EV two-wheeler sales soared 34x in 4 years, but market share stuck at 4%: Study
In the electric two-wheeler (E2W) segment, sales jumped from 19,333 units in FY2019 to over 6.5 lakh units in FY2023. However, the adoption rate – the share of electric vehicles in overall two-wheeler sales – was only 4% by the end of 2023. 'FAME-II's higher subsidy intensity (28.65%) compared to FAME-I (14.32%) boosted absolute E2W sales by up to 9 times, but had limited impact on the overall market composition,' the report states.
According to Charith Konda, Energy Specialist at IEEFA and one of the co-authors, 'The government should continue offering purchase subsidies to sustain momentum but clearly communicate a phased-down trajectory for the longer term.'
In the electric three-wheeler passenger (E3WP) segment, early policy support under FAME-I drove a 10x market multiplier effect. Around 27,000 additional vehicles were directly attributed to subsidies under FAME-I, with total sales reaching 2.67 lakh units by March 2019. The segment, however, matured during the FAME-II period and showed limited incremental impact from later subsidies.
The electric three-wheeler cargo (E3WC) category saw a market share rise from 0.03% in 2015 to over 31% by 2023. The study found this growth was largely driven by operating cost advantages rather than central subsidies. A 1% reduction in operating cost led to a 0.563% increase in sales, highlighting the role of business economics in commercial segments.
In the electric four-wheeler commercial (E4WC) category, sales improved after FAME-II and PLI schemes were implemented. A one-standard-deviation increase in subsidy intensity led to a 5% rise in sales. However, the adoption rate was still less than 1%. States that implemented incentives saw 211% higher sales growth than those that did not.
For electric four-wheelers in the private segment (E4WP), sales grew due to new model launches and consumer demand, but adoption rates remained below 2%. The report highlights the need for continuing support in this segment.
The report found that both FAME-I and FAME-II failed to make a statistically significant impact on electric bus (e-bus) adoption. Only 4,766 units were subsidised against a target of 7,262, and the sector continues to face structural barriers such as limited financing access and high upfront costs.
'Coordinated central and state action, pairing targeted purchase incentives, infrastructure rollout, and manufacturing scale-up can help electric cars compete effectively with their counterparts in India's commercial vehicle market,' said Saurabh Trivedi, Sustainable Finance Specialist at IEEFA.
The study recommends continued fiscal support, investment in public charging infrastructure, interest rate subvention for buses, and targeted financing support for smaller commercial operators.
'As India transitions from FAME schemes to PM E-DRIVE and other similar initiatives, policymakers must recognise that each EV segment requires tailored intervention,' Konda added.
The report draws on panel data of 21,526 observations over 10 years, offering a first-of-its-kind empirical assessment of India's EV subsidy performance using econometric techniques such as difference-in-differences and synthetic control methods.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Economic Times
30 minutes ago
- Economic Times
Tryst with EVs
iStock More than three decades ago, India saw an automobile revolution unfolding. GoI's pro-liberalisation policy thrust, which subsequently led to the opening up of the market, helped create an entire manufacturing ecosystem, making it possible to produce quality and affordable passenger cars. This enabled millions of Indians to fulfill their dream of owning a car. Today, personal mobility in India – and the world – is poised on the threshold of a tectonic transformation. It is now a globally acknowledged fact that reducing reliance on fossil fuels by replacing vehicles running on conventional internal combustion engines (ICE) with EVs is the need of the hour. Furthermore, for a country like India that has abundant sun, wind and water for RE and enough coal for thermal power, there is an absolute need to become self-reliant and stop importing millions and millions of barrels of oil. While government support has played an important role in creating a market for EVs so far, a 2023 McKinsey survey suggests that consumer preferences are also now driving the demand for electric cars. More than two-thirds of customers in the survey considered buying an EV as their next car purchase. The market is responding to this emerging EV demand. Car manufacturers in India are making considerable efforts towards designing and manufacturing EVs that are safe, comfortable, and offer quality features and style as preferred by Indian