logo
Towards economic resilience: Malaysia's SST expansion is a tough but necessary step if done right — Goh Lim Thye

Towards economic resilience: Malaysia's SST expansion is a tough but necessary step if done right — Goh Lim Thye

Malay Maila day ago
JULY 7 — On 1 July 2025, Malaysia implemented a revised and expanded Sales and Service Tax (SST) under the Madani economic framework. While this move had been anticipated by policymakers and industry players, it nevertheless sparked considerable public backlash, particularly among middle-income and urban households already coping with rising living costs. Such frustration is understandable. However, it is also crucial to examine the rationale, intended outcomes, and broader implications of the revised SST through a clear, evidence-based lens. Though not without flaws, the policy represents an important step in Malaysia's broader effort to strengthen fiscal stability and could deliver long-term benefits if implemented thoughtfully and fairly.
The SST, reintroduced in 2018 to replace the GST, has been criticised for its narrow tax base and inefficiencies in enforcement. The revised SST seeks to correct some of these weaknesses. The new measures include an increase in the service tax rate from 6 per cent to 8 per cent for selected sectors, excluding essential services such as food and beverage, telecommunications, logistics, and parking. It also expands the scope of taxable services to include private clubs and karaoke centres. Importantly, the government responded to public sentiment by exempting daily essentials such as rice, vegetables, fish, eggs, and certain imported fruits like apples and oranges from sales tax. Additionally, the threshold for SST registration for financial and rental services was raised from RM500,000 to RM1 million, shielding many MSMEs from the expanded tax burden.
Malaysia climbed 11 positions to 23rd in the 2025 IMD World Competitiveness Ranking, its highest placement since 2020. Fiscal management is one of the key pillars in this ranking. A stronger tax structure that supports reduced fiscal deficits and sustainable debt management sends a positive signal to investors and rating agencies. — Unsplash pic
From a macroeconomic standpoint, Malaysia's tax-to-GDP ratio was just 12.2 per cent in 2022 and has since risen modestly to 13.2 per cent as of Q3 2024. This remains significantly lower than Thailand (16 per cent) and well below the OECD average of over 30 per cent. Such a low tax base constrains the government's ability to fund development expenditure and social protection sustainably. The 2025 Budget estimates an additional fiscal revenue of RM5 billion from newly included items under the revised SST, helping to close the fiscal gap. With Malaysia's national debt standing at RM1.22 trillion — around 63 per cent of GDP as of April 2024 — and the fiscal deficit narrowing from 5.0 per cent in 2023 to 4.1 per cent in 2024, enhancing domestic revenue mobilisation is not a policy choice but a necessity for fiscal resilience. The government has targeted a further reduction in the deficit to 3.8 per cent by 2025.
This strategy is not unique to Malaysia. Many economies have broadened their indirect tax systems in the wake of the pandemic. Singapore currently imposes a 9 per cent Goods and Services Tax (GST) as of January 2024, having increased it from 8 per cent the year before. This rate is higher than Malaysia's and reflects a commitment to broad-based consumption taxation while maintaining redistributive policies through schemes like the GST Voucher and permanent U-Save utilities rebates. Indonesia applies a Value Added Tax (VAT) of 11 per cent as of 2022, up from 10 per cent, and is considering increasing it further to 12 per cent by 2025. This reflects an ongoing effort to strengthen revenue mobilisation and support long-term fiscal sustainability. New Zealand runs a 15 per cent GST with minimal exemptions but offsets regressivity through targeted welfare transfers and a progressive income tax system. These international examples underscore that indirect tax systems can be sustainable if designed and implemented within a broader framework of redistribution and transparency.
Nonetheless, the regressivity of indirect taxes remains a valid concern. Lower-income households tend to spend a larger portion of their income on consumption and are thus more vulnerable to price hikes. To address this, it is essential that part of the revenue generated from SST expansion be reinvested into targeted assistance. Strengthening direct cash transfer schemes like Bantuan Tunai Rakyat (BTR), expanding food and transport subsidies, and enhancing public healthcare accessibility are crucial to offset the distributional impact of the tax. Moreover, policymakers must ensure there are no leakages in revenue deployment. Effective monitoring by the Auditor General and the Public Accounts Committee (PAC), alongside the use of digital public finance dashboards, would enhance accountability and trust.
An often overlooked dimension of tax reform is its contribution to macroeconomic stability and global competitiveness. Malaysia climbed 11 positions to 23rd in the 2025 IMD World Competitiveness Ranking, its highest placement since 2020. Fiscal management is one of the key pillars in this ranking. A stronger tax structure that supports reduced fiscal deficits and sustainable debt management sends a positive signal to investors and rating agencies. If the additional SST revenue contributes to narrowing the deficit from 5 per cent to the targeted 3.8 per cent of GDP over the medium term, it could enhance Malaysia's sovereign credit outlook and investor confidence.
Still, effective policy implementation requires clear and consistent communication. The government's decision to reverse the taxation of beauty services and exempt select fruits after public outcry shows policy responsiveness but also highlights the need for better stakeholder engagement. Economic policy, particularly one that affects consumer behaviour and firm-level pricing decisions, must be grounded in transparent consultation. Deliberative dialogue with civil society, chambers of commerce, and think tanks can help preemptively identify blind spots and build public buy-in.
Ultimately, the revised SST is a step toward fiscal sustainability and institutional maturity, not an endpoint. It must be accompanied by broader structural reforms improving tax administration efficiency, reducing procurement leakages, and adopting medium-term expenditure frameworks. Equally important is ensuring that taxation is linked to visible and equitable service delivery. Citizens are more likely to accept taxation if they see tangible returns in the form of improved infrastructure, quality education, and accessible healthcare.
In conclusion, while the expanded SST is far from perfect, dismissing it outright would ignore the urgent fiscal imperatives confronting Malaysia. The challenge lies in translating tax collection into inclusive development. If additional revenues are allocated with integrity and directed toward closing equity gaps, the SST reform could represent not merely a tax hike, but a pivot toward a more resilient and just economic model.
* Dr Goh Lim Thye is a senior lecturer at the Department of Economics, Faculty of Business and Economics, Universiti Malaya, and may be reached at [email protected]
** This is the personal opinion of the writer or publication and does not necessarily represent the views of Malay Mail.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Singapore competition watchdog grants conditional nod to Malaysia Airlines-SIA tie-up
Singapore competition watchdog grants conditional nod to Malaysia Airlines-SIA tie-up

