Judge recommends that case against Wisconsin Judge Hannah Dugan proceed
Milwaukee County Circuit Judge Hannah Dugan was arrested in April and indicted on federal charges in May. She pleaded not guilty.
The case highlighted a clash between President Donald Trump's administration and local authorities over the Republican's sweeping immigration crackdown.
Democrats have accused the Trump administration of trying to make a national example of Dugan to chill judicial opposition.
Dugan filed a motion in May to dismiss the charges against her, saying she was acting in her official capacity as a judge and therefore is immune to prosecution. She argued that the federal government violated Wisconsin's sovereignty by disrupting a state courtroom and prosecuting a state judge.
U.S. Magistrate Judge Nancy Joseph on Monday recommended against dropping the charges. The ultimate decision is up to U.S. District Judge Lynn Adelman, who can accept the other judge's recommendation or reject it.
'We are disappointed in the magistrate judge's non-binding recommendation, and we will appeal it," Dugan attorney Steven Biskupic, a former federal prosecutor, said in a statement. "This is only one step in what we expect will be a long journey to preserve the independence and integrity of our courts.'
Joseph wrote in her recommendation that while judges have immunity from civil lawsuits seeking monetary damages when engaging in judicial acts, that does not apply to criminal charges like those in this case. Joseph also rejected Dugan's other arguments in favor of dismissal.
'It is important to note that nothing said here speaks to the merits of the allegations against Dugan,' the judge said in the recommendation. 'Dugan is presumed innocent, and innocent she remains, unless and until the government proves the allegations against her beyond a reasonable doubt to a jury at trial.'
No trial date has been set.
Dugan is charged with concealing an individual to prevent arrest, a misdemeanor, and obstruction, which is a felony. Prosecutors say she escorted Eduardo Flores-Ruiz, 31, and his lawyer out of her courtroom through a back door on April 18 after learning that U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents were in the courthouse seeking to arrest him for being in the country without permanent legal status.
Agents arrested Ruiz outside of the courthouse after a brief foot chase.
Dugan could face up to six years in prison and a $350,000 fine if convicted on both counts.
Her case is similar to one brought during the first Trump administration against a Massachusetts judge, who was accused of helping a man sneak out a courthouse back door to evade a waiting immigration enforcement agent. That case was eventually dismissed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
36 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Father swept away after he refused to give up 'babies' while clinging to tree during Texas flood
A father who lost his life in the tragic Texas floods had desperately clung to his 'babies' as the waters ravaged the RV park where his family was vacationing. John Burgess, 39, was found dead after the deluge swept him away from the RV park with his two young boys. Their mother was also take by the floodwaters. Family members confirmed John's death and recently announced that his wife, Julia Anderson Burgess, 38, was also killed in the floods. Their two young boys - James, 1, and Jack, 5 - are still missing. The couple's daughter, Jenna, was staying at a nearby camp that wasn't impacted by the floods. She has been found safe but was left to deal with the tragedy. Witnesses said the father's haunting last moments were spent clinging to a tree while trying to save his sons. Lorena Guillen, the owner of the Blue Oak RV Park in Kerr County, told the New York Post that she saw John hold his children before the floods swept them away. 'My husband was in the water trying to ask them, "Please throw me your baby!" The man was holding tight to his babies, and he just got swept away,' Guillen recalled. Guillen said the family had come to the RV park to celebrate the holiday weekend and the kids were 'so excited' to be there. She recalled the haunting images she witnessed during the floods, including when she rushed to the riverside to see multiple RVs washed away. Guillen and her husband awoke in the middle of the night to a rescue team on their property. 'My husband and I ran down. By then, the first level of the RVs was already washing away. The river went up about 10 feet at that time,' the park owner said. 'A family of five was stranded because they were the ones closest to the river. Their RV was floating away. It was pitch black, it was so dark.' She said emergency responders recovered eight bodies from her property and the neighboring RV park had 40 missing people. Authorities have issued a massive search and rescue operation since the tragedy, as the death toll has hit over 100 victims. As officials comb through the rubble for bodies and survivors, dozens of families have been left to grieve the lives lost. Tributes have already begun to pour in for the Burgesses, as many hold out hope for word on their two young sons. Michael Schwab, a family member, confirmed the deaths on X. 'These past few days have been devastating for my family as we continue to mourn the loss of John Burgess, and have been praying for Julia Anderson Burgess and their two sweet boys,' he wrote. 'We were deeply saddened to learn this morning that my cousin Julia Anderson Burgess's body has now been found. We continue to pray for their two boys who are still missing at this time.' Julia was a teacher at Liberty Elementary in Liberty, Texas, a small town of just about 8,000 outside of Houston. Liberty shared a tribute for Julia writing on social media, 'Our hearts are with the Burgess family -- please continue to pray.' Mark Linabury, the president and CEO of East Montgomery County Chamber of Commerce, posted a photo of John cutting a ribbon for his financial services business, and wrote, 'I still find it hard to accept the news about John Burgess. 'We just saw him at our luncheon on Wednesday before the tragic event. As I search through photos, I can't help but notice your amazing smile that could light up any room, and that of your beautiful family.' Laura Taylor-McGuire, a colleague of Julia's told local CBS affiliate, KWTX-TV, 'They were the sweetest and kindest family and would do anything for anyone.'
