‘It is wrong' – Ceann Comhairle urged to meet Oireachtas broadcast staff working on ‘contract basis'
He said he was writing on behalf of Fianna Fáil Oireachtas members in relation to the workers' pay and conditions and an upcoming contract review for their employer, PI Communications.
Political pressure has ramped up for the workers who claim some earn around €12,000 a year and have no income during summer and Christmas breaks.
In the letter sent on June 17, Mr McAuliffe said members of the Dáil were asked to sign a petition to support this group of 'essential workers'.
'It seems extraordinary that this group are only employed on a contract basis,' he said.
'It is not as if their work is temporary as it is through their good work that all of the Dáil's deliberations, debate and discussions get communicated to all of the public.
'This is crucial work for every elected representative and goes to the core of our democracy.'
He said it is crucial and 'only fair' that their grievances are addressed as soon as possible.
Mr McAuliffe told the Irish Independent it is up to the Houses of the Oireachtas Commission to make a decision, as it tenders for the service, and the ceann comhairle is the chair.
'I believe it is wrong that these staff are not on the same terms as other who contribute to the parliamentary community, including ushers and catering staff,' he said.
ADVERTISEMENT
A PI Comms spokesperson said it provides a range of video and streaming services to public and private sector organisations of which the Houses of the Oireachtas is one.
He said the company is contracted on a pay per public minute model for coverage of live proceedings and can only bill for broadcasts that are capable of public transmission.
The spokesperson said all part-time employees in this group have a guaranteed entitlement to a fixed amount of work each full sitting week, certainty of income for their contracted work, and are free to work on other projects or for other employers.
He said they earn substantially more than the national living wage, with attractive bonus arrangements, and get paid leave and sick pay.
They are eligible to enrol in pension schemes, have collective agreements that are recognised, and are provided with training and other staff benefits, he added.
'Furthermore, all salaries and payments are regularly benchmarked and are commensurate with roles, skills, experience and responsibilities,' he said.
He said the company is currently engaged in trade union negotiations with the assistance of the Workplace Relations Commission.
'We operate in a very competitive sector and are immensely proud of both the service and value we provide our clients and the access, opportunity and supports we provide to our valued staff, many of whom are also engaged in roles for other employers,' he said.
'We are surprised and disappointed that some who have commented on our operations did not first fact-check the accuracy and veracity of ill-founded claims.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Journal
8 hours ago
- The Journal
Being a first-time TD: 'The hours are mad, if I finish at 9.30pm it feels like a half day'
YESTERDAY WE CAUGHT up with Social Democrats TD Sinéad Gibney on her experience of being a first-time TD, today we hear from the Labour Party's Conor Sheehan. At 32 years of age, the Limerick City TD is one of the youngest representatives in the Dáil. He talks us through the highs and lows, adjusting to hotel living and how he sometimes feels like he's talking to a brick wall. Is life as a TD what you expected? 'In ways it is and in other ways it isn't. I'll never forget the first time I stepped into the Dáil chamber. Sometimes I pinch myself when I'm sitting there during one of the week's set pieces like Leaders' Questions or whatever. 'The thing that struck me was actually how small the chamber is and how small the campus is as well. How often you bump into people the whole time.' Pit and peak Sheehan said he has had 'many highlights' so far. Notably, being on the panel for temporary chairs for the Dáil, which means he is sometimes called on to sit in as chair of the Dáil when Ceann Comhairle Verona Murphy is not available. Other highlights have been working on legislation. 'It's really interesting, you know, doing committee stage in the chamber, and listening to the amendments,' he said. 'The delay in getting committees set up and everything like that was quite frustrating,' Sheehan said, adding that from a legislative perspective, the Dáil really only kicked into business in the last six weeks. He said at the beginning of the term, he felt like a huge amount of the Dáil schedule was dedicated to statements on a variety of topics, a move he feels was done to 'pad' the schedule because there wasn't much legislation coming through from the government. Sheehan said he finds it frustrating at times, as an opposition TD, to see government TDs vote down opposition bills or amendments and instead come back with a reply that is 'generic blather'. 'The thing that really annoys me is when you go in and you do a private member's motion, or you do a debate or whatever, and it's almost like sometimes the minister is coming in to read a pre-prepared reply and isn't actually engaging with you on the substance of the issues you are raising. 