Cross-sex hormones for under 18s could be restricted or banned
The case calling for a full judicial review was brought after the NHS announced in December last year that under-18s would no longer be prescribed puberty blockers at gender identity clinics.Campaigners argued that the prescription of cross-sex hormones should also be addressed and criticised the government's failure to intervene.But Lady Justice Whipple said it was not "unreasonable or irrational" for the government to address the question of puberty blockers first and later come to cross-sex hormones.The court in London was also told health officials are looking at "alternative legal mechanisms" to tackle issues around private and overseas providers who prescribe such drugs.Cross-sex hormones are given to people who identify as a gender that is different to their biological sex. The medication helps someone who is transitioning to develop characteristics associated with their preferred gender.For instance, it would help a trans man, a biological female who identifies as a man, develop a deeper voice and facial hair. Existing NHS guidance allows the hormones to be prescribed people aged 16 and over.They differ from puberty blockers, which stop the onset of puberty by suppressing the release of hormones.Existing NHS guidance allows the hormones to be prescribed to people aged 16 and over.The case calling for a full judicial review was brought by Keira Bell and two others, who are remaining anonymous. They wanted a ban on the prescription of cross-sex hormones by non-NHS organisations, such as private clinics and overseas providers.As a teenager, Ms Bell was given cross-sex hormones after attending the now closed NHS Gender Identity Development Service (GIDS) run by the Tavistock clinic.At the time she identified as male, but says she deeply regrets the decision to take medication that altered her body permanently.Responding to this afternoon's judgment she said: "I am relieved that the secretary of state is now actively considering a ban on cross-sex hormones outside of the NHS. "These powerful drugs should not be given to children and young people."Her barrister, Zoe Gannon, had argued that while the health secretary banned the private prescription of puberty suppressing drugs in gender cases involving under-18s, he had "failed or refused" to take the same action in relation to cross-sex hormones, and this was "irrational". Iain Steele, barrister for the Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC), told the court Mr Streeting "is currently seeking clinical and expert advice from NHS England".He also said there were a wide range of medical uses for hormones, such as testosterone and oestrogen, which made decisions on whether to restrict or ban their use in different situations complex.Delivering the judgment rejecting the application for a judicial review, Lady Justice Whipple, sitting with Mr Justice Johnson, said the secretary of state had acted rationally.She said, "This is an immensely difficult and sensitive area of policy formation where there are strong and genuinely held views on each side of the debate and where there is no consensus."She added Mr Streeting was taking practical steps and was therefore entitled to more time to consider the issues.She continued that it was appropriate that there was an active review and that was to be welcomed.
A Department for Health and Social Care spokesperson said children's healthcare "must always be led by evidence". "That is why this government is implementing the recommendations from the Cass Review and acted immediately to extend the puberty blockers ban and make it permanent."The government continues to work with the NHS to reform gender services to young people, the spokesperson added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Brits shouldn't be signed off work for anxiety and depression, says former Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt
Former health secretary Sir Jeremy Hunt fears society is 'over medicalising' the impact of normal traumatic events – and warned against signing people off work with anxiety and depression. The Tory grandee, who held the role between 2012 and 2018, spoke out as the Government has faced stiff opposition from its own MPs against welfare reforms. People with mental health conditions are believed to account for around half of the rise in working age adults claiming disability benefits in England and Wales since the pandemic, according to the Institute for Fiscal Studies. The number of working-age adults in England and Wales paid disability benefits rose by nearly 1million people to 2.9million between 2019 and 2024, with 7.5 per cent of 16- to 64-year-olds claiming. In a report in March, the Institute for Fiscal Studies calculated that about 500,000 of the rise is from mental health claimants. Sir Jeremy said that 'in some ways it's rather positive' that people talk openly about mental health issues. But he said: 'I do worry we are sometimes over-medicalising it. Everyone has trauma – bereavements, sometimes losing their jobs. That is not the same as mental illness. 'I think it's immoral we are signing off 3,000 people a day saying they don't have to look for work. The Tory MP, most recently Chancellor under Rishi Sunak (pictured) and who narrowly held onto his seat by 819 votes at last year's General Election, said: Everyone has trauma – bereavements, sometimes losing their jobs. That is not the same as mental illness' 'The majority of those have anxiety and depression and the one thing they need is social contact. If you sign them out of the world of work, their anxiety is going to get worse rather than better.' Sir Jeremy, speaking at the Buxton Literary Festival, Derbyshire, said the focus should be on supporting people with anxiety or depression so they can continue to work and lead their lives. The Tory MP, most recently Chancellor under Rishi Sunak and who narrowly held onto his seat by 819 votes at last year's General Election, added: 'What we should be doing is increasing mental health provision on the NHS. 'For that individual, it's far better but it's also better for Rachel Reeves when she's trying to make the numbers add up for her budget.' During the talk, Sir Jeremy backed current Tory leader Kemi Badenoch, saying his beleaguered party should not undergo another leadership change to improve its fortunes. He said: 'I don't think anyone else would have done much better. We've had four leaders in four years. If changing leader was the answer, we'd be doing much better in the polls than we are doing. 'We had the worst defeat in our history a year ago and it's going to take time for the country to give us a hearing again.' He urged Ms Badenoch to 'move on from contrition' to 'offering solutions' to Britain's problems. Sir Jeremy said: 'There's a football pitch-sized hole in politics for a party offering solutions. Labour is ducking decisions; Reform is not credible. 'I hope she [Kemi] turns things around but I recognise there's still a lot to do.' The MP, who represents Godalming and Ash, Surrey, ruled himself out of a return to frontline politics any time soon. He said: 'I made it clear to Kemi that I didn't wish to serve [in a front bench post in opposition] but if she wanted to bring me back before an election and if it would help, I would be around.' Jokingly, Sir Jeremy revealed being photographed more often with his pet labrador Poppy may have improved his poll ratings. The pet was pictured with the MP, his wife Lucia and their three children as they left 11 Downing Street for the final time following last July's election defeat. He said: 'Someone tweeted 'God, he's got a labrador, can I change the way I voted?'. That's the British public!'