The Independent
43 minutes ago
- The Independent
White House challenged over Epstein client list claims
The White House has been challenged over its declaration that no Jeffrey Epstein client list exists. This challenge follows Attorney General Pam Bondi 's previous statements that she had the list 'ready to review' and it was 'sitting on my desk'. During a press conference, Karoline Leavitt was questioned by Fox News ' Peter Doocy about the Department of Justice 's new memo stating no further investigations into other individuals would be launched. Leavitt clarified that the Attorney General was referring to 'all of the paper in relation to Jeffrey Epstein's crimes' when she mentioned having the list. Watch the video in full above.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Democrats call for violence to counter Trump agenda and tell lawmakers to prepare to 'get shot'
Democrats have begun a full-blown freakout over their voters, who have determined they must be willing to 'get shot' and 'want blood' from their resistance to Donald Trump. The party, completely out of any institutional power in the wake of Trump's resounding win in November, remains directionless has it heads toward the 2026 midterms, with polls showing their approval with their own voters at rock bottom. Now, they're fearful that their voters may have taken their hatred of Trump too far, telling them to potentially bend the law or even resort to violence to resist the president. 'Our own base is telling us that what we're doing is not good needs to be blood to grab the attention of the press and the public,' an anonymous Democrat lawmaker admitted. The voters' solutions: follow Newark Mayor Ras Baraka and New Jersey Congresswoman LaMonica McIver, who both put themselves in legal trouble to visit an ICE detention facility. However, another anonymous liberal told Axios that even that wouldn't be enough, with one saying 'civility isn't working' and to man up for 'violence.' 'Some of them have we really need to do is be willing to get shot.' 'The expectations aren't just unreal. They're dangerous,' said one more. While House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries is being savaged for poorly photoshopped promo pictures and even posting holding a baseball bat, some Dems worry there's nothing they can do to satiate their base, which they say is 'white, well-educated and live in upscale' neighborhoods. 'We've got people who are desperately wanting us to do matter what we say, they want [more],' said Illinois Congressman Brad Schneider, who says he's desperately tried to beat back voters who want yet another impeachment of Trump. One thing they hear consistently is that they want the Democrats to get down and dirty and try to beat what they see as Republicans' own game. 'This idea that we're going to save every norm and that we're not going to play [Republicans'] game...I don't think that's resonating with voters anymore,' another anonymous Congressmember said. Another added that when voters 'who are angry don't accept that. They're angry beyond things,' with yet another comparing how they feel to 'the Roman Coliseum.' Ro Khanna, a California Congressman who ranks as one of their more outspoken progressives, went against the grain, preaching the need for pragmatism. 'The most effective pushback to Trump's unconstitutional actions is to model a reverence for the Constitution and the rule of law,' he said. The Democrats believe that their voters' attitude will keep Donald Trump in power. 'We've got people who are desperately wanting us to do matter what we say, they want [more],' said Illinois Congressman Brad Schneider (pictured), who says he's desperately tried to beat back voters who want yet another impeachment of Trump 'Not only would that be a gift to Donald Trump, not only would it make the job of Republicans in Congress easier if we were all mired in legal troubles...[we are] a group that is disproportionately people of color, women, LGBTQ people — people who do not fare very well in prison.' Just months ago, approval of the Democratic Party hit a brutal record low as Democrats are split over how to take on President Donald Trump in the first few months of his second term, new polling finds. Among Americans overall, the Democratic Party's favorability rating stands at just 29 percent, CNN found. It's the lowest favorability the party has seen since CNN first started conducting its polling back in 1992. It's also a 20 point drop in approval since Trump left office more than four years ago at which time approval of the Democratic party was 49 percent. It's also a ten point drop from just before the November election. At the same time, a new NBC News poll released Sunday similarly found only 27 percent of voters had a positive view of the Democratic Party. That was the lowest positive rating in NBC News polling history dating back to 1990. The CNN polling released in March was conducted just days before ten Senate Democrats joined with their Republican colleagues in a vote to advance a stopgap spending bill to avoid a government shutdown in a move that has deeply divided the party even further. Some Democrats are now calling for Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer to step down as a Democratic Party leader while others have said he should be challenged when he's next up for reelection in 2028. The record low approval of the Democratic Party has been driven by increased dissatisfaction from within, the CNN polling found. Just 63 percent of Democrats or Democratic-leaning Independents had a favorable view of their own party, a drop from the 72 who had a favorable view of their party in January and 81 percent when President Biden took office. Democrats are also torn over the direction of their party should take, the polling found. Among Democratic-aligned adults, 52 percent said that the party leadership is taking the party in the wrong direction while 48 percent said they are taking the party in the right direction. At the same time, a growing number of Democrats want the party leadership to do more to stop the Republican agenda as Trump barrels through the first two months of his second term. The polling found 57 percent believe the party should do more to stop the GOP agenda while just 42 percent believe party leadership should work with Republicans.
