Animal rights advocates renew calls to end colony-cage egg farms
Photo:
Jakub Kapusnak for Unsplash
There are renewed calls from animal rights advocates for an end to colony-cage egg farms.
The Open Wing Alliance, launched an international campaign about conditions in caged egg production farms which they said were harmful for chicken's welfare and created conditions that increased the risk of disease like avian influenza.
However, the Egg Producers Federation of New Zealand rejected such claims as "a nonsense".
Jennifer Dutton, of Animals Aotearoa which is part of the Open Wing Alliance, shared their concerns.
She said colony cages weren't much better than battery, or conventional cages, which were phased out of use in New Zealand over 10 years by 2023.
"New Zealanders are under the impression we don't have caged eggs and that's been deliberately cultivated," she said.
"We still very much have the colony cage. Sometimes called the enriched cage."
Dutton said she wanted an end to colony cages in New Zealand too.
"When we look at birds that have been trapped in colony cages stacked up as if they are a product, you see birds that are massively missing feather patches, you see pale cones. They're totally deprived of all those natural in-built chicken behaviours, scratching in the dirt, foraging for bugs, even fully stretching out their wings."
However, Michael Brooks of the Egg Producers Federation of New Zealand said colony egg farms were a "credible system".
He said the National Animal Welfare Advisory Committee (NAWAC) "unanimously and independently" decided to allow egg producers to move to colony cages, barns and free-range systems after the ban of battery cages.
"The height is higher, they have a nesting area, they have a scratch pad, and they have perches for every bird. And the three primary welfare behaviours of a layer hen are nesting, perching and scratching," he said.
"Therefore that is one of the reasons there was support for the colony system. Combine that with the reduced risk from environmental reasons is one of the reasons it was approved by NAWAC."
Of concerns raised about the potential spread of avian influenza in such set ups, he said it was "a nonsense".
"Avian influenza is in the environment. It's actually our free range operations that are most at risk from avian influenza. It's not the colony sector that's going to be a major risk."
Brooks said the federation and the Poultry Industry Association of New Zealand (PIANZ) had been working closely with farmers, along with the Ministry for Primary Industries, to try and
mitigate the risks of avian influenza spreading
.
MPI's director of compliance and response Glen Burrell said of the seven complaints received by the Ministry this year about the welfare of layer hens on commercial farms, no offending was found in six, with one case still being investigated.
Burrell said following the ban of conventional, or battery cages, egg producers had the option to move to colony cages, barns and free-range systems.
He said it was decided by NAWAC that colony cages and barns provided more space than battery cages, and enable hens to express normal behaviours such as perching, pecking, nesting, and scratching.
NAWAC plans to review of the Code of Welfare for layer hens as part of its work programme
.
Meanwhile the
Commerce Commission has opened a compliance project
in relation to the labelling of colony-laid eggs.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Green housing advocates celebrate no roll back of insulation standards
Photo: 123rf Green housing advocates are celebrating the end of plans to lower insulation standards. Green Building Council head Andrew Eagles said the decision to save the standards meant 30,000 additional whānau would be in healthier, warmer homes each year. RNZ revealed last year that building and construction minister Chris Penk wanted to roll back insulation standards that saved a new home an estimated 40 percent on heating. Some builders had told Penk the new standards had forced up insulation costs by $40,000-$50,000 but he later acknowledged independent advice did not back that up. The Ministry for Business Innovation and Employment has announced there will be no roll back of the standards, however it is removing one of the options for meeting the standards, a "blunt tool" called the schedule method that was adding between $2000 and $15,000 per new home build. Builders will now have to calculate the total effect of windows and other design choices on insulation across the whole home and will no longer have the option of meeting the standards by selecting items individually from an approved list. Insulation had also been blamed for overheating, but research again showed that was incorrect. Eagles said Penk should be congratulated for listening to the science. "I'm really proud to say that Certified Builders, Construction Industry Council, ADNZ (Architectural Designers New Zealand), BRANZ (Building Research Association of New Zealand) and others stepped in and said, no you should not be taking out insulation, and it's bad design that is to blame not insulation for overheating," he said. "It's overglazing, lack of shading and other issues are causing that. "Those insulation levels will stay, and the schedule method is gone. "It (the schedule method) meant that many were using more expensive products than they needed to," Eagles said.