Malay Mail

time20 minutes ago

  • Malay Mail

Singapore competition watchdog grants conditional nod to Malaysia Airlines-SIA tie-up

SINGAPORE, July 8 — The Competition and Consumer Commission of Singapore (CCCS) on Monday granted conditional approval for the proposed commercial cooperation between Singapore Airlines Ltd (SIA) and Malaysia Airlines Bhd. The proposed cooperation will see the two airlines work together on scheduling, pricing, sales and marketing, and other commercial areas, including expanded codesharing and special prorate arrangements. In a statement, CCCS said the airlines had submitted a set of proposed commitments to address the commission's concerns over price and capacity coordination that could restrict competition on the Singapore-Kuala Lumpur (and vice versa) route. The proposed commitments include maintaining weekly seat capacity at current levels, increasing capacity upon meeting certain performance benchmarks, reporting annual operational data for their low-cost carriers (LCCs) on the route, and appointing an independent auditor to monitor compliance. 'Taking market developments into account, including the impending permanent cessation by Jetstar Asia Airways Pte Ltd, CCCS accepted the proposed commitments as being sufficient to address its competition concerns arising from the proposed cooperation,' the commission stated. CCCS noted that no concerns were raised by industry stakeholders during the consultation period from February 11 to March 4, 2025. CCCS chief executive Alvin Koh said such joint ventures could improve connectivity and offer more choices for travellers. 'The proposed commitments offered by Singapore Airlines and Malaysia Airlines allow for flexibility to react to market developments and ensure that more flights will be added along the Singapore-Kuala Lumpur route as travel demand increases, which would translate to more travel options and better prices for passengers in the long run,' he said. Koh added that CCCS would continue to monitor developments in the sector to ensure competition delivers positive outcomes for consumers. SIA and Malaysia Airlines submitted a joint application to CCCS on March 24, 2023, on whether the proposed cooperation would be an anti-competitive agreement under the Competition Act 2004. A further submission was made on November 3, 2023, stating that the cooperation would be limited to their full-service carriers and would not extend to their affiliated LCCs, namely Scoot and Firefly. CCCS is a statutory board of the Ministry of Trade and Industry that administers and enforces the Competition Act 2004 and the Consumer Protection (Fair Trading) Act 2003, to guard against anti-competitive activities and unfair trade practices. — Bernama

