears lipstick to get a confidence boost and as a tie to her Latina culture. Rabbi Rebecca Keren Jablonski, an author and religious leader in New York City, has said that she adopts a glam look partly so young people in her community can see that she's just like other adults they know, and not a distant, unapproachable figure.
When young women have agency to choose their own clothing and makeup, they can be more confident, less anxious, and even kinder, Shakaila Forbes-Bell, a London-based psychologist who specializes in aesthetics and mental health and is the author of Big Dress Energy, told me.
Women's sense of agency over their appearance can also, in certain arenas, influence cognitive performance. The authors of a 2012 paper on 'enclothed cognition' suggested that clothes 'can have profound and systematic psychological and behavioral consequences for their wearers.' And a 2017 study found that female students scored higher on academic assessments when they applied their preferred style of makeup before taking a simulated exam.
[Read: 'Intensive' parenting is now the norm in America]
The desire to have control over our appearance—and to appear on the outside as we feel on the inside—begins in childhood, Forbes-Bell told me. 'Letting kids look how they want,' she said, 'especially when they're playing, is so, so important.' Does that mean all beauty products are great for all kids? Absolutely not, which is why some of the parental concern over kids' desire to use makeup is well placed: Some dermatologists have said that many brands popular on TikTok have stronger chemical compounds (such as retinol) that, though helpful for older adults, could irritate young skin. (Obviously, if you're too young to get drunk, you don't need a Drunk Elephant brand anti-aging serum.) More alarming is a 2023 study from Columbia University, which noted that children who've been exposed to personal-care products—not just makeup but also some hair gels—might absorb toxic chemicals from the formulas into their skin, eyes, and mouth. The scientists behind the study called for greater government restrictions, especially on products marketed to children.
Physical safety is one thing. A moral panic about playing pretend is another. Although it's true that no child, whatever their gender, should be told their worth is primarily communicated through their looks—and parents understandably want to reinforce that message—banning 'girly' play can come with its own harms. At an innate level, children know that their appearance can help communicate who they are, and who they might want to be in the world. Pretending to apply makeup with toys, or occasionally smearing some real makeup on with adult supervision, can be a healthy way for kids to explore that idea—and a fun, even thrilling way to assert their sense of self. Letting children take the lead is the point, even if it leads to lipstick instead of Legos.
When you buy a book using a link on this page, we receive a commission. Thank you for supporting The Atlantic.
Article originally published at The Atlantic

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Learn how to mom – and gain a group for support
During pregnancy, all eyes are on mom, but after delivery, the change of focus can feel swift and jarring. Of course, babies need, deserve and thrive with attentive, stable caregivers, but postpartum moms too often get lost in the shuffle. Nicole Parmelee, mother of two and owner of New Mom School Greenville, is out to change that. Her New Mom School is helping mothers learn with their peers as they adapt to the biggest change of their lives and embrace the season of the fourth trimester. Parmelee said New Mom School started in California in 2012. It began franchising locations about two years ago. 'I was looking for different ways to have a business in the community, but serve the community,' she said. 'I love this because when I moved to Greenville in 2013 I was 33 weeks pregnant. I was part of a Facebook group, and they were my lifesavers. And when I ran into this, I was like, this is the Facebook group, but local and in person. That's how we're different than a prenatal education class or even a postpartum education class, because a lot of that focuses on the baby. We focus on the mom because we believe that if the mom is supported, then that benefits the whole family unit – it benefits the baby's development. It benefits the spousal relationship or the relationship with other children in the home.' Mommy and Me – for moms The program at New Mom School is similar to a Mommy and Me program, with the focus on mom. Women are grouped by baby's age, and there is a separate group for second-time moms, with the changes that come from baby No. 2. 'We encourage registrations while pregnant, so that we get the due dates,' Parmelee said. Once Parmelee groups pre-registered moms by due date, others can join if they have not pre-registered. 'The goal is that we consistently have these pre-registrations and we can group the moms as close together as possible, and that way they're all kind of going through the same things at the same time,' she said. Mom and infant classes are 90 minutes once a week for eight weeks. For many of the sessions, a visiting expert talks to moms about their area of expertise, such as information about postpartum body changes from a pelvic floor therapist, feeding information from a speech therapist and postpartum worry and anxiety from a postpartum mental health counselor. The classes not only increase knowledge but build connections for moms to local experts and to each other. 