Supreme Court sets standard for prosecutors seeking adult sentences for youth
OTTAWA — The Supreme Court of Canada has established a standard Crown prosecutors must meet when they are seeking adult sentences for youth offenders.
The court says they must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the youth has the developmental age and capacity for moral judgment of an adult.
Under the Youth Criminal Justice Act, youth have what is known as diminished moral culpability.
The onus is on Crown prosecutors to prove that principle doesn't apply to a specific offender.
The Supreme Court was reviewing two Ontario cases in which youth offenders were sentenced as adults.
It upheld one of those cases and overturned the other.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 18, 2025.
Anja Karadeglija, The Canadian Press
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
a minute ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Lawyer says he's not been allowed to see 5 immigrants deported by the US to a prison in Eswatini
MANZINI, Eswatini (AP) — Five immigrants deported by the United States to Eswatini in a secret deal last month had served their criminal sentences before they were sent to be held in a prison in the African country, a lawyer working on their cases said Friday. The Eswatini lawyer also said the men from Cuba, Jamaica, Laos, Yemen and Vietnam sent to southern Africa under President Donald Trump's third-country deportation program have been denied access to legal representation while being held in Eswatini's main maximum-security prison. The lawyer, Sibusiso Nhlabatsi, said he hasn't been allowed to see the men and that he filed court papers Thursday against the head of Eswatini's correctional services department and the country's attorney general, demanding access to them. He said he is representing them on behalf of lawyers in the U.S. and was prevented from seeing them by Eswatini prison officials on July 25. It's unlawful for the men, who have been in Eswatini for around two weeks, to be denied access to a lawyer, he added. The Eswatini government has said the men will be held in solitary confinement until they can be deported to their home countries, which could take up to a year. 'They have served their sentences,' Nhlabatsi told The Associated Press. 'If a person has committed a crime and they have served a sentence, why are you then keeping them in a prison?' Nhlabatsi said the men have not been able to communicate with their families or receive visitors since arriving in Eswatini, although prison officials said they were in the process of setting up devices to allow them to speak with their families. He alleged their ongoing detention could have legal implications for Eswatini, a small country bordering South Africa and one of the world's last absolute monarchies, ruled by a king accused of cracking down on dissent. The Trump administration has come under scrutiny for its choice of African countries to strike deportation deals with. It deported eight immigrants described as violent criminals to South Sudan in early July in an operation that was halted by a legal challenge in the U.S. The eight were held for weeks in a converted shipping container at an American military base in nearby Djibouti while the case was decided. A Supreme Court ruling eventually cleared the way for them to be sent to South Sudan. Both South Sudan, which is in danger of tipping into civil war, and Eswatini have poor rights records and governments accused of being repressive. Critics say the deportees, who the administration says were in the U.S. illegally, will likely be denied due process in those countries. The five sent to Eswatini were also described by the U.S. Department of Homeland Security as serious criminals. Their convictions included murder and child rape, the department said in social media posts, calling them 'uniquely barbaric.' The department, which did not say if they had completed their sentences, did not immediately respond to a request for comment on Friday. An Eswatini government spokesman also declined to comment on Nhlabatsi's allegations, saying it was now a matter for the courts. Nhlabatsi said the deportees are being held at the Matsapha Correctional Complex near the administrative capital, Mbabane, the same prison said to hold pro-democracy activists on trumped up charges. The government has declined to say where the five men are being held, citing security concerns. Eswatini's statement about the five men ultimately being deported to their home countries appears to contradict claims by the U.S. that their home countries refused to take the men back. Activists in Eswatini have demanded that the details of the agreement with the U.S. be made public but the government has said they are 'classified.' South Sudan has also declined to give details of its agreement to take deportees from the U.S. ___ AP news on the Trump administration:
CTV News
a minute ago
- CTV News
Barrie high school music teacher facing sex crimes involving male student
Loading the player instance is taking more time than usual Loading the player instance is taking more time than usual Warning: Content in this article may be upsetting or triggering to some readers. A Barrie high school music teacher is facing serious allegations of sex crimes involving a male student. Jennifer Elise Lawrence, 31, was a music teacher at Maple Ridge Secondary School in the south end of Barrie until April of this year, when police charged Lawrence following an investigation. According to court documents obtained by CTV News, Lawrence, who was removed from teaching in late April, is charged with sexual exploitation, child luring, sexual assault and making sexually explicit materials available to a person under the age of 18. Jennifer Elise Lawrence Jennifer Elise Lawrence (Source: Supplied) The charging documents reveal the allegations stems from incidents between February and April 2025. According to the Ontario College of Teachers, Lawrence has been an educator for about four years. She remains in good standing pending the outcome of the criminal proceedings. Released on a promise to pay $1000, Lawrence is not allowed to work as a teacher, volunteer, or be in a position of trust or authority, or have any contact or communication with children. Lawrence's lawyer, Saman Wickramasinghe, told CTV News neither he nor his client are in a position to comment on the ongoing matter. The Simcoe County District School Board, which oversees Maple Ridge Secondary School, also declined to comment on the teacher's charges or her status as an employee, directing any questions to Barrie Police. Maple Ridge Secondary Maple Ridge Secondary School in Barrie, Ont., on Wed., July 30, 2025. (CTV News/David Sullivan) A communications representative with Barrie Police Service declined to answer any questions and offered no information on the case, citing a court-imposed publication ban. Two publication bans were ordered in April protecting the identity of the complainant and any evidence heard in court from being released. The allegations against Lawrence have not been tested in court. The accused returns to a virtual courtroom later this month.
CTV News
a minute ago
- CTV News
Charges laid in Langley, B.C., double-shooting that left 1 man dead
Nearly one year after a double-shooting in Langley, B.C., that left a 41-year-old man dead, a suspect has been charged with second-degree murder. Authorities said they found two men shot after responding to report of gunfire on 202B Street in the early morning hours of Aug. 2, 2024. One of the victims, Langley resident Dillan Unger, succumbed to his injuries in hospital. On Friday, the Integrated Homicide Investigation Team announced charges against Stephen Johnson. 'Investigators can confirm that Mr. Unger and Mr. Johnson were known to each other,' IHIT said in a news release. 'Mr. Johnson remains in custody.' The accused is also charged with four counts of attempted murder, one count of aggravated assault, one count of using a firearm in the commission of an offence, and one count of reckless discharge of a firearm. Authorities have never commented on a possible motive in Unger's killing. IHIT said it will not be providing any further details while the case is before the courts.