Shafie raises alarm over ballooning expenditure
Shafie raises alarm over ballooning expenditure

Daily Express

time44 minutes ago

  • Daily Express

Shafie raises alarm over ballooning expenditure

Published on: Tuesday, July 08, 2025 Published on: Tue, Jul 08, 2025 By: Abbey Junior Text Size: Shafie also raised concerns about the lack of transparency in certain allocations, including an additional RM1 billion channelled to the Chief Minister's Department, describing it as odd based on his 36 years of political experience. Kota Kinabalu: Former Sabah Chief Minister Datuk Seri Mohd Shafie Apdal raised alarm over the State Government's ballooning expenditure under the 2025 Supplementary Supply Bill, warning that unchecked spending and vague allocations risk deepening the divide between the Government and the people. Debating the Bill, the Senallang Assemblyman and opposition Parti Warisan President said the additional RM1.1.86 billion allocation, on top of the previously approved RM6.7 billion, pushes total state spending to almost RM8 billion this year, yet there remained little clarity on how this would generate tangible returns for the rakyat. 'We are spending billions, but how much revenue are we actually generating? With this scale of spending, I believe Sabah is now facing a serious deficit,' said the former Chief Minister. He also criticised what he described as glaring imbalances in budget priorities, noting that while rural communities receive just RM500,000 each for water and electricity supply, millions are channelled into official functions, mass gatherings and non-essential activities. 'For rural water, RM500,000. For rural electricity, RM500,000. But you have celebrations here and there, lucky draws… millions are being spent,' he said. He questioned whether such events — including those featuring lucky draw giveaways and extravagant ceremonies — were appropriate uses of taxpayer money, especially when many in Sabah still lacked basic infrastructure. Shafie also questioned the Government's decision to raise RM900 million through sukuk bonds to bail out Sabah International Petroleum Sdn Bhd, likening the move to the controversial 1MDB case at the federal level. 'The State Government is now in debt. A bailout of this size deserves scrutiny. It is not just about issuing sukuk, the real question is, is this money going where it is truly needed?' he asked. He stressed that every sen of public funds must lead to measurable outcomes, such as job creation, income generation, or directly solving issues affecting people's daily lives, particularly the long-standing water and electricity problems in rural areas. Shafie highlighted the frustration of many Sabahans who still struggle to access clean water, referencing some viral videos on social media of families and peaceful riots pleading for basic needs. 'They don't want luxury…they just want basic necessities like water to drink, shower and use the toilet,' he said. Shafie also raised concerns about the lack of transparency in certain allocations, including an additional RM1 billion channelled to the Chief Minister's Department, describing it as odd based on his 36 years of political experience. 'We need clear answers. We request breakdowns, but often receive vague replies, such as 'for schools and students'. 'I will scrutinise and audit these expenditures, and if there is a change in government, I will ensure any abuse is addressed,' he said firmly, referring to the coming 17th state election, which is due by year's end. He reminded the House that these were public funds, paid by everyday Sabahans through taxes on basic goods like stationery, phones and clothing. Touching on key issues like land rights, energy control and foreign policy, Shafie urged better coordination between federal and state agencies to avoid repeating past mistakes like those seen in the Sipadan and Ligitan disputes. 'We need to work with our neighbours (Indonesia on developing Ambalat), yes…but not at the cost of Sabah's autonomy or resources. Let's not allow others, including Petronas, to dominate all our assets. 'We cannot allow this kind of spending to continue without results. The people deserve better … they deserve real development, not promises,' he said. * Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel and Telegram for breaking news alerts and key updates! * Do you have access to the Daily Express e-paper and online exclusive news? Check out subscription plans available. Stay up-to-date by following Daily Express's Telegram channel. Daily Express Malaysia

Malaysia rooting for 30pc locally grown shallots by 2030 — but here's why it's a tough row to hoe
Malaysia rooting for 30pc locally grown shallots by 2030 — but here's why it's a tough row to hoe

Malay Mail

time2 hours ago

  • Malay Mail

Malaysia rooting for 30pc locally grown shallots by 2030 — but here's why it's a tough row to hoe

