B.C. Mountie loses bid to stay charges in obstruction of justice case
In July 2024, Const. Arthur Dalman was found guilty of obstructing justice for ordering a bystander to delete cellphone video showing the aftermath of the police takedown and arrest of Dale Culver on July 18, 2017.
The 35-year-old Gitxsan and Wet'suwet'en man died in police custody 29 minutes after he was arrested, following a struggle with multiple police officers. Dalman is one of two officers who went on trial in the obstruction of justice case.
The constable filed an application to stay his 2024 conviction, arguing that lengthy pre-trial delays meant he was denied his Charter rights to a trial within a reasonable timeframe.However, in a ruling on May 29, Judge Adrian Brooks dismissed Dalman's application. His next court appearance is on June 19 to schedule a date for his sentencing.
The other officer accused of obstruction of justice, Staff Sgt. Bayani (Jon) Eusebio Cruz was found not guilty in 2024.
Culver's arrest and death happened nearly eight years ago, on July 18, 2017. That was followed by an investigation by B.C.'s Independent Investigations Office (IIO), an oversight agency that investigates anytime a police-involved incident results in serious harm or death.
It filed its initial report to Crown counsel in July 2019, followed by an updated report in May 2020.
Close to three years later, in February 2023, Crown prosecutors announced charges of manslaughter against two Mounties and charges of obstruction against three others, the first time the accused were publicly named.
Charges against the two officers accused of manslaughter were stayed in April 2024.
Charges against one of the officers accused of obstruction were stayed a month later, while the trial for the other two officers accused of obstruction was completed on July 25, 2024, resulting in Dalman's guilty verdict.
'Rare occurrence,' civil rights group says
Culver's death and its aftermath have been viewed by civil rights advocates and First Nations leadership groups in B.C. as a key test of the justice system's ability to hold police accountable.
The B.C. Civil Liberties Association (BCCLA) hailed the recent dismissal of Dalman's application, with a staff lawyer saying it's uncommon for officers to be charged with criminal offences and even less common for them to be found guilty.
"We recognize that this is such a rare occurrence — that not only was Const. Arthur Dalman found guilty of obstruction of justice, but that despite his application to challenge that verdict, the judge upheld his guilty verdict," said Latoya Farrell.
"And now we're going to be moving to sentencing, which is monumental in steps towards the police accountability."
In a statement shared by the BCCLA, Culver's daughter asked how many people would have to die before the public realized the justice system was broken.
"We have been waiting eight long years for this, and I have somehow managed to remain positive about my feelings that eventually someone would be held accountable," Lily Speed-Namox said.
However, the National Police Federation's Pacific-North director, Chris Voller, was critical of Dalman's application being dismissed.
"I think that this was an error," he told CBC News. "I think it was very clearly demonstrated, throughout the testimony of all involved, that Const. Dalman's Charter rights were clearly denied."
Voller said the IIO, which forwarded a report to Crown prosecutors in Dalman's case recommending that charges be laid, made evidentiary errors in the case.
"The public of British Columbia want and deserve to have the ability to say the oversight of their police officers is competent, timely and reasonable," he said.
"We would request a review of the competency, timeliness and reasonableness associated to both the IIO investigations and charge assessment by the Crown counsel."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Los Angeles Times
an hour ago
- Los Angeles Times
Canadian police arrest 4 in alleged anti-government militia plot
VANCOUVER, British Columbia — Canadian police arrested and charged four people, including active members of the Canadian military, who were allegedly involved in an extremist plot to forcibly take possession of land in the Quebec City region, authorities said Tuesday. Royal Canadian Mounted Police said in a statement that three of the suspects 'took concrete actions to facilitate terrorist activity.' Marc-Aurèle Chabot, 24, and Raphaël Lagacé, 25, both of Quebec City, and Simon Angers-Audet, 24, of Neuville, Quebec, were charged with facilitating terrorist activity. They were arrested early Tuesday in Quebec City. 'The three accused were planning to create anti-government militia,' the RCMP said. 'To achieve this, they took part in military-style training, as well as shooting, ambush, survival and navigation exercises. They also conducted a scouting operation.' A variety of firearms, some prohibited, as well as high-capacity magazines and tactical equipment were allegedly used in these activities. Court documents say the acts took place between June 2021 and January 2024 in Quebec City; Montreal; and Rolphton and Petawawa, Ontario; and elsewhere in Quebec, Ontario and Canada. The three are also facing additional charges relating to the alleged illegal storage of firearms, and possession of explosives and prohibited devices. Police said that a fourth suspect, Matthew Forbes, 33, of Pont-Rouge, Quebec, has been charged with possessing firearms, prohibited devices and explosives, among other offenses. Police haven't identified which suspects were members of the Canadian Armed Forces. Police said that the investigation began in March 2023. Searches conducted in January 2024 in Quebec City led to the seizure of 16 explosive devices, about 11,000 rounds of ammunition and other weapons. RCMP Cpl. Erique Gasse described the case as 'ideologically motivated violent extremism.' The suspects wanted to start an anti-government 'community' north of Quebec City, and allegedly used a private Instagram account to recruit members and supporters, Gasse said. RCMP distributed a photo from that Instagram account showing seven people in military-style uniforms brandishing firearms. Gasse didn't say who was pictured. 'We know there were followers on that site,' he said. 'They were trying to recruit people who had knowledge about guns, and they were telling people where they were training in Quebec or in Ontario.' When asked about the possibility of more arrests, Gasse said the investigation of the four suspects was complete, but new inquiries could begin if more evidence comes to light. Court documents say the suspects had in their possession weapons including grenades, night-vision goggles, high-capacity magazines, and improperly stored firearms. Morris writes for the Associated Press.
