Polytech boss launches withering attack on government
In an interview with the Otago Daily Times , the polytechnic's executive director, Megan Potiki, was withering in her criticism of the government.
Topics she covered included Vocational Education Minister Penny Simmonds' failure to respond requests for meetings and her belief Otago Polytechnic had been singled out for the worst treatment of any institution in the government's shake-up of the sector.
Her interview comes as the polytechnic undergoes two separate but simultaneous restructures — one affecting management; the other general staff — and grapples with the fact it has been placed into a federation with the Open Polytechnic and Universal College of Learning rather than being independent.
"It feels like we have had completely different treatment to everyone else, it's been utterly unfair.
"What was [Ms Simmonds'] understanding to get to this point where she decided that others were going to stand up that were clearly similar to us or worse, in some cases?
"We have had no conversation with her about us going into a federation, it was a complete surprise."
Dr Potiki likened the situation to "building a ship while we're actually sailing" because the minister had not met her to explain how the federation model would actually work.
Otago Polytechnic had one of the highest degree completion rates in the country, and placing it in a federation with Open Polytechnic could drag down its reputation, she said.
"Not to be disrespectful to the Open Polytech, but they've got very low completion of degrees.
"There's a risk of being dragged down to the lowest common denominator. If our stake in the ground is that we have exceptional learning and great learning outcomes for our akonga and our community, why would we want to put that at risk?"
Dr Potiki said Otago Polytechnic's management and staff "bled blue and gold" — and she had been impressed by the community response to its troubles.
"We've re-engaged stakeholders and we had a really successful stakeholder meeting the other night with about nearly 80 people and we've got community people who have reached out who care and we're wanting to engage them as well."
Dr Potiki said among the institutions to have received better treatment was Invercargill-based Southern Institute of Technology, which was allowed to stand alone.
"SIT leadership reached out because, actually, I have a really good relationship with them through Te Pūkenga ... so those are relationships I don't want to burn.
"We want to have continued strong relationships in the South Island with all polytechnics. But the minister has muddied the waters."
Dr Potiki acknowledged staff would be getting mixed messages in recent times about their future.
"We're receiving mixed messages from government.
"We just want more clarity and a path for us.
"What we're asking staff to consider now is, unfortunately, they've been through this before, and nothing happens quickly."
The nature of the funding model of polytechnics meant "reviews" of staff could happen annually.
"It's good practice. I think that's part of something that staff need to understand.
"But actually, we want to look at our vision, our values, our future and get to that point. We haven't had the chance to really do that. So there's a lot of good work to come."
Ms Simmonds said supporting Otago Polytechnic to achieve a surplus was critical.
"With the support of a soon to be appointed Establishment Advisory Group (EAG), I am sure Otago Polytechnic will continue to progress along their financial viability pathway. At that stage, they would not require the support of the Federation if they did not wish to use it."
She had met Dr Potiki on several occasions and "was committed to continuing open and constructive engagement".
"The federation approach avoids the drawbacks of the centralised, one-size-fits-all model of Te Pūkenga and instead supports regional polytechnics to thrive, while offering the option to access system-wide efficiencies through the Federation."
matthew.littlewood@odt.co.nz
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
a day ago
- RNZ News
Nobby Clark not impressed by brother's surprise mayoral bid
Invercargill Mayor Nobby Clark is not supporting his younger brother's bid for the job. Photo: RNZ / REECE BAKER Invercargill mayor Nobby Clark is not backing his brother's attempt to take over his job when he finishes up this election. Nelson-based Andrew Clark is running for mayor in the southern city while simultaneously standing for Tasman district mayor. Up there, he is running as Maxwell Clark. The move has irked big brother Nobby, who is finishing up as mayor after just one term at the helm. "I do not support my brother's nomination," mayor Clark told Local Democracy Reporting. "Why is he using Andrew and not using his known name (Maxwell) - while he is also standing for the Tasman mayoralty for the fifth time?" Andrew Clark said he told Nobby he was running for mayor on Thursday after his nomination went in. He hadn't said anything earlier because he didn't want to rely on "connections". It could be difficult to get hold of Nobby, he said, and he didn't want to overload him in light of recent health issues. Andrew Clark, who also goes by middle name Maxwell, is standing for mayor at opposite ends of the South Island. Photo: Supplied The Invercargill mayor was hospitalised in late June following a minor stroke. Andrew wasn't sure why his brother hadn't taken the news well, but said the two were conversing. "I think there's a lot of stresses and strains in his life," he said. As for Invercargill, Andrew said he had been there "a few times" and would move down if successful. "I have a belief that ratepayers should come front and centre, and as a mayor I would treat the public's money in the same way I treat my own - carefully, intentionally and with accountability." The mayoral hopeful is not completely unfamiliar to council. At a June 2024 meeting, he surprised elected members by making his way to the table mid-meeting to introduce himself and thank them for being supportive in a time of need. Mayor Clark was under fire at the time for a code of conduct matter relating to comments he'd made at a private event a few months earlier. LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.