'Now, some ministers are better at that than others, but some are very frustrating. You just feel like you're talking to a wall.' Low point? 'The low point for me was all the crap that happened at the start of the year, around the recognition of the technical group and as to whether the [Regional Independents] were in government or opposition. It was totally unnecessary. 'The whole thing was unedifying… I thought it was a waste of everyone's time, and I don't understand why government were so insistent — Like they've created this other members' questions thing at the moment, which is almost like eight minutes of tumbleweed blowing through the Dáil chamber,' Sheehan said. Is there still animosity between the opposition and government since then? 'I think there is some bit of animosity, but I do think that things are thankfully no longer as tense as they were in the early part of the year,' Sheehan said, arguing that this is probably down to the fact the Dáil was busier in its last few weeks. 'Sometimes when you're in a vacuum, things can have a bit of an undue significance.' Advertisement At 32 years of age, Sheehan is one of the youngest TDs in the Dáil. How is he finding the career change from that perspective? 'The first thing I'd say is there are far too few young people in politics, right? 'I would be friendly enough with some of the other younger politicians, there would be people across different parties that I would be very fond of. 'People like Mairéad Farrell in Sinn Féin. She's great. Keira Keogh in Fine Gael, really, really, great. Just decent people that you can talk to about issues. 'There's an awful lot of people who think politics is just constant hand-to-hand combat, but it's actually not like that. An awful lot of the time, you disagree with people on certain things, but you'll agree with them on other things. And I always believe in finding common ground.' On the commute from Limerick, Sheehan opts for the train over driving so that he can get some work done, but he said this means he does a lot of 'pulling and dragging'. 'I'm used to it now, but people always slag me when they see me in Leinster House, because I always have a big, huge suitcase. 'I feel like I should have shares in Irish Rail at this stage. I drove a couple of times, coming down late on a Thursday, leaving Leinster House, snaking onto the Naas Road and just being like uh, when will I actually get home?' Sheehan said what he found tough initially was sleeping in hotels. 'I would go to bed in a hotel and 10 o'clock would become like one or 2 am and I would literally be wide awake in bed and not able to sleep. 'I would just feel out of sorts. Too hot or too cold, or it would be too loud, or I could hear footsteps. All very much first-world problems, but I did find that stuff, until I got into a routine, a bit tough. Whereas now I'm totally used to it.' Another aspect of the gig Sheehan said he finds tough is trying to maintain a healthy diet. 'You're constantly eating on the go, and it's not the most healthy lifestyle in the entire world,' Sheehan said, adding that his diet since becoming a TD has consisted of 'a lot of chips'. 'One of the things I do miss when I'm in Dublin is just being able to cook your dinner. 'Because I'm currently in and out of hotels in Dublin, I suppose I don't get that. But I love the job. It's really been such an enormous honour and privilege.' What I wish I knew Sheehan said the biggest thing any first-time TD has to be careful of is making sure they pace themselves, both mentally and physically. 'The thing about Leinster House is that the working hours are mad. I've often arrived in on a Wednesday morning around 8 am to get maybe an hour's work done before a committee meeting or a briefing at nine, and then I am still there that Wednesday evening at 10 or 11 o'clock at night.' Sheehan said it is rare to finish up any earlier than this on a Tuesday or Wednesday when the Dáil is sitting. 'I remember one Wednesday, about six or eight weeks ago, we got out at twenty past nine, and I felt like I'd had a half day.' Any surprises? 'The amount of people in a similar situation as myself trying to figure everything out. And the amount of decency that's in the Oireachtas.' Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Irish Times
11 hours ago
- Irish Times
Miriam Lord's Dáil end-of-term awards: from cute hoors to rookie errors and good operators
