A5: Fair compensation needed for route landowners
Infrastructure Minister Liz Kimmins said it was an "extremely disappointing day" but added she was not giving up on delivering a safer A5.
More than 50 people have died on the A5 since 2006 and campaigners have called for the road to be upgraded.The road is the Northern Ireland part of the major arterial route that connects the north-west of the island - Donegal and Londonderry - to Dublin, via towns including Strabane, Omagh and Aughnacloy.The dual carriageway scheme was first announced back in 2007, but has been beset by a number of delays.
The State of Us: The A5 upgrade has been blocked… againJudge rules against the long-delayed A5 road project A5 ruling shows impact of Stormont climate change legislation
The 58-mile (94km) £1.7bn project was given the green light by Stormont ministers in October last year.Speaking to BBC's Good Morning Ulster programme Mr McClenaghan said "land was taken away" from farmers last October and "they have not been able to use that land....the level of compensation has not yet even been determined and farmers have been reluctant to accept offers which may have been made because they don't know what the final costs will be"."Our feeling is that if our farmers are to be displaced they should be fairly compensated," he added. "Twenty years this has been going on and the important thing is that the A5 is safer for all the people that use it". "We need to get on with improving the A5 road and we do not disagree with that."It's ridiculous how long it's been left," he said.He said there are 330 farmers affected."This is there home where they've lived, there's an attachment on the land that goes passed any value or compensation amount and there are other farmers that want to get on with their business.
'Chilling' comments for victims' families
Stephen Kelly's father Terry was killed instantly when the van he was a passenger in left the road at Bready, on the stretch of the A5 between Strabane and Derry.Mr Kelly said he was disappointed by the decision, which he described as "the latest episode" in the "disaster" of trying to deliver a critical piece of infrastructure.He said the judge's comment that the delay would cause more loss of life was "chilling"."The judge is trying to make clear there is a strong moral case for this to be done … but as a family member, to hear a member of the judiciary saying it's very likely more people are going to die as a result of his decision yesterday didn't go down very well with me certainly."Mr Kelly said the judge's request for the department to provide more information "did leave the door open" for the scheme to progress in the future, which was "one thing to take away".
The Chair of Stormont's Infrastructure Committee, Deborah Erskine, said there were worries over how new road projects will be delivered."We are going to have to look at climate change legislation. It has huge implications for major road infrastructure projects across NI," she told Good Morning Ulster She added that there were "major questions" going forward for the Department of Infrastructure. "Why was land ripped up and made unrecognisable while a high court judgement was underway? And when will these farmers received this land back? "I've had farmers who've been chatting to me, very worried about those facts," she said.
What happened in court?
The High Court judgement blocking the upgrade of the A5 road - because the plans do not comply with government climate change targets - shows the reach and impact of Stormont's climate change legislation - but the judgement is clear that shortcomings in the project can be remedied.Justice McAlinden urged officials to make "concerted efforts" to address them so a safer road can be built.A solicitor for the Alternative A5 Alliance campaign group, which brought the successful case, said his clients' efforts had been "vindicated" and it was an important day for the environment.Safety campaigners from the Enough is Enough group said they were disappointed with the decision but added the judgement provides a "roadmap" for how the upgrade could proceed.
'It's certainly not the end'
Kieran Kennedy, chair of Strabane Business Improvement Districts group, said Monday's judgement was a shock."We in the north west depend on infrastructure to carry goods along the A5 corridor...this is just a severe blow to business in Strabane and the north west in general," he told BBC Radio Foyle's North West Today programme."I think about the families who have lost loved ones. There are obviously going to be more families affected in the future by this judgement."Mr Kennedy said it is now time to "work to try and make sure we get everything lined up, to make sure this road can go ahead."He he it was a set back but "not the end".
