Cuts to the fire service in Scotland could cost lives, says union
The Scottish Fire and Rescue Service (SFRS) is proposing the closure of up to 13 stations, new arrangements for night and weekend cover at others and the permanent withdrawal of 10 appliances nationwide.
The Fire Brigades Union (FBU) says wide-ranging changes to the fire service in Scotland could cost lives.
The Scottish Fire and Rescue Service (SFRS) is proposing the closure of up to 13 stations, new arrangements for night and weekend cover at others and the permanent withdrawal of 10 appliances nationwide.
Five stations in Dundee, Glasgow, Edinburgh and Musselburgh could be shut down or merged.
The 23 options, which were published on Wednesday, involve more than 30 fire stations in 14 local authority areas - and the service has warned that more change is likely in years to come.
Senior officers have insisted that public safety will not be compromised - but the FBU has spoken out against the proposals saying the service is "already on its knees" after a decade of "real-terms cuts".
FBU Scottish secretary, John McKenzie said: 'Our members and the Scottish public have suffered more than enough cuts to the fire service.
'For over a decade, real-terms budget cuts have increased risks to public safety, with firefighter numbers slashed and response times increasing as a result. The service is already on its knees because of these cuts. That has led to increases in response times and when this time is lost, tragically lives will also be lost.
'This is unacceptable and any proposals to further compromise our service and public safety must be rejected. What we need instead is more, not less, investment that takes into account new and emerging threats that our services and our members are having to deal with on a day-to-day basis. We need funding that enhances and improves public safety rather than worsening it.'
In all, the SFRS has set out 23 different options for change across the fire service in Scotland, which it says is needed to match staff, stations and resources to 'operational risk and demand' across the country.
The proposals also include plans to repair or rebuild stations in some areas, and transfer some staff and vehicles to 'more effective' locations.
The consultation will remain open for 12 weeks, with the SFRS saying it wants 'as many people as possible' to submit their views on the proposed changes.
Chief officer Stuart Stevens said: 'We have an opportunity for the first time since our national service was formed in 2013 to review how we provide our emergency service every minute of the day, every day of the year. Building a modern fire and rescue service that is fit for purpose is the reason we are bringing these proposed changes forward.
'We recognise that these 23 options represent a significant level of change. However, we have a duty to ensure that the right resources are in the right locations to meet new risks that exist within today's communities.
'We also need to spend public money wisely. We have a backlog of repairs in our buildings, fleet and equipment that would cost more than £800 million to address and this just isn't an option available to our service.
'Therefore, along with the need for sustained investment, we need to consider how we operate and reduce running costs for assets that are not serving our staff or communities. We must also be able to adapt to meet current and future risks, such as those posed by extreme weather events or wildfires.'
Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community!
Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today.
You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland.
No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team.
All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in!
If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'.
We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like.
To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'.
If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice.
The service said eight of the fire stations slated for closure have been 'long-dormant' due to recruitment difficulties for on-call firefighters in rural locations.
Meanwhile, the five city fire stations had been identified as potential closures or mergers because of low demand, or because they are close to other facilities that SFRS said could provide effective cover.
The proposals also include the implementation of a daily shift pattern for firefighters in some areas, which would see full-time staff work from 8am-6pm, supported by on-call firefighters outwith these times.
They would be assisted by the creation of a 'nucleus crew' in two locations – Galashiels in the Scottish Borders and Lesmahagow in South Lanarkshire – which could be deployed 'tactically' across an area as required.
Permanent solutions are also being proposed following the temporary withdrawal of 10 appliances in 2023, including in Perth & Kinross, Fife, Lanarkshire, Inverclyde and Glasgow.
Mr Stevens added: 'These options have been developed over many months involving staff, trade union representatives and other stakeholders. There will be a 12-week period to give people time to submit their views on the changes. We would encourage as many people as possible to participate in public consultation process.'
Community safety minister Siobhian Brown said: 'The emergencies the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service (SFRS) responds to have changed, with fewer house fires and more wildfire and flooding incidents.
'It is right, then, that the service considers how to adapt to the changing risks to remain effective and efficient, with firefighters in the right place at the right time to ensure people and communities are protected.'