School's out for summer. Some TDs are skipping lightly home with their end-of-term report cards. Others are losing their schoolbags and hoping nobody notices. It's no big thing this year. Continuous assessment is how it goes in politics; and where the class of 2025 is concerned their Dáil and Seanad journeys are just beginning. The general election may have happened last November, but business in both Houses of the Oireachtas only started in January. Business proper took months to get going thanks to the mammoth opening schmozzle over independent deputies who signed up to support the Government muscling in on the Opposition's speaking rights. READ MORE The row derailed Micheál Martin's big day in the Dáil when his election as Taoiseach had to be abandoned amid chaotic scenes in the chamber. The rules were tweaked to allowed these independents, along with government backbenchers, a chance to table questions to the Taoiseach directly after the Opposition's slot. The controversy, which considerably delayed the working of the Dáil, has blown over for now, although the backbenchers and independents attempts at grilling the Boss have been such a damp squib one has to wonder why they bothered making such a fuss about it in the first place. Most unexpected controversy award went to skorts. Here Sinn Féin Oireachtas members stand in solidarity with camogie players who had called for the right to choose between shorts and skorts when playing. Photograph: Sinn Féin But this episode will be not forgotten by the Opposition. Unlike most of the term which followed. Just seven Bills have been enacted this year. That first one was a vital piece of emergency legislation, nobody said. It allowed the Government to increase the number of Junior Ministers on its books to mob proportions and festoon five of its domesticated independents with Super Junior status. The committees are only getting into their stride now. The sluggish start didn't give politicians much of a chance to shine. Much of the new intake barely got a look-in. Maybe some of them might have the makings of a report card by the end of the year. In the meantime, here's a few who made it on to the summer prizegiving list for their performance so far. Top of the class: Jim O'Callaghan Traditionally, this tends to go to a party leader. But none them has had a stellar start. The politician who has stood out in what has not been a particularly competitive field so far is Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan . He has proved the most proactive member of Cabinet so far, he doesn't tend to waffle and his Dáil performances have been measured and conciliatory. Minister for Health Jennifer Carroll MacNeill is a close second in a very difficult portfolio. Best senator: Michael McDowell He's been at this politics lark forever now and maybe there are other Seanad performers who deserve a look in, but Michael McDowell has had a great term. Still busy on the legislative front, still the best speaker in the Upper House and still happily batting away the bouquets from people who want him to run for president. He was first senator elected to the 27th Seanad, topping the poll in the National University constituency. No wonder he's been padding contentedly around the Leinster House campus, smiling like a Chesire Cat. Opposition best boy: Alan Kelly The former Labour leader is full of beans these days and when he isn't asking probing questions about Garda accountability (he seems to have a terrific source or two), he's happy out chairing the showbiz Committee on Arts, Media, Communications, Culture and Sport. Deputy leader of the Labour Party Alan Kelly is the standout Opposition figure. Photograph: Stephen Collins/Collins Guaranteed a few headlines there and AK-47 isn't going to miss them. Opposition best girl: Jennifer Whitmore The Social Democrat TD for Wicklow is more low-key than best boy Kelly, but that's not a bad thing. Jennifer is consistently good with her contributions across a range of issues and her Leaders' Questions clash with constituency colleague and Tánaiste Simon Harris on the last day of term showed she can mix it with the best of them as she called out a Government of 'epic wasters', which was 'reckless and feckless' with a giveaway budget before the election, but was now 'moralising' about financial restraint. Another Opposition TD who doesn't go in for showboating is Sinn Féin's Pat Buckley (Cork East) who is very considered and thoughtful in his contributions, particularly on social issues. Fianna Fáil's occasionally difficult backbencher, John McGuinness, also had an excellent term. He was elected Leas-Cheann Comhairle and had the satisfaction of hearing the State apology to Lucia O'Farrell, who had long campaigned for the truth surrounding the death of her son Shane, who was killed by a driver out on bail. McGuinness was one of Lucia's staunchest allies all through the years when most TDs had moved on. Cutest hoor in class: Micheál Martin/Michael Lowry This is a tie between Micheál Martin and the independent deputy formerly known (by the Taoiseach) as the disgraced TD for Tipperary North, Michael Lowry . Hard to imagine that Micheál once told the Dáil that Michael was not fit to be a member of that august house after the Moriarty tribunal found that Lowry, a former Fine Gael minister, attempted to help businessman Denis O'Brien secure the State's second mobile phone licence in 1995. This didn't stop the Taoiseach striking a deal with Lowry and his group of Regional Independent TDs who became, in the words of Mary Lou McDonald, 'the wobbly leg of the Coalition stool'. Taoiseach Micheál Martin struck a smart deal with independent TDs. Photograph: Dara Mac Dónaill Micheál bagged a cohort of supporters with benefits who will remain loyal once they are minded, further cementing his government's grip on power. As he will probably bow out at the next election, if not before, the Lowry stroke won't come