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BreakingNews.ie
36 minutes ago
- BreakingNews.ie
‘Brazen' disregard for roads policing needs to be addressed quickly
A 'brazen' disregard for roads policing duties needs to be addressed as quickly as possible, a minister has said. Garda Commissioner Drew Harris said that an unpublished report found gardai showed a 'blatant disregard' for their job while they knew their actions were being reviewed. Advertisement It comes amid a focus on road safety in Ireland, with the government introducing new speed laws and the Garda Commissioner mandating that frontline gardai dedicate 30 minutes of road policing duties per shift. Sean Canney, a junior minister with responsibility for road safety, said the findings were 'shocking' and 'serious'. 'There's no point in us bringing in laws, reducing speed limits, doing all of this kind of thing, if we don't have a functional enforcement section within the gardaí,' he said on RTE Radio. Mr Canney said his thoughts were with the families of the 95 people who had died on Irish roads so far this year. Advertisement He said he had not read the report conducted by the consultancy firm Crowe, which has carried out investigations on behalf of An Garda Siochana previously, but planned to meet the Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan and both the outgoing and incoming Garda Commissioners over the issue. 'I'll be talking to the commissioners to express my deep concern with what is in this report,' he said. He said the independent Crowe report was conducted while the reviewer was 'sitting in the car with a garda that wasn't doing his duty and didn't seem to have a problem with that'. 'So I think there is definitely a serious case to be answered here as quickly as possible.' Advertisement Mr Harris said he commissioned the examination after he received an anonymous report from a whistleblower. The chairwoman of the Policing and Community Safety Authority, Elaine Byrne, said the report was 'shocking' and found some gardai showed a 'blatant disregard' for road policing while they knew their actions were being reviewed. 'They were openly hostile to doing their job,' she said, in what she described as a 'wake-up call' for An Garda Siochana. She also described an issue with fear among Garda managers of carrying out poor performance management, which she said Mr Harris agreed was an issue. Advertisement
Telegraph
12 hours ago
- Telegraph
Nurse backing calls for strikes promotes Corbyn's new party
A socialist nurse who supports Jeremy Corbyn's new hard-Left party is backing the campaign for NHS strikes, The Telegraph can reveal. Harry Eccles, an activist for the campaign group NHS Workers Say No, has said he felt hope at the rise of 'strong striking workers' as the health service faces disruption. The Royal College of Nursing (RCN) is the latest to threaten strike action after rejecting the Government's 3.6 per cent pay rise for 2025-26. Mr Eccles has called for Mr Corbyn's new party to work with the Greens and 'change things together''. Posting on X, he shared a graphic from the new Your Party, set up by Mr Corbyn, which referred to its 600,000 sign-ups as 'impressive'. Just days ago he shared a photograph of himself with Mr Corbyn, wearing a red shirt, and saying 'Jeremy Corbyn didn't run Labour into the ground by pursuing Right-wing policies – that was Starmer'. On the same day, he wished followers a 'Happy Socialist Sunday' and added he could feel hope rising with 'the emergence of a strong Zack led Greens, a mighty Sultana/Corbyn party, and the strong striking workers'. 'Nine out of 10 nurses in England, Wales and Northern Ireland reject pay award' — Harry Eccles (@Heccles94) July 31, 2025 On Thursday, he promoted news that nine out of 10 nurses had rejected the latest pay offer, warning that they would strike if their salary demands were not met. NHS Workers Say No took to X on Thursday afternoon, responding to a message from Wes Streeting, the Health Secretary, referencing strike action, and saying 'Nurses next' alongside an emoji of a raised fist. The RCN said 91 per cent of 170,000 members that voted on this year's pay award had rejected it. Prof Nicola Ranger, who earns more than £200,000 per year to lead the nurses' union, said her colleagues felt 'deeply undervalued, and that is why record numbers are telling the Government to wake up, sense the urgency here and do what's right by them and by patients'. She continued: 'Record numbers have delivered this verdict on a broken system that holds back nursing pay and careers and hampers the NHS,' she said. 'As a safety-critical profession, keeping hold of experienced nursing staff is fundamentally a safety issue and key to the Government's own vision for the NHS. 'To avoid formal escalation, the Government must be true to its word and negotiate on reforms of the outdated pay structure which traps nursing staff at the same band their entire career.' Nurses next ✊ — NHS Workers Say NO! (@NurseSayNO) July 31, 2025 Nurses in Wales and Northern Ireland also voted to reject the pay award. The profession staged its first-ever walkouts over pay in 2022 and 2023, but strike action came to a halt after it was unable to renew its mandate to keep striking when turnout fell below the legal threshold of 50 per cent. Earlier on Thursday, the Telegraph revealed GPs were also considering winter strikes over the NHS plan, which they believe 'threatens the survival' of the current general practice model. Resident doctors, formerly known as junior doctors, ended a five-day walkout on Wednesday morning and have a mandate to strike until the new year. Consultants are currently holding an 'indicative ballot' to assess their appetite to strike. Unions representing other healthcare workers from paramedics to cleaners have also rejected pay awards from the Government.