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Trump demands UK pharmaceutical giants to lower drug costs sparking fears NHS could pay the price if they refuse
Donald Trump has demanded UK pharmaceutical giants lower prices for America and suggested charging others to make up the difference. He said if they didn't, the US would deploy 'every tool in our arsenal' to protect families from 'continued abusive drug prices', sparking fears the NHS will end up paying more. Mr Trump suggested he would use tariffs to push through higher prices if countries resisted. In May Mr Trump signed an executive order demanding drugmakers cut US medicine prices to match those abroad. Yesterday in a letter to 17 pharma companies he said he expected them to deliver on measures by September 29. He asked them to apply 'most favoured nation' pricing to Medicaid, the US health programme for people on low incomes. Mr Trump also asked drugmakers to offer new medicines at the same price in the US as in other developed countries. He said: 'Our citizens pay massively higher prices than other nations pay for the same exact pill... subsidizing socialism aboard [abroad].' British pharma companies AstraZeneca and GSK were among the recipients. Others included Eli Lilly, Johnson & Johnson, Pfizer and Sanofi. The UK Government said it would 'continue to work closely with the US to get the best deal for our pharma industry and deliver mutual benefits for both our countries'.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Heston Blumenthal reveals he's taking weight-loss drug Wegovy and shares fears that slimming jabs could pose a threat to the food industry
Heston Blumenthal has revealed he's taking the weight-loss drug Wegovy. The celebrity chef, 59, told how he's been taking the slimming aid to help combat the effects of his bipolar medication, having been diagnosed with type 1 bipolar in 2023. Heston also expressed his fears that the rise in popularity of weight loss jabs could pose a threat to the food industry. Speaking to Times Radio, Heston explained: 'I've put on so much weight, but it's starting to come off now', before adding that his use of the drug is a 'paradox' given the fact he's a restaurateur. The TV personality remarked how he'd lost 'eight kilos' on Wegovy so far, however, he has also dealt with side effects including brain fog, slurred speech and problems with balance. The drugs contain semaglutide, an amino acid, which suppresses appetite by mimicking a hormone telling the brain you are full up. In a new interview, the celebrity chef, 59, told how he's been taking the slimming aid to help combat the effects of his bipolar medication, having been diagnosed with type 1 bipolar back in 2023 [Boxes of Wegovy pictured] Heston issued a warning to the food industry, remarking how the continued use of the popular slimming jabs could have a detrimental affect on it. He explained: 'Wegovy, Ozempic, Mounjaro – you still enjoy food, but it stops appetite, so what's going to happen is people are going to want smaller portions.' Heston added that things were 'going to get much worse in the next six months' for restaurants, before expressing that supermarkets would also be affected. However, the food writer noted that he's 'formulating a plan' in a bid to help the food industry. Elsewhere, last month, Heston revealed he 'had thought about different ways of ending [his life]' before eventually receiving treatment for bipolar disorder. The London-born celebrity chef, who holds a total of seven Michelin stars across his restaurants, was diagnosed with type 1 bipolar after being sectioned - on the insistence of his wife, French entrepreneur Melanie Ceysson - in November 2023. Bipolar disorder is a brain disorder which causes unusual and often sudden changes in mood and energy levels. He spent two weeks heavily medicated in a psychiatric hospital and a further six weeks in a clinic, where he continued with intensive treatment and practised walking meditation. Yet, four years previously, he had already hit rock bottom and was contemplating the method he would use to take his own life. Looking back to filming the cookery show Crazy Delicious in 2019, Heston told The Times: 'I remember lying on the sofa the night before I was due to go to do the show - I didn't want to do it, because of the condition I was in - and I had thought about different ways of finishing [my life]. 'I went through a list: knife? No, can't do that. Gun? Don't have one. Rope? I don't think I could do that; wouldn't know how. It would probably slip off or whatever. 'And there was no train station anywhere near to jump in front of a train.' The father-of-four, whose first eatery, The Fat Duck, was named the best restaurant in the world in 2005, added that he didn't perceive that he was in a depressive state - even when he 'was talking about suicide or death'. He told the publication: 'I must have been in a mixed state [a period of rapid highs and lows], because I was excited about planning my funeral, planning my wake. What music I wanted, who I wanted there - I got quite excited about that.'
