Health Reforms Raise Fears Of Two-Tier System And Workforce Shortages
The Australian and New Zealand College of Anaesthetists (ANZCA) is one of the largest specialist medical colleges in Australia and New Zealand and the region's leading authority on anaesthesia, pain medicine and perioperative medicine.
Dr Graham Roper, chair of ANZCA's New Zealand National Committee, says the outsourcing plans will negatively affect the training of anaesthetists, who are critical for operations to proceed, and see existing specialists move from public hospitals to the private sector.
'Trainees' practical experience will be impacted, with a loss of exposure to outsourced clinical cases, and skewed amounts of urgent and complex work. It will take longer for trainees to get their required experience, delaying their entry into the workforce. Anaesthesia training will become less desirable, threatening the ability to produce much-needed specialists.
'Anaesthetists are a central part of both the hospital and the surgical team – without them, operations simply can't go ahead.'
Dr Roper says the changes will lead to public system specialists facing a large amount of complex and urgent patients, requiring the highest level of care with extended hours of work. This would lead to specialists choosing to move to the private sector, further increasing the strain on the public system.
He is also questioning the ability of some private facilities to provide the required level of care and training opportunities.
'Not all private facilities are set up to deliver the same level of clinical care as the public system. Private providers do not take on the same complexity of work in the same volumes as the public system, and may not provide high-dependency care, intensive care, acute pain services, pre-admission clinics and access to urgent investigations. Any significant complications during or after surgery will see the patient transferred to the public system for ongoing care.
'Many private facilities do not have on-site medical cover overnight and have a limited ability to respond to medical emergencies,' Dr Roper says.
'Our Māori and Pacific peoples, with increased complexity of health needs, are unlikely to benefit from this outsourcing model. In addition, our rural and remote communities may not be well served with this change.
'People living in rural areas are not always close to a private provider, can have transport difficulties, and lose family and whānau support if they have to travel long distances for surgery.'
Dr Roper says ANZCA is willing to be involved in finding solutions to the unmet need of elective surgery across Aotearoa New Zealand.
'The provision of high-quality safe and equitable care for our community remains the core aim of our profession and the New Zealand public should expect that access to anaesthesia and surgery is future-proofed.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scoop
15 hours ago
- Scoop
Raising The Bar Serves Up Fresh Thinking In Auckland Pubs
Press Release – University of Auckland With 20 talks held across ten bars in Aucklands CBD on one night, Raising the Bar gives alumni and the general public a chance to directly engage with top academics from the University of Auckland, all while enjoying their favourite drop. Raising the Bar is back, pouring the University of Auckland's most fascinating and future-shaping research straight into bars across the inner city Among the topics on the menu at this year's event on August 26 are the power of urban design to create and connect communities, how cutting-edge science is personalising health treatment like never before, the science of safer drug use and why big tech's unchecked AI development is a code red for democracy. With 20 talks held across ten bars in Auckland's CBD on one night, Raising the Bar gives alumni and the general public a chance to directly engage with top academics from the University of Auckland, all while enjoying their favourite drop. 'At its heart, Raising the Bar is about making research real and relevant,' says Mark Bentley, Director of Alumni Relations and Development at the University of Auckland. 'These talks bring important ideas into everyday spaces, sparking conversations about health, technology, culture and more – conversations that extend far beyond the University.' Originally launched in New York in 2013, Raising the Bar is now a global initiative – and the University of Auckland has proudly brought the event to local audiences since 2017. This year's talks will be held at bars across Auckland's CBD, including in Wynyard Quarter, Victoria Park and City Works Depot. Each venue will host two sessions, starting at 6pm and 8pm, with punters free to move from one bar to another to catch their preferred talks. All talks are free, but with the event expected to sell out early registration is recommended. Visit to register your place now. This year's full line-up: Merryn Tawhai – Reimagining healthcare with human digital twins Rhys Ponton – From lab coats to late nights: the science of safer drug use Simon Young – Broken knees, bionic fixes and the rise of robot surgeons David Krofcheck – Out of this world: the smallest and most surprising liquid in the Universe Justin O'Sullivan – Swab, sequence, surprise! How science is personalising your health Mohsen Mohammadzadeh – Robo-rides and city life: what could go right…or wrong? Andrew Erueti – The limits of liberal equality and the future of Māori self-determination Christina Stringer – Closer than you think: migrant exploitation and modern slavery in Aotearoa Olaf Diegel – 3D printing the future Darren Svirskis – The quest to find a