She urged people to take part in the consultation 'so their voices are heard', but stressed: 'As ever, keeping communities safe will remain the SFRS's top priority, supported by substantial year-on-year budget increases from the Scottish Government.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
3 hours ago
- The National
Donald Trump to 'visit Turnberry golf course during visit to Scotland'
The US President is due to visit the UK for an official state visit, but no date has been announced. Trump previously revealed that plans are being drawn up for this to take place in September. And now, the Scottish Mail on Sunday reports that Trump will visit his three Scottish golf courses by the end of July, including Turnberry. He previously suggested his visit would coincide with the grand opening of a second 18-hole course at Trump International Golf Links in Aberdeenshire, named the MacLeod course after his Scottish mother. READ MORE: Inside the SNP's political strategy ahead of 2026 Scottish election According to the newspaper, security services are preparing for Air Force One to land at Prestwick Airport, in Ayrshire, in the final two weeks of July. Trump's last visit to Turnberry, during his first term as President, prompted a protest on a beach overlooking the golf course, featuring now sadly deceased Scottish comedian Janey Godley. The Turnberry course has seen several protests since Trump took over the White House for the second time. Protesters sprayed red paint on the clubhouse at the 800-acre resort, and damage was also caused to the greens where the words 'Gaza is not for sale' were also painted. (Image: PA) Palestine Action, who are set to become a proscribed terror group after spraying red paint into the engines of two aircraft at RAF Brize Norton, said they targeted Trump's golf course over the US administration's plan 'to ethnically cleanse Gaza'. And in April, Greenpeace UK revealed a large sand artwork on the beach outside the South Ayrshire golf course. Trump was expected to meet King Charles in Scotland ahead of his official state visit in September, but the meeting was called off due to diary clashes. The state visit was confirmed when Prime Minister Keir Starmer handed Trump a letter from the King inviting him to Scotland during a meeting at the White House. READ MORE: Wes Streeting forced to admit Labour wants fewer people claiming PIP However, it is understood that there were "logistical challenges" surrounding an informal visit, with conflicts in both the King's and Trump's diaries meaning a private meeting was not possible. Speaking to reporters in the Oval Office in April, Trump said he did not 'know how it [the state visit] can be bigger than the last one' but that 'they say it's going to be even more important'. Precedent for second-term US presidents who have already made a state visit is usually tea or lunch with the monarch at Windsor Castle, as was the case for George W Bush and Barack Obama.
STV News
3 hours ago
- STV News
Government accused of 'contempt' over lack of running water at fire stations
The Conservatives have accused the Scottish Government of treating firefighters with 'contempt' after figures revealed 18 fire stations around the country do not have running water. According to the stats, which were obtained by the Scottish Conservatives via a Freedom of Information request, the 18 stations are mainly located across rural areas in the Highlands and Islands. Most consist of fire appliance garages, but four have only a 'garden shed' and three are listed as 'no building'. The party said that at one of the sites, a fire appliance garage at Foyers, it had been reported that fire crews were having to use wet wipes to clean equipment. The Tories said the figures come in the wake of proposals unveiled by the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service (SFRS) to close up to 13 fire stations due to 'funding cuts', with the body having seen its budget fall by £57m in real terms over 10 years. Scottish Conservative shadow community safety minister Sharon Dowey MSP said: 'These shocking figures are proof of the SNP's contempt for Scotland's brave firefighters. 'It's shameful and negligent that they are risking the health and wellbeing of dedicated emergency workers by denying them access to the most basic yet essential facilities at work. 'SNP ministers have been short-changing the service for years, leaving firefighters to do their job with one hand behind their back, jeopardising public safety. 'On their watch, the number of firefighters is plummeting, stations are being earmarked for closure and now we learn a growing number of bases lack running water. 'This situation is intolerable, unsustainable and could have devastating consequences. 'SNP ministers must ensure all of Scotland's fire stations are fit for purpose immediately.' The Conservatives said in 2022 there were at least 11 fire stations reported as having no running water, which they said meant the problem had 'worsened, or no action has been taken'. They also pointed to SFRS figures from April 2024 showing that 45% of fire stations are in poor condition and 75% are deemed 'unsuitable'. The party added that the SFRS was also criticised by the Health and Safety Executive earlier this year over the condition of some fire stations. Assistant chief officer Craig McGoldrick, director of training, safety and assurance at SFRS, said SFRS has an 'insurmountable' capital backlog of more than £800m, and that many of its ageing buildings 'require action'. He went on: 'We can only address this by changing how we work. We're currently running a public consultation that outlines 23 options for change to help address urgent property issues and ensure our resources – staff, stations and appliances are matched to operational risk and demand across Scotland. 'We recognise that there are limited welfare facilities at some fire stations, and we have issues with RAAC in other sites, all of which form considerations as part of the public consultation.' Mr McGoldrick said: 'The safety of our firefighters will always be a priority and it's important that our crews can shower and clean kit following attendance at an incident with potential contaminants. '£3.2m is being invested by the service into the management of fire contaminants and this includes boosting our reserves of personal protective equipment, enhanced storage for contaminated kit and new laundry procedures. 'For the small number of stations without running water, specialist decontamination wipes have been provided.' A Scottish Government spokesperson said: 'Scotland's firefighters do an amazing job and the Scottish Government continues to support the SFRS to deliver the high standard of services required to keep Scotland safe with an overall budget of £412.2m, an increase of £18.8m for 2025-26. 'Scotland continues to have more firefighters per capita than other parts of the UK. 'The SFRS has been clear that the changes proposed are not about cuts but so it can adapt to the changing risks and demands of communities and ensure firefighters are in the right place at the right time. 'For example, eight of the 13 stations in the review have not been operational for a number of years and dwelling fires have reduced by over 20% since 2013, whilst climate-related events such as flooding and wildfires have increased.' Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Scotsman