Scoop
a day ago
- Scoop
New Caledonia's Oldest Pro-Independence Party Denounces 'Bougival' Deal
, Correspondent French Pacific Desk New Caledonia's oldest pro-independence party, the Union Calédonienne (UC), on Thursday officially rejected a political agreement signed in Paris last month. The text, bearing the signatures of all of New Caledonia's political parties represented at the local Congress, a total of 18 leaders, both pro-France and pro-independence, is described as a "project" for an agreement that would shape New Caledonia's political future. Since it was signed in the city of Bougival (West of Paris) on 12 July, after ten days of intense negotiations, it has been dubbed a "bet on trust" and has been described by French Minister for Overseas Manuel Valls as a commitment from all signing parties to report to their respective bases and explain its contents. The Bougival document involves a series of measures and recognition by France of New Caledonia as a "State" which could become empowered with its own international relations and foreign affairs, provided they do not contradict France's key interests. It also envisages a double citizenship - French and New Caledonian - provided future New Caledonian citizens are French nationals in the first place. It also describes a future devotion of stronger powers for each of the three provinces (North, South and Loyalty Islands), especially in terms of tax collection. Since it was published, the document, bearing a commitment to defend the text "as is", was hailed as "innovative" and "historic". New Caledonia's leaders have started to hold regular meetings - sometimes daily - and sessions with their respective supporters and militants, mostly to explain the contents of what they have signed. The meetings were held by most pro-France parties and within the pro-independence camp, the two main moderate parties, UPM (Union Progressiste en Mélanésie) and PALIKA (Kanak Liberation Party). Over the past two weeks, all of these parties have strived to defend the agreement, which is sometimes described as a Memorandum of Agreement or a roadmap for future changes in New Caledonia. Most of the leaders who have inked the text have also held lengthy interviews, in explanation mode, with local media. Parties who have unreservedly pledged their support to and have signed the Bougival document are: on the pro-France side, Les Loyalistes, Rassemblement-LR, Wallisian-based Eveil océanien and Calédonie ensemble and on the pro-independence side, UNI-FLNKS (which comprises UPM and PALIKA). But one of the main components of the pro-independence movement, the FLNKS (Kanak and Socialist National Liberation Front) and its main pillar, the Union Calédonienne, have held a series of meetings at different levels, indicating their resentment of their negotiators signing the contested document. UC held its executive committee on 21 July, its steering committee on 26 July, and FLNKS convened its political bureau on 23 July. A 'lure of sovereignty' All of these meetings concluded in an increasingly clear rejection of the Bougival document. Speaking at a news conference on Thursday in Nouméa, UC leaders made it clear that they "formally reject" the agreement because, in their view, it is a "lure of sovereignty" and does not guarantee neither real sovereignty nor political balance. FLNKS chief negotiator Emmanuel Tjibaou, who is also UC's chair, told local reporters he understood his signature on the document meant a commitment to return to New Caledonia, explain the text and obtain the approval of the political base. "I didn't have a mandate to sign a political agreement, my mandate was to register the talks and bring them back to our people so that a decision can be didn't mean an acceptance on our part", he said, mentioning a "temporary" document subject to further discussions. Tjibaou said some amendments his delegation had put on the table in Bougival "went missing" in the final text. 'Bougival, it's over' "As far as we're concerned, Bougival, it's over", UC vice-president Mickaël Forrest said. He said the time was now to move onto a "post-Bougival phase". Meanwhile, the FLNKS also consulted its own "constitutionalists" to obtain legal advice and interpretation on the document. In a release associated with Thursday's media conference, UC states that the Bougival text cannot be regarded as a balance between two visions, but rather a way of "maintaining New Caledonia French". The text, UC said, has led the political dialogue into a "new impasse" and it leaves several questions unanswered. "With the denomination of a 'State', a fundamental law (a de facto Constitution), the capacity to self-organise, an international recognition, this document is perceived as a project for an agreement to integrate (New Caledonia) into France under the guise of a