back to bite him. As to the kingmaker formerly known as the disgraced deputy for Tipperary North, he's thrilled with himself. He couldn't look happier if he was giving the two fingers to that Dublin socialist, Paul Murphy. Mr Congeniality: Cian O'Callaghan The acting Social Democrat leader never seemed comfortable with the tricky situation surrounding prodigal TD Eoin Hayes, who pulled off a shock victory for the party in Dublin Bay South only to be exiled from the parliamentary party for misleading colleagues over when he got rid of shares he held in a company with links to the Israeli military. On one of the many occasions Cian was asked about the party's on-off relationship with Eoin (he came in very handy for ballast when they needed an extra body for committee appointments), he declared awkwardly: 'I said hello to Eoin just last week.' Happily, word came through on Friday that the suspension has been lifted. They have killed the fatted calf and now they can all say hello to each other whenever they want now. Prizes for honesty and courage: Minister of State and Chief Whip Mary Butler and Sinn Féin senator Nicole Ryan During statements on Pride Week, Mary was one of many TDs to speak on the subject. But as it was the penultimate day of the Dáil term, those statements got very little attention. The Fianna Fáil TD for Waterford said she was speaking not only as a minister, 'but as a proud mother, ally and advocate for the full inclusion of LGBTQ+ people in Irish life. I am especially proud of who I am and who my family is. My son is a transgender young man and seeing him grow into his own identity reminds me daily of the urgent need for compassion, dignity and fairness in public policy. 'Sometimes the debate in relation to trans issues rages on social media without facts or understanding. It can be very hurtful. We should all reject those nasty opinions from people who do not understand the hurt and pain for young trans people who have to navigate a difficult enough pathway in their lives.' Sinn Féin's Nicole Ryan won plaudits for speaking out in the Seanad about domestic violence. Photograph: Sam Boal/Collins Cork-based senator Nicole Ryan was loudly applauded by her colleagues in the Upper House for her moving contribution during a debate on the Domestic Violence Bill. She told how she witnessed domestic abuse as a child, living in a violent home from the age of four to seven. 'As a child, when you're developing through that stage, it shapes how you see the world' she said. 'For two decades, I lived in the shadow of shame.' She learned how to read people. 'I would know the kind of mood that he'd be in by the way that his foot crossed the threshold of the front door.' Her mother escaped, 'but none of us got out unscathed'. Senator Ryan said she was sharing her story 'to stand up for all the other young children that are out there that are living in these homes'. Best gaffe: Darragh O'Brien The Minister for Transport wowed all the guests at the British Ambassador's summer garden party with a lovely speech made all the more enjoyable by the many nice things he had to say about his friend Jonathan, His Majesty's envoy to Ireland. Except that the ambassador's name is Paul. Second place in this highly contested category is Sinn Féin's Pearse Doherty, for delivering a high-decibel, passionate speech in the Dáil about rip-off grocery prices, fulminating about Irish-owned grocery chain SuperValu being owned by a major American food distribution company. He was one of three SF speakers who made the same mistake, having been fed the wrong information in their supplied scripts. Most unexpected controversy: skorts The row over allowing elite camogie players to choose between wearing shorts or skorts ended up in the Dáil. Minister of State Charlie McConalogue had to deal with it. 'It is important that they come together to find a resolution that is comfortable for everyone,' he wittered, oblivious to the reason why the athletes rebelled in the first place. Most unexpected venue for the launch of a presidential campaign: The High Court Michael Flatley's declared intention to run for the Áras was revealed by his barrister during a High Court case the choreographer has taken in relation to works carried out at his Castlehyde mansion in Co Cork. Flatley is even going to move back to Ireland in the coming weeks to push for a nomination. Rookie error prize for thinking out loud: James Lawless As he confidently breezed through a radio interview with RTÉ's Justin McCarthy at the end of June, the Minister for Higher Education addressed the one-off cash support which students heading to college had enjoyed for the last three years. To fee, or not to fee, that is the question. Well, James? He revealed that student fees 'as things stand' were likely to go up by a whopping €1,000. Chaos ensued. It could have been worse for James as angry constituents piled around the country with complaints about higher fees. But when Fine Gael began muttering about the increase, pressure eased on the Kildare North TD. Amid talk of a rift between the two coalition parties, the FF deputies circled the wagons around James and rallied to his defence. (Even if they were privately raging.)