RNZ News
7 hours ago
- RNZ News
Pensioner with no power in caravan for six years finally gets new home
Steven Connelly in his new home at the Katikati elder housing village, a big step up from the leaky caravan he lived in for six years. Photo: LDR / Alisha Evans A pensioner living in a leaky caravan with no power for six years now has a new home to call his own. Steven Connelly, 67, moved into his home at the new elder housing village in Katikati two weeks ago after four years on the waitlist. Connelly previously lived in a caravan on a relative's property. There was no power, a long-drop toilet and Connelly slept with a bucket on the bed to catch the leaks when it rained. Asked if it was good to have somewhere warm and dry to live, he said: "Oh hell, yeah." The village was named Te Āhuru Mōwai o Hiria, meaning the sanctuary of Hiria. Hiria Wills, of Ngāi Tamawhariua hapū, and her husband Vic were residents of the original elder village in the 1980s. They did not have children so Ngāi Tamawhariua hapū kaumatua gifted the village the name to keep their memory alive. Ngāi Tamawhariua hapū chairman Hone Winder-Murray said the three housing blocks were named after the maunga they faced, Kaimai, Mauao and Hikurangi. Ngāi Tamawhariua hapū chairman Hone Winder-Murray at the opening of the Katikati elder housing village. Photo: LDR / Alisha Evans Māori principles had been incorporated into the design and the brickwork patterns were inspired by tukutuku panels at Te Rereatukāhia Marae. Winder-Murray said the village was a "monumentally beautiful thing on the landscape of Katikati". Western Bay of Plenty Mayor James Denyer said the village came in under budget but did not disclose the final cost. He said providing safe, secure and affordable housing was one of the most effective ways to enhance people's lives. "These new homes are about more than just the buildings themselves. They represent the kind of community we want to be, a community that values its elders, supports their wellbeing, and creates spaces where people can live with dignity and connection." Denyer said the opening of the village was a special day for Katikati. Ian and Jo Dickey have a secure place to live for the rest of their lives at the new elder village. Photo: LDR / Alisha Evans Ian and Jo Dickey, both 76, had been renting in Tauranga but Ian had to work fulltime at his gardening business to be able to afford the rent. Ian had undergone two hip replacements and would be tired from heavy lifting all day, Jo said. They also worried their rental would be sold. Ian and Jo moved into one of the two-bedroom homes, allowing Ian to drop to working one day a week. The Katikati elder housing village of 26 units is named Te Āhuru Mōwai o Hiria. Photo: LDR / supplied Jo was so excited about their new home she would visit the site every fortnight while it was being built. "I was really wanting something for the rest of our lives and this is a place that feels secure," she said. "It's brand new, warm and dry and cosy." Currently, 20 of the units are tenanted and the council is working through applicants on its waitlist. LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.
RNZ News
10 hours ago
- RNZ News
Conservationists concerned at hundreds more pests caught on Transmission Gully
Pest control work on Transmission Gully prior to it being finished. Photo: NZTA / Waka Kotahi Some conservationists are concerned about the potential impact of ferrets entering Wellington amid a significant rise in the number of pests being caught on Transmission Gully. Documents released under the Official Information Act show that between January 2024 to 14 April this year, 701 pests were trapped or killed on the road. That's up from RNZ's previous reports of 226 pests trapped between November 2022 and January 2024. The animals killed in the latest data set included stoats, weasels, deer, rabbits, rats, pigs and possums. Predator Free Wellington has been working for years to get rid of all pests in the capital. Project director Julian Wilcocks told RNZ there had been quite a lot more trapping done along Transmission Gully. But Wilcocks said it had also been a "bumper season" recently for mustelids which included animals such as stoats, ferrets and weasels. "That is a real massive concern because we don't have ferrets in Wellington City and so obviously, we want to really keep those from getting into the city." He said if ferrets got into the city it would be "dire straits" for their work. "Ferrets - they have a very high metabolism, so they need to eat a lot of protein which is often our native species." They also had huge roaming distances and were particularly damaging to kiwi, Wilcocks said. "It has taken us a number of years' effective methodologies for eliminating rats, stoats and weasels and so we wouldn't want to be adding ferrets to the mix." The furthest south a ferret has been found on the motorway was at Haywards in 2023. NZTA Waka Kotahi regional manager Mark Owen told RNZ $165,000 had been allocated for pest management on Transmission Gully for this financial year. Owen said the investment aligned with Greater Wellington Regional Council's pest management plan. "The plan dictates that NZTA/Waka Kotahi is responsible for controlling pests on road reserves that it occupies. "NZTA/Waka Kotahi also manages pest plants in accordance with this plan." He said that it followed best practice and focused on feral pigs, mustelids and deer. Predator Free Waikanae member Kevin Sheppard said his organisation had been trapping along the Kāpiti Expressway which linked up to Transmission Gully. Sheppard told RNZ the pests were quite lazy and would take the easiest route north and south. He said since they started trapping on the expressway 220 animals had been caught by the group. Sheppard said that while new roads such as Transmission Gully and the Kāpiti Expressway have been "an amazing addition" to the region, work needed to be done to continue trapping along the roads. "It obviously does simply create a pathway for animals such as stoats and ferrets to move along quickly." He said that there were likely gaps in the trapping network at least along Kāpiti Expressway. "We're trapping between Waikanae heading up to Peka Peka on one side, so there's nothing happening on the other side." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