decolonisation". "But the FLNKS has never accepted a status of autonomy within France, but an external decolonisation by means of accession to full sovereignty (which) grants us the right to choose our inter-dependencies", the release states. The pro-independence party also criticises plans to enlarge the list of persons entitled to vote at New Caledonia's local elections, the very issue that triggered deadly and destructive riots in May 2024. It is also critical of a proposed mechanism that would require a vote at the Congress with a minimum majority of 64 percent (two thirds) before any future powers can be requested for transfer from France to New Caledonia. Assuming that current population trends and a fresh system of representation at the Congress will allow more representatives from the Southern province (about three quarters of New Caledonia's population), UC said "in other words, it would be the non-independence (camp) who will have the power to authorise us -or not- to ask for our sovereignty". They party confirmed that it had "formally rejected the Bougival project of agreement as it stands" following a decision made by its steering committee on 26 July "Since the fundamentals of our struggle and the principles of decolonisation are not there". Negotiators no longer mandated The decision also means that every member of its negotiating team who signed the document on 12 July is now de facto demoted and no longer mandated by the party, until a new negotiating team is appointed, if required. "Union Calédonienne remains mobilised to arrive at a political agreement that takes into account the achievement of a trajectory towards full sovereignty". On Tuesday, FLNKS president Christian Téin, as an invited guest of Corsica's "Nazione" pro-independence movement, told French media he declared himself "individually against" the Bougival document, adding this was "far from being akin to full sovereignty". Téin said that during the days that lead to the signing of the document in Bougival "the pressure" exerted on negotiators was "terrible". He said the result was that due to "excessive force" applied by "France's representatives", the final text's content "looks like it is the French State and right-wing people who will decide the (indigenous) Kanak people's future". Facing crime-related charges, Téin is awaiting his trial, but was released from jail, under the condition that he does not return to New Caledonia. The leader of a CCAT (field action coordinating cell) created by Union Calédonienne late 2023 to protest against a proposed French Constitutional amendment to alter voters' rules of eligibility at local elections, was jailed for one year in mainland France, but was elected President of FLNKS in absentia late August 2024. CCAT, meanwhile, was admitted as one of the new components of FLNKS. In a de facto split, the two main moderate pillars of FLNKS, UPM and PALIKA, at the same time, distanced themselves from the pro-independence UC-dominated platform, materialising a rift within the pro-independence umbrella. The FLNKS is scheduled to hold an extraordinary meeting on 9 August 2025 (it was initially scheduled to be held on 2 August), to "highlight the prospects of the pursuit of dialogue through a repositioning of the pro-independence movement's political orientations". Valls: 'I'm not giving up' Reacting to the latest UC statements, Valls told French media he called UC "on a great sense of responsibility". "If tomorrow there was to be no agreement, it would mean the future, hope, would be put into question. Investment, including for the nickel mining industry, would no longer be possible." "I'm not giving up. Union Calédonienne has chosen to reject, as it stands, the Bougival accord project. I take note of this, but I profoundly regret this position." "An institutional void would be a disaster for [New Caledonia]. It would be a prolonged uncertainty, the risk of further instability, the return of violence," he said. "But my door is not closed and I remain available for dialogue at all times. Impasse is not an option." Valls said the Bougival document was "'neither someone's victory on another one, nor an imposed text: it was build day after day, with partners around the table, following months of long discussions." In a recent letter specifically sent to Union Calédonienne, the French former Prime Minister suggested the creation of an editorial committee to start drafting future-shaping documents for New Caledonia, such as its "fundamental law", akin to a Constitution for New Caledonia. Valls also stressed France's financial assistance to New Caledonia, which last year totalled around €3 billion because of the costs associated to the May 2024 riots. The riots caused 14 dead, hundreds of injured and an estimated financial cost of more than €2 billion in material damage.