customers. Original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) are also building charging infrastructure at a record pace to ensure that the EVs have uninterrupted and adequate power supply. As of FY25, there are about 25k charging stations in India, a 2x growth since last over 50 mn passenger cars on the road, India is now the third largest passenger car market in the world, behind China and the US. The Indian PV market is expected to grow at 6-7% CAGR over the next 5 years, adding 5-6 mn cars a year. It is the need of the hour for a significant portion of these cars to be EVs. Not only are EVs better for our planet and air quality, but also for our current account, reducing our dependence on imports in a meaningful is encouraging to see that India is taking important policy strides to enable EV adoption. The government has given generous subsidies, such as the FAME (Faster Adoption and Manufacturing of EVs) scheme and lower GST rates, on EVs to stimulate consumer demand. Incentives to boost the manufacturing of batteries for EVs have also been provided. Moreover, OEMs, as a community, are working together to further EV awareness and effective policy measure is the corporate average fuel efficiency (CAFE) norm that mandates OEMs to manufacture more fuel-efficient vehicles, thereby limiting the carbon dioxide emitted by the total fleet produced by them in a year. Manufacturing and selling more EVs—which have zero tailpipe emissions compared to petrol or diesel cars—allows OEMs to comfortably meet their annual CAFE is now seeking to strengthen CAFE norms in existence since 2022, with an updated version that aims to significantly improve the fuel efficiency benchmark in India. Such a move will be a major turning point, as it will spur more carmakers to make an aggressive shift towards EVs, helping the ecosystem grow. Also, faster EV adoption will help create economies of scale, thereby improving the global competitiveness of India's auto industry. According to estimates, India's passenger EV market is expected to grow to 1.0 mn vehicles by at the crossroads of clean mobility and energy view electric vehicles not just as a technological shift, but as a strategic win for business, the economy, and the planet. This is the foundation of their commitment to the growth of the EV ecosystem in India. But unlocking their full potential will require collective and collaborative action—from both GoI and the entire manufacturing ecosystem. Policy interventions such as CAFE and other supply-side mandates to manufacture more EVs have played and will continue to play a critical role in this journey. (Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this column are that of the writer. The facts and opinions expressed here do not reflect the views of Elevate your knowledge and leadership skills at a cost cheaper than your daily tea. From near bankruptcy to blockbuster drug: How Khorakiwala turned around Wockhardt Paid less than plumbers? The real story of freshers' salaries at Infy, TCS. As deposit ground slips under PSU banks' feet, they chase the wealthy If data is the new oil, are data centres the smokestacks of the digital age? Stock Radar: M&M likely to break out from 1-year consolidation range; time to buy? Will consumer stocks see a comeback this festive season? 12 stocks to keep an eye on even when analysts are not bullish Don't fear volatility, focus on businesses: 5 mid-cap stocks from different sectors with upside potential of up to 27% Best way to deal with volatility, just ' Hold' for wealth creation: 7 large-cap stocks with an upside potential of up to 41%
Time of India
8 hours ago
- Time of India
Govt keeps tabs on capex as private investment lags
Representational Image NEW DELHI: Govt is keeping a close watch on capex as private investment remains weak, some of which may be on account of the global uncertainty induced by the US President Donald Trump's tariff regime. During April-May, Centre's capital expenditure has been higher with ministries and departments spending 20% of their allocation for the year, compared with 13% in the first two months of the last fiscal year. Over the last five years, capex by the Centre has been a key policy tool to boost investment in the economy with the expectation that the multiplier effect will generate demand for inputs and create jobs and spur private investment. The private sector has, however, largely watched from the sidelines barring sectors such as cement and steel where companies are lining up investment to meet the demand created by public investment in roads & railways. There has been heightened activity in sectors such as electronics, induced by schemes such as PLI. But overall capacity utilisation is not seen at levels where companies would ramp up investment to set up new production