Auckland solicitor Gautam Jindal suspended for six months after harassing fellow lawyer
Gautam Jindal committed "disgraceful and dishonourable" misconduct, a standards committee found.
Photo:
An Auckland solicitor faces possible suspension for six months and having to pay more than $62,500 after a "vengeful crusade" against another lawyer.
Gautam Jindal set up a website and printed leaflets alleging the other lawyer "lied under oath" after a civil court case went against him.
A Standards Committee of the New Zealand Law Society found Jindal committed "disgraceful and dishonourable" misconduct.
It imposed penalties on Jindal, but these have been stayed after he appealed the committee's decision to the High Court.
The standards committee, in a recent decision, said Jindal had been consumed by his "crusade" after he perceived an injustice to himself.
The committee imposed a non-publication order on the other lawyer's name and identifying details, referring to him as "Mr Y".
A judge in the court case between Y and Jindal determined that Y had not told lies in court.
The committee said that, in addition to the website, Jindal printed off leaflets and delivered them to Y's home, his neighbours' houses, and to his law firm, where they were seen by staff.
Jindal did not take the website down even after a settlement in the legal dispute had been reached and a complaint made against him to the Law Society.
"We have no doubt that the harassment involved in Mr Jindal's conduct is very serious misconduct," the committee's decision said.
"It was appalling conduct to react to a judicial decision by setting up a web address featuring Mr Y's name, to intrude on Mr Y's private home for seemingly no purpose other than to harm him, and to retain the website even after ... notice of complaint to the Law Society."
The committee censured and suspended Jindal from practising law for six months from 22 May - the delay was to minimise inconvenience to Jindal's clients and legal firm.
It also ordered him to pay $4784 in compensation to Y, $40,866 in costs to the standards committee, and $16,874 to cover the costs of the NZ Lawyers and Conveyancers Disciplinary Tribunal.
However, Jindal appealed to the High Court, which on Wednesday ordered a stay of the committee's decisions.
Jindal's barrister Steve Keall told NZME Jindal's appeal "has merit".
"He expects to be vindicated in time when the appeal has been determined," he said.
The committee's decision earlier said that the harm caused to Y and his family was significant.
"Mr Y talks of sleepless nights, his wife's fears, and loss of enjoyment of activities," the decision said.
Y also had to engage another lawyer to try to stop Jindal's actions.
When asked about his reaction to the committee's decision, Jindal said: "I've just been pinged for being too vocal about my thoughts.
"I think it is a very, very peculiar case and sometimes, unfortunately, people get caught in very peculiar and unfavourable circumstances."
Two successive standards committee decisions reveal that the dispute began with a $999 fee charged to Jindal by Y.
Y took district court proceedings against Jindal when he did not pay, and the judge found in Y's favour.
Jindal appealed, but withdrew that appeal after a confidential settlement out of court.
In the meantime, however, Jindal had put up a website carrying a large photo of Y, his name and the words "lied under oath".
He printed the web page out as a leaflet and delivered it to Y's house, his neighbours, and law firm.
"We regard the intimidatory nature of the home (and neighbour) delivery of the leaflets ... an aggravating feature," the committee said.
Jindal, who used to work in information technology, had also bought an internet domain which matched Y's name, and which would have put any content about Y published on it at the top of search engines.
In his defence, Jindal, who was admitted to the bar in October 2021, told the committee that he was acting in his personal capacity and not that of a lawyer when publishing the website.
He said that it represented his opinion and thoughts, and was done in good faith.
He also said that lawyers have a right to freedom of expression.