Newsroom
a day ago
- Newsroom
Last-minute rush of local election nominations not enough to fill all seats
Analysis: It's mayhem at the offices of Ltd and Election Services Ltd on Friday morning, as the two council election providers process late-landing nominations for local government elections. Christchurch-based Electionz is running the postal ballots for 47 territorial authorities and eight regional councils. The stress is palpable in the voice of harried electoral officer Warwick Lampp. It's just two hours from the midday deadline for nominations, and 'I'm busy', he says. 'There's plenty of candidates coming in.' Are there as many as last time? Are there enough candidates to fill the empty positions on councils and community boards? 'We're too busy to be worrying about that at this point in time,' he says. 'I've got two hours to go. My phone's going nuts all the time.' There's a similar final day rush at Election Services in Auckland, which is running the elections for 23 councils. But Dale Ofsoske, the veteran chief electoral officer and managing director, finds a few quick minutes for Newsroom, and checks the numbers. With two hours to go, he tells me, they have 1250 candidates – that's down on the 1490 they had in 2022. Some councils won't have enough candidates for the available governing body and board positions, he says – though we are at least tracking to have a full slate of mayors. As the deadline approached, the election firms hadn't yet published any nominations from Dunedin mayor Jules Radich or Kawerau mayor Faylene Tunui – though both had been expected to seek re-election. At 10am today, Gisborne mayor Rehette Stoltz was still unopposed, and on track to keep the chains without requiring a vote. So too David Moore in Ōpōtiki, and Marie Black in Hurunui. In Kawerau, locals expected Tunui (who was unopposed in 2022) would dash off a nomination at the last minute, but weren't 100 percent sure – and Tunui wasn't answering her phone. For now, the only mayoral candidate is councillor Carolyn Ion, but she's taking nothing for granted. 'All you can do is put your application in – your 150 words, your mug shot, all of that – then wait for midday and see who else is in.' (Update, Friday 1.20pm: Radich and Tunui both confirm they have lodged their nomination forms, and are seeking reelection to their towns' mayoralties). Ion agrees, nomination numbers appear low in Kawerau and nationwide. 'It's tough out there. It's a hard place to be, and you've got to have thick skin, to be in local government for your communities.' It underscores the real problem with engagement and participation in local government – and I'm told that's been made worse by the way the Government has hung them out to dry in the past 12 months. They've been accused by the PM of wasteful spending; Local Government Minister Simon Watts has told them to stick to the basics: roads, water and rubbish. Of course, average rates rises of 12.2 percent last year are impossible to accept or justify. Even those mayors and councillors who voted for them agree. But they claim they had no alternative, with their borrowing capacity maxed out and increasing costs imposed on them by inflation, insurance and central government. It's a vicious downward spiral. Without enough good candidates, and without real engagement in local politics, councils will struggle to get people out to vote. And if they don't vote, they're less likely to feel any ownership of decisions. Ion encourages anyone still dithering, their finger poised on the send key of their nomination form in the final hour, to go for it. 'It's for the good of the place. You've got to have some skin in the game. You've got to stick up for your community. Otherwise, I think we'll just be bulldozed.' Kawerau should know. Its population of fewer than 8000 people, in a district that you can walk across in 20 minutes, has been fighting for survival as its mills close. And there's increased talk of amalgamating with other councils in the eastern Bay of Plenty, like Whakatane. The struggle finding more than one person who even wants to be mayor can only worsen the risk that it will have to amalgamate. 'The 'A' word has been floating around ever since I walked in the place,' Ion says. 'But to retain your autonomy, to be in charge of your own your future, is really important.' Local Government NZ's working group on electoral reform has proposed a return to in-person voting at polling booths; security services have advised that online voting isn't secure, and this may be the last local election that the flailing NZ Post can realistically get the voting papers out and back again. Ofsoske agrees there are problems with postal voting, but he believes the answer is online. There's no security issues they can't handle, with sufficient resourcing, he says. And so we come back to the problem that councils are strapped for cash – they can't pay to invest in new election technology. As of Wednesday, there were 47 regional council seats where there were no candidates, or only one. The country's city and district councils are similarly impacted. Like Lampp, Ofsoske remains hopeful of a last-minute rush. 'It's just human nature for people to leave it to the last minute,' he says. 'We've had a very busy last couple of days for our councils, about 250 nominations per day.' And there is much to take heart about. There may not be a lot of candidates, but they represent a range of voices in their communities. 'What I'm observing with nominations, that have been coming in the last couple of weeks, is a good diversity of candidates, and a good spread of different nationalities to reflect the makeup of communities like Auckland. I'm really encouraged by that.'
