logo
Consumption tax cut not a given even after Upper House election

Consumption tax cut not a given even after Upper House election

Japan Times2 days ago
A consumption tax cut that was such a pivotal issue in Sunday's Upper House election is not a foregone conclusion given the political realities of a minority government and the economic realities of Japan, some analysts say.
In the historic vote, the Liberal Democratic Party-Komeito coalition lost its majority and now controls neither house of parliament, although it still has the Cabinet.
It has stood firmly against lowering the consumption tax — which is currently set at 10% for most items and 8% for food and beverages — while most opposition parties have called for a reduction of the tax or simply abolishing it.
The problem for the opposition parties is that they might not be able to agree on enough to be effective against a coalition that remains the largest bloc in both houses despite lacking a majority.
'It's probably quite difficult for them to find common ground,' Tomohisa Ishikawa, chief economist at the Japan Research Institute, said of the opposition.
Markets may also make consumption tax cuts difficult.
Investors were already rattled ahead of the election, in part on the possibility that government revenues could take a hit with the implementation of policies pushed by the opposition.
The yield on 30-year Japanese government bonds surged to a record 3.2% last week, and that on 20-year JGBs hit the highest level since November 1999. Bond prices move inversely to yields.
"I believe the recent rise in the yield on superlong-term bonds was a sign that Japan's fiscal risks were being taken more seriously,' said Daiju Aoki, regional chief investment officer at UBS SuMi Trust Wealth Management.
Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba stood firm on his stance against the tax cuts right up through election day on concerns about the fiscal stability of the country.
'If we were to implement such a policy, how would we secure funding for social welfare programs?' he said Sunday.
While pressure on the government to spend more will undoubtedly increase post-election, Aoki said a tax cut may be implemented in a way that won't seriously hurt fiscal soundness.
'By teaming up with parties against a massive government bond issuance, the LDP and Komeito can still form a majority,' he said.
Virtually all opposition parties stress the need for a consumption tax cut, but details are different.
The Constitutional Democratic Party of Japan (CDP), which is the largest opposition party and is led by former Prime Minister Yoshihiko Noda, is looking to make food nontaxable for one year.
Noda, who is considered to be on the side of fiscal discipline, said his party would only advocate a consumption tax cut that's fully funded and not dependent on bond issuance.
The LDP and Komeito could work with the CDP to minimize the fiscal risk, if a consumption tax cut really becomes a policy option, Aoki said.
'In that sense, there might be some short-term volatility, but if the bond market recognizes that there won't be a massive tax cut, I think this will help curb an excessive rise of long-term rates," he said.
Pro-fiscal spending parties remain popular, and this does add an element of uncertainty.
The Democratic Party for the People (DPP) won 17 seats on Sunday and now has 22. It has said that tax relief can be backed by issuing government bonds. The DPP hopes to temporarily lower the consumption tax rate on all products to 5% until real wages start rising again.
Sanseito, which significantly increased its presence by winning 14 seats, advocates eventually abolishing the consumption tax altogether, saying the government can issue bonds to finance the policy. Reiwa Shinsengumi and the Japanese Communist Party have also proposed scrapping the consumption tax.
Nippon Ishin no Kai plans to reduce the 8% tax on food to zero for two years.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Tokyo stocks end up over 3% at 1-year highs on Japan-US tariff deal
Tokyo stocks end up over 3% at 1-year highs on Japan-US tariff deal

The Mainichi

time44 minutes ago

  • The Mainichi

Tokyo stocks end up over 3% at 1-year highs on Japan-US tariff deal

TOKYO (Kyodo) -- Tokyo stocks' key indexes ended up over 3 percent at one-year highs on Wednesday after Japan and the United States reached a trade deal with 15 percent U.S. tariffs on autos and other products, lower than initially proposed by President Donald Trump. The market was further lifted by investors hoping for a new Japanese government as Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba's resignation is viewed as inevitable, following the major setback for the governing coalition in Sunday's House of Councillors election. The 225-issue Nikkei Stock Average advanced 1,396.40 points, or 3.51 percent, from Tuesday to 41,171.32, its highest level since July 16, 2024. The broader Topix index finished 90.19 points, or 3.18 percent, higher at 2,926.38. All industry sectors advanced on the top-tier Prime Market, with gainers led by transportation equipment, bank and metal product issues. The U.S. dollar briefly weakened to the lower 146 yen range in Tokyo as the Japan-U.S. trade deal helped ease concerns over the prospects for the Japanese economy, boosting the yen. But the U.S. currency later strengthened to the lower 147 yen level at one point as the yen was sold on worries that Japan's financial health may deteriorate further due to fiscal expansion measures that could be adopted in the future, dealers said. Such concerns sent long-term interest rates sharply higher. The yield on the benchmark 10-year Japanese government bond hit 1.600 percent, the highest level since October 2008. Stocks rose across the board, with auto shares surging after Tokyo and Washington agreed that U.S. tariff on automobiles, imposed since April, will be cut to 15 percent from 27.5 percent for Japanese cars. "Since the Japan-U.S. tariff negotiations had been expected to be prolonged, the market reacted positively as the trade deal was announced relatively soon after the national election" on Sunday, said Masahiro Ichikawa, chief market strategist at Sumitomo Mitsui DS Asset Management Co.

Japanese Prime Minister Ishiba reiterates intention to stay in office
Japanese Prime Minister Ishiba reiterates intention to stay in office

NHK

time44 minutes ago

  • NHK

Japanese Prime Minister Ishiba reiterates intention to stay in office

Japanese Prime Minister Ishiba Shigeru has reiterated his intention to remain in office despite his ruling bloc's defeat in Sunday's Upper House election. Ishiba spoke to reporters on Wednesday after meeting with some of his predecessors at the Liberal Democratic Party headquarters in Tokyo. He said he was joined by LDP Secretary-General Moriyama Hiroshi in talks with former prime ministers Aso Taro, Suga Yoshihide and Kishida Fumio. He said they shared a strong sense of crisis and agreed that the party should never become divided. Ishiba denied media reports that he will resign. He said he cannot afford to create a political vacuum as he must respond quickly to challenges to his policies.

Ishiba lauds tariff deal with U.S. as result of 'strong efforts'
Ishiba lauds tariff deal with U.S. as result of 'strong efforts'

Asahi Shimbun

timean hour ago

  • Asahi Shimbun

Ishiba lauds tariff deal with U.S. as result of 'strong efforts'

Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba fields questions from reporters at the prime minister's office after U.S. President Donald Trump announced an agreement on tariff negotiations with Japan on July 23. (Takeshi Iwashita) Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba touted the Japan-U.S. tariff agreement, emphasizing the achievement reached after long negotiations, and pledging to meet with U.S. President Donald Trump if needed. Regarding the 15 percent tariffs on automobiles and reciprocal tariffs, Ishiba told reporters on July 23, 'This is the lowest figure to date among countries with trade surpluses with the United States.' He also noted that the Japanese side did not lower tariffs on agricultural and other products imported from the United States. 'This is the result of our consistent advocacy and strong efforts to reach out to the United States,' he said. As for whether he would meet with Trump in the future, the prime minister said, 'If necessary, we will have talks by phone or in person.' Regarding whether he will remain in office following the LDP-led coalition's loss of the majority in the Upper House on July 20, Ishiba said, 'I can't make a statement without carefully examining the details of the (tariff) agreement.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store