lines. In sectors such as automobiles and energy, the shift towards greener technologies is resulting in some investments being held up, industry sources said. While acknowledging the weak private investment, govt sources said efforts are being made to understand the measures that may be needed to boost activity. Further, the sources said, some of the central projects may not have more absorptive capacity to step up capex and govt may explore newer segments of the economy to divert more public investment. These could include spaces such as urban infrastructure with the finance ministry and other wings of govt expected to hold discussions in the coming months. Given the needs of the economy and the growth expected in coming years, the focus on capex is going to remain, with private sector expected to take the baton sooner or later. For the current fiscal year, the Centre has budgeted for capex of Rs 11.4 lakh crore of which nearly half is allocated to roads and railways. Stay informed with the latest business news, updates on bank holidays and public holidays . AI Masterclass for Students. Upskill Young Ones Today!– Join Now
Mint
14 hours ago
- Mint
Hero MotoCorp gets approval for PLI-Auto scheme
New Delhi: Hero MotoCorp Ltd, India's biggest two-wheeler maker by sales, has received approval for its electric scooter to be a part of the ₹ 25,938 crore production-linked incentive scheme for automobiles and auto parts (PLI-Auto), according to the scheme's portal. The approval from testing agencies came on 8 July for the VIDA V2 Pro model, which allows the company to claim incentives from the ministry of heavy industries. The approval makes Hero MotoCorp the fourth electric two-wheeler maker in the PLI roster, after Ola Electric Mobility Ltd, TVS Motor Co. Ltd, and Bajaj Auto Ltd. Also read | Govt names Toyota Kirloskar as first component maker to get auto PLIThe PLI-Auto scheme has been integral to boost the margins of electric vehicle makers in the country. Vivek Anand, chief financial officer, Hero MotoCorp Ltd, said during the company's earnings call on 14 May that its efforts to reduce Bill of Materials (BOM) costs through localization, along with the PLI benefit that the company will receive, will make the company's operations profitable. He said then that the company is in the process of applying for PLI sops for multiple models, and was expecting an approval by July. Hero MotoCorp is the 17th company to get its models approved under the scheme, and has initiated the process to get other models approved. Hero MotoCorp recorded a 175% rise in sales of its electric Vida scooters to reach 48,674 units during the year, Mint reported in May, citing data from the Federation of Automobile Dealers Associations (FADA). Also read | Electric journey helps Tata Motors, Mahindra become first to win auto PLIThe company had a 4.2% market share among electric two-wheelers in FY25, according to the Vahan portal, the central registry of vehicles. Disbursals under the PLI-Auto scheme have been low, with about ₹ 322 crore doled out to approved companies in FY25. While 16 companies had been approved for PLIs before Hero MotoCorp, only four had received these payouts till FY25. Tata Motors and Mahindra & Mahindra were granted about ₹ 246 crore in January 2025, followed by ₹ 73.74 crore to Ola Electric in March. The ministry of heavy industries said on 26 March that Toyota Kirloskar Auto Parts had also received disbursals, but did not disclose the amount. An uptick is expected in FY26, union heavy industries minister H.D. Kumaraswamy told Mint in June. The minister had said the government is expecting PLI claims worth about ₹ 2,000 crore from nine companies in FY26. Under the marquee scheme to support the production of zero-emission vehicles, manufacturers receive 13-18% of their incremental sales as kickbacks. Manufacturers have to procure at least 50% of the components locally. While key manufacturing components such as cells for electric vehicles have to be imported, others can be sourced from Indian auto components makers. Also read | About 12 companies including BHEL and Kia Motors to be excluded from Auto PLI Manufacturers also have to meet investment targets under the scheme, or face removal, according to PLI-Auto guidelines. Incumbent vehicle makers must have annual revenues of at least ₹ 10,000 crore and invest ₹ 3,000 crore in fixed assets. For component makers, the thresholds are ₹ 500 crore in revenue and ₹ 150 crore in investment. New entrants from outside the auto sector need a global net worth of ₹ 1,000 crore and must commit investment over five years. The continued addition to the roster of PLI-approved auto products comes as sales of electric vehicles have risen about 17% in FY25 to over 1.9 million, compared with about 1.6 million in FY24.