* This story originally appeared in the
New Zealand Herald.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
3 hours ago
- RNZ News
Nine penguins found dead in Golden Bay over past fortnight
Nine penguin have been found dead in Golden Bay over the past fortnight or so. File picture. Photo: 123RF The Department of Conservation is warning dog owners to keep their pets under control, after nine little penguins were found dead in Golden Bay over a nearly two-week period. On Wednesday, three kororā were found dead on Pakawau Beach in Golden Bay and were believed to have been killed by a dog. The dead birds have been sent to Massey University for a necropsy and DNA testing, which would confirm if a dog was to blame. The bodies of six others were found on nearby Parapara beach over the 12 days prior, all of them killed by a dog. DOC acting Golden Bay operations manager Shane Butland reminded owners to keep dogs on leads during the day and contained at night, if there were penguins in the area. "Kororā are the world's smallest penguin, about 25cm long when fully grown. They have a conservation status of 'At Risk - Declining'. "Threats include dog attacks, predation from introduced predators and being hit by vehicles, and they are easily disturbed by people." Golden Bay ward councillor Celia Butler said the situation was not unprecedented. "There is a problem ongoing with penguins being killed by dogs, and part of the problem is that dogs are very, very attracted to the smell of penguins and they are nesting at the moment." Butler said, under council rules, dogs should be under control at all times, which meant they should not be able to roam at night. "This can be a particular threat to penguins. When people allow dogs to roam at night, they are breaking the bylaw, but it's very difficult to know whose dog it is." Kororā are fully protected by the Wildlife Act, and harming or killing them is illegal. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
3 hours ago
- RNZ News
Landlord finds squalid home, tenant Jessica Michelle Duffy ordered to pay $4822
By Catherine Hutton, Open Justice reporter in Wellington of Photo: 123rf A landlord's final inspection of a house revealed some surprises, including baseball bats and chains under the beds and couches, modifications to the garage and a flatmate still living there with his dog. The landlord, whose name is suppressed, provided the Tenancy Tribunal with photographs of the house to show tenant Jessica Michelle Duffy made no attempt to clean it before she left in February. The landlord described the state of the house as squalid, which the tribunal accepted. "Cupboards were still full, dishes were piled in the sink and bench, the bathroom still had personal items, furniture was still in all the rooms and the woodshed was piled with a tremendous amount of rubbish. "Baseball bats and chairs were found under the beds and couches. The wood burner was loaded with the remnants of burnt aluminium cans and glass bottles. "The bathroom required an immediate application of Exit Mould and personal items removed with gloves, before being considered hygienic enough for occupancy and professional cleaners." During an inspection on 28 January, the landlord also discovered a missing downpipe and a broken window in one of the rooms. Despite being asked in writing to make repairs before mid-February, Duffy made no effort to do so, the decision said. In another room, four large rectangles had been cut into the carpet, destroying it. The carpet also had suspected paint stains that couldn't be removed. As well as the damaged carpets, there was a strong smell of cigarettes, ash and dog throughout all the rooms. As a result, the landlord decided to replace the carpet and sought a contribution from the tenant. The garage had been heavily carpeted, and the walls and windows boarded up and lined with underlay and black material. While the flatmate removed the wall lining, an extensive quantity of boards, material, carpet, underlay, rubbish and personal effects remained in the garage. The garage door was also broken and had to be replaced, because it had been levered open. The recently released decision also noted that, because the keys weren't returned, the locks had to be replaced and the lawn needed to be mowed. In its decision, the tribunal accepted the landlord's claim that the clean-up required two skip bins, and "many hours of stressful and disgusting work" shifting the tenant's rubbish and possessions, although the decision noted the flatmate also helped. Taking into account betterment and depreciation, the tribunal ordered that Duffy, who didn't attend the hearing, pay $4822 to the landlord for the costs they'd incurred. That included rent arrears, rubbish removal, replacing carpet, curtains, and repairs to the window and downpipe, garage door, and replacement locks. - This story originally appeared in the New Zealand Herald .
RNZ News
4 hours ago
- RNZ News
Toddler found in suitcase in bus luggage compartment
File photo. Photo: RNZ / Angus Dreaver A young girl was found in a suitcase in a bus luggage compartment this afternoon, and a woman has been charged with ill-treatment of a child. Detective Inspector Simon Harrison said police were called at 12.50pm, after a passenger asked for access to the luggage compartment during a planned stop in Kaiwaka. "The driver became concerned when he noticed the bag moving. When the driver opened the suitcase, they discovered the two-year-old girl." Harrison said the little girl was reported to be "very hot", but otherwise unharmed. She has been taken to hospital for an extensive medical assessment. A 27-year-old woman was arrested and has been charged with ill-treatment/neglect of a child. She is due to appear in the North Shore District Court tomorrow. "We would like to acknowledge and commend the bus driver, who noticed something wasn't right and took immediate action, preventing what could have been a far worse outcome," said Harrison. "Police enquiries into this incident are ongoing and further charges cannot be ruled out. Oranga Tamariki has also been notified."