The Hill
an hour ago
- The Hill
Canadian police arrest 4 in alleged anti-government militia plot
VANCOUVER, British Columbia (AP) — Canadian police arrested and charged four people, including active members of the Canadian military, who were allegedly involved in an extremist plot to forcibly take possession of land in the Quebec City region, authorities said Tuesday. Royal Canadian Mounted Police said in a statement that three of the suspects 'took concrete actions to facilitate terrorist activity.' Marc-Aurèle Chabot, 24, and Raphaël Lagacé, 25, both of Quebec City, and Simon Angers-Audet, 24, of Neuville, Quebec, were charged with facilitating terrorist activity. They were arrested early Tuesday in Quebec City. 'The three accused were planning to create anti-government militia,' the RCMP said. 'To achieve this, they took part in military-style training, as well as shooting, ambush, survival and navigation exercises. They also conducted a scouting operation.' A variety of firearms, some prohibited, as well as high-capacity magazines and tactical equipment were allegedly used in these activities. Court documents say the acts are alleged to have taken place between June 2021 and January 2024 in Quebec City; Montreal; and Rolphton and Petawawa, Ontario; and elsewhere in Quebec, Ontario and Canada. The three are also facing additional charges relating to the alleged illegal storage of firearms, and possession of explosives and prohibited devices. Police said that a fourth suspect, Matthew Forbes, 33, of Pont-Rouge, Quebec, has been charged with possessing firearms, prohibited devices and explosives, among other offenses. Police haven't identified which suspects were members of the Canadian Armed Forces. Police said that the investigation began in March 2023. Searches conducted in January 2024 in Quebec City led to the seizure of 16 explosive devices, about 11,000 rounds of ammunition and other weapons. RCMP Cpl. Erique Gasse described the case as 'ideologically motivated violent extremism.' The suspects wanted to start an anti-government 'community' north of Quebec City, and allegedly used a private Instagram account to recruit members and supporters, Gasse said. RCMP distributed a photo from that Instagram account showing seven people in military-style uniforms brandishing firearms. Gasse didn't say who was pictured. 'We know there were followers on that site,' he said. 'They were trying to recruit people who had knowledge about guns, and they were telling people where they were training in Quebec or in Ontario.' When asked about the possibility of more arrests, Gasse said the investigation of the four suspects was complete, but new inquiries could begin if more evidence comes to light. Court documents say the suspects had in their possession weapons including grenades, night-vision goggles, high-capacity magazines, and improperly stored firearms.
Miami Herald
5 hours ago
- Miami Herald
Nicaragua's crackdown on opposition extends beyond its borders
July 8 (UPI) -- Nicaragua faces a widespread and intensifying political crackdown under President Daniel Ortega, as international organizations report that the persecution now extends beyond the country's borders through killings, threats and surveillance targeting exiled dissidents. "The persecution of individuals perceived as political opponents in Nicaragua not only continues, but has become a recurring practice that extends beyond national borders, putting exiles at serious risk of death and physical harm," the U.N. Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights said in a recent report. The June 19 killing of retired Nicaraguan Army Maj. Roberto Samcam in San José, Costa Rica, is among the recent cases cited by the United Nations. Samcam had been living in exile in Costa Rica since 2018 after accusing Ortega's government of human rights violations. Costa Rica's Judicial Investigation Agency said his killing may be linked to Sandinista cells operating in the country. The agency reported that at least 137 Nicaraguan dissidents living in exile in Costa Rica have been killed or violently attacked over the past two years. Maarit Kohonen Sheriff, director of the U.N. Human Rights Office's Division of Global Operations, said the human rights situation in Nicaragua has significantly deteriorated over the past year. She said those targeted include human rights defenders, journalists, Indigenous and Afro-descendant communities, and both religious and lay leaders. In its May 2025 annual report, the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights warned of Nicaragua's continued backsliding on human rights, the erosion of judicial independence and escalating attacks on democratic freedoms. The report cited a pattern of targeted criminalization of political opponents both inside the country and in exile, including the revocation of legal status, arrest warrants, de facto statelessness and vague laws to suppress dissent. The rights of Indigenous and Afro-descendant communities are also under threat, said Kohonen Sheriff, after the approval of a presidential decree eliminating public consultation for natural resource exploitation in protected areas -- many situated on Indigenous and Afro-descendant lands. Attacks on these communities continue, including killings, sexual violence and arbitrary detentions. According to a United Nations report, at least 54 people remain in arbitrary detention, including 10 Indigenous individuals. "Arbitrary detentions continue to be used as a tool of political repression, reinforcing a climate of fear to silence critical voices," Kohonen Sheriff said. Copyright 2025 UPI News Corporation. All Rights Reserved.