'Our hope is at the end of the eight weeks they've learned, but they've also built a community for themselves,' Parmelee said. 'We're constantly saying, hey, why don't you guys get together outside of class? Create a group chat, go meet at the mall. Our instructors are trained to facilitate getting them together outside of class, so that they have that community.' Classes in Greenville Classes are held at New Mom School on Howell Road, not far from Haywood Mall. Parmelee said the space has been created to cultivate calm – something new moms may find in short supply given the momentous changes babies bring. 'There's not a lot of clutter,' she said. 'The colors are all very neutral because we want the moms to feel like they're coming to a peaceful place when their home is chaotic and baby stuff is everywhere. We're located in a facility that has ample parking, so that's not a concern. We email them before classes start, and we say, do a drive by, come see, because a lot of times, especially for the newborn class, the first time they're out alone with their baby is to New Mom School.' Learn more about New Mom School For details and registration for New Mom School Greenville, visit Classes are offered beginning with newborns up to rising toddlers (ages 6 – 12 months) for first-time and second-time moms. Additional options include prenatal yoga, a free breastfeeding support group, workshops and more. A superbill can be provided for possible HSA, FSA and/or insurance coverage. This article originally appeared on Greenville News: New Mom School helps moms through the fourth trimester Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
7 hours ago
- Yahoo
I'm an ob-gyn — but I make more money countering health misinformation on TikTok
Meet Dr. Fran. When ob-gyn Dr. Franziska Haydanek, aka Paging Dr. Fran, first started posting videos on TikTok, she wasn't trying to make money or get famous — she wanted to combat the misinformation about women's health that she kept seeing while scrolling online. What started as a side gig to help others has grown into a platform with more than 650K followers on TikTok alone. She's now earning triple her doctor's salary making these myth-busting and educational videos. In this interview with Yahoo's Rachel Grumman Bender, Dr. Fran shares in her own words how she got started, the reason she wants other doctors to join her on social media and why, despite her success, she'll never give up her day job as a doctor. When I graduated from medical school in 2021, I took six months off to be home with my kids before I started my real job in a hospital. TikTok had blown up over the past couple of years. I'd been scrolling on it myself and kept seeing incorrect things about birth control, labor and delivery, pregnancy and breastfeeding — either people trying to mislead you or just people misunderstanding how things were. I was like, 'Well, I feel like someone should address this. I've got nothing but time.' So I started making videos. I had a couple thousand followers — not that big of a deal. And then in early 2022, when the Dobbs decision was leaked [overturning Roe v. Wade, which had guaranteed the right to abortion on a federal level], I was in a Facebook group with a bunch of ob-gyn moms, and we were talking about how we can help people. We created this list within our own private Facebook group of doctors who would be willing to tie younger patients' tubes [known as tubal ligation, which prevents pregnancy]. So I was like, well, this list doesn't help anyone in this private Facebook group. So I asked if they would be willing to be in a public list, and then 150 of those doctors signed up — and that's how I created the TikTok tubal list [which now has thousands of doctors in the U.S. and beyond]. I posted it, and it went viral. I gained almost 100,000 followers in about a month. Then I just kept doing what I had been doing, addressing misinformation or clarifying things or just talking about things in medicine or being a mom in medicine. And here we are three years later. The pros and cons of getting medical information online Combating misinformation is the root of my whole platform, and it continues to be what I find the most rewarding. It's very important to me that I continue to show up, especially for ob-gyn. Our medicine is so deeply intertwined with politics and people's political and religious agendas, more than probably most other aspects of medicine. So I think it's really important that there's someone there who is saying what the actual evidence-based information is. I hope people realize that sometimes the internet can be a really great source of information, but also they should take everything with a grain of salt. I always encourage people to use what they have available to them. So if using things like TikTok or Reddit or whatever is how they start to educate themselves about options, I think that should be highly encouraged. It's also why I encourage other doctors to make content because ours should really be the first one that people see. But you can get really sucked into the wrong place. You don't know how to verify the information or if it applies to you and your health. So I think social media is a great place to start educating yourself, but then you really need to take it back to your own doctor and be like, "Hey, I saw this. Do you think this applies to me?" Or, "How does this affect my care?" Rather than just using a TikTok video to self-diagnose and then treat yourself. 