The Sun
14 hours ago
- The Sun
Starmer wasn't elected to virtue signal on Palestine – it was to fix these very real problems HERE
WHEN Sir Keir Starmer was elected Prime Minister, did anyone remember to tell him which country he was supposed to be running? I only ask because he seems to be blissfully unaware of the fact that he's meant to be in charge of THIS country, the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, and not spending his time pontificating about whether any other country should exist or not. 9 9 9 That would certainly explain why the British PM chose to call an emergency Cabinet meeting this week to discuss an urgent issue of great import which turned out to have nothing to do with this country at all. Instead, after the ministerial meeting, Sir Keir pompously strode to the No10 podium and announced to the world that Britain would recognise a Palestinian state in September, unless Israel agreed to abide by key conditions, such as allowing more food aid into Gaza and signing up to a two-state solution to the Middle East conflict. Let's forget for one moment that the PM was delivering yet another U-turn in a bid to appease his leftie backbenchers. And let's leave to one side the abject immorality and absurdity of placing conditions on Israel while having no requirement that the Hamas terrorists release their remaining hostages and lay down their weapons. Here to lap up free hotels and handouts Let's even ignore the fact that Sir Keir's pledge was so mind-blowingly wrong that it was cheered by Hamas leaders while condemned as 'shameful' by their former hostages, or that it will not save a single life in Gaza or bring about an end to the war one day sooner. Putting ALL of that to one side, the most striking thing about Sir Keir Starmer's announcement was that it wasn't about Britain, the country he is supposedly in charge of. You know, the one he was elected to run, the one where he's supposed to be busy delivering 'change' with a steely-eyed focus on growth. Yes, that one. Yet there was no emergency Cabinet meeting about any of the myriad problems back here in Blighty. Does the Prime Minister really believe there is so little that needs to be done at home? Awkward moment Trump blasts 'nasty' Sadiq Khan for 'terrible job'… before Starmer interrupts: 'He's a friend of mine!' After all, there are no end of items in his 'in-tray' that could merit an emergency Cabinet meeting. He could start with immigration — both legal and illegal. Yet again, we've had new official figures showing that almost all of a 700,000 increase in our population in just one year came not from births but from new arrivals. 9 9 9 And once again we saw boatloads of thousands of illegal migrants, mostly undocumented men of fighting age, coming to our shores to lap up the free hotels, the handouts, the black market jobs and the near-certain promise that they will never be deported. Did Sir Keir and his Cabinet ministers have anything to say about the growing protests outside asylum hotels spreading across the country? Starmer, Angela Rayner and their mates might even want to talk about the cost-of-living crisis still hitting millions of families who face prices, bills and rents going up... And what about having an emergency Cabinet meeting about the rising tide of crime after a report revealed that offences in London have rocketed by 86 per cent in the past ten years under Labour Mayor Sir Sadiq Khan? Didn't ministers wonder why only one in 20 muggings in our capital city ever results in a prosecution? Or why so many grooming gangs have yet to be prosecuted? Or is that just not worth a few minutes of their time during the summer recess? Maybe they might also want to discuss the chaos in our NHS after another five days of strikes by junior doctors, with nurses and GPs likely to follow suit, while millions of patients sit on waiting lists. Starmer, Angela Rayner and their mates might even want to talk about the cost-of-living crisis still hitting millions of families who face prices, bills and rents going up while Chancellor Rachel Reeves takes even more money in taxes out of their hard-earned wages. Indeed, they might want to wonder where all the jobs have gone since the employer National Insurance hike, or why we have millions of people languishing on welfare, many claiming mental health issues, or why hundreds of thousands of children are now routinely absent from school. Tackle the very real problems at home What about an emergency Cabinet meeting to discuss why we are a country where it rains half the year, yet we face hosepipe bans most summers and, despite being an island surrounded by North Sea oil and gas, we have some of the highest energy bills in the world, with the threat of blackouts thanks to the folly of Net Zero? They could even have a chat about why, whether it's planes, trains or automobiles, we can't get anywhere in this country any more thanks to technical failures at air traffic control, or the wrong leaves on the line or the one million-plus potholes on our roads. Frankly, if you can't work out how to fill potholes, run the NHS or stop dinghies crossing the English Channel, I'm not sure why you'd think you're up to solving one of the most intractable conflicts of the past century... Or perhaps they could ponder why we don't have the Armed Forces or the military hardware to defend our own nation, let alone any of our allies, despite the growing instability in the world. Every single one of these issues — and there are countless more — would be worthy of an emergency Cabinet meeting. Yet it is the plight of the Palestinian people that concerns our PM, not that of the people he is supposed to represent. Frankly, if you can't work out how to fill potholes, run the NHS or stop dinghies crossing the English Channel, I'm not sure why you'd think you're up to solving one of the most intractable conflicts of the past century in a far-flung region halfway across the world, but there we are. Someone needs to break it to the Prime Minister that he wasn't elected to virtue signal on the world stage about a nation ABROAD that doesn't yet exist. Instead, he should spend his time doing the job he is paid to do and tackle the very real problems hitting ordinary people AT HOME. 9 9 9