KUALA LUMPUR, July 8 — A generous sprinkle of bawang goreng or fried shallots is undoubtedly the best way to top off most local meals — be it nasi goreng, Maggi goreng or even a bowl of porridge. Perhaps the fact that shallots are a staple in almost all our meals has made us assume that the humble bulbs can thrive anywhere, even in our backyard. Well, we couldn't — up until now. Malaysia has been importing shallots, big onions and garlic for decades because it was the cheaper option and there was no suitable variety that could adapt to our local climate. But after a breakthrough discovery by the Malaysian Agricultural Research and Development Institute (Mardi) in 2023, Malaysia is now aiming to produce 30 per cent of its shallots locally by 2030. Wan Rozita Wan Engah, a senior research officer at the Malaysian Agricultural Research and Development Institute (MARDI), led the initiative that discovered three suitable shallot varieties for planting in Malaysia. — Picture courtesy of Mardi Why cultivate now? Currently, Malaysia fully relies on imported onions and garlic, with China, India, Pakistan, the Netherlands and Thailand as its major suppliers. For instance, Malaysia imported 687,000 metric tonnes of onions worth RM1.58 billion in 2022. Of this, shallots comprised 38,000 metric tonnes worth RM2.5 million. Wan Rozita Wan Engah, a senior research officer who led Mardi's shallot cultivation initiative, said the institute launched a study on the viability of producing shallots locally in the 1980s. However, the plan was later shelved as shallot cultivation was an expensive endeavour, and there was no suitable heat-tolerant variety that could adapt to Malaysian weather back then. Wan Rozita said shallots only make up less than 10 per cent of Malaysia's total onion imports. However, a massive flood in India triggered a severe shortage of shallots in 2019, causing prices to jump from RM4 per kg to RM18 per kg. The following year, movement restrictions imposed due to the Covid-19 pandemic in 2020 also disrupted supply chains. The supply chain shock led Mardi to resume its search for a suitable variety of shallot to cultivate locally. While the cost of producing shallots locally remains a key challenge, Wan Rozita said food security concerns necessitate Malaysia to venture into shallot farming. Unlike shallots, garlic thrives best in countries with four seasons and requires a longer harvest period, making it less ideal for cultivation in Malaysia. — Picture by Firdaus Latif So, what's the breakthrough? Wan Rozita said shallots require year-round sun and thrive in relatively warm weather, between 25 and 32 degrees Celsius. Shallots must also be grown on loose and well-drained soil, as water retention could cause the bulbs to rot. 'The soil has to be moist but not too wet. So, the best time to plant shallots in Malaysia is between February and August because the rainy season starts after this period. 'Since each season takes about 65 days, we can carry out two planting seasons every year — from February to April and then from June to August,' Wan Rozita said. From 2021 to 2023, Wan Rozita and her team collected 15 varieties of shallots from various countries — including India, China, Pakistan, Indonesia and Thailand — and planted them in Malaysia as part of an adaptation study. After a rigorous series of selections, they shortlisted three varieties that could thrive in Malaysia: BAW-1, BAW-2 and BAW-3. Currently, the BAW-1 and BAW-3 varieties are cultivated via bulb, while BAW-2 is cultivated using seeds. Last year, Agriculture and Food Security Minister Datuk Seri Mohamad Sabu announced the government's ambition to locally produce 30 per cent of shallots by 2030 in two phases. The first phase, or the pre-commercial phase, will run from 2024 to 2025. During this phase, Mardi will distribute 70 tonnes of shallot seeds and 230kg of seed grains. An area of 100ha will also be designated for shallot cultivation. The second phase, or the commercialisation phase, will run from 2026 to 2030. A total of 1,347ha of land will be earmarked for shallot cultivation during this period to meet the 30 per cent target. But why only shallots — and what's next? Wan Rozita said tubers like big onions and garlic thrive best in countries with four seasons and require a long harvest period, ranging between eight to 10 months. 'By contrast, shallots have a shorter harvest period and farmers can see returns faster,' she said. Mardi is also currently carrying out a cross-breeding exercise to develop a new variety of shallot for Malaysia in Cameron Highlands. If successful, Malaysia's shallot industry will become self-sustaining — without having to rely on foreign varieties for farming.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store