'I tripled my income' Everyone wants more information about the things that they're seeing online and in real life, so having someone lay it out for them in an easy-to-digest format is something that people really respond to. In 2023, I started making money from my videos, in addition to getting paid for views on TikTok and Instagram. Once in a while, I would have people reach out like, "Hey, will you talk about this dry shampoo you're already using?' or, 'Hey, we're trying to promote this over-the-counter COVID test." And I was like, "Yeah, sure" — that all aligns with what I'm doing. By the time we got to early 2024, I found it very overwhelming to be a full-time doctor and a mother while managing all these things [with social media]. So I signed with a management company that now does all of that for me. In 2024, I tripled my income from the previous year. At this point in 2025, I've already surpassed what I made in 2024. So it's just been steadily growing, and we're focusing on long-term partnerships with people and companies that I really believe in. I'm very selective of who I work with. I decline probably about 90% of the things that come my way because they don't all align with my views or what I believe in medically or personally. But I get to work with companies that I do believe in, and it's been really rewarding. Making more money has been very nice because as doctors you put off about 10 years of financial income. In addition, I still have a lot of student loans I'm working off. My husband is also a doctor and has student loans. So it was nice because it just let us ramp up our emergency fund. It let us create savings accounts that we hadn't had in our mid-30s, which most people start in their mid-20s. It has given us more of a financial safety net. I've always said — even back before I ever went to medical school and I was making some money from social media — that the platform is fickle and there's no guarantee that the money will still be there tomorrow. So, for me, I've always considered this a nice supplement to my normal income, but I would never give up my real job for this. I love what I do, and I love being able to take care of patients in real life. I'll probably cut back just a little bit on my hours because I do work a lot and I have three young children. I want to have some flexibility for that. So my long-term goals are to keep doing what I'm doing, being a source of truth for people and still making it interesting. This has been edited for length and clarity.


USA Today
17 hours ago
- USA Today
Indiana Fever release statement updating Caitlin Clark injury status
The Indiana Fever provided an important injury update for their star point guard on Thursday. Caitlin Clark has missed the last two regular-season games and the All-Star game with a right groin injury. It's the third different soft tissue injury Clark has dealt with this season, leading to her being in and out of the lineup all year long. Clark has already been ruled out for Thursday night's game against the Las Vegas Aces, and the Fever provided an update on her injury and recovery process on Thursday. In a statement released on X, the Fever put out a highly-anticipated update on Clark's injury and the additional testing that happened earlier this week. "Caitlin Clark underwent further medical evaluations earlier this week, which confirmed that no additional injuries or damage were discovered. Clark will continue working with the medical team on her recovery and rehabilitation, with the priority on her long-term health and well-being. There is no timetable available for her return," the Fever's statement read. It's good and bad news for the star guard. It's great that the testing from earlier this week found no additional injuries. Now, the Fever and Clark know they're just dealing with that right groin injury and can put together a treatment and recovery plan based on that. The bad news is that there is still no timetable for Clark's return as of now. While this isn't surprising news, as that treatment plan is probably still being worked on, it's unfortunate for the rest of the team and the fans that Clark's return timeline is still up in the air. The most important thing for Clark and the Fever is her long-term health, as mentioned in the statement released by the team. If keeping her out of game action for a while ensures she fully recovers, then that's the right move for all parties. In the meantime, the Fever will have to find ways to win games without their point guard, which has proved to be a challenge this season. They're 4-7 without Clark this season, including the Commissioner's Cup final, and they're 9-5 with her playing. Indiana (12-12) continues their season on Thursday when they host the Las Vegas Aces (12-11). Tip-off is scheduled for 6 p.m. CT on Amazon Prime Video. Contact/Follow us @HawkeyesWire on X (formerly Twitter) and like our page on Facebook to follow ongoing coverage of Iowa news, notes and opinions. Follow Zach on X: @zach_hiney