Irish Examiner
16 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Paul Hosford: Public patience has limits — especially when their tax cut is on the line
Like Christmas, it feels like the budget comes around earlier every year. Part of that is the fallow summer period during which the idle hands of the country's political journalists are searching for work. Without the day-to-day Punch and Judy show of the Dáil, there has to be a focus somewhere, though ask ministers at doorsteps and press conferences about the budget any time pre-August, and you will find them rolling their eyes to heaven and asking has it gotten earlier this year and repeating a mantra about the "budgetary process". Given that much of the mid-summer choreography focuses on the summer economic statement and the release of the Tax Strategy Group papers, it is no wonder that those idle hands drift towards budget speculation. This year, the focus has started early on one key issue, not just because it is being speculated upon, but because its actual merit is being discussed, which is novel at least. Usually, budget measures are seen as something of a fait d'accompli and in recent, more prosperous, times everything was on the table because everything was possible within reason. Of course, there were competing interests, but with huge economic surpluses the last government was well able to cater to everyone even a little. However, while Tuesday's announcement of the summer economic statement brought with it news of another surplus, there is a serious question about how it is going to be deployed. Contained in the document was the news that the overall tax package in the October 7 budget is due to be around €1.5bn. Over a billion and a half euro to spend solely on cutting taxes is the stuff of dreams for many governments and one to which this coalition has become quite accustomed. Where does the money go? Last year's €1.6bn income tax package was aimed squarely at low- and middle-income earners with the main tax credits; the personal employee and earned income tax credits increased by €125. On top of that, the standard rate cut-off point was increased to €44,000 and the USC was cut to 3%. Across the board, there were increases in carer tax credits, in credits for renters, in benefit in kind, in capital acquisitions and and with it an extension of mortgage interest tax relief. This year, however, the landscape is somewhat different. With €1.5bn to play with, the Government has already tacitly pledged a large chunk of that away. While a commitment to cut the Vat rate for the hospitality sector is not in the programme for government, despite what some have said this week, it was agreed as part of government formation talks and was taken as a win by Fine Gael, which had pushed hard for the reduced rate. The problem with the reduced rate for restaurants and hotels comes with its costs. In the Tax Strategy Group papers published on Thursday, the authors outlined that cutting the Vat rate for the hospitality sector, including pubs, restaurants, hotels, and hairdressers, would cost €867m per year. While that is lower than the estimated figure put out by finance minister Paschal Donohoe of between €950m and a billion euro, it is a sizable chunk of the tax package available to the government in just two-and-a-half months. Political and social choices On Tuesday, as the government announced a €30bn capital plan alongside the summer economic statement, which warned of moderated spending, it was put to Mr Donohoe that the commitment to one industry could come at a cost to workers. This he accepted, but said that every budgetary decision comes with trade-offs. While the idea of sacrificing tax cuts for workers in order to aid one specific industry is an argument which has been carried out all week, it was refreshing to hear Mr Donohoe say explicitly that the budget is a mechanism of political and social choice. Too often it has been framed as a winners and losers argument, but what it is in actuality is an argument of priority, a statement of intent and the positioning of where we are at any given moment. It is a series of political choices, not a mere shopping list. In a radio debate on Wednesday, economist Barra Roantree argued against a blanket Vat cut, saying that the biggest beneficiaries would be the biggest chains. Why, he questioned, should McDonald's get a Vat cut at a time when its profits have jumped almost 17%? The counterargument, of course, is that the real beneficiary of a cut is the customer. It will come as no surprise that the cost of eating out has risen alongside the cost of food in supermarkets. In my house we use the crudely designed and implemented Spice Bag Index. Through the miracle of food delivery apps keeping receipts, we are able to track the cost of a spice bag in our local Chinese in the years since we bought our home. In that seven-year stretch, the price has jumped from €6.40 to €10.20, though it must be said that the quality remains excellent. There is no question that hospitality, like every other industry, is facing a crunch. The sector has come through covid lockdowns only to face rising costs, constrained supply lines, and a public less willing or able to spend money on entertainment. Divisions But hearing Fianna Fáil junior minister Niall Collins on radio this week saying that he did not believe a blanket cut in the Vat rate was justified, while Fine Gael's enterprise minister Peter Burke "unequivocally" backed it, shows that there will be friction in the run-up to the budget on the issue. Government sources questioned on Thursday whether Mr Collins had gone on something of a solo run given that he had somewhat contradicted his party leader Taoiseach Micheál Martin on the issue. But those in government who want to see the cut in the books that Jack Chambers and Paschal Donohoe hold up on the steps of Government Buildings in 10 weeks, might be minded to listen to the message of Mr Collins. Speaking to Limerick's Live 95, Mr Collins said that there was no evidence that a previous reduction in the Vat rate to 9% was "actually passed on to the consumer" and that there was price gouging in the sector. While the budget will lay out a statement of priorities, the passage and success of this particular measure will depend on public buy-in. Convincing stretched middle-income earners to forego tax cuts, which would put somewhere in the region of €75 a month back in their pockets in favour of an industry which many believe has been too expensive for too long will require some finesse in its messaging. While the row has focused on the differing opinions of coalition partners, the consumer has been left out of the discussion. If the Government is faced with a list of choices that are broken down into binary winners and losers, the average person will always choose to win. But if a Vat cut can be sold as a net good for employment, for tax take and for those who just wish to eat out once a month, then it has a chance of resonating with the public. Simply telling members of the public that businesses are a Vat cut away from viability is not a communications strategy, because it doesn't hold up to any scrutiny. If the public sees nearly €700 million spent, they will want to know what's in it for them, be it affordability or the greater good. Otherwise, it will be back to splitting a €10.20 spice bag. Read More Government to invest €102bn in infrastructure by 2030 under revised National Development Plan
