Ex-LG staff plead guilty to obstructing commerce investigation
Photo:
RNZ / Alexander Robertson
A former New Zealand country manager for global electronics giant LG and two staff members have pleaded guilty to criminal charges of obstructing a Commerce Commission investigation nearly four years ago.
The historic case has just come to light after name suppression lapsed for two of the trio.
The three were discharged without conviction after assessments of their individual circumstances.
The case dated back to a 2020 investigation into possible anti-competitive conduct in the supply and pricing of televisions, which might have restricted the ability of retailers to set their own prices.
LG's then- country manager, Dowan Kim, admitted telling a key account manager, Nicholas Clarke, and another staff member, who has permanent name suppression, to delete any messages with customers that might possibly be an "issue" in the investigation.
Kim said it was done at the instruction of an overseas manager, which LG denied.
The Commerce Commission queried why it had not been given all the information required, including instant messages, after being tipped off by a whistleblower about the message deletions.
Commission Chairperson John Small said it was a blatant attempt to obstruct the investigation.
"We will take action against parties who attempt to obstruct our investigations," Small said.
"In this particular case, given the conduct occurred after a direction from the most senior New Zealand manager of a large global electronics supplier, we considered the conduct to be sufficiently serious for the charges to be filed under the Crimes Act."
The Commission recovered some of the deleted messages, which did not reveal any breaches of the Commerce Act.
The result of the investigation was a compliance letter to LG about potential wrong conduct, and a warning to Panasonic.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter
curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
2 days ago
- NZ Herald
Surcharge ban a win for consumers but will it save them money?
But will it ultimately save shoppers money? This is the question, after the Government revealed its proposed surcharge ban this week. The Retail Payment System (Ban on Surcharges) Amendment Bill is expected to be introduced by the year's end, and the change made by May. The proposed ban follows the Commerce Commission's decision to reduce bank interchange fees that businesses pay to accept credit card payments. This change is expected to save businesses about $90 million a year. Surcharges at the till allow businesses to recoup additional costs associated with providing certain payment methods, such as credit cards and contactless. New Zealanders are paying up to $150m in surcharges every year. The Government says this includes excessive surcharges of up to $65m. Commerce and Consumer Affairs Minister Scott Simpson describes them as 'a hassle and an unwelcome surprise' for shoppers at the till, and says consumers will be able to 'shop with confidence knowing how much they will pay for their purchases'. The Commerce Commission will oversee enforcement. Consumers will be entitled to a refund if a business applies a surcharge. Consumer NZ welcomes the change, describing it as 'a no-brainer'. Retail NZ chief executive Carolyn Young is pleased changes are being made but warns that retailers will continue to face costs to accept debit and credit card payments and 'these costs will likely be added to product prices in future'. Hospitality New Zealand agrees, saying the move could result in higher prices because margins are tight. There was strong criticism from Dairy and Business Owners Group chair Ankit Bansal, who argues the proposed changes unfairly target small retailers instead of fixing the real problem – the banks. 'The reality is that large retailers enjoy significantly lower banking fees, while small businesses – with no power to negotiate – are left paying inflated rates.' The Government deserves praise for tackling the wider issue of costs associated with people using certain credit cards and contactless cards in shops. The reduction in interchange fees will help businesses. The surcharge ban will be positive for consumers and mean a more transparent process. But it's a fair bet that most businesses, especially those under pressure, will be unable to absorb any extra cost. Some consumers may well ultimately end up paying higher product prices at the till to compensate. Sign up to the Daily H, a free newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
3 days ago
- RNZ News
Women feeling brunt of tough economy, Retirement Commission data shows
The Retirement Commission's financial tracker shows more than half of women are now feeling financially uncomfortable. Photo: Emil Kalibradov/Unsplash Women are feeling the brunt of tough economic times, new data from the Retirement Commission indicates. Its financial sentiment tracker shows 62 percent of women are now feeling financially uncomfortable, compared to 51 percent of men. The proportion of women worried about their finances pay-to-pay and their levels of debt has reached the highest since the research began in July 2021. The gap between men and women's self-rated financial comfort as widened significantly over the past four years, moving from a five percentage point gap in 2022, to 11 percentage points in 2025. Viewed quarterly, it was apparent that while men were starting to recover financially, women's perceived financial situation has not recovered, the commission said. In total, 44 percent of people did not have an emergency fund in place, which the commission said threatened their financial resilience. Women were less likely to have an emergency fund. Tom Hartmann, the commission's personal finance lead, said much of the difference came back to income. When incomes were equal, there was less difference reported. "There is a lot that happens after that. But if that's not there…." He said in households with more traditional roles, women might also have a clearer view of the family finances and "what would be useful to have". Liz Koh, founder of Enrich Retirement, said