3 hours ago
- Scotsman
Scottish Labour MP lays into Keir Starmer's 'race to the bottom' as welfare cuts pressure mounts
Sign up to our Politics newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... An outspoken Scottish Labour MP has accused Sir Keir Starmer of continuing a 'relentless race to the bottom' with proposed benefit cuts as he refused to back the Prime Minister leading the party into the next general election. The pressure comes as Sir Keir said he took 'ownership' of the internal row engulfing his leadership. The Prime Minister has attempted to take pressure off his chief of staff Morgan McSweeney, who is facing accusations of driving the UK government's policy direction rather than the Labour leader. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Keir Starmer's government has now provided three major opportunities, in relatively quick succession, for opposition parties to accuse him of performing a U-turn (Picture: Ben Stansall) | PA Brian Leishman, Labour MP for Alloa and Grangemouth, is one of the key rebels piling pressure on Sir Keir to reverse his controversial cuts to disability benefits. Original plans restricted eligibility for Pip and cut the health-related element of Universal Credit. To try and see off the Labour rebellion, the changes to Pip will be implemented in November 2026 and apply to new claimants only, while all existing recipients of the health element of Universal Credit will have their incomes protected in real terms. The policy is devolved and will not apply in Scotland, but Holyrood's funding for social security is dependent on how much UK ministers allocate to the policy area. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Asked by the BBC if the revised plans will pass in the Commons on Tuesday, Mr Leishman said: 'I hope not.' Rebels still a threat to Starmer He added: 'I'm certainly working to make sure that it doesn't. Quite simply, the concessions that were made at the tail end of last week, they are not enough. 'The sensible thing to do, the common sense thing that the government should do, is to withdraw the Bill and consult with organisations and charities that are experts in the field - come back to the table with a proper welfare system.' Brian Leishman, MP for Alloa and Grangemouth. Pic: Michael Gillen Mr Leishman said 'some have been placated by the compromises and the concessions', but he warned there was 'a healthy amount of us, a big cohort of MPs, who feel this [legislation] should be withdrawn'. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad He said: 'Behind the scenes, there's conversations being held all the time. My gut reaction would be there is enough of us to think again.' MP criticises cuts Mr Leishman, who has been the only Scottish Labour MP to openly criticise Sir Keir, insisted 'what we have seen over the last decade-and-a-half has been chronic austerity that has really impoverished some of the most vulnerable people in the country'. He added: 'The notion that we solve these austere cuts with more cuts, that's frankly ridiculous. Instead of this relentless race to the bottom that cut after cut after cut ultimately leads to and decimates society, what we've got to do is look at how we raise revenues.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Asked if Labour was the party for him, amid speculation former Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn could set up a breakaway party, Mr Leishman said: 'I'm proud to be a Labour party member. 'The Labour party really is the most likely vehicle to achieve a much more equitable and fairer society. I have to try and shift the Labour party to where I think it should be.' Mr Leishman, who said he was not proud of Labour's first year in government, was asked if Sir Keir was the right person to lead the party into the next general election. He said: 'I'm not interested in the personnel. I think the Prime Minister has shown that degree of honesty that I think the electorate will appreciate. He admits he's made mistakes. One year into a five-year term, we've got to do better.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The UK government has been criticised for its proposed cuts to disability benefits The MP stressed the situation was 'not irretrievable for him [Starmer]', but warned backbench MPs 'should be consulted much more on policy' going forward. He said: 'The next election is four years away and we've got to see demonstrable change in culture from the government.' Amid pressure on his chief of staff that he has misread the mood of Labour backbenchers over the controversial welfare reforms, Sir Keir told the Sunday Times 'all these decisions are my decisions and I take ownership of them'. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad He said: 'I do not talk about staff and I'd much prefer it if everybody else didn't.' Sir Keir Starmer's chief of staff, Morgan McSweeney, in Downing Street. Photo: Jonathan Brady/PA Wire | Jonathan Brady/PA Wire The Prime Minister also told the paper that allegations in a book by Patrick Maguire and Gabriel Pogrund, Get In, that Mr McSweeney was setting the government's agenda were 'total b*******'. Sir Keir has hit back at allegations his government's agenda is not in tune with traditional Labour values. 'I'm sorry, that is a charge I do not accept,' he said. Further concessions possible 'We settled the public pay dispute. We've got breakfast clubs being rolled out in 750 schools. We've announced free school dinners today for children from families on Universal Credit. That's 500,000 children who will now get free school meals. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad "We've just re-nationalised the railways. We've set up the first publicly owned company in I don't know how long, in GB Energy. You name it, each one of the things I've just run through is core Labour value. I don't accept that charge.' UK Health Secretary Wes Streeting | Jeff Overs/BBC/PA Wire Health Secretary Wes Streeting has signalled confidence the UK government will win a crunch vote on welfare reforms on Tuesday, but did not rule out further concessions. Mr Streeting said the changes 'have put us in a much better position' and give 'peace of mind' to those in receipt of personal independence payments. 'When things change and evolve as you bring in new systems, it does change sometimes from group to group, student finance being an example,' he told the BBC's Sunday With Laura Kuenssberg programme. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad He said 'we've got to listen' when asked if further concessions could be made on Pip. Unite general secretary Sharon Graham has called for the government to start from scratch on the Bill and said the latest plans were 'divisive and sinister'.