cure for spinal cord injury Claire Meehan: Not just jokes: how misogyny online is shaping teen culture Alexandra Andhov – Code red for democracy: when big tech becomes bigger than government Sophie Tomlinson – 'Tragical-comical-historical-pastoral': Shakespeare's Cymbeline Marcelo Rodriguez Ferrere – We know animals are sentient. What does that mean for their legal status? Chris Ogden – Global authoritarianism: how to spot it and how to stop it Joel Rindelaub – Breathing plastic: Aotearoa's invisible pollution problem Antje Fiedler – Rewriting the playbook: how Kiwi businesses can thrive in a changing world Lee Beattie – Beyond buildings: urban design's power to create and connect communities Laura Burn – A human history of looking up: from stargazing to space lasers Tom Allen – A carbon fibre yarn: weaving fossil fuel roots into a sustainable future
RNZ News
16 hours ago
- RNZ News
Four confirmed and one probable dengue-related death in Samoa
Photo: 123RF The Samoan government says more than 5600 clinically diagnosed dengue cases have been recorded since January. Of these, 2619 are laboratory-confirmed. An outbreak of the disease was declared in April. In a press statement delivered by caretaker prime minister Fiame Naomi Mata'afa, she said there have been four confirmed and one probable dengue-related death. She said household inspections of more than 2000 homes showed poor waste disposal practices, stagnant water and overgrown vegetation are major contributors to heightened mosquito breeding places. Dengue is fairly common in Pacific countries but this year the number is the highest it has been since 2016 , according to the World Health Organisation's Pacific Technical Support director, Dr Mark Jacobs. He told Pacific Waves in late July the high case numbers in the region were due to a range of factors, including the movement of people between Pacific nations. Dengue can't spread from person to person, but once a certain type of mosquito bites an infected person, that mosquito can spread it to someone else. Dr Jacobs said the climate change and shifting weather patterns in the region also increased the risk around dengue spread; and the lack of understanding around dengue hot-spots was another risk factor. Meanwhile, the country's Education Minister Ae'au Chris Hazelman said all schools will remain closed this week due to the outbreak, including ECE and universities. "Based on the data provided to us by the Ministry of Health, not only at our national hospital at Moto'otua but all of our district hospitals as well and also the hospital in Savai'i - it is based on those numbers that we have made the decision to close the schools." Schools were closed last week and a fumigation programme was launched. Te Whatu Ora - Health New Zealand said last week there were 34 confirmed cases of dengue reported in Auckland in July among people coming back into New Zealand - with approximately half of those acquired in Samoa. Health NZ said New Zealand does not have mosquitoes able to transmit dengue.
RNZ News
16 hours ago
- RNZ News
Doctors on alert as dengue fever cases surge among people returning from overseas
The Asian tiger mosquito is one of the vectors responsible for transmitting dengue fever. Photo: SCIENCE PHOTO LIBRARY Doctors are being warned to be on alert for people with symptoms of dengue fever as the number of cases in New Zealand surges. National Public Health Service physician Dr Sharon Sime told Midday Report public health teams are also seeing a surge in cases among people returning home after picking up the illness overseas. Dengue cases in the Pacific are at their highest level in almost a decade, with Samoa particularly affected with more than 2000 cases reported and multiple deaths since an outbreak was declared in April. In New Zealand, there have been 208 cases of dengue nationally in the year to date. Of those, 103 cases were recorded in Auckland this year, double the amount recorded for all of 2024. Around a third of the cases so far this year have also ended up being hospitalised. "What's different with dengue fever is many people with dengue don't have symptoms," Dr Sime said. "So, the ones that we diagnose is likely an under representation of the number of cases." New Zealand does not have mosquitoes able to transmit dengue, so you can't get the disease in New Zealand, Dr Sime said. While you cannot catch dengue fever from another person, you can get it from infected mosquitoes in an area or region that has dengue, and there is no available vaccine in New Zealand. "At the moment, our climate wouldn't work for the particular type of mosquito that carries dengue. We do also have a monitoring programme at our airports and our ports where we are constantly monitoring for any imported mosquito, just so that we would get an early warning of any chance of these mosquitoes surviving in New Zealand," Dr Sime said. Symptoms of dengue fever include a sudden high fever, intense headache, pain behind the eyes, muscle and joint pain, tiredness, nausea, vomiting and a fine rash, which may be itchy and usually begins on the extremities, but spares the palms and soles of the feet. Many people infected with dengue will only have mild symptoms, but a small number of people may get severe dengue and require hospital care. Dr Susan Jack, National Clinical Director for National Public Health Service, said people over 60 years old and children aged 10 and under are also at greater risk of severe illness from dengue. Dr Jack said if you're travelling outside Aotearoa New Zealand to an area with dengue, protect yourself by: Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