women tended to plan ahead financially more than men did, and could worry about money more. "In addition, women tend to be in a weaker financial position than men due the gender pay gap, and periods out of the work force which affect their savings. Women also tend to underestimate their financial capability, while men are more likely to overestimate it - so there is a confidence factor at play that can make women feel as though they are out of their comfort zone when dealing with money issues." Financial mentor David Verry, of North Harbour Budgeting Services, said he was not surprised by the data. "In some situations we come across, the female has the better credit record and loans are taken out in the female's name - sometimes for a vehicle for the use of the male. The male then takes off, with vehicle or other assets, leaving the female with the obligation. "Men are also less likely to admit they are in trouble or ask for assistance, from financial mentors or anyone else for that matter. We will see the female in a relationship ask for the first meeting and then have to drag the male to subsequent ones, if at all. Head in the sand, I don't need help, bravado." Young people were also worse off - the proportion of 18 to 34 year olds feeling financially comfortable dropped from 53 percent in 2022 to 43 percent this ear. For Māori, it fell from 42 percent two years ago to 34 percent this year. Hartmann said it was not hard to trace discomfort to the wider economic conditions. Although the research looked at the existence of emergency accounts, this was the sort of time when people might need to tap into those savings, he said. For the year 56 percent of people overall said they were financially uncomfortable, compared to 49 percent in 2021/22. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Otago Daily Times
4 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Warning Aurora power bills may rise $10
Household electricity bills for Aurora Energy customers could increase by an average of about $10 a month next year, the Commerce Commission says. Commissioner Vhari McWha said the commission was seeking feedback on its draft decision to allow the Dunedin City Council-owned lines company to recover up to $663.7 million over four years from 2026 to 2030. "We are conscious of the effect on electricity bills across Otago, and we've ensured this spend remains reasonable and limited to what's necessary to give consumers a safe and reliable network now and into the future," Ms McWha said. "It means Aurora can continue to renew ageing assets on its network while also meeting significant growth in demand for electricity in its regions." Aurora said yesterday its initial view was the draft decision outlined a level of cost savings that would "seriously inhibit" its plans to support economic growth and improve network resilience. Advocates for those struggling to pay bills said high electricity prices were already having a significant effect on some in the community. Ms McWha said the draft decision meant the average household electricity bills in the areas Aurora served could increase by about $10 a month next year and about $3 a month each year thereafter. Aurora's customised price-quality path (CPP) was put in place in March 2021 to allow the company to recover a set amount of revenue from customers over five years as it repaired and upgraded its network. However, the company's present revenue limits were due to expire in March next year, and new revenue limits would be set under general arrangements that applied to other price-quality regulated lines companies, Ms McWha said. "While Aurora has made significant progress during the CPP on the safety of its network, its investment catch-up was always planned to occur over a longer period. "In Aurora's CPP application, it anticipated investment would not return to a steady-state level until around 2030." In its draft decision, the commission had removed $16m related to projects with potential to be deferred by alternative solutions such as residential solar, Ms McWha said. Aurora Energy chief executive Richard Fletcher said the company would provide a formal response to the commission's draft decision. "However, our initial view is that the level of operating cost efficiencies referenced by the commission would be impracticable to achieve and, if not corrected in the final decision, would seriously inhibit the company's ability to deliver its published plan and improve network resilience. "It would also constrain the planned development of the company's network and operations to support customers' electrification transition and the economic growth of our operating regions." The draft decision appeared to be based on high-level benchmarking information from 2018 and did not appear to have been updated to reflect the company's current operating environment, Mr Fletcher said. He said the company was proud of what had been achieved over the past five years and found it "very disappointing" the commission had not raised concerns about the efficiency of the company's operating position in any of the formal annual progress reviews it had undertaken. Dunedin Budget Advisory Service manager Andrew Henderson said there was a lot of pressure on low to middle-income households at the moment — and the draft decision by the Commerce Commission "seems to fly in the face of that". The budget advisory service, which administered the Dunedin City Council's Consumer Electricity Fund, was processing between 80 and 90 applications each month from people struggling with the cost of electricity. "That's probably the tip of the iceberg. "It's just pressure from all angles on low to middle-income households," Mr Henderson said. A Grey Power Otago committee member, who asked not to be named, said people were already distressed due to increases in electricity bills. A woman had recently called Grey Power's South Dunedin office in tears after signing up with a new electricity supplier and receiving a power bill of $400 for her two-person household. Feedback on the draft decisions closes on August 22. A final decision is due to be published by the end of November.
