SNP to dump 100 truckloads of waste a day in England

Telegraph

16-06-2025

The SNP is set to dump up to 100 truckloads of rubbish into England each day after a landfill ban.
The Scottish Government has banned black bag waste from being buried in landfill north of the Scottish Border after Dec 31 this year.
But Scotland does not have enough incinerators to manage the waste, which experts have said could amount to 600,000 tonnes in the ban's first year.
Councils and commercial waste companies have approached rubbish-handling operators in England to negotiate 'bridging contracts'
However, most incinerators have limited spare capacity, meaning that much of Scotland's excess waste is expected to be sent to landfills in England instead.
The move has provoked fury, with the Scottish Tories questioning 'what the point is in introducing this ban if it is still going to result in so much waste just being shipped south of the Border'.
David Balmer, a waste expert from ERS Remediation, told BBC Scotland's Disclosure programme: 'You're looking at the equivalent of between 80 and 100 trucks minimum running seven days a week to take this material to a facility in England or abroad.'
The fleet of lorries transporting the rubbish to sites in England, which could include Cumbria, Northumberland or Manchester, would also cause a rise in greenhouse gas emissions.
'Temporary situation'
Gillian Martin, the SNP's climate action and energy secretary, said: 'The reason for the incineration gap is due to outside factors, particularly inflation and the cost of initially building them.
'We've got plans for more incinerators, with energy from waste schemes, to come on in the next year and over the next three years – so it is a temporary situation.'
She said 'the positive environmental impact of stopping landfill far outweighs any impact of any temporary measures to export' the rubbish over the Border.
Ms Martin explained that 'landfill produces methane, which is a particularly potent gas' and said this was 'vastly responsible in the short and medium term for warming up the planet'.
Methane is around 28 times more potent than carbon dioxide. However, it was pointed out that these emissions would still be created, only in England rather than Scotland.
'Some of them will be going to incineration in England. We're not the only country that has waste-to-energy plants,' Ms Martin said.
'The north of England has many as well. There's a very short-term measure until more of our incinerators and waste-to-energy plants come on stream.'
The Scottish Government had previously planned to impose a ban on sending biodegradable waste to landfill from Jan 2021, but the deadline was delayed five years after industry leaders warned that the country was not ready.
The lack of waste treatment capacity prompted warnings at the time that a million tonnes of rubbish would have to be disposed of outside Scotland, with the majority of it simply shifted across the Border.
This caused a rush to build more incinerators but SNP ministers decided to curtail the number of developments because of overcapacity concerns. There are currently eight operating in Scotland.
Capacity gap widens
Zero Waste Scotland (ZWS), an SNP quango, has estimated that the capacity gap is now 600,000 tonnes, but ministers have ruled out a further delay to implementing the ban.
Among the rubbish barred from landfill in Scotland will be non-recyclable black bag municipal waste, wood, textiles, paper and food. Some inert material, such as ash from incinerators and building rubble, will still be allowed at landfill sites.
Douglas Lumsden, Scotland's shadow net zero and energy secretary, said: 'There should be red faces all round among SNP ministers at this news.
'Their landfill ban has already been pushed back several years yet in typical nationalist fashion they have still failed to get their ducks in a row.
'The public will frankly be asking what the point is in introducing this ban if it is still going to result in so much waste just being shipped south of the Border.'
Earlier this year, the UK Government published a consultation on the 'near elimination of biodegradable waste disposal in landfill from 2028'. However, there is no immediate plan for a ban in England.
Scotland's recycling rates have increased by fewer than two percentage points over the past decade to 43.5 per cent of waste. They are lower than the figures for England and Wales, and far behind the 64.7 per cent recorded in Wales.
The Scottish Government said the 'vast majority' of councils had alternative measures in place before the landfill ban comes into force, but they will 'work closely with local authorities and sector bodies to monitor and review any related issues, which may arise as the date of